logo
Baby died in Scarborough 'after midwives dismissed concerns'

Baby died in Scarborough 'after midwives dismissed concerns'

BBC News20-07-2025
Midwives "dismissed" the concerns of a mother whose baby died shortly after being born, her lawyers have said.Leah Parker, 27, told staff at Scarborough General Hospital about her son Sonny's heart rate slowing during labour in November 2022, but said she was "ignored".She said: "I went into hospital with a perfectly healthy baby after a great pregnancy with no issues or concerns, but left without a baby to take home and raise."The York and Scarborough Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust apologised to Sonny's family and said it had implemented changes.
Medical negligence specialists Hudgell Solicitors said that soon after arriving at hospital, Ms Parker was told that her baby would need to be induced because he was "on the larger side".It was alleged that medication used to make her womb contract should have been stopped four hours before it was.This was potentially harmful to Sonny, the firm said, because his heart rate was slowing with every contraction.According to the firm, the Trust admitted the allegation on 5 July and also accepted Sonny's death may have been prevented if a decision to deliver him was made more than 90 minutes before it was.
'Absolutely devastating'
In a statement issued by the solicitors, Ms Parker said the experience was "heartbreaking"."My mum was with me when I was in labour and she was looking at the heart rate monitor and calling the midwives using the call button as she could see it dropping," she said."We were concerned but every time the midwives would come and say not to worry, and that they were checking it from their station, and so didn't need calling. It made us feel like we were being a nuisance."She said each physical examination became more painful, and she could tell something was wrong after Sonny was delivered because a midwife had tears in her eyes."There was no crying at all and I could hear a lot of activity, but nobody was saying anything," she said."To lose Sonny was absolutely devastating. It sounds an awful thing to say, but if I could go back, I would have taken the option to have had him delivered by Caesarean section, as I don't feel midwives can be trusted."
Ms Parker criticised the communication she received by NHS services following the death of her son."About a week after, I received a message from the doctor's surgery congratulating me on the birth of my baby," she said."I just cried when I opened it. When I went for my post-birth check-up, the doctor had no idea Sonny had died."Ms Parker and her partner have now had a baby girl, who was born in Hull.She said their daughter "really got us through all the difficult days".Medical negligence specialist Samantha Gardner, of Hudgell Solicitors, said the case was "wholly avoidable".She added: "Over the years our lawyers have seen hundreds of apologies to parents who have suffered loss and injury due to maternity negligence, and presently, we're seeing more than ever."In June, a national inquiry was announced into maternity failings.Ms Gardner welcomed the investigation, adding that it "must be driven by the experiences of patients, families and staff".
'Appropriate steps'
A spokesperson for the York and Scarborough Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust offered "sincere condolences and apologies to Sonny's family".They said they "fully acknowledge how devastating the loss of a child is".A statement added: "The family has since met with our obstetric and paediatric teams."Sonny's case was referred to the Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch (HSIB), and we accepted and acted on the safety recommendations outlined in their report. We have also fully co-operated with the coroner's inquiry."The inquest concluded that there was an opportunity for Sonny to have been delivered earlier, which the spokesperson said was noted by the Trust.They said: "The coroner was satisfied and reassured that the Trust is taking appropriate steps to implement changes to clinical guidelines and deliver a range of improvements in maternity care."
Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'I've played football with broken leg - my heart scare on plane didn't worry me'
'I've played football with broken leg - my heart scare on plane didn't worry me'

Daily Mirror

time29 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

'I've played football with broken leg - my heart scare on plane didn't worry me'

Stuart Pearce infamously broke his leg but played on in 1999 (Image: Jamie McDonald /Allsport) Severe chest pains and a searing heart rate at 30,000 feet is enough to traumatise anybody. Yet, for Stuart Pearce, the former England captain affectionately known as 'Psycho', there was no out-of-body experience nor life-changing lesson to be learned. 'Terminator' may have been a more suitable nickname for Pearce, who has a history of treating debilitating pain as a mild inconvenience. In March, before hopping on a flight from Las Vegas to London, the ex-Manchester City and Nottingham Forest defender felt increasing pain within his chest. Not to make a fuss, he planned to sleep it off during his journey back across the pond. The pain did not ease and before he knew it, the plane was diverting to Newfoundland, Canada, where he would spend five days in hospital. A virus had caused his heart rate to soar to 155 beats per minute, a hugely dangerous and life-threatening speed. In hospital, his heart was stopped and then restarted to bring its speed back to normal levels. But despite the most terrifying of all health scares taking place at the worst possible moment, Pearce told Mirror Football that his old school mentality helped him through. He said: "I am very matter-of-fact, to be honest with you. "Even at the time, because my family have got no medical history of heart problems, I almost went through with a, 'Right, I'm in your hands. Get on with it. What do you need me to do?' mentality. "I'm very matter-of-fact as a person. I've always been like that. It has served me well to be fair. I do not overthink things. That's been the case. Pearce opened up about his heart scare in March (Image: Richard Pelham - The FA/The FA via Getty Image) "I've probably tried to use it, when I can, to help other people, if you like, to make sure they get themselves checked out regularly. I've got the League Managers' Association (LMA), which I am a member of. They go through a lot of medical checks. "I had a heart check last summer as well. Regularly, I get checked up as well anyway. I know I am on top of these things. I'd like to turn round and say, because it would be a better story, that I have had a life-changing experience, but I am not wired that way." Barely a fortnight after his huge health scare, Pearce was back to work, commentating on England's narrow 2-0 victory over Albania. He has never been one to wallow in his own pain. Even a broken leg was not enough to stop him from finishing a half of football. Stuart Pearce was back commentating barely two weeks after his scare (Image: 2025 Crystal Pix/MB Media) In September 1999, playing for West Ham against Watford at the start of the Premier League campaign, Pearce went in for a characteristically hard challenge against Micah Hyde. The bruising and powerful nature of the challenge gave the 78-cap ex-England international a limp for the rest of the match. In Pearce's mind, it was no drama. 'Just run it off,' he said to himself. He came out of the challenge assuming he had broken his shin pad. He had actually broken his leg. "I went in for a challenge and I thought my shin pad had cracked, because I had heard a cracking noise," he said. "But it was my bone, rather than my shin pad. Stuart Pearce's toughness was iconic during his playing career (Image: Phil Cole/ALLSPORT) "I fractured my tibia just before half-time. I came to the side of the pitch. I hadn't realised. I knew it was painful, but you don't realise that, near enough, the bone has gone right through. "I tried to ice it at half-time, not knowing, thinking it was just a bang on my shin bone. When I tried to run in the tunnel to loosen it up a little bit, I knew full well something was not quite right at that stage when the adrenaline stopped pumping. "We all have a slightly different pain threshold, and when you are involved in football, sometimes, bizarrely, you can get away with doing things you couldn't in everyday life. I put mine down to a little bit of ignorance and not knowing that my shin bone was broken." Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Sky Sports discounted Premier League and EFL package Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle ahead of the 2025/26 season, saving members £192 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more. Sky will show at least 215 live Premier League games next season, an increase of up to 100 more.

Hospitals are meant to cure and care for our loved ones, not destroy their quality of life
Hospitals are meant to cure and care for our loved ones, not destroy their quality of life

Telegraph

time29 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Hospitals are meant to cure and care for our loved ones, not destroy their quality of life

Among the daily cascade of statistics about the state of the NHS lie, as we all know, individual human stories and for some a quiet rage about how hospitals meant to cure and care for patients are destroying their quality of life. Last weekend, we 'celebrated' my older brother's 82nd birthday in a nursing home. Not where he or we had planned to spend it. In early April, he went into a West Midlands hospital with an infection, shortly afterwards diagnosed as pneumonia. He was in a four-bed section of a ward which appeared fairly well-staffed. But despite numbers, it's difficult to do one's job properly or competently when there's a dominant culture of not caring. A father of three and formerly a successful business owner, my brother has had dementia for several years now but, prior to his admission, he had a good quality of life. The pub one day or night a week for a zero beer with old friends and new, who made a fuss of him, meals out, and two days a week at dementia day care. Supported by a number of privately paid part-time carers, my sister-in-law cared for him so well, and he tucked into his food and watched his beloved sport on TV. So, what happened to all that? After four weeks in an NHS hospital, my brother was finally discharged, cured of pneumonia but unable to walk, doubly incontinent and having lost quite a lot of weight. He was not taken to the toilet but kept throughout in 'nappies'. My sister-in-law frequently had to tell staff when his bed was soaking wet. He lost weight because meals were deposited in front of patients – if you were able-bodied you ate, if not, or confused with dementia, the meal just sat there before it was taken away. Only one male nurse we saw made any attempt to help patients eat. Physio was initially offered but only when he was still very ill with pneumonia. When well enough, we asked for physio but were told he hadn't engaged. So, no physio, despite protests. He now sits in a wheelchair in what is an excellent nursing home paid for by his wife, after she discharged him, but the life he had is gone forever. Precious time was wasted at the hospital as unworkable home care packages were proposed. Having fractured her spine last summer lifting my brother from a fall and also recovering from an NHS treatment that has – at least temporarily – worsened her health, my sister-in-law can no longer care for him at home in the state he is now in. It's more than fortunate that she has the funds (for now) to pay for a nursing home. So many others have no choice but to be in the hands of cash-strapped councils. I've deliberately not shared my brother's name to protect his dignity and privacy, nor identified the hospital as a formal complaint will be made. I know that my brother's plight is not unique. But how can we ensure that the elderly and vulnerable, unable to speak for themselves, are not robbed of their mobility, dignity and quality of life as a result of such a short hospital stay. I'm angry and sad in equal measures, and determined to warn others who are older and liable to require hospitalisation, to beware. Your NHS may have some nasty surprises in store. Meanwhile, Secretary of State, it's too late for my brother, but what are you going to do and when to ensure that NHS hospitals are places of safety and prolong rather than shorten a decent quality of life?

Nurses expected to vote to reject proposed pay deal
Nurses expected to vote to reject proposed pay deal

The Independent

timean hour ago

  • The Independent

Nurses expected to vote to reject proposed pay deal

Nurses in England are expected to 'overwhelmingly' reject a proposed 3.6% pay rise, it has been reported. The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) has been balloting its members over the prospective pay rise, which was accepted by the Government in May. BBC reports suggest the offer will be firmly rejected by nursing staff. The RCN previously described the award as 'grotesque', saying it will see nursing staff receive a pay rise 'entirely swallowed up by inflation' – with doctors, teachers, prison officers and the armed forces all receiving a bigger increase. Any decision on strike action would not be made until later in the year, the public broadcaster reports. It comes days after GMB health workers, including ambulance crews, rejected the Government's pay deal. The union said its members voted by 67% against the 3.6% pay award offered for 2025/26 in England. GMB has written to Health Secretary Wes Streeting calling for an urgent meeting to discuss pay and other issues of importance to its members working across the NHS and ambulance services. Rachel Harrison, GMB national secretary, said: 'We await his reply with interest.' The GMB represents about 50,000 health workers, including 20,000 in the ambulance service. The announcement was made on the first day of a five-day strike by resident doctors, also over pay. The RCN has been contacted for comment.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store