Letters to the Editor: tariffs, water and racists
The issues surrounding Mr Trump's imposition of duties on all and sundry in the wider world makes fascinating news, as is his support of American business' right to do anything they like.
For example the minimum taxes organisations such as Google, Facebook et al pay from revenue generated in countries such as ours. And of course a country as small as New Zealand is the proverbial weakling v the sumo bully.
Currently this tax is around $8 million against total revenue of around $3 billion. Good luck to anyone thinking that goodness of heart and all that will make the biggies get honest.
But there is more than one way of skinning cats. Why not just make all advertising by New Zealand business on those platforms non claimable as a business expense?
It might, as a spin-off, direct more advertising revenue into New Zealand advertising channels, all of whom appear to be struggling.
As an aside, I read this morning that several large beef retailers will not stock US beef. As I said, more than one way to skin cats. Pipes or seesaws
I refer to Gillian Macleod's letter (1.8.25): I think she has missed the point of MP Sam Uffindell's comments. I am sure Sam is not wanting to be the "fun police".
I certainly enjoy taking my grandchildren to playgrounds around Dunedin. I have had fun on the George St seesaw.
However all of us who enjoy the recreational amenities should also give a thought to Lynne Newall in Surrey St. It is totally unacceptable that we have a sewerage system that has repeatedly failed.
I am sure Lynne would choose to have her toilet working rather than a seesaw. I certainly would prioritise the former.
Dunedin and many other communities have to decide on priority spending. Those of us who benefit from functioning Three Waters should advocate for those who don't and forgo our recreational activities in favour of the health and safety of others.
Interestingly the DCC is paying $600,000 a week in interest payments. This is actually the first priority of our spending. Water woes
Thank you for the article on North East Valley water worries and congratulations to Mary Williams for yet another thoughtful, well-researched story about an urgent issue.
I think there were at least five decent stories in just that one article — the DCC's lackadaisical approach to logging sewage outflows being the most salient.
I've lived in NEV since the 1990s. I walked through Chingford Park during the 2015 floods. I think one tree falling there would have been enough, such was the power of the water, to create a dam within minutes.
This is urgent, local news. Being forewarned and forearmed against a disastrous flood must be worth millions. Remember Ally
It was good to see the sports article in today's ODT (5.8.25) acknowledging Niamh Fisher-Black's fifth placing overall in the Tour de France Femmes along with Ella Wyllie 12th placing overall.
Missing from the story was that Ally Wollaston, another Kiwi cyclist, was a member of the best team overall (FDJ-Suez). It was great to see her on the top step of the podium with her team at the finish of the world's greatest multi-day road cycling race. An unseemly stir among the keyboard warriors
In your words, "The appointment of Nikhil Ravishankar as Air New Zealand's incoming chief executive has caused a stir, after major news outlets were forced to disable comments on their social media platforms due to receiving a barrage of racist remarks."
In an interview Taika Waititi once described New Zealand as "as racist as f... ."
Accordingly people were up in arms. How dare he say that, they asked, mostly on talkback radio.
This sort of situation proves his point.
As an indirect shareholder in Air New Zealand I couldn't care less if an eleven-eyed, multi-tentacled green alien from Planet Byrzzgh4 got the job, as long as they were competently able to lead the company forward.
I wouldn't mind betting that all these secret assailants hammering away on their keyboards would be among the first to say "I'm not a racist, but . . .". Turning off
The 2017 All Blacks series against the Lions was drawn as a result of an incorrect refereeing decision, the 2023 Rugby World Cup Final was decided by the television match official, the Lions' series win over Australia is shrouded in controversy .
And rugby administrators wonder why people are switching off their game?
Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Autocar
an hour ago
- NZ Autocar
Tesla awards CEO Musk millions of shares worth billions
Tesla has given Elon Musk a stock grant of $NZ49bn as a reward for years of 'transformative and unprecedented' growth. That's despite a recent switch into right-wing politics that hurt sales, profits and Tesla's stock price. In gifting almost 100m restricted shares, the electric car company board noted that Musk hasn't been paid in years. That's because his 2018 compensation package was rejected by a Delaware court. The share gift comes eight months after a judge revoked the 2018 pay package for a second time. Tesla has appealed the ruling. The Tesla board said the grant was a 'first step, good faith' way of retaining Musk and keeping him focused. Musk said recently that he needed more shares and control so shareholder activists couldn't oust him. 'Rewarding Elon for what he has done and continues to do for Tesla is the right thing to do,' the company said in a recent filing. It noted an increase of $NZ1.242tn in Tesla's value on the stock exchange since 2018. However, Tesla shares have dropped by 25 per cent this year following Musk's brief affiliation with President Donald Trump. Moreover, Tesla faces intensifying competition from the big American automakers, and from China. Read our review of the current Model 3. In its most recent quarter, Tesla reported that quarterly profits plunged from NZ2.35bn to $NZ691m. Investors have grown worried about the trajectory of the company after Musk spent much of his time in Washington, trying to slash government expenditure. The electric vehicle maker said in the regulatory filing that Musk must initially pay Tesla $NZ39.45 per share which is equal to the exercise price per share of the 2018 pay package. A US analyst commenting on the payment said: 'We believe this grant will now keep Musk as chief executive of Tesla at least until 2030 and removes an overhang on the stock.' Tesla's stock rose nearly two per cent in trading after the announcement.
Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
Public Service Association Endorses Government's War Agenda
New Zealand's largest trade union, the Public Service Association (PSA), is fervently supporting moves to roughly double the military budget in preparation for war. Under the guise of seeking to protect jobs in the NZ Defence Force (NZDF), the union has denounced the National Party-led government, from the right, for not maintaining a strong enough military to join the coming US-led war against China. The NZDF confirmed on July 21 that it intends to cut 255 civilian jobs. They include roles in the army, air force, strategy, financial, health and safety, defence college, joint defence services, joint support group, chief of staff office and veterans affairs. It brings a total of one in ten positions axed in the last year, including 'voluntary' redundancies. A further 45 may also be cut. At the same time, a major escalation of military front-line capability, equipment and weaponry is under way. With the support of the opposition Labour Party, the government plans to nearly double defence spending from just over 1 percent to 2 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), a $NZ9 billion increase, in line with demands of the US Trump administration and NATO powers. Defence Minister Judith Collins last week told graduating army recruits to prepare for the real possibility of combat 'as the world faces its most complex and volatile global environment in decades.' Nearly 700 NZDF troops this month joined the massive Talisman Sabre exercise in Australia, a multi-national dress rehearsal for war against China. A NZDF spokesperson told Stuff they were 'reprioritising' the workforce to focus on 'maintaining combat readiness' and 'delivering core military activities.' It is establishing 276 new civilian roles while disestablishing 281 currently filled with a further 250 vacant positions not replaced. The PSA criticised the cuts from the standpoint of promoting the government's vast military buildup. The union's national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons condemned the cuts as 'incredibly shortsighted' and 'not how you build a modern, combat-ready defence force at a time of rising security risks.' Fitzsimmons added that civilian defence workers were needed to support new investment in military equipment and technology and warned the cuts would force 'those in uniform to pick up the work of the civilian workers. That is not what they signed up to do and won't help NZDF improve retention.' Fitzsimons commented: 'This is all about saving money, not strengthening security. It doesn't make any sense when tensions are rising across the Asia Pacific area and in Europe… It was only a few months ago that a warship from China was in the Tasman Sea.' In February a 'live fire' exercise by three Chinese warships in nearby international waters was seized upon by the New Zealand and Australian governments, along with the corporate media, to stoke hysteria about an escalating 'threat' posed by Beijing and to justify the military spend-up. The US and its allies routinely carry out naval drills in waters close to the Chinese mainland. The pro-war position advanced by Fitzsimons is thoroughly anti-working class. It expresses the reactionary nationalist outlook of the labour and trade union bureaucracies at home and abroad that are closely integrated with the capitalist state. In May, Spain's General Union of Workers (UGT) and Workers' Commissions (CCOO), the two largest trade union federations, threw their full support behind the European Union's plans for mass rearmament, aligning themselves with the European establishment's preparations for war against Russia. In the US, the leader of the United Auto Workers Union, Shawn Fain, a rabid Trump supporter, has cited the collaborationist labour mobilisation of the American economy during World War II as the model for today's trade unions. There is mass opposition to war, witnessed in the ongoing protests against the genocide in Gaza. In every country, however, including in New Zealand, the union bureaucracy has refused to take any action to stop the supply of weapons and other materials for Israel's war machine. All the imperialist powers are involved the rapidly escalating wars that are engulfing the globe. New Zealand is no exception. A minor imperialist power in the Pacific and a US ally, it is part of the US-led Five Eyes spying network; NZ troops are in Britain training Ukrainian conscripts to fight Russia; and NZ forces are involved in repeated provocative military exercises aimed against China. The trade union apparatus supports the war drive of its 'own' national bourgeoisie because it represents the interests of a privileged layer of the upper middle class, whose wealth is bound up with enhancing the position of NZ imperialism. Unmentioned by Fitzsimons and other union leaders is the fact that the massive armaments upgrades can only be carried out at the expense of the social conditions and basic rights of the entire working class. The PSA is an accomplice in the deepening attacks on jobs and conditions among public sector workers. Prior to the 2023 election the union openly supported Labour's own plan to slash public service budgets by up to 4 percent as 'a prudent move to tighten the belt'—as PSA leader Duane Leo put it in a Radio NZ interview. Fitzsimons was a Labour candidate in that election. In the past 18 months, NZ's far-right government has launched a scorched earth policy against all the social services on which the working class depends. Over 10,000 public sector jobs have been eliminated with no serious resistance from the PSA, which has over 95,000 members, or any of the unions. With unemployment increasing from 3.6 percent in 2023 to 5.1 percent this month and forecast to continue rising, the government is increasingly despised. The right-wing nationalist NZ First and libertarian ACT Parties—which are part of the National-led coalition government—are leading the assault on the working class, despite gaining only 6.08 percent and 8.6 percent respectively of the popular vote in 2023. A broad-based mobilisation against job losses in the public and private sectors would win widespread support in the working class. The government's 2024 budget was handed down amid nationwide protests. In the capital, Wellington, a crowd of 7,000 descended onto parliament grounds while protests coincided with a two-day strike over pay by 2,500 junior doctors. Since then, the unions have dissipated the opposition, with the Council of Trade Unions boasting a purported new 'policy vision' that will be unveiled for the 2026 elections. The corporatist unions have enforced the thousands of job cuts. The PSA's strategy has been to take a handful of legal cases in the Employment Relations Authority, including against the Ministry of Education (MoE) and Health NZ, over the way in which the cuts have been managed. Instead of challenging mass layoffs, the union insists that they are carried out according to provisions in employment agreements which require 'consultation' with the unions. PSA spokesman Leo declared the MoE had rushed through its restructure without complying with the collective agreement, which requires the MoE and PSA to first 'try to agree to the outcomes of cost-cutting exercises and present that view to the management of the MoE.' The fight against austerity cannot be separated from the struggle against war. The demand must be raised for the vast resources being wasted on the military to be redirected to solve the crisis in public education and healthcare, and to put an end to poverty and homelessness. But to carry forward a real fight against war and austerity, workers and young people must recognise who their enemies are. They face a political struggle against not only the National Party-led government, but also the opposition Labour Party and its allies—the Greens, Te Pāti Māori, the various pseudo-left organisations—and the union bureaucracy. The PSA's open support for escalating war preparations against China underscores the urgent need for workers to build new organisations that they themselves control. Rank-and-file committees should be established in every workplace, independent of the union apparatus, to mobilise the working class against militarism and war, and to defend jobs, working conditions and vital public services. This fight must be informed by a socialist political perspective, aimed at putting an end to the capitalist system, which is plunging the world into war.
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Protesters toppled this Confederate statue. Now, it's coming back to Washington
The announcement is also the latest demonstration of President Donald Trump's interest in imposing his personal stamp on Washington, where local leaders have few options to stave off federal intervention. Protesters with ropes and chains toppled the statue in the northern summer of 2020, as the United States faced a racial reckoning after the killing of George Floyd by Minneapolis police. DC police officers watched the statue fall but did not intervene. The statue has since been in storage. Pike was the only Confederate leader memorialised with an outdoor statue in DC. Earlier this year Trump ordered the creation of the 'DC Safe and Beautiful Task Force', a vehicle for his broader mission to ramp up deportations nationwide and present a 'tough on crime' persona, and for his long-held fixations on quality-of-life issues in the nation's capital. When the statue was toppled in 2020, Trump took note. Then in his first presidential term, he tweeted: 'The DC police are not doing their job as they watch a statue be ripped down & burn. These people should be immediately arrested. A disgrace to our Country!' Even before 2020, there was widespread agreement that Pike, standing on a plinth near Judiciary Square at D Street between Third and Fourth streets NW, had to go. The DC Council, for example, petitioned the federal government to remove it in 1992. In 2017, someone splashed red paint on the statue, which depicts Pike with a beard and hair billowing to his shoulders, dressed in a double-breasted vest and a long coat. He has a book in one hand, and his other one is outstretched. An activist projected the words 'remove racism', and a banner draped around it declared the Trump Administration to be 'modern confederates'. That year, Mayor Muriel Bowser (Democrat) and the chair of a congressional committee that would have had to approve its removal, said it was fine to take Pike down. No one wanted custody of the bronze behemoth. Even the Scottish Rite of Freemasonry, the fraternal organisation that commissioned the Pike statue, petitioned Congress for its installation and reveres Pike as a hero, doesn't want to accept responsibility for it. 'I have no clue,' Arturo de Hoyos, grand archivist for the Scottish Rite, told the Washington Post in 2017 when asked what should be done with the Pike statue. 'I haven't even thought that far. It's [federal] property; they can do with it what they want with it.' Born in 1809, Pike served for more than three decades as Sovereign Grand Commander of the Ancient Rite of Scottish Freemasonry. His critics contend that he also was instrumental in the formation of the Ku Klux Klan. Masons insist that evidence doesn't support that, but he was known to oppose racially integrating Masonic lodges. Pike died in Washington in 1891. Eight years later, Congress approved the Freemasons' request to erect a statue in his honour. The statue was pulled down after a day of peaceful protests and Juneteenth celebrations throughout the city. It came amid a nationwide movement to topple perceived symbols of racism and oppression as demonstrations over police brutality expanded to include demands for what protesters called a more honest accounting of American history. During the protests, monuments criticised as symbols of the Confederacy and historical oppression were often defaced and sometimes brought down in actions that critics decried as vandalism. After Pike fell, protesters marched through the city, chanting and lighting fireworks. 'Whose streets? Our streets!' they chanted. The mayor's office declined yesterday to comment on the statue's return. Eleanor Holmes Norton, the District's non-voting delegate in the House, said in a statement that 'I've long believed Confederate statues should be placed in museums as historical artifacts, not remain in locations that imply honour. A statue honouring a racist and a traitor has no place on the streets of DC.' She said she intends to reintroduce a bill that would permanently remove the statue of Pike.
