Social media aimed at kids is driven by profit, not safety
TikTok says: 'We've designed our app with safety in mind, implementing a 'safety by design' approach that ensures we are building protection for our users, including teens and their parents'.
Roblox claims its platform 'was developed from the beginning as a safe, protective space for children to create and learn'.
Unsurprisingly, all of the popular services that children use make similar claims about the importance of the safety of their product. Claims that are at best, lofty ideals, and at worst, deliberately misleading.
There is plenty of evidence these claims are far from the reality of what children and young people are experiencing on platforms such as YouTube and TikTok, both of which use an incredibly powerful AI-powered recommender system to recommend content that maximises attention, rather than what is age-appropriate, content from friends, or even the kinds of things they're interested in seeing.
A hard-hitting 2024 report by DCU's Antibullying Centre showed how recommender algorithms being used in YouTube and TikTok shorts were actively fuelling the spread of misogyny and 'male supremacy' content.
There were two other notable findings to this research. Firstly, the speed with which the content started to appear was staggering, taking only 23 minutes after the account became active.
Secondly, once the user started to show any interest at all in the recommendations, the content increased dramatically in both volume and in toxicity.
Girls are not immune to being served harmful content either, though it tends to fall into different categories, such as eating disorders and body dysmorphia.
In a report published last year, the Centre for Countering Digital Hate reported YouTube's recommender algorithm is pushing 13-year-old girls down rabbit holes of harmful content.
An analysis of 1,000 recommended videos found one in three were related to eating disorders, two in three focused on eating disorders or weight loss, and one in 20 involved content about self-harm or suicide.
Snapchat, which is incredibly popular (like YouTube and TikTok) with children who are under the platform's own minimum age requirement of 13 (36% of eight-12 year olds use it, according to our latest research), promises it is 'deeply committed to helping teens on Snapchat have a healthy and safe experience', yet Snap Inc, its parent company, is currently facing multiple lawsuits in the US that allege its harmful design fosters addictive behaviors and exposes children to risky content, such as cyberbullying, substance abuse, and self-harm material.
The horrifying impact of this content is well documented in a soon to be released Bloomberg documentary called Can't Look Away.
There can be no doubt these online products and services widely used by children are far from being 'safe by design'. They may not be intentionally harmful to children, but it is the consequence of their design. Their design is to deliberately maximise profit, not safety, which has largely been an afterthought.
A more recent market offering has been Instagram's teen accounts from Meta, which promises parents that 'teens are having safe experiences with built-in protections on automatically [sic] .'
Certainly, at surface level, this new design sounded promising, with greater efforts made to ensure there would be far stronger protections in place from harmful content and harmful contact for those under 16.
But two recent reports suggest it's not as safe by design as its widely circulated ad campaign would have us believe. Accountable Tech released a report this month which found despite Meta's controls, all accounts had been recommended sensitive, sexual, and harmful content, with minimal educational recommendations and distressing experiences reported by most users.
Another report published in April by the 5Rights Foundation titled Is Instagram Now Safe for Teens? had very similar findings.
There can be no doubt these online products and services widely used by children are far from being 'safe by design'. They may not be intentionally harmful to children, but it is the consequence of their design. Their design is to deliberately maximise profit, not safety, which has largely been an afterthought.
How is it that other industries are expected to adhere to far more stringent regulations? The toy industry, for example, is subject to a strict range of regulations to sell into the European market, including the CE standard, which shows the toy meets European safety standards for children. This ensures the toy has passed checks for things like dangerous chemicals, durability, and age-appropriate design. This is all before it reaches the consumer.
It is simply inconceivable that an industry as powerful and as widely used by children is not subject to anything even close to this level of scrutiny and testing at the design stage. This is despite the passing of the EU Digital Services Act, which does attempt to put some minimum standards in place and impose risk assessments on some of the larger platforms.
It's hard to fathom how WhatsApp was able to unleash its AI buddy — a virtual assistant powered by artificial intelligence — onto all of its subscribers' feeds, with the small caveat that 'some messages may be inaccurate or inappropriate".
Forty per cent of children aged eight–12 have a WhatsApp account in Ireland, according to our research. For any parents who may not want such a powerful resource in their children's pockets, it's unfortunately not a feature that you can unsubscribe from, despite it being described as "optional".
As we continue to navigate the online landscape, it's clear the promise of "safety by design" from major tech companies is almost always falling short of its stated goal. While big tech must be held accountable for these shortcomings, it's crucial that we demand stricter regulations and oversight from Government and regulators to ensure they are truly safe and appropriate for the young audiences they serve.
Until these changes are made, children will continue to face a digital environment that prioritises profit over their wellbeing and exposes them to very real harms.
Alex Cooney is chief executive of Ireland's online safety charity, CyberSafeKids. Find resources to help protect children on its website.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
4 days ago
- The Irish Sun
I've lost 5 stone on Mounjaro but have a ‘painful', ‘burning' side effect no one talks about – it's driving me crazy
A WOMAN who dropped five stone using Mounjaro has warned other users of a 'painful' side effect that's making her life hell. Ann, who shares her weight loss journey on TikTok, opened up about her lesser-known struggle after taking the popular jab for 40 weeks. 2 A tiktoker has shared her rarely discussed Mounjaro side-effect 2 Ann has lost five stones on Mounjaro Credit: @beingann She says the treatment, which has helped thousands shed serious weight, has left her with extreme skin sensitivity that feels like 'burning' and 'sandpaper'. And despite trawling the internet for answers, she says there's little info on it and wants others to speak up if they're suffering too. In the video, she explained: 'I've been on Mounjaro for 40 weeks and lost about five stone. "But one thing I'm really struggling with is this skin sensitivity. It's a side effect that just isn't spoken about.' Read more on mounjaro Anne described the sensation as 'painful and 'It feels like someone's taken sandpaper to my skin,' she said. She claims the pain, which is on the outside and back of her thigh, hip and knee, is extremely painful, driving her crazy. She added that it's so bad, she can't sleep properly because the discomfort keeps her up at night. Most read in Fabulous While she initially thought it could be linked to her injection site, she recently switched from stomach to thigh and the pain appeared on the opposite side, ruling that out. I went on fat jabs but the hair loss was unbelievable so I quit - I'd rather be chubby with hair than skinny and bald The comment section lit up with others saying they'd experienced similar but, like Anne, couldn't find much official guidance. One fellow user said: 'Yes, I've had it too. It's not spoken about enough!' And Ann's not the only one raising the alarm. Other TikTokers have reported soreness, itching, and acne since starting Mounjaro, with many saying they feel 'hypersensitive' in the sun. In fact, one Mounjaro user recently warned followers to up their SPF game this summer as the drug can make your skin more prone to burning. That's why experts are urging anyone on GLP-1 meds like Mounjaro or Ozempic to step up their sun protection game. Skincare brand HydroPeptide has dropped a high-end range of SPFs packed with peptides and soothing ingredients to shield sensitive skin. Their Or there's If you're looking for a more budget-friendly option Superdrug now stocks It's already earning rave reviews for being an on-the-go SPF essential. Meanwhile, skincare brand Image has launched the first ever GLP-1-friendly moisturiser designed to tackle so-called 'Ozempic face' to help fix the gaunt, sagging skin look. So if you're shedding the pounds but feeling the burn in more ways than one, you're not alone. Ann says she's speaking out in the hopes that others will share their experiences too and get the support they need. Because when it comes to Mounjaro, weight loss might be the headline but for some, the side effects are the real story. Meanwhile, experts are getting candid on a complication that might shock many. From eggy burps to stomach-churning nausea, there appears to be an What to do if you lose too much weight too quickly whilst on Mounjaro IF you're losing too much weight too quickly while on Mounjaro, it's important to take action to avoid potential health risks like muscle loss, malnutrition, dehydration, and fatigue. Here's what you can do: Evaluate Your Caloric Intake Mounjaro reduces appetite, which can make it easy to eat too little. If you're losing weight too fast (more than two to three lbs per week after the initial adjustment period), try: Tracking your food intake to ensure you're eating enough calories (apps like MyFitnessPal can help). Increasing protein intake to preserve muscle mass (aim for 0.6–1g per pound of body weight). Adding healthy fats and complex carbs (e.g., avocados, nuts, whole grains) for balanced energy. Adjust Your Dosage (With Doctor's Approval) If your weight loss is too rapid or causing side effects, your doctor may: Pause dose increases or lower your dosage. Adjust your treatment plan to stabilise your weight loss. Strength Training & Exercise To prevent muscle loss: Incorporate resistance training at least two to three times per week. Stay active with low-impact exercises like walking or yoga. Hydrate & Manage Electrolytes Drink enough water (Mounjaro can reduce thirst). Electrolytes matter - Consider adding magnesium, sodium, and potassium if you feel weak or fatigued. Monitor for Malnutrition & Deficiencies Rapid weight loss can cause vitamin/mineral deficiencies (especially B12, iron, and electrolytes). If you experience: Fatigue, hair loss, or dizziness, ask your doctor about supplements. Consider Further Medical Guidance If your weight loss is excessive or causing health concerns, speak with your healthcare provider. They might adjust your dosage, diet, or exercise plan to help stabilise your weight loss.
The Irish Sun
4 days ago
- The Irish Sun
I'm a masseuse & many of my clients have BBLs – the disgusting truth will make you think twice about getting one
A MASSEUSE has shared the grim reality of getting a Brazilian Butt Lift. Neiden, from the UK, took to social media to share her experience as she had many clients with 2 Neiden shared her experience working with BBL clients Credit: Tiktok/@neidenefitness 2 She was left horrified by what she saw Credit: Getty The woman had worked with numerous people who had the She said: "To start off, what I've seen are gaping wound holes. Speaker 1: gaping wound holes like they're open. "Why would you call me to come and give you a massage while the holes are gaping and they're open?" Neiden said that often the wounds aren't even dressed in bandages and that when she is massaging the area, air comes gushing out of the holes. READ MORE REAL LIFE STORIES The masseuse said that many of her clients with a BBL end up in constant pain and are unable to walk properly because of it. "It's just agonising pain," she added. "Not being able to walk, not being able to sit, not being able to lie down." Another grim reality was that many people were unable to clean their bum properly because of the procedure. "It's a breeding ground for infection," she claimed. Most read in Fabulous Naiden said these were just some of the side effects, and that wasn't even the worst of it. She said other clients have told her they needed blood transfusions and needed to be resuscitated all for a 'big bum.' 'Katie Price's BBL doctor nearly KILLED me' - Self-styled celeb 'beauty consultant' charging women £2k for ops exposed The biggest shock for Naiden was that many of these women had kids at home and were risking their lives for their looks. She added: "I know the streets are hard but you don't need the big bum to survive." The clip has since gone viral on her TikTok account @ People were quick to share their thoughts in the comments. One person wrote: "Having a BBL sounds like a disease." Another commented: "Whoever I know who has had a BBL have all said the same it's so scary." What are Brazilian Butt Lifts and why are they so popular? Buttock enlargement surgery - known as a Brazilian butt-lift (BBL) - is used to make the bum look bigger, rounded and lifted. Surgeons transfer fat, inject filler or insert silicone-filled implants. It is the fastest growing cosmetic procedure but also one of the most dangerous, according to the British Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (BAAPS). Many patients are travelling to the likes of Turkey or seeking out unregistered surgeons in the UK and are not given full information on the risks. BBLs carry the highest risk of all cosmetic surgeries - with more than one death occurring per 4,000 procedures. Due to celebrities undergoing such ops, many women are hoping to emulate their looks. Consultant clinical psychologist Dr Anu Sayal-Bennett, a chartered member of the British Psychological Society, told Many people travel abroad for the procedure because it is cheaper and advertising is "terribly seductive", combined with the idea of a beach holiday, added Dr Sayal-Bennett. "I didn't even get a surgery but I feel traumatised from the stories at this point," penned a third. Meanwhile a fourth said: "BBLs are dystopian." "BBLs need to stop,' claimed a fifth Someone else added: "Please listen to her don't get it. If you get any complications the NHS or even any private health service in the UK will refuse to fix it."
Irish Times
4 days ago
- Irish Times
Emer McLysaght: Sleeping in the heat is no joke, so I pulled out the big guns
During the recent bout of very hot weather I, like many of my country people no doubt, was finding it difficult to sleep. Our homes are built to thrive, for the most part, in colder and damper weather. We are not an air-conditioned nation. Visitors to our shores from much warmer climes often find themselves struggling in the high humidity, brought about by our proximity to the Atlantic Ocean. On the night in question, I had tried everything. I swapped the duvet for a sheet. I flapped around with one leg in, one leg out. Both legs out. One foot on the ground. An extremely brave move given it's a sure-fire way to invite a creature from the underworld to wrap its claws around your ankle. I tried window open, but swiftly had to revert to window closed because a cat that does not belong to me attempted to move in. At my wits end, at about 3am, I pulled out the big guns. I took my pillow, put it down at the bottom of the bed where the feet usually go, and I slept upside down. Until recently I would have believed that I was among a small cohort of people who rely on this method in times of insomnia. Of course it was TikTok that rid me of that assumption. TikTok is wonderful for reminding you that you've never had a unique experience in your entire life. I saw a TikTok once that described that feeling when the palm of your hand is itching and you try to scratch it, only to realise that the itch is actually off in a different dimension. Turns out, lots of people experience the phantom palm itch, just as a lot of people employ the pillow switch. READ MORE I started doing the pillow switch organically as a child. I have no memory of how I discovered it and no idea why it works. Presumably it helps to reset your brain and set it on a new path towards sleep. Experts say that if you're lying in bed struggling to sleep for 30 minutes or more it's essential to change something – get out of bed for a few minutes, perhaps change your pyjamas. Another unorthodox method I've tried when sleep has evaded me is to lie on the floor. This involves, no surprises here, getting out of bed to lie on the hard floor for a good 15 or 20 minutes, enough so you're uncomfortable. Then when you get back into bed, your body realises that bed is the business and slips happily into sleep. A few years ago, during an extended stay in hospital I was struggling to sleep at night. Hospitals, despite being places that are supposed to encourage healing, are often the antithesis of getting a good rest, between the oven-like temperatures, the woeful beds and the nurses waking you up to tell you it's time to go to sleep. In desperation I asked for something to help me drift off and was prescribed promethazine, an antihistamine and anti-nausea drug which comes with terrific sedating effects. Unfortunately for me one of its potential side effects is to aggravate restless leg syndrome, a condition I am tormented by. Restless leg syndrome manifests as an uncomfortable and uncontrollable urge to move and stretch your legs. It's a creeping, crawling feeling in your lower limbs, often made worse by sitting or lying down. I've had some of my worst attacks in cinemas and on aeroplanes. On this night in question in the hospital I took the promethazine and went off to bed full of hope. Fast forward 40 minutes and my brain is trying to sleep while my legs just wanted to dance. I was scuttling around the room like a super speedy zombie from 28 Days Later. A recent addition to my insomnia arsenal is cognitive shuffling. It involves choosing a random everyday word like door and taking each letter from the word and naming as many words as you can that start with that letter, before moving on to the next. The mental exercise helps to calm racing thoughts and ease your brain into sleep. I've tried it, and it does work. A word of warning though: don't get competitive with yourself, nothing says 'up until 4am' like trying to think of 40 words that start with the letter Q. When all else fails I return to the old favourite of the pillow swap. Will you get a fright when you wake up? Yes. Is it worth it for the best sleep of your life? Also yes.
