Punjab to Aotearoa documentary ‘a preservation of our legacy'
The featurette was screened in the East Auckland suburb of Botany on 18 June, attended by descendants of early migrants from India - families who have been in New Zealand for more than a century.
The official premier took place at the Indian High Commission in Wellington in mid-May.
Presented by Harjot Singh, the 48-minute documentary is directed by Gagan Sandhu.
Harjot Singh, presenter of Punjab to Aotearoa
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
It is co-produced by Parminder Singh, host at Punjabi radio station Radio Spice, and Navtej Randhawa, a trustee at NZ Punjabi Multimedia Trust, which backed the documentary.
"Today, we showcase the first part of a series we will be producing ... documenting the proud history of Indian migration to Aotearoa New Zealand, especially from the villages of Punjab," Randhawa said.
Randhawa is great-grandson of Inder Singh Randhawa - one of the early Indian migrants to New Zealand and a founding member of pioneering Indian associations such as the Country Section New Zealand Indian Association and New Zealand Indian Central Association (both established in 1926).
"This documentary is a preservation of our legacy, a gift for generations to come," Randhawa said.
"We have detailed the Indian migration experience - highlighting the story of four families using rare archival footage and personal accounts," he said.
"It's fascinating to learn how the earliest Indian arrivals here worked in agriculture first and went on to enrich New Zealand's economy and culture."
Attendees at a screening of Punjab to Aotearoa in Auckland.
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
Indians were living in New Zealand as early as the 19th century, according to
Indian-origin academic Sekhar Bandyopadhyay
and historian Jane Buckingham, as noted in a book titled Indians and the Antipodes.
In fact, the 1881 Census counted six Indians living in New Zealand at the time.
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon highlighted the century-old ties between New Zealand and India during his trip to the South Asian nation in March.
"At the beginning of the 19th century - well before we became a nation - Indian sailors jumped ship in New Zealand, with some meeting locals and marrying into our indigenous Māori tribes. A few years later, Māori traders began travelling to Kolkata to sell tree trunks used in sailing ships," Luxon
said at the time
.
The Indian sailors, seafarers and soldiers that arrived on British East India Company ships stayed to engage in activities such as mining, trench-digging and bottle-collecting.
Attendees at a screening of Punjab to Aotearoa in Auckland.
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
Many of the earliest Indian settlers travelled from regions in the modern Indian states of Gujarat and Punjab.
"The ongoing development of rural areas in the North Island provided many Punjabi settlers with opportunities, firstly in hawking and then in flax-cutting in the swamps of the Hauraki Plains and Waikato," according to a book titled Mokaa: The Land of Opportunity, published by the New Zealand Indian Central Association.
These Punjabi Sikhs, many of whom had farming experience, subsequently settled in the Waikato district and
embraced dairy farming
.
Attendees at a screening of Punjab to Aotearoa in Auckland.
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
The history of Punjabi migration has been documented in a book titled Punjabis in New Zealand: A History of Punjabi Migration 1890-1940, written by historian W.H. McLeod.
"McLeod's work is seminal in the sense it provided the first recorded history of our migration to New Zealand," said Harjot Singh, who is also listed as researcher of Punjab to Aotearoa. "Our audio-visual production is a tribute to his efforts."
Harjot Singh's research took him to Te Awamutu in Waikato, which is just north of Kihikihi - an important town for Indian history in New Zealand, according to McLeod.
"The first definite example of a Punjabi dairy farm appears to be a small 50-acre (20-hectare) property near the Waikato township of Kihikihi, purchased by Harnam Singh ... during the rates period 1918/19," McLeod writes in his book. "This purchase evidently preceded that of the celebrated 'Hindu farm', which was acquired soon after by Inder Singh Mahasha."
In Te Awamutu, Harjot found the grandstand at the Te Awamutu Rugby Stadium named after the son of an early migrant Phuman Singh who came to New Zealand in 1920.
"[Phuman's] son, Gurdyal Singh (1935-2018), who was fondly called Guru Singh, contributed to the local rugby scene so much that the community decided to honour him by naming the grandstand as Guru Singh Grandstand," Harjot Singh said.
Attendees at a screening of Punjab to Aotearoa in Auckland.
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
In the documentary, Joginder Singh, Gurdyal's son, shared the story of his great-aunt's marriage in 1933, with a local band leading the wedding procession and the entire town shutting down.
The family still has in its possession a 100-year-old copy of Sikh holy book Guru Granth Sahib that was shipped from India in the early 1920s.
As Indians were settling in the Waikato region, it was important for them to have harmonious relations with the local Māori population.
"While researching this, we made some important discoveries," Harjot Singh said.
"Located 15 kms to the southeast of Te Awamutu is the Paaraawera Marae, where we find the graves of Madhav Chunilal and his wife, Bhikhi Chunilal, who died in the 1940s and '50s. These graves have been lovingly maintained by the local whenua for the past 75 years.
"Madhav's father arrived in 1919 from Surat (Gujarat) in India."
In the same vein is the story of Sheru Singh Lagah, an early Indian migrant who married the daughter of Tuhoe prophet Rua Kenana - a well-known historical Maori figure.
The documentary features Sheru's daughter, Shardee Singh Lagah, based in Auckland and his grandson, Tane Singh Lagah, who lives in Rotorua.
Another section is dedicated to the families of Juwala Singh, who migrated to Pukekohe from India in 1920, as well as his son-in-law Ganges Singh, whose parents migrated to Fiji.
Passing away in 2016, Ganges came to New Zealand in the 1950s and has the distinction of being the first Punjabi Sikh to be awarded a Queen's Service Medal in 1990.
"Juwala Singh was the first Indian immigrant to own a commercial property on King Street in Pukekohe. In recognition of this, the Franklin District Council as part of Franklin's first Heritage Week celebrations in 2010, resolved to name a pedestrian walkway on King Street as Juwala Singh Lane," Harjot Singh said.
Gagan Sandhu, director of Punjab to Aotearoa
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
For documentary director Sandhu, who has been living in New Zealand for the past 14 years, what stood out in the early Indian settlement stories was the isolation of women who came with their husbands.
"How they coped up with the entirely new environment, with no one to talk to, is beyond comprehension," Sandhu said. "They didn't know the language, the food was alien and there was no family support. Still, they persevered."
Sophie Dhaliwal Sidhu, who lives in Cambridge and is the great-granddaughter of Gina Singh, who migrated from Sultanpur in Punjab, shared memories of what the women of that era faced.
"My great-grandmother, Karam Kaur, was shocked to learn when she visited India 34 years for the first time after arriving in New Zealand that her parents had passed away long back," Sidhu said.
Navtej Randhawa, co-producer of of Punjab to Aotearoa
Photo:
Supplied
Careful not to underplay the struggles of early Indian migrants, the documentary discusses the discrimination they faced for decades, something documented by Jacqueline Leckie in a book titled Invisible: New Zealand's history of excluding Kiwi-Indians.
"[In] the 1930s, Indians faced exclusion from whites-only spaces in Pukekohe," Leckie wrote.
"Barbers refused to cut the hair of Chinese, Māori or Indians. These groups were also banned from the better-quality dress circle within a Pukekohe cinema.
"White racism at Pukekohe, while localised and extreme, nonetheless had widespread support throughout the country."
Parminder Singh, co-producer of Punjab to Aotearoa
Photo:
RNZ / Yiting Lin
"This is the reason we started thinking about this documentary project almost five years back, in 2020, when Navtej's family completed their 100 years in New Zealand after having arrived here in 1920," co-producer Parminder Singh said.
"As we proudly say in our community, we are standing on the shoulders of these giants," Singh said.
"They come here, struggled with isolation and discrimination, and then established themselves over time with hard work and perseverance. In turn, they made it easy for the next generations of Indians."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
15 minutes ago
- RNZ News
School curriculum rewrite had serious problems, managers considered using AI to help
Students learning in a school classroom. Photo: Unsplash/ Taylor Flowe Internal Education Ministry documents sighted by RNZ reveal serious problems plagued the rewrite of the school curriculum earlier this year and managers were considering using AI to help with the work. The latest leak from the organisation shows only a few months ago it lacked a clear definition of the core concept underpinning the entire rewrite - "knowledge rich" - even though it had already published primary school maths and English curriculums by that time and had nearly completed draft secondary school English and maths curriculums. It was also struggling with repeated requests for changes. Primary school principals and the secondary teachers union told RNZ they were worried about the curriculum development process. They said they still had not seen a clear definition of the term 'knowledge-rich' as it applied to the New Zealand curriculum. The Education Ministry told RNZ content of the English and maths curriculum was "consistent with knowledge-rich curriculum design principles" but it failed to provide a definition of knowledge-rich despite being asked for one. The latest leak followed a series of disclosures of internal documents that prompted the ministry to hire a KC to investigate where they were coming from. A "programme status report" sighted by RNZ said the introduction of a new process for developing the curriculum posed an "extreme" issue to the work. "The new delivery process is adding complexity to both internal and external delivery and review procedures as we do not have a clear definition of a knowledge rich curriculum and what it looks like in a NZ context," it said. "There is no international comparison we can pick up and use." Elsewhere, the document said lack of an agreed definition was affecting all learning areas of the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC) and Te Marautanga o Aotearoa (TMoA), the curriculum for Māori-medium schools. "Both the NZC and TMoA curricula lack a clear design framework for defining a knowledge-rich curriculum. This absence of a design point is impacting the development of all learning areas, as continuous refinement and clarification are required," it said. "Options are now being looked at to bring in overseas experts to help us develop templates and frameworks for the curriculum which we can then apply." The report said the programme was in red status for the month of February. It said the key challenge was the lack of a constant template for the work it was producing. The document said even if the ministry resolved that problem it still faced challenges including having to revise its work due to changing expectations, lack of a clear and consistent understanding of the term 'knowledge rich', and lack of a design framework. The status report warned that governance groups associated with the rewrite were ineffective because they provided conflicting advice and their feedback was not always followed. It said stakeholders had different expectations about the use of mātauranga Māori in the curriculum and contributing groups lacked skills and experience. The ministry told RNZ it was developing the curriculum framework, Te Mātaiaho, to be consistent with a knowledge-rich curriculum. It said since last year its work on defining a knowledge-rich curriculum was informed by several sources and a literature review had been commissioned. However, it did not provide any definition, despite being asked for one. The ministry told RNZ the curriculum rewrite was currently at red status after being in amber status in the previous two months. "Due to the scale and complexity of this work, shifts between Amber and Red status are expected. The Ministry actively manages programme risks using its risk management framework, with mitigation strategies in place, regularly monitored, and escalated when necessary," it said. It said the work had 10 high risks, 25 moderate risks and five low risks. Post Primary Teachers Association vice-president Kieran Gainsford told RNZ teacher subject association leaders met recently and were worried about a lack of clarity about key terms such as the 'science of learning' and 'knowlege-rich curriculum'. Gainsford said teachers had been saying for some time it was critical that the curriculum was clear. "If even officials aren't sure of what they mean by the terms of science of learning and knowledge-rich curriculum, knowledge-rich in particular, then it leads to the question of how on earth are schools and teachers supposed to know what they mean by that," he said. He said the ministry was yet to publish a clear definition of the term knowlege-rich and it needed to be crystal-clear. "At the moment we're trying to respond in many cases to stuff that's poorly-defined and that leads to debate or discussion that isn't particularly fruitful," he said. Principals Federation president Leanne Otene said it was clear to primary and intermediate principals the curriculum was "being built as the plane was flying". She said a knowledge-rich curriculum would define what needed to be taught at each level of learning, but the ministry had not delivered on that. Otene said parts of the published curriculums read like they had been cut and pasted from elsewhere. Association of English Teachers president Pip Tinning said the problems outlined by the ministry documents were not normal for curriculum development. She said the ministry had not explained knowledge-rich in terms of the English curriculum or its definition of the science of learning. Meanwhile, a separate Education Ministry document from December last year titled "Options for change to the curriculum regulatory system" showed plans to allow the Education Minister to set different curriculum expectations for different types of schools. The document said the power could be useful to help schools better support their students. "For example there could be a pedagogy that only schools and kura with technology hubs must use, or a curriculum statement that applies specifically for kura kaupapa Māori," the document said. The document said education sector groups were largely supportive of the plans, which would ensure the curriculum was reviewed and updated regularly. A document about the Science curriculum outlined shortcomings with the existing curriculum which the ministry said resulted in over-crowded lessons and few children enjoying the subject and continuing it at university. It said the curriculum needed to be revised to help students understand science in day-to-day life and other countries were changing their science curriculums for similar reasons. A senior manager's briefing to ministry staff raised the possibility of using AI to write some of the material underpinning the curriculum. The manager said they could use AI to synthesise the curriculums of countries such as Singapore, NSW, British Columbia, with New Zealand information almost instantly. They said it could also ensure the use of consistent language between curriculum documents. Asked about the use of AI, the ministry told RNZ: "The Ministry is exploring how artificial intelligence tools can support curriculum development, particularly by analysing and synthesising information from international curricula and related knowledge frameworks. AI is not being used to directly write curriculum content but may assist with background research and insights."
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Auckland YMCA accommodation staff scared of job losses if restructure goes ahead
The proposed restructure will affect the jobs of accommodation staff at the YMCA's City Lodge and at the Y's Pitt Street hostel in Auckland. Photo: Google Maps YMCA North staff who work in the Auckland accommodation team say they're scared of losing their jobs, worry about their mental health deteriorating and safety being compromised, if a proposed restructure goes ahead. The front-line accommodation staff at the Y's Pitt Street hostel and its City Lodge had a week to give feedback on a restructure proposal. If the proposal goes ahead, workers called Guest Service Agents who have been working both across day and night shifts will only be able to work either in a day or night role. Staff question how the proposal fits with the YMCA's key values. Guest Service Agents are staff who deal with customers who are staying at the YMCA's hostel and lodge, manage security, cleanliness, bookings and billing. Currently, they work both day and night shifts and are stationed at either the Pitt Street Hostel or the City Lodge. In the proposal - these roles will be disestablished. Staff will now have to apply to be either a day worker or a night worker and will work across two different locations. Night GSAs are the only reception and security staff on site - it means they must handle emergencies and security incidents by themselves. A staff member who usually works night shifts at the City Lodge hostel told Checkpoint they did not feel prepared. "All we had was a safeguarding training. The safeguarding is more related to protecting children and vulnerable people rather than yourself. So, in the security sense, we're not prepared." They said the security company the YMCA contracts is not based on site, so GSAs must call a hotline if they face issues. "I needed to evict an intruder that was in the building. A visitor there was not allowed to be there. He said, 'okay give me 40 minutes and I'll be there.' If we have a real emergency, real urgency, that's what we [are] dealing with. "Probably we'll have to sort it out ourselves or call the police." The worker said while they had been working people had tried to break in, the worker told Checkpoint they often carried a knife as they felt unsafe. As part of their roles, on the night shift they must watch the entrances and exits and do hourly walk throughs of public areas. "Night shifts are extra tough on health, on physical, mental health. You are extra tired even if you're just sitting on a chair [most] of the night." As part of Auckland Council's service agreements, which started on 1 April this year, service partners must pay their workers the living wage. Some Auckland Council leisure centres and pools are managed by the YMCA, meaning those YMCA staff must be paid the living wage. However, because the YMCA's accommodation centres are not part of this service agreement, it means workers don't have to be paid the living wage. The worker said after the restructure if they would only be working nights and the pay remained the same at $25 an hour, it would be unfair as they would be taking on more risk and a heavier workload. "We are the ones who are taking aggressive customers, being on safety hazards, we are the ones taking the burden." The worker said the way the proposal had been carried out went against the core values of the YMCA around Caring, Honesty, Respect and Responsibility. If the proposal is confirmed to stay the same, there will be interviews held over the rest of July and staff will be told the outcomes of the interviews at the end of the month. For staff who aren't selected for the new roles, if their current role is disestablished, they will be made redundant from 1 August. If the worker loses their job, they're worried about the current job market and if they will be able to find work at all within the next couple of months. "We live pay check by pay check, so I don't have any savings to my name. I should have like $10 to my name. It will be devastating, honestly, and I'm sure [it will] affect any area in my life financially, emotional, mental health wise." On 15 July accommodation staff who work across the YMCA's City Lodge and Pitt Street hostel were sent a letter outlining the proposal. The YMCA said it was because they were facing financial underperformance due to a mix of structural and market-related challenges. They say the roles will give clarity to the workers' responsibilities and accountability. YMCA North chief executive Rebecca Russell said in statement the proposed new structure would see greater streamlining across the two accommodation sites. The YMCA is actively seeking feedback from affected staff and no final decisions have been made. Security was a top priority, she said - with measures including mandatory door locking, pass cards and external security able to be called if needed. Russell said she would be concerned if staff were having to arm themselves and this had not been raised with management. But anyone worried about safety should provide that feedback during the consultation, she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Anchor rediscovery reopens wounds from early encounter between Māori, European
The rediscovery of one of New Zealand's oldest European artifacts has reopened scars from an early encounter between Māori and a European explorer. An anchor that once belonged to the French ship Saint Jean Baptiste, captained by Jean-Francois Marie de Surville, has been located in the waters of Doubtless Bay in the Far North. In a storm in 1769 they lost an anchor and had to cut two more loose. Two of them have already been found - and the 3rd was discovered by Kelly Tarlton in 1982 - however the co-ordinates were misplaced until now. Photo: Hamish Williams Chair of Ngāti Kahu and Professor of Māori Studies at the University of Auckland Margaret Mutu said the crew of the Saint Jean Baptiste arrived in Doubtless Bay "in great disarray", several had scurvy and were nursed back to health by members of Ngāti Kahu. "That time of the year in December, January we know up at Karikari that that's a time when you're subjected to the tail ends of cyclones that come down from the Pacific, it happens every year. So storms were quite common and during a storm apparently one of their boats... got washed ashore. You know things get washed ashore up there at home, they're ours and we'll take them." Mutu said de Surville and his crew then "turned on" Ngāti Kahu, ransacked their kāinga (settlement) and then kidnapped a local rangatira named Ranginui. He latter died of thirst and scurvy aboard the Saint Jean Baptiste. The kidnapping was a portent of what was to come not unlike when Captain James Cook made first landfall at Tūranga, a visit that ended when the British killed or wounded nine Māori, she said. Ngāti Kahu chair Margaret Mutu Photo: RNZ / Leigh-Marama McLachlan Many years later Ngāti Kahu were approached at Haiti-tai-marangai Marae, not far from where the ship lost anchor, asking them to support a plaque commemorating de Surville, she said. "We talked about it at Haiti-tai-marangai... our mātua told us what had happened and we told those people to go away, we don't want to know about your de Surville." But she said the recovery of the anchor may be a chance to discuss this part of New Zealand's history. Mutu said one of the first things she did when she heard about this find was to ring home and make sure people there had heard it too. "Well people didn't know about it, so that's the first thing, we need to know about it, we need to sit down and talk about it and we will decide what happens to that anchor. "I just get a little bit annoyed about that people came into our territory, we welcomed them, we nursed them back to health, we saved them, they did the dirty on us and now they're coming back and telling us 'we're going to this, we're going to that, we're going to do the other.'" Heritage New Zealand have recommended the site of the anchor remain undisturbed until tangata whenua have been consulted, and the area can be assessed by a professional archaeologist. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
