
Global streamers fight CRTC's rule requiring them to fund Canadian content
OTTAWA — Some of the world's biggest streaming companies will argue in court on Monday that they shouldn't have to make CRTC-ordered financial contributions to Canadian content and news.
The companies are fighting an order from the federal broadcast regulator that says they must pay five per cent of their annual Canadian revenues to funds devoted to producing Canadian content, including local TV news.
The case, which consolidates several appeals by streamers, will be heard by the Federal Court of Appeal in Toronto.
Apple, Amazon and Spotify are fighting the CRTC's 2024 order. Motion Picture Association-Canada, which represents such companies as Netflix and Paramount, is challenging a section of the CRTC's order requiring them to contribute to local news.
In December, the court put a pause on the payments — estimated to be at least $1.25 million annually per company. Amazon, Apple and Spotify had argued that if they made the payments and then won the appeal and overturned the CRTC order, they wouldn't be able to recover the money.
In court documents, the streamers put forward a long list of arguments on why they shouldn't have to pay, including technical points regarding the CRTC's powers under the Broadcasting Act.
Spotify argued that the contribution requirement amounts to a tax, which the CRTC doesn't have the authority to impose. The music streamer also took issue with the CRTC requiring the payments without first deciding how it will define Canadian content.
Amazon argued the federal cabinet specified the CRTC's requirements have to be 'equitable.'
It said the contribution requirement is 'inequitable because it applies only to foreign online undertakings and only to such undertakings with more than $25 million in annual Canadian broadcasting revenues.'
Apple also said the regulator 'acted prematurely' and argued the CRTC didn't consider whether the order was 'equitable.' It pointed out Apple is required to contribute five per cent, while radio stations must only pay 0.5 per cent — and streamers don't have the same access to the funds into which they pay.
The CRTC imposes different rules on Canadian content contributions from traditional media players. It requires large English-language broadcasters to contribute 30 per cent of revenues to Canadian programming.
Motion Picture Association—Canada is only challenging one aspect of the CRTC's order — the part requiring companies to contribute 1.5 per cent of revenues to a fund for local news on independent TV stations.
It said in court documents that none of the streamers 'has any connection to news production' and argued the CRTC doesn't have the authority to require them to fund news.
'What the CRTC did, erroneously, is purport to justify the … contribution simply on the basis that local news is important and local news operations provided by independent television stations are short of money,' it said.
'That is a reason why news should be funded by someone, but is devoid of any analysis, legal or factual, as to why it is equitable for foreign online undertakings to fund Canadian news production.'
In its response, the Canadian Association of Broadcasters said the CRTC has wide authority under the Broadcasting Act. It argued streamers have contributed to the funding crisis facing local news.
'While the industry was once dominated by traditional television and radio services, those services are now in decline, as Canadians increasingly turn to online streaming services,' the broadcasters said.
'For decades, traditional broadcasting undertakings have supported the production of Canadian content through a complex array of CRTC-directed measures … By contrast, online undertakings have not been required to provide any financial support to the Canadian broadcasting system, despite operating here for well over a decade.'
A submission from the federal government in defence of the CRTC argued the regulator was within its rights to order the payments.
'The orders challenged in these proceedings … are a valid exercise of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission's regulatory powers. These orders seek to remedy the inequity that has resulted from the ascendance of online streaming giants like the Appellants,' the office of the attorney general said.
'Online undertakings have greatly profited from their access to Canadian audiences, without any corresponding obligation to make meaningful contributions supporting Canadian programming and creators — an obligation that has long been imposed on traditional domestic broadcasters.'
The government said that if the streamers get their way, that would preserve 'an inequitable circumstance in which domestic broadcasters — operating in an industry under economic strain — shoulder a disproportionate regulatory burden.'
'This result would be plainly out of step with the policy aims of Parliament' and cabinet, it added.
The court hearing comes as trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada have cast a shadow over the CRTC's attempts to regulate online streamers.
The regulator launched a suite of proceedings and hearings as part of its implementation of the Online Streaming Act, legislation that in 2023 updated the Broadcasting Act to set up the CRTC to regulate streaming companies.
In January, as U.S. President Donald Trump was inaugurated for his second term, groups representing U.S. businesses and big tech companies warned the CRTC that its efforts to modernize Canadian content rules could worsen trade relations and lead to retaliation.
Then, as the CRTC launched its hearing on modernizing the definition of Canadian content in May, Netflix, Paramount and Apple cancelled their individual appearances.
While the companies didn't provide a reason, the move came shortly after Trump threatened to impose a tariff of up to 100 per cent on movies made outside the United States. Foreign streamers have long pointed to their existing spending in Canada in response to calls to bring them into the regulated system.
Anja Karadeglija, The Canadian Press

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Globe and Mail
39 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Luc Vincent Hair Care Welcomes Steve Montminy as National Director of Education, Development, and Artistic Creation
, July 3, 2025 /CNW/ - Luc Vincent Hair Care , an innovative leader in the hair care and professional coloration industry, is proud to announce the appointment of Steve Montminy to the strategic position of National Director of Education, Development, and Artistic Creation – Luc Vincent Pro Coloration Division. This appointment marks a decisive step in our company's strategy, which aims to transform the at-home professional coloration experience through education and support for pharmacy professionals. Steve Montminy joins our team with recognized expertise, acquired within prestigious brands such as JOHN PAUL MITCHELL SYSTEMS, TOP BEAUTY GROUP, REVLON PROFESSIONAL BRANDS, and SCHWARZKOPF PROFESSIONAL. His exceptional career demonstrates his ability to innovate, share his knowledge, and elevate the standards of professional coloration. In his new role, Steve Montminy will lead the development of educational programs specially designed for pharmacy professionals, to enable them to better advise and support customers in the use of professional color at home. His role will also be to stimulate innovation in our coloration formulas and techniques, while instilling an artistic vision in line with global trends and the needs of end-users. "Our mission is clear: to democratize access to quality professional hair color, by equipping pharmacy professionals to become true expert advisors to their clientele," declares Luc Vincent , president of Luc Vincent Hair Care . " Steve Montminy's arrival reinforces our commitment to offering cutting-edge education and supporting our partners in their key role with consumers." Steve Montminy adds: "I am honored to join Luc Vincent Hair Care , a company that places education and innovation at the heart of its strategy. I am enthusiastic about developing programs that will allow pharmacy professionals to play a central role in the success of at-home coloration, while continuing to inspire creativity and excellence." This appointment is part of Luc Vincent Hair Care's desire to be the preferred partner for pharmacy professionals, by offering them tailor-made tools, training, and support to meet the growing expectations of consumers for at-home professional coloration. About Luc Vincent Hair Care : Luc Vincent Hair Care is a recognized leader in the beauty industry, specializing in hair care and professional coloration products. With over 30 years of experience, the company is committed to offering innovative products, cutting-edge education, and unparalleled support to pharmacy professionals and their clients across Canada .

National Post
an hour ago
- National Post
Exchange Income Corporation Announces Commitment to Expand the Atik Mason Indigenous Pilot Pathway in Nunavut
Article content WINNIPEG, Manitoba — Exchange Income Corporation (TSX: EIF) ('EIC' or the 'Corporation') a diversified, acquisition-oriented company focused on opportunities in the Aerospace & Aviation and Manufacturing segments, announces it will commit to double the capacity of its Atik Mason Indigenous Pilot Pathway in Nunavut for 2026 (the 'Program'). The Program removes significant barriers to flight training faced by Indigenous students including cost and location and honors the importance of retaining a deep connection to Indigenous culture while training. Article content The Program was initially established in 2022 in Thompson, Manitoba and was expanded to Rankin Inlet, Nunavut in 2024 which is the first and only of its kind in Nunavut. With the completion of the acquisition of Canadian North which expands our footprint in Nunavut, the doubling of the capacity of the Program in Nunavut for next year was an obvious and natural choice for EIC and consistent with the Corporation's history of investing in the communities we serve. Article content Article content 'We take seriously our responsibility to invest in the regions which we serve. This is why we originally expanded the Program to Rankin Inlet where it has been remarkably successful with the first student starting to fly for us this year and five others will be completing their training in 2026 with jobs waiting for them at our airlines,' stated Mike Pyle, CEO of EIC. He continued, 'With the acquisition of Canadian North we are thrilled to be materially expanding the Program in Nunavut and see many more Inuit joining our companies as pilots. Through this expansion we will not only invest in the assets needed in Nunavut to support the Program's growth but also invest in the Inuit living in the communities. They are our future pilots. These types of investments are a cornerstone of who is EIC is, how we operate and what will continue to drive our success operating in the North.' Article content About Exchange Income Corporation Article content Exchange Income Corporation is a diversified acquisition-oriented company, focused in two segments: Aerospace & Aviation and Manufacturing. The Corporation uses a disciplined acquisition strategy to identify already profitable, well-established companies that have strong management teams, generate steady cash flow, operate in niche markets and have opportunities for organic growth. For more information on the Corporation, please visit Article content Article content ). Article content Caution concerning forward-looking statements Article content The statements contained in this news release that are forward-looking are based on current expectations and are subject to a number of uncertainties and risks, and actual results may differ materially. Many of these forward-looking statements may be identified by looking for words such as 'believes', 'expects', 'will', 'may', 'intends', 'projects', 'anticipates', 'plans', 'estimates', 'continues' and similar words or the negative thereof. These uncertainties and risks include, but are not limited to, external risks, operational risks, financial risks and human capital risks. External risks include, but are not limited to, risks associated with economic and geopolitical conditions, competition, government funding for Indigenous health care, access to capital, market trends and innovation, general uninsured loss, climate, acts of terrorism, armed conflict, labour and/or social unrest, pandemic, level and timing of government spending, government-funded programs and environmental, social and governance. Operational risks include, but are not limited to, significant contracts and customers, operational performance and growth, laws, regulations and standards, acquisitions (including receiving any requisite regulatory approvals thereof), concentration and diversification, maintenance costs, access to parts and relationships with key suppliers, casualty losses, environmental liability, dependence on information systems and technology, cybersecurity, international operations, fluctuations in sales prices of aviation related assets, fluctuations in purchase prices of aviation related assets, warranty, performance guarantees, global offset and intellectual property risks. Financial risks include, but are not limited to, availability of future financing, income tax matters, commodity risk, foreign exchange, interest rates, credit facility and the trust indentures, dividends, unpredictability and volatility of securities pricing, dilution and other credit risk. Human capital risks include, but are not limited to, reliance on key personnel, employees and labour relations and conflicts of interest. Article content Article content Article content Article content Contacts Article content : Article content Mike Pyle Article content Article content Chief Executive Officer Article content Article content Exchange Income Corporation Article content Article content (204) 982-1850 Article content Article content MPyle@ Article content


Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Exchange Income Corporation Announces Commitment to Expand the Atik Mason Indigenous Pilot Pathway in Nunavut
Exchange Income Corporation (TSX: EIF) ('EIC' or the 'Corporation') a diversified, acquisition-oriented company focused on opportunities in the Aerospace & Aviation and Manufacturing segments, announces it will commit to double the capacity of its Atik Mason Indigenous Pilot Pathway in Nunavut for 2026 (the 'Program'). The Program removes significant barriers to flight training faced by Indigenous students including cost and location and honors the importance of retaining a deep connection to Indigenous culture while training. The Program was initially established in 2022 in Thompson, Manitoba and was expanded to Rankin Inlet, Nunavut in 2024 which is the first and only of its kind in Nunavut. With the completion of the acquisition of Canadian North which expands our footprint in Nunavut, the doubling of the capacity of the Program in Nunavut for next year was an obvious and natural choice for EIC and consistent with the Corporation's history of investing in the communities we serve. 'We take seriously our responsibility to invest in the regions which we serve. This is why we originally expanded the Program to Rankin Inlet where it has been remarkably successful with the first student starting to fly for us this year and five others will be completing their training in 2026 with jobs waiting for them at our airlines,' stated Mike Pyle, CEO of EIC. He continued, 'With the acquisition of Canadian North we are thrilled to be materially expanding the Program in Nunavut and see many more Inuit joining our companies as pilots. Through this expansion we will not only invest in the assets needed in Nunavut to support the Program's growth but also invest in the Inuit living in the communities. They are our future pilots. These types of investments are a cornerstone of who is EIC is, how we operate and what will continue to drive our success operating in the North.' About Exchange Income Corporation Exchange Income Corporation is a diversified acquisition-oriented company, focused in two segments: Aerospace & Aviation and Manufacturing. The Corporation uses a disciplined acquisition strategy to identify already profitable, well-established companies that have strong management teams, generate steady cash flow, operate in niche markets and have opportunities for organic growth. For more information on the Corporation, please visit Additional information relating to the Corporation, including all public filings, is available on SEDAR+ ( Caution concerning forward-looking statements The statements contained in this news release that are forward-looking are based on current expectations and are subject to a number of uncertainties and risks, and actual results may differ materially. Many of these forward-looking statements may be identified by looking for words such as 'believes', 'expects', 'will', 'may', 'intends', 'projects', 'anticipates', 'plans', 'estimates', 'continues' and similar words or the negative thereof. These uncertainties and risks include, but are not limited to, external risks, operational risks, financial risks and human capital risks. External risks include, but are not limited to, risks associated with economic and geopolitical conditions, competition, government funding for Indigenous health care, access to capital, market trends and innovation, general uninsured loss, climate, acts of terrorism, armed conflict, labour and/or social unrest, pandemic, level and timing of government spending, government-funded programs and environmental, social and governance. Operational risks include, but are not limited to, significant contracts and customers, operational performance and growth, laws, regulations and standards, acquisitions (including receiving any requisite regulatory approvals thereof), concentration and diversification, maintenance costs, access to parts and relationships with key suppliers, casualty losses, environmental liability, dependence on information systems and technology, cybersecurity, international operations, fluctuations in sales prices of aviation related assets, fluctuations in purchase prices of aviation related assets, warranty, performance guarantees, global offset and intellectual property risks. Financial risks include, but are not limited to, availability of future financing, income tax matters, commodity risk, foreign exchange, interest rates, credit facility and the trust indentures, dividends, unpredictability and volatility of securities pricing, dilution and other credit risk. Human capital risks include, but are not limited to, reliance on key personnel, employees and labour relations and conflicts of interest. Except as required by Canadian Securities Law, Exchange Income Corporation does not undertake to update any forward-looking statements; such statements speak only as of the date made. Further information about these and other risks and uncertainties can be found in the disclosure documents filed by Exchange Income Corporation with the securities regulatory authorities, available at .