Attorney for defendant in fatal OVI crash files motion to suppress blood evidence
In a motion filed Tuesday in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court on behalf of Walter Bolt, 65, of Struthers, attorney Rhys Cartwright-Jones said blood drawn from Bolt after the March 3 crash should be excluded from trial because it was not collected according to state law.
Cartwright-Jones also said the affidavit to get a warrant for the blood draw was not sufficient.
Bolt has been in the Mahoning County jail on $250,000 bond since his arrest after a grand jury indicted him on two counts of aggravated vehicular homicide, a second-degree felony; aggravated vehicular assault, a third-degree felony; and operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, a first-degree misdemeanor.
He is accused of driving drunk on March 3 and causing a head-on crash that killed Angela Brown, 44, and her son, Jason Daff, 15, at state Route 170 and Unity Road in Springfield Township.
Another son of Brown's was injured in the crash and is presently recovering.
Bolt pleaded not guilty to the charges at his arraignment May 19. Court records list a July 9 pretrial hearing and July 14 trial before Judge R. Scott Krichbaum.
Troopers say his blood-alcohol content was .215, over the legal limit of 0.08. At a bond hearing last week before Judge R. Scott Krichbaum, Assistant Prosecutor Steve Maszczak said troopers and police also found several beer cans scattered throughout Bolt's car in the wake of the crash.
In his motion Tuesday, however, Cartwright-Jones said the affidavit written by state troopers from the Canfield Barracks of the Ohio State Highway Patrol requesting a blood draw did not say if those beer cans were open and did not provide a link between the cans and their suspicions that Bolt was drunk.
Although accident reports said Bolt appeared confused after the crash, Cartwright-Jones wrote in his motion that it would be reasonable for someone to appear confused following a head-on collision.
'The warrant application relied heavily on the presence of beer cans and a generalized claim of impairment without confirming the condition of the containers or establishing a clear nexus between any alleged alcohol abuse and the crash,' Cartwright-Jones wrote.
Cartwright-Jones also wrote that the way Bolt's blood was drawn goes against state law because medical records fail to identify who took the blood when Bolt was being treated at St. Elizabeth Health Center or the qualifications of the person who drew the blood.
Also, the state has failed to provide a 'chain of custody' for how the blood got to the state crime lab, or a documented chain of people who had the blood from the time it was taken until the time it got to the lab.
'Really, no one can say how the blood got to the state lab, let alone who took it, let alone whether anyone took the sample in an Administrative Code-compliant way,' Cartwright-Jones wrote.
Prosecutors have yet to file a response.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
She's accused of fleecing $3.6 million from Jackson Foundation. Here is what we know
Charmaine Gatlin was on her way to becoming the top executive of Jackson Health Foundation, the fundraising arm of Miami-Dade County's public hospital system. She received high marks on her evaluations as the nonprofit's chief operating officer and was described by her bosses as a 'highly ethical' leader. 'I always do things for the betterment of the foundation,' Gatlin wrote in her 2021 evaluation. Two years later, she said in another evaluation that she was 'refining and enhancing my skills so that I can lead as President/CEO when the time comes.' In late October, Gatlin's rising star imploded. She was put on paid administrative leave while an internal investigation 'related to potential misconduct' got underway. In early November, she was 'terminated for cause' by the Foundation's chairman. Her termination letter, obtained by the Miami Herald, did not elaborate. Her abrupt dismissal led to an FBI probe and a shocking revelation in May: Gatlin, 52, a Foundation executive over the past decade, was arrested on charges of fleecing $3.6 million from her former employer, fabricating fake invoices from vendors and receiving $1 million in kickbacks from them. She used the money to buy Louis Vuitton and Gucci goods, including a Vuitton bag for $4,350, and had a $15,617 rose gold golf cart delivered to her Weston home, court records show. Her alleged defrauding of the Jackson Health Foundation, however, extended well beyond Miami, according to an indictment. It stretched all the way to Atlanta, where an unnamed 'audiovisual company' and a 'co-conspirator' suspected of collaborating with Gatlin submitted $2 million in 'false and fraudulent' invoices to the Foundation for purported services that were instead provided to a civic organization in Georgia's capital, the indictment says. Atlanta connection While the indictment doesn't identify the company or the co-conspirator, the Herald has learned from multiple sources that Gatlin allegedly schemed with Yergan Jones, the CEO of American Sound Design in Atlanta. Public records obtained by the Herald show Jones' company submitted dozens of invoices to the Jackson Health Foundation that Gatlin approved between 2019 and 2024. The indictment alleges the company's invoices were for 'audiovisual services that did not occur' at Jackson Health System or the Foundation. Instead, the Herald has confirmed those services were provided by Jones' company to the civic organization in Atlanta, which is 100 Black Men of America, with chapters nationwide including South Florida. The indictment further alleges that half of the Foundation's $2 million payments to the audiovisual company were 'returned' by the co-conspirator, Jones, to Gatlin's personal bank account. And 'to conceal the kickbacks,' the indictment says, they 'created false invoices making it appear as though Gatlin did 'event management' for the audiovisual company events' at Jackson Health System or the Foundation. Both Gatlin's defense lawyer, David Howard, and Jones' defense lawyer, Hector Flores, declined to comment. Gatlin pleaded not guilty to multiple conspiracy and fraud charges in mid-June in Miami federal court. Jones did not respond to an emailed inquiry by the Herald, and he has not been charged in the case. David Zambrana, president and chief operating officer of Jackson Health System, recently told its governing board that Jackson 'terminated the employees believed to be involved' in Gatlin's alleged scheme. He did not say how many were fired nor did he identify them. Jackson Health System spokesperson Krysten Brenlla declined to provide more details, saying Jackson 'will not be commenting on ongoing criminal proceedings.' In a statement, the 100 Black Men of America said it was not aware of Gatlin's alleged false invoice and payment kickback scheme with Jones and his audiovisual company, including billing the Jackson Health Foundation for services that his firm instead provided to the Atlanta organization. Jones provided those services to the youth mentoring group for its annual conferences between 2019 and 2024 under a different audiovisual company, American Electronic Entertainment, aka, AEE Productions, 100 Black Men of America confirmed. In fact, 100 Black Men of America said it directly paid Jones' company more than $500,000 for his work, but the organization did not provide details of the payments. '100 Black Men of America, Inc. has no knowledge of Ms. Gatlin's alleged receipt of cash payments or fraudulent invoices being submitted by Ms. Gatlin or any other vendors in the indictment involving Jackson Health Foundation,' the organization said in the statement provided to the Herald, adding that 'Gatlin has never been paid by the 100 BMOA as a 'go-between' to then pay vendors for services provided to 100 BMOA.' Gatlin had worked for 100 Black Men of America from 2009 to 2014 before Jackson's Foundation hired her a decade ago. During her tenure at Jackson, she continued to work with the Atlanta organization as an unpaid volunteer. After the Foundation dismissed Gatlin last November, 100 Black Men of America hired her in January as a contractor for its annual conference in 2025 —but fired her in May when the organization said it learned about her indictment. 'We are fully cooperating with law enforcement and will continue to do so until this matter is concluded,' the organization said. Atlanta lawyer Ronald Freeman, who represents Jones' company, AEE Productions, which provided services to 100 Black Men of America, said it was not the audiovisual company referenced in the Gatlin indictment. In a statement, he said: 'We remain confident that the legal process will fairly and accurately determine the facts.' Fraud and money laundering charges Gatlin, a University of Florida graduate with a bachelor's degree in French, was arrested on May 21 in a town near Savannah where she now lives. The indictment, filed by Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Young, charged her with a single count of conspiring with other individuals to commit wire fraud, 26 counts of wire fraud and five counts of money laundering. If convicted, the charges carry sentences that could send her to prison for years. Gatlin is accused of authorizing Jackson Health Foundation funds to pay not only Jones' audiovisual company in Atlanta but also a store that sold designer goods and an event planning company in South Florida that created videos, a website and other services for a family member's softball team in Broward County, the indictment says. She's also accused of using the Foundation's money to buy school supplies that were delivered to a church in Riceboro, Georgia, where she lives with her husband. After her arrest, Gatlin was granted a $30,000 bond. Court records show that one of the conditions of her bond was not to contact four contractors, including Jones, who 'were paid' by the Jackson Health Foundation based on 'purported invoices for goods and services approved by' Gatlin, according to the indictment. Trail of 'false' invoices By far, Gatlin's dealings with Jones dominated her alleged criminal activity, the Herald has learned from sources and court records. Jones' company, American Sound Design, submitted about 40 invoices to the Foundation that Gatlin approved between 2019 and 2024 for services that his firm says were provided to the Jackson Health Foundation, according to financial documents obtained by the Herald through a public records request. But Jones is better known as the president of AEE Productions, which on its website claims to have done business for major corporations, such as Coca-Cola, Delta Airlines and Walmart, along with NASCAR and 100 Black Men of America. The Jackson Health Foundation was also one of its clients, according to a testimonial by Gatlin, the Foundation's former COO. 'Working with AEE Productions is always an exciting time for me. They listen to my ideas and help me create 'the wow' that I am looking for during each event,' reads an online testimonial by Gatlin on AEE Productions' website. 'I have been working with Yergan and his team for over 15 years and each event is better than the last one.' In the aftermath of her arrest, AEE's website is no longer active. Financial records obtained by the Herald show the Jackson Health Foundation received millions of dollars worth of invoices ranging from $5,900 to $81,500 each from Jones' company. American Sound Design claimed in those bills that it provided lighting, sound, staging and production management services for events at Jackson Health System or the Foundation, the invoices show. But the Gatlin indictment says that Jones' company, though not identified by name, never provided any of these services. And it's unclear from the indictment how many of these events hosted by the Foundation even took place. One American Sound Design invoice for $5,900 was billed to the Jackson Health Foundation for services that Jones' company purportedly provided at the Foundation's annual 'Guardian Angel' luncheon at the Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne in November 2018. The event, which featured a runway fashion show and a performance by Grammy-nominated recording artist Flo-Rida, raised over $500,000 to support the pediatric neurosurgery program at Holtz Children Hospital, part of Jackson Health System. The Herald has confirmed the event happened. But the indictment says Jones' company provided no services. Another American Sound Design invoice for $30,250 was billed to the Foundation for a 'back-to-school block party' that was held at Gibson Charter School in the Overtown Youth Center in August 2019. Academica, which operates the charter school, did not respond to the Herald's attempts to verify if Jones' company provided services for the event. 'Future CEO' Gatlin, who was described as 'future CEO' in one of her earlier evaluations, managed the Jackson Health Foundation's day-to-day operations while it transitioned several years ago into its current leadership structure, where the president's job was split between Gatlin and co-president and chief development officer Flavia Llizo. In 2023, Gatlin had an 'extensive discussion' with Ana Milton and David Coulson, members of the Foundation's volunteer board, and was given a salary increase and bonus, according to her most recent evaluation. The Foundation's executive committee approved the raise. Gatlin's yearly salary as the Foundation's chief operating officer rose to about $300,000 in 2024. When Gatlin was put on administrative paid leave last fall, Llizo became the Foundation's CEO. Caution label for foundation After Gatlin's firing and the subsequent scandal, the Jackson Health Foundation now has a 'Proceed with Caution' label on the website of Charity Navigator, a nonprofit that rates U.S. charities on a variety of measures, including stability, efficiency and sustainability to help people with their donation decisions. The charity rater references Miami Herald and South Florida Sun Sentinel reporting as the reason for the warning. The month-long investigation and subsequent firing of Gatlin in November came after Jackson Health System discovered a 'misappropriation of funds' while 'restructuring' the Foundation's leadership last year to develop stronger oversight and accountability, according to Zambrana, president and COO of Jackson Health System. Zambrana told the Public Health Trust during its May 28 meeting that the health system had 'fully cooperated' with the investigation by the FBI and the U.S. Attorney's office. New safeguards, including additional 'financial controls and administrative oversight,' are now in place over the Foundation and Jackson has 'terminated the employees believed to be involved,' he said. 'The allegations of money stolen from the public's health system are egregious, and we are all still reeling from the profound breach of trust and the impact it has on our team, our community and the many people who support Jackson,' Zambrana said, noting that 'integrity is non-negotiable.' 'We will not allow this incident to jeopardize its reputation or its momentum.'
NBC Sports
3 days ago
- NBC Sports
Former Dolphins safety Reshad Jones has $2.58 million stolen
Former Dolphins safety Reshad Jones had $2.58 million stolen by a 49-year-old woman with the help of a former Merrill Lynch financial advisor, Ryan Mackey of Local 10 News reports. An arrest warrant obtained by the station says Isaiah Williams, Jones' financial advisor from January 2022 to March 2024, stole approximately $1.58 million from Jones' bank account in 133 wire transfers. Williams used the money to pay off two of his American Express credit cards. The money was used to fund first-class airline tickets, hotel stays with multiple women, nightclub tabs, strip clubs, car rentals, designer clothes, jewelry, legal fees as well as child support. He also went on duty-free shopping sprees in Mexico, according to Fort Lauderdale police. Jones had another $1.03 million laundered from his account with help from Octavia Monique Graham, of Dallas, Georgia. Jones told investigators he had never met Graham. Jones is pressing charges, and Graham, who turned herself in Monday, is facing two counts of money laundering and one count of first-degree grand theft. Williams has not been arrested yet, according to court records. Jones, 37, made two Pro Bowls in 10 seasons with the Dolphins and earned $58.1 million.
Chicago Tribune
4 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Chicago man gets 10-year split term for shooting ex-girlfriend in plea
When Desmond Webb filed a motion to withdraw from a plea deal for shooting his ex-girlfriend in the face, Judge Gina Jones said Tuesday she concluded he just wanted to back out. He had three months between when it was filed on Halloween to Jan. 30 to think about it. He had already appeared in court and swore under oath that the plea was accurate. He filed the motion Jan. 29. 'I think that's what happened,' Jones told Webb. 'Maybe I can beat these cases.' That's legally 'not a reason' to quash a plea, she said. 'It's called buyer's remorse.' Webb, 38, of Chicago, signed a plea deal Oct. 31 for aggravated battery, a Level 3 felony. It called for a 10-year cap. Jones denied his bid to throw out the plea Tuesday. She sentenced him to eight years in prison, and two years in Lake County Community Corrections. One of those final years is eligible for home detention. He is also ordered to finish an anger management course and batterer's intervention. Court records allege he stalked the woman, then shot her just below her left eye on Oct. 27, 2022 as she got out of a black Audi in the alley on the 5600 block of Hohman Avenue in Hammond near a beauty school where she worked. Her child and new boyfriend were also in the car. They were not physically hurt. The shooting left her permanently disfigured — with an artificial eye. Since Webb appeared in court last fall, the case was in 'limbo,' his new lawyer Joe Roberts, who picked up the case in January, said in court. Ultimately, Webb blamed his first lawyer Lakeisha Murdaugh, who undertook complex negotiations for the plea deal, saying he had ineffective counsel and had contacted the state's disciplinary commission for attorneys. His client's understanding was that he would have to take the plea deal, or restart alone. 'He felt like he was backed into a corner,' Roberts said. Later in the hearing, Deputy Prosecutor Judy Massa defended Murdaugh, saying it was documented that their relationship became strained and she did her due diligence as his lawyer. Massa noted Murdaugh said in court that she reviewed the plea agreement with Webb, his mother and siblings, prepared a memorandum and made sure he knew the risks of going to trial. It was a 'difficult case to navigate with him,' Massa said. 'It sounds like what he's trying to do now is to get a better plea offer.' A trial was not ideal for the victim, the prosecutor said. She 'never wants to see him' and has since moved out-of-state. Jones said lawyers told her the plea was a compromise, after 'evidentiary issues,' 'heavy negotiations,' and the fact that Webb was on bond during the shooting. Massa said the former couple dated on-and-off for eight years and the case was a 'textbook version of domestic violence.' Webb fired nine shots, luckily missing her new boyfriend and the child. She asked for 10 years. 'He was totally out of control,' she said, 'and tried to kill her.' Two other cases for stalking and invasion of privacy involved the same woman and would be dismissed with the plea, she noted. Roberts said various factors, including an Illinois warrant, made him eligible for only prison or probation. Webb trained as a chef and was 'eager to return to his profession.' Imprisonment would harm his kids, the lawyer said. Webb spoke briefly, saying the court 'did the best' they could with the facts and he just wanted to get back to his family. 'I just hate' that no one in the court system deterred you from getting to this point, Jones said. A 'light bulb' should have gone off before you 'escalated' to the shooting. Near the end of the hearing, Webb said that the woman came to see him even as there was a no-contact order, including one time when he was hospitalized. I get that, Jones told him, but you had a legal responsibility to stay away from her. Roberts said Webb would 'sleep on' whether he would appeal.
