Judge finds ‘Utah Fits All' scholarship unconstitutional, legislature to review options
The suit, brought by the Utah Education Association, originally claimed that the scholarship program was unconstitutional because the program used funds from Utah's income tax, which is earmarked exclusively for public education funding.
It further claimed that the Utah Constitution guarantees that all children will be included in public education, and that the school voucher program did not do this.
PREVIOUS: UEA files lawsuit against controversial school voucher program, claims it's unconstitutional
The court agreed with both points, saying, 'The legislature does not have plenary authority to circumvent these constitutional requirements by simply declining to 'designate' the program as part of the public education system. And because there is no genuine dispute that the program fails to meet these 'open to all children' and 'free' requirements, it is unconstitutional under article X of the Utah Constitutional.'
'In reaching this conclusion, the court makes no judgement as to the value of 'school choice' or private school vouchers,' The ruling continues. 'But 'school choice' or vouchers for children without disabilities was never discuss, much less debated, in connection with the legislatures passage of Amendment G. And, more importantly, the voters were never informed that Amendment G was about 'school choice' or vouchers for children without disabilities.'
In a statement to ABC4.com, UEA Communications Director Hailey Higgins said, 'The Utah Education Association celebrates today's court ruling deeming the Utah Fits All voucher program unconstitutional. This is a significant victory for public education and a reaffirmation that public money belongs in public schools.'
Rep. Candice Pierucci (R-South Jordan), the original sponsor of the Utah Fits All program, called the decision made by Judge Laura S. Scott 'judicial activism,' and says she is not done fighting.
'This past year, thousands of families have had access to the Utah Fits All Scholarship Program to customize their child's learning experience,' Pierucci's statement reads. 'The decision made by Judge Scott is judicial activism; it is not the job of judiciary to set policy on the bench and infuse personal opinion and ideology into their decisions. We are not done fighting this fight and will appeal this decision to the Utah Supreme Court.'
Utah legislative leadership and Governor began to weigh in after the ruling was rendered. Senate President J. Stuart Adams saying in a statement, 'It is disappointing that the court would remove parents' ability to choose the best educational path for their children. However, we remain unwavering in our commitment to providing the best education for all Utah families and kids. We will carefully review the court's decision and then determine the next steps.'
Speaker Mike Schultz shared similar sentiments calling the decision a 'devastating setback' for Utahns.
'This decision is a devastating setback for Utah families,' Schultz began. 'The Utah Fits All Scholarship isn't just about choice; it's about empowering parents to secure the best possible learning environments for their children's future success. We're unwavering in our commitment to ensuring that every Utah student, irrespective of zip code or income, has equal access to the educational opportunities they rightfully deserve. We will vigorously pursue every avenue, including the Utah Supreme Court, to overturn this decision and restore hope for Utah's students and families.'
In a statement on X, formerly known as Twitter, Governor Cox expressed disappointment in the decision, saying that Utah Families had a right to make choices about their children's education, and said they will be reviewing ruling with legal staff.
'While we are disappointed in the court's decision, our commitment to Utah families and their right to make choices about their children's education remains unchanged,' Cox said. 'We will be reviewing the ruling without attorneys and preparing to appeal.'
At this time, details are limited on what an appeal would look like. A status conference is scheduled for the decision on April 23. It is also currently unknown how the decision will affect ongoing voucher payments to current recipients.
This is a developing story. ABC4 will update this post as new information becomes available.
Judge finds 'Utah Fits All' scholarship unconstitutional, legislature to review options
Appeals court halts Boasberg's contempt proceedings against Trump administration
Meet 'Safety Stache': UFA shares fire safety messages with a touch of humor
Clearer skies arriving this weekend
Utahn recalls largest Good Friday earthquake, the largest in U.S. history
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17-07-2025
- Yahoo
Utah Supreme Court case could redefine citizen power in Utah
The Utah Supreme Court on Wednesday accepted an extraordinary writ regarding the power of citizens to propose and pass ballot initiatives in the state. The request, asking for clarification on the state's decision, was seen as a victory for the Citizens Initiative Reform Committee, following the lieutenant governor's denial of three of the four initiatives the group had previously filed. The issue revolves around whether Utah citizens genuinely possess power equal to the legislature — as the Utah Constitution indicates — or if officials can obstruct or weaken initiatives they oppose. 'If the court rules in our favor, it finally addresses and answers the question in Gallivan v. Walker: How are the people equal to and or superior" to the state legislature, Steve Maxfield, chairman of Citizens Initiative Reform Committee, told the Deseret News. 'No way, shape, or form have we been treated like equals.' The four main citizen initiatives filed by committee aimed to bring significant changes to Utah law: Initiative and referendum rules. GRAMA (open government/public records laws). Revenue and taxation. Land use laws. According to a press release obtained by the Deseret News, each initiative 'fundamentally alter(ed) and reform(ed) how Utah's government conducts the People's business.' Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson's office only allowed one initiative to move forward, blocking three others, resulting in Citizens Initiative Reform Committee going to the Utah Supreme Court requesting the justices 'to overturn Henderson's interference, restore the timeline for all four initiatives, and pause the enactment/enforcement of any 2025 legislative bills that impact these subjects,' per the press release. Henderson's office told the Deseret News it will not comment on pending or active litigation. Utah's citizen initiative process is among the strictest in the nation. To get a law on the ballot, an individual or group must gather signatures from at least 8% of active registered voters across the state, with requirements met in at least 26 of Utah's 29 Senate districts. Maxfield stated that millions of dollars are invested in grassroots efforts to create citizen-driven action, and that Utah's initiative laws infringe on their rights as American citizens under the 14th Amendment to institute real change. 'We are aiming at a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that the people's legislative power right to reform, alter or abolish the government is unfettered and unrestricted. It is my intent to force reform. If they resist, they will be abolished.' Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
19-06-2025
- Yahoo
Poll: Almost two-thirds of Utahns support contentious ‘Utah Fits All' school voucher program
While the fate of the Utah Fits All Scholarship program will likely be decided by the Utah Supreme Court, the divisive school voucher program appears to have fairly wide public support. In a Deseret News/Hinckley Institute Poll conducted last month, 805 Utah registered voters were asked if they support or oppose 'Utah Fits All.' Almost two-thirds — 62% — responded positively. Meanwhile, 31% voiced opposition — while 8% responded, 'Don't know.' In 2023, the Utah Legislature created the 'Utah Fits All Scholarship,' which allows parents to apply for up to $8,000 in state funding that can be used for homeschooling, to attend private school, or toward other education providers. Some have argued the scholarship takes money away from the public education system. Others say it allows parents more flexibility in determining their children's education. While over 60% of poll responders voiced some level of support for 'Utah Fits All,' only 28% said they 'strongly support' the program. The other 34% 'somewhat support' it. On the flip side, 16% of poll responders were in the 'strongly oppose' camp — just a single percentage point more than those who 'somewhat oppose' the 'Utah Fits All Scholarship' program. The results of the recent Deseret News/Hinckley Institute poll seem to reflect the divisiveness regarding school vouchers across the country. Locally, the program has faced spirited debate at the Utah Capitol, across the opinion pages and inside the courtrooms. In 2023, the state was sued by the Utah Education Association and several individual plaintiffs after the school voucher program was enacted — giving eligible K-12 students up to $8,000 a year for private school tuition and other costs. Utah Fits All went into effect last fall. The teachers union and its fellow petitioners argued that the program violated the Utah Constitution because it diverts income tax revenue to fund private schools. In April, 3rd District Judge Laura Scott ruled that the school voucher program currently being utilized by thousands of Utah children was, indeed, unconstitutional. The judge said that because the Utah Fits All program is created by the Legislature and a publicly funded educational program, it must satisfy the constitutional requirements applicable to the 'public education system' set forth in the Utah Constitution. The Legislature, added Scott, does not have the authority 'to circumvent these constitutional requirements by simply declining to 'designate' the program as part of the public education system.' The judge agreed with the union and other plaintiffs in her April ruling, saying the program violated sections of the state Constitution that require the state to fund a public education system open to every student that is free of charge, and to use state income tax to fund public schools and to support children and people with disabilities. Proponents of the program had argued the program did not affect the state's system of public schools, but was in addition to that constitutional requirement, and that it cleared the bar of using income tax to support children. Scott would later rule that the school voucher program could continue pending the expected defendants' appeal before the Utah Supreme Court. The judge also ruled, in May, on a couple of outstanding 'claims for relief' issued by the plaintiffs. Scott's follow-up actions essentially allowed the defendants in the case against Utah Fits All — which includes Utah Gov. Spencer Cox and Utah Attorney General Derek Brown — to move forward with the appeals process. Since last month, the Utah Fits All Scholarship program has been administered by Odyssey, a national technology company. During this year's Utah legislative session, some new funding guidelines and accountability guardrails were put in place under HB455. Homeschooled 'Utah Fits All' students 5 to 11 years old will have access to $4,000 a year, while those 12 to 18 years old will get $6,000. Private school students are still eligible for $8,000 a year, the previous amount available to all. The new law also limits extracurricular expenses to 20% of the scholarship amount and limits physical education expenses to an additional 20%.
Yahoo
16-06-2025
- Yahoo
Utahns remember local fashion designer killed in protest
SALT LAKE CITY, Utah (ABC4) — Earlier today, Salt Lake City Police identified the victim killed in Saturday's shooting during a 'No Kings' protest in downtown Salt Lake City. Police say Arthur Folasa Ah Loo, 39, was hit and killed by a stray bullet during yesterday's protest by a 'peacekeeper' volunteer. The volunteer told police they fired at Arturo Roberto after spotting him with an AR-15 style rifle. Shooting victim in SLC 'No Kings' protest dies in hospital Ah Loo was taken to the hospital after the shooting but died from their injuries. According to a GoFundMe set up for the family, Ah Loo — also known as 'Afa' — was well known with his work with the nonprofit Creative Pacific Foundation and as a fashion designer here in Utah. Ah Loo appeared several times on Good Things Utah as a guest to showcase his designs and promote Pacific Islander events in the community. Utah Rep. Doug Fiefia remebered Ah Loo in a post on social media: 'Heartbroken by the tragic loss of Afa Ah Loo. My prayers are with his family, friends, and all who knew him. He was a bright light in our Polynesian community and will be deeply missed. May his loved ones feel peace and comfort during this difficult time.' Utah Rep. Tyler Clancy also issued a statement on social media: 'My heart goes out to the Ah Loo family at this time. Afa was a wonderful man & father who looked out for his community. Sending all of the love and prayers.' Here is Ah Loo's most recent appearance on Good Things Utah three weeks ago: Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
