Charity hits out at 'fundamentally inaccurate' warnings about draft Mental Health Bill
A row has broken out over the impact of the draft Mental Health Bill with the national charity SHINE saying warnings of negative impacts are 'fundamentally inaccurate'.
The draft bill was published last year to much concern from psychiatrists and will be discussed at the first sitting of the Oireachtas Health Committee on Wednesday.
The Irish Medical Organisation (IMO) is expected to criticise criteria for involuntary admission, timing of patients' psychosocial assessment, and care plan regulations.
Professor Matthew Sadlier, a psychiatrist and chair of the IMO consultants committee, is due to say: 'Effectively, where a patient is found to lack capacity to consent to treatment, the bill would lead to a situation where rather than treating patients, consultants will be required to make an application to the High Court to get permission to do so.'
He is expected to warn that patients with serious mental illness could be denied 'the right to timely and often life-saving medical treatment'.
He is also due to discuss the practicalities of the proposals and is expected to say, while around 760 psychiatrists are needed, Ireland only has 570 approved posts, with almost 30% unfilled or filled on a temporary basis.
However SHINE CEO, Nicola Byrne, has raised concerns about 'deeply stigmatising language and worrying predictions' used in discussions over the last few months.
'Claims that the bill abandons individuals with severe mental illness or removes the ability to intervene when someone is unwell and lacks the capacity to understand their situation or the need for help are fundamentally inaccurate,' she said.
"This legislation aims to provide a clearer, more rights-respecting framework for involuntary mental healthcare.'
She defended the proposed admission criteria, saying: 'The legislation is designed to intervene when a mental disorder presents specific risks or urgent treatment needs.'
There are already 'significant safeguards' in the Bill, she argued.
'What is too often missing from these discussions is the reality that the vast majority of people living with psychosis or schizophrenia are not in crisis, they are studying, working, parenting, volunteering, and contributing to their communities like anyone else,' she said.
Read More
Suzanne Crowe: People with severe mental illness will be failed by proposed new law
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
5 days ago
- Irish Examiner
How will seven-day a week healthcare work in reality?
What changes will patients and health staff see now that the HSE and unions have agreed on working over seven days instead of mainly Monday-Friday? The big change will be more staff at weekends to help address spikes in overcrowding and target waiting lists. However, do not get excited just yet, as staff were told of a lead-in time of at least 63 days in a circular issued on Monday. Thousands who now work Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, will move to working five days across a seven-day roster. Hours will extend from 8am to 8pm. It could also see more patients discharged home at weekends. However as many elderly people know it is very hard to get homecare at weekends already, so how will sudden hospital discharges be supported? We asked about this, and services such as Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (Camhs) and the Integrated Care Programme for Older Persons, however the HSE said only they are working on: 'plans to introduce extended working arrangements in the areas with most need and these requirements will vary from site to site'. CEO Bernard Gloster was in Cork on Tuesday to discuss having some weekend clinics up and running by August. Expanding clinic hours and reducing patient delays are his priorities, the HSE said. It is voluntary. However, managers were advised to assign people to new rosters if necessary by HSE chief people officer Anne Marie Hoey in the circular seen by the Irish Examiner. This all follows Forsa, just last month, finding that 68% of members describe staff morale as either 'low' or 'terrible'. The long hangover from the pandemic years, coupled with recruitment challenges and a growing number of patients, have left many exhausted. Despite this, the pressures to make savings and slash waiting times are only growing, including from the productivity and savings taskforce, amidst a record budget of €26.9m which is seen as not reducing delays quickly enough. Forsa expects local managers' proposals for each site will make the practicalities clearer. 'It remains our position that while these proposals can work in some areas, the resource challenges in other areas may inhibit efforts to extend services,' a spokesman said on Tuesday. A similar fear was expressed by the Irish Medical Organisation (IMO). 'The IMO is not ideologically opposed to extended services, but their introduction cannot be based on robbing Peter to pay Paul where there may be a reduction in services on other days,' said consultants committee chair Dr Matthew Sadlier. All unions, including Siptu, have called for urgent investment in staffing. Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said the plans are 'a major, major reform' which she expects to reduce waiting lists. She expects to see evening outpatient clinics and more scans at weekends. 'We want to get to the point where we are using our theatres on Saturdays, spreading into Sundays,' she told RTÉ. The minister said the move will include community services without specifying which ones. She also brought the Patient Safety (Licensing) Bill before Cabinet on Tuesday. This could address problems such as use of unapproved springs in children's spinal surgery at Temple Street hospital, she expects. The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation called for this legislation to include a legal requirement for safe nursing and midwifery staffing levels. Read More HSE reaches deal with unions to extend hospital hours and tackle overcrowding
The Journal
5 days ago
- The Journal
Seven-day roster is 'robbing Peter to pay Paul', say consultants, as staffing still a pain point
CONSULTANTS HAVE EQUATED the health minister's decision to spread outpatient services across seven days with 'robbing Peter to pay Paul'. Minister Jennfier Carroll MacNeill today announced that thousands of healthcare staff – including senior consultants, social workers, administrative employees and therapists – will have to work weekends in an effort to curb overcrowding and reduce waiting times. The Irish Medical Organisation's (IMO) Consultant's Committee says, despite the minister's plans, no new rostering arrangements outside of existing contracts can be invoked. 'There has been no change to the contractual provisions already in place; consultants on the new public-only contract may be rostered over six days from Monday to Saturday. 'Meanwhile, those on older contracts may be rostered in line with their contractual provisions.' Professor Matthew Sadlier said they recognise the need to extend services to the weekend, but the presence of staff on these days will not be enough to alleviate the long delays for patients. 'We desperately need to see wholescale recruitment of staff and the elimination of the effective recruitment freeze,' he said. 'We also need greater capacity in acute beds so that all patients, once deemed ill enough to be admitted, can be moved to an appropriate bed and treated in the right setting.' Professor Sadlier warned that weekend rostering cannot come at the expense of weekday treatment. 'The IMO is not ideologically opposed to extended services, but their introduction cannot be based on robbing Peter to pay Paul where there may be a reduction in services on other days. 'If the HSE and government want extended services, they must invest in workforce and capacity and ensure that all services are safe for those working in them and using them.' Sinn Féin's health spokesperson David Cullinane said weekend rostering is a step in the right direction, but existing staff shouldn't be burdened by an increased workload. Advertisement 'This change by itself will see more staff working at weekends, but without additional staff it will mean less staff working during the week,' said Cullinane. 'The HSE must ensure that there is the same level of productivity and quality of care delivered whether it is during the week or at the weekend. More staff working ordinary contracted hours at the weekend and during the evenings is the best way to achieve this. 'Tinkering around the edges will only give the appearance of change, but it will not solve the waiting list crisis.' The health minister said the new arrangements will create a 'more spread out and stable hospital system'. Carroll MacNeill told RTÉ's News at One that those visiting hospitals this week will notice a 'huge difference' in the contrast of activity between weekdays and weekends. 'I've heard this argument from consultants: If you come in on Saturday, we won't be available another day. I already know that.' She said it's about having the same standard of care available every day of the week. The plan means more appointments for scans and other diagnostic activities will take place in the evenings and on weekends, with the hope of eventually having theatres operating on weekends too. MacNeill says she will now engage with hospital managers and clinical leadership about how the expanded roster can be implemented. She is to hold a conference in the Department of Health in September to hear how hospitals are finding the changes. The Irish Hospital Consultants Association (IHCA) says they 'have no issues' working weekends and 'have done so for decades', but they welcome the provision of additional support staffing at weekends to help deliver care. 'However, it must be acknowledged that there is a finite number of consultants in the system. Simply rearranging rosters does not address the underlying and chronic issues facing our health service,' a spokesperson said. 'The core problem remains a capacity crisis — a shortage of beds, staff, and facilities — and any initiative that suggests otherwise risks creating a misleading sense of reassurance.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
6 days ago
- Irish Independent
Large turnout for dawn Wexford tractor run raising mental health awareness
The tractor run was organised by farmer Patrick Hipwell and was created in inspiration of the Darkness into Light walk which raises funds for Pieta House, a charity supporting those affected by suicide and self-harm. At 4.30 a.m. 100 tractors and drivers set off for their route across the nine stones before returning to the community centre for early morning refreshments and a chat. Speaking on why he chose this specific route, he said that he believed it demonstrated a message he was trying to convey. "Since we had to go up Mount Leinster, the message is about giving it time and allowing yourself to get over the humps in life. Life will move again.' He added that it was great to see such a great show of community from within and outside the county. "We had a full house even at 3.30 a.m. and there were drivers from Carlow and Kilkenny who saw the event on social media and decided to join. It was very successful. It was unreal to also have around 30 – 40 young people as well.' Also in attendance was MEP for the South constituency Cynthia Ní Mhurchu, Enniscorthy councillor Pat Kehoe, Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy and IFA deputy president Alice Doyle. Over €2,300 was raised and was shared between Slaney Search and Rescue, Ballindaggin Community Development Group, Caim Community Development Group, Kiltealy Men and Women's Shed, Awareness Head to Toe, and Shine's green ribbon. Awareness Head to Toe is a voluntary organisation formed to promote mental health across rural farming communities while Shine's green ribbon campaign is the national stigma reduction programme for Ireland. "People are already talking about doing it next year. It is amazing what we can achieve when the community works together,' he said.
