Why Millions of Student Borrowers Could See a Big Drop in Their Credit Scores - Your Money Briefing
Full Transcript
This transcript was prepared by a transcription service. This version may not be in its final form and may be updated.
Ariana Aspuru: Hey, Your Money Briefing listeners, this is Ariana Aspuru. Here at YMB, we're all about bringing you important personal finance and career news. We're working on making some changes to the show and we want to hear from you. Our question today is, what kinds of life issues, related to money, do you want to hear more about? If you're listening on Spotify, look for our poll under the episode description, or you can send us an email to ymb@wsj.com, that's Y-M-B at W-S-J dot com. Now onto the show. Here's Your Money Briefing for Wednesday, April 2nd. I'm Ariana Aspuru for the Wall Street Journal. Now that pandemic-era protections are over, more than 9 million student loan borrowers could see their credit scores tank.
Oyin Adedoyin: We reported that about 43% of borrowers, who owe payments on federal student loans, hadn't resumed making them. And that was according to an analysis of government data by VantageScore, a credit score provider. So that's millions of people who are either seeing that their credit scores are dropping pretty dramatically, or on track to see those drops in the coming months.
Ariana Aspuru: We'll talk with Wall Street Journal reporter, Oyin Adedoyin, about what borrowers need to know if they're at risk. That's after the break. The pause on student loan payments helped borrowers' credit scores for years, but that's over and they're now in jeopardy. Wall Street Journal reporter, Oyin Adedoyin, joins me to talk about it. Oyin, you reported that student loan delinquency rates have hit a new high. What exactly is driving this surge?
Oyin Adedoyin: It's a host of things. So for student loan borrowers, many of them haven't had to pay for their student loans in years. First, the pandemic hit, which caused there to be a pause on student loan repayments, then the Biden administration released a host of policies aimed at making student loans more affordable, lowering monthly payments for borrowers, and for some borrowers, pausing those payments altogether. So earlier this year, the education department had to start reporting delinquent student loans to credit bureaus, and that is what is causing this drop in credit scores for borrowers.
Ariana Aspuru: So how long has it been since loan payments have resumed? How long has it taken for that to hit people's credit scores?
Oyin Adedoyin: The pandemic-era of relief on student loans was extended in 2022. And then in 2023, borrowers were placed in a 12-month on-ramp period. So that meant that they could start paying their student loans, but if for some reason they missed a payment or they didn't have the money that month, it wouldn't negatively affect their credit score. Now, in the fall of last year, that is when the 90-day clock started, before the education department had to start reporting those delinquent loans to the credit bureaus. And student loans are really interesting because they don't get reported when they're 30 days late or 60 days late, they only get reported when they're 90 days late. So by then you would've missed at least three payments.
Ariana Aspuru: Let's talk about the numbers. I want to know what kind of credit score drops are we seeing?
Oyin Adedoyin: So the interesting thing about this is that people with higher credit scores get hit the worst when they have a delinquency for their student loans. For example, those with a credit score of 760 or above, were expected to see an average credit score decline of 171 points after student loan delinquency. By comparison, those with credit scores of less than 620, were only expected to see an average drop of 87 points. And those are estimates from the New York Fed.
Ariana Aspuru: How many borrowers are being affected by this?
Oyin Adedoyin: More than 9 million student loan borrowers are set to see their credit scores drop in the first half of this year, and that's according to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. We reported that about 43% of borrowers, who owe payments on federal student loans, hadn't resumed making them. And that was according to an analysis of government data by VantageScore, a credit score provider. So that's millions of people who are either seeing that their credit scores were dropping pretty dramatically, or on track to see those drops in the coming months.
Ariana Aspuru: And you mentioned in your story that past-due balances are now higher than they were before the pandemic. Why is that?
Oyin Adedoyin: Before the pandemic, the share of past-due balances had hovered near 14% throughout 2019, and that's because the pause on payments also led to a pause on delinquency reports. So a lot of people saw a boost in credit scores. A lot of people during the pandemic also benefited from stimulus payments, and so people were actually able to maybe pay down debt that they owed. And so overall credit health looked a lot better in the pandemic. And after payments resumed, the volume of past-due loans quickly returned back to pre-pandemic levels. And today it's reached a new high of 15.6%. So that means more than 250 billion in delinquent debt held by 9.7 million borrowers. And the people who I spoke to said this was a time for reprioritizing for them. They knew that their student loan payments weren't going to be counted, and so they said, "Let me pay down this mortgage debt, or save up for a car, or pay down my credit card debt." So they were basically shifting their priorities and putting student loans on the back.
Ariana Aspuru: What's the easiest way for someone who has student loans and wants to make sure that their credit doesn't get hit by accidentally missing them?
Oyin Adedoyin: Interestingly enough, a lot of borrowers found out this was happening because they had apps like Credit Karma or CreditWise already on their phones. So people today actually have easier access to information like their credit score. Most people's banks have free credit checking services, so you can see every time you check your banking app, what your credit score is. And a lot of people have those notifications already set, and that's something that financial advisors do recommend you keep your notifications on for your credit score so that you know when there's a change. And then you can see in your credit report why that change is happening.
Ariana Aspuru: If this has hit your credit score, what can you do? Can you dispute it?
Oyin Adedoyin: Credit experts say that if you are experiencing this, the first thing you should do is pay that overdue balance. If there is an error in the credit report, like it's not accurate, you did make that payment and you have the paperwork to back it up, then you should definitely dispute it. But if it is accurate, a dispute may not always work. Credit experts say that you should contact your student loan servicer and try to get placed in a forbearance or a deferment on your loan. So that means that you're not going to be charged that monthly fee, especially if you don't have the income to support it. Student loans are really unique because you can't get rid of them with bankruptcy, they're pretty sticky in that way. And a delinquency for student loans in your credit report could last for up to seven years. So credit experts are really encouraging borrowers not to ignore it and wait for it to go away.
Ariana Aspuru: Is this something that we've ever seen in the past, when it comes to student loan payments?
Oyin Adedoyin: Well, the volume of past-due loans have returned to and exceeded pre-pandemic levels. So this is something of a record high when it comes to past-due student loan balances, and we're still waiting to see what long-term effects this may have. But this does stand to have pretty significant economic impacts. It could lead to a chilling effect on spending, or big ticket purchases for young people in their 20s and 30s.
Ariana Aspuru: That's WSJ reporter, Oyin Adedoyin. And that's it for Your Money Briefing. This episode was produced by me, with supervising producer, Melony Roy. Additional help from Dalvin Brown. I'm Ariana Aspuru for the Wall Street Journal. Thanks for listening.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Wall Street Journal
6 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Musk Taps Into Private Credit to Fund AI Ambitions - What's News
Full Transcript This transcript was prepared by a transcription service. This version may not be in its final form and may be updated. Alex Ossola: Elon Musk is turning to new funding sources to keep pace in the artificial intelligence race. Plus, private credit firms are seeking in-house lawyers as their deals get more complex. Isaac Taylor: A few years ago, private credit mainly referred to middle market direct lending, and now it encompasses everything from asset-based lending all the way to collateralized loan obligations and BDCs. Alex Ossola: And discord over the Jeffrey Epstein investigation brings the House of Representatives to a standstill. It's Tuesday, July 22nd. I'm Alex Ossola for The Wall Street Journal. This is the P.M. Edition of What's News, the top headlines and business stories that move the world today. In an exclusive, we're reporting that xAI, Elon Musk's artificial intelligence startup is looking to secure up to $12 billion to fuel its ambitious expansion plants. That's according to people familiar with the situation. The money would be used to buy a massive supply of advanced Nvidia chips that would be leased to xAI for a new jumbo-sized data center. Meant to help train and power the AI chatbot Grok. Valor Equity Partners, an investment firm whose founder Antonio Gracias has closed ties to Musk is in talks with lenders to raise the capital. Musk needs all the financial firepower he can get to stay competitive in a wild and costly AI battle with well-funded rivals like Google, Microsoft, and Meta. Grok hasn't gained nearly as much traction as OpenAI's ChatGPT. The funding push comes just weeks after the company raised $10 billion through sales of stock and debt. With xAI's balance sheet already stretched, Musk is getting creative to keep the money flowing. SpaceX recently invested $2 billion into xAI, effectively moving cash from the coffers of one Musk company to fund another. People familiar with the situation said that for the $5 billion in debt xAI raised in June, the company pledged its most prized asset, the intellectual property behind Grok as part of the collateral. General Motors reported that new tariffs on imported cars and auto parts took a 1.1 billion dollars bite out of its bottom line and net income shrank 35% in the second quarter. Chris Otts covers autos for The Journal and joins me now. Chris, how are President Trump's tariffs weighing on the industry? Chris Otts: This is really the first look. GM is the biggest automaker in the U.S., both by volume and market share. And Trump's tariffs came on in early April. So this quarterly results that are starting to flow in really give us the first kind of full picture of what this is going to mean for the industry. They said the impact could be a little bit greater even in the third quarter. Most analysts see the auto industries slowing down in the second half of the year, which is adding to the pressure. Alex Ossola: Are consumers yet feeling the price increases potentially from some of these tariffs? Chris Otts: There have been some price increases here and there, but for the large part, automakers have actually avoided raising prices. In GM's case, they've been quite explicit that they want to keep things consistent. And for them, the prospect of Trump reaching a deal with Mexico, Canada, and or Korea could really go a long way to getting them out of the tariff problems. So there really hasn't been much discernible impact yet. Most analysts think that in the long run, this situation can't hold you, just can't add these structural costs and not expect them to ripple through the market. Alex Ossola: That was WSJ reporter Chris Otts. Thank you so much, Chris. Chris Otts: Thank you. Alex Ossola: The U.S. reached trade pacts with the Philippines and Indonesia today, while Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell should finish out his term if he so decides. Major U.S. stock indexes ended the day mixed. The S&P 500 Rose 0.1%, giving it another record high. The Dow rose 0.4% and the Nasdaq retreated 0.4% from yesterday's record weighed down by such as Nvidia. Furor over disclosures from the Jeffrey Epstein investigation brought the House of Representatives to a standstill today. Republican leadership has cut short this week's session and put off any action until September as some GOP members demanded votes on more releases related to the disgraced financier and sex offender. Washington has been gripped by the fallout from the Justice Department's decision earlier this month to refuse to release more documents from the Federal Bureau of Investigation probe of Epstein. At a news conference, House Speaker Mike Johnson called for, "Maximum transparency around the investigation," but said he wanted to give the Trump administration space to handle the issue. Mike Johnson: He has now ordered his DOJ to do what it is we've all needed DOJ to do for years now, and that is to get everything released. So they're in the process of that. There's no purpose for Congress to push an administration to do something that they're already doing. Alex Ossola: Earlier, a senior Justice Department official said he would seek to interview Epstein's longtime associate Ghislaine Maxwell, who's serving a 20-year prison sentence for sex trafficking. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche said that he had contacted Maxwell's lawyer to see if she would be willing to speak with federal prosecutors. A lawyer for Maxwell confirmed in a post on X that they're in discussions with the government and thanked President Donald Trump for, "His commitment to uncovering the truth in this case." Asked by reporters at a meeting with Filipino President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., President Trump said he wasn't aware of Justice Department plans to interview Maxwell. Donald Trump: Yeah, I don't know about it, but I think it's something that would be... Sounds appropriate to do. Yeah. Speaker 6: Do you have any concern that your Deputy Attorney General is your former attorney would be conducting the interview given- Donald Trump: No, I have no concern. He's a very talented person. He's very smart. I didn't know that they were going to do it. I don't really follow that too much. It's sort of a witch hunt... Alex Ossola: Coming up, choosing to buy now, pay later on an expensive purchase, your bank might punish you for it. More after the break. The option to buy now pay later with companies like Affirm or Klarna is becoming an increasingly popular way for consumers to pay for everyday goods like groceries. But banks are wary of them. And now they're saying that binging on buy now, pay later might actually hurt your chances of getting approved for a mortgage or credit card. WSJ personal economics reporter, Imani Moise joins me now with more. Imani, how can buy now, pay later affect your credit? Imani Moise: It really depends. Right now, it seems like it can go both ways. So FICO, the largest credit scoring agency in the US announced last month that they are rolling out a new model that can actually incorporate buy now, pay later data into your credit score, which is the first time you're going to see these types of loans impact your credit score directly. And really the first time FICO has had to update a model specifically to accommodate a new kind of loan. That's how fast this thing is growing. But according to that new model, the average buy now, pay later user will actually see their score increase. But what banks are saying is that as this data gets reported, they're going to scrutinize it a little bit more and it actually might hurt your chances of getting approved. Alex Ossola: So why are banks worried about buy now, pay later? Imani Moise: Mostly because it's growing so quickly. And historically, buy now, pay later hasn't been reported to credit bureaus, which means that banks really do not have an independent way of seeing how much debt potential borrowers are taking on. Some banks have called it phantom debt, which means that it's harder for them to measure risk and figure out how much credit, whether it's a credit card, mortgage, auto loan, anything else they should extend to a customer because they can't see how much other debt they might already have. It's also a threat to their business model because a lot of buy now, pay later plans are zero interest. So as buy now, pay later becomes more popular, people are less likely to use credit cards, which is a big profit driver for the banks as well. Alex Ossola: So banks that are worried about this, what are they doing? Imani Moise: Some lenders are being more proactive than others. I spoke with one credit union that's actually proactively reaching out to customers when they notice heavy buy now, pay later use in their transaction history because in their view, they think their products are safer for consumers because it does come with a higher personal touch in terms of counseling. And they're afraid that some of their customers are going to get in over their head because it's so easy to apply for buy now, pay later. And some big banks have moved to block their customers from repaying buy now, pay later loans with their credit card. But at the same time, some of these banks are launching their own products that look very much like buy now, pay later. For example, on Chase credit cards, they have something called pay over time, which lets you separate transactions or individual purchases into installment payments, which is effectively what buy now pay, later is. Alex Ossola: That was WSJ reporter, Imani Moise. Thanks, Imani. Imani Moise: Thank you. Alex Ossola: We've talked before on the show about the rise of private credit, loans provided by non-bank lenders. Now to facilitate their work, private credit firms are increasingly building up their own staple of in-house legal talent. For more, I'm joined now by WSJ Pro reporter Isaac Taylor. Isaac, why are some of these private credit firms doing this? Isaac Taylor: It's really because of a rise in deal-making complexity and also regulatory compliance complexity as well. And this demand has really been driven by fundraising needs, firm growth and a surge in deal volume within the private credit sector. And as private credit has grown, the breadth of what is being done in-house has expanded so much that a lot of these firms are realizing that maybe they didn't have the in-house technical skills or knowledge and they're really looking to expand that talent pool now. Alex Ossola: And where are they looking to find this expertise? Isaac Taylor: A lot of these private credit firms are really poaching people from law firms. And these are your elite blue chip law firms. And it's really because they have the technical expertise to really come in and get started and get the ball rolling from day one. A first year J.D. coming straight out of school makes an annual salary of about $225,000. And when you add a bonus, which is usually about 20,000, that comes out to a total compensation of about 245,000. And so to poach someone, obviously these private credit firms need to expand past that. And one of the ways that they're doing that is offering carried interest, which is a share of investment profits. Alex Ossola: Sounds like a pretty good deal for some of these private credit firms. But what does this mean for law firms? Isaac Taylor: A lot of law firms really aren't moving mountains to keep their people from going in-house. And it really has to do with when these people go in-house, a lot of times they'll send that firm's business back to the law firm that they just came from. And so law firms don't really view it as a net negative if one of their top people leaves. Of course, they probably didn't want that, but if that person in turns just sends a deal or some type of structure back to the law firm for them to work on it, it's really a positive for them. Alex Ossola: That was WSJ Pro reporter Isaac Taylor. Thank you, Isaac. Isaac Taylor: Thank you. Alex Ossola: And that's What's News for this Tuesday afternoon. Today's show is produced by Pierre Bienaimé with supervising producer Michael Kosmides. I'm Alex Ossola for The Wall Street Journal. We'll be back with a new show tomorrow morning. Thanks for listening.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Musk's xAI to raise up to $12 billion in debt for AI expansion, WSJ reports
(Reuters) -Elon Musk's artificial intelligence startup xAI is working with a financier to secure up to $12 billion more for its expansion plans, the Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday, citing people familiar with the situation. Valor Equity Partners, an investment firm whose founder, Antonio Gracias, has close ties to Musk, is in talks with lenders to raise the capital, according to the report. The money would be used to buy a massive supply of advanced Nvidia chips that would be leased to xAI for a new huge data center meant to help train and power its AI chatbot Grok, the WSJ reported. Advertisement Valor and xAI did not immediately respond to Reuters' requests for comment. Some lenders want the debt to be repaid within three years and to cap the amount of money borrowed in order to limit their risk, the report said. Training and deploying advanced AI systems is expensive, requiring costly hardware, intensive compute and skilled engineers in a highly competitive market where rivals such as OpenAI, Google and China's DeepSeek are trying to dominate the technology. XAI is training Grok on 230,000 graphics processing units, including Nvidia's 30,000 GB200 AI chips, in a supercluster, with inference handled by the cloud providers, Musk said in a post on X on Tuesday. Advertisement He added that another supercluster will soon launch with an initial batch of 550,000 GB200 and GB300 chips. The AI startup was expected to burn through about $13 billion over the course of 2025, according to media reports. Earlier this month, the Financial Times reported that xAI was in talks to raise more money in a deal that could value the AI startup between $170 billion and $200 billion. In response, Musk had said xAI was not seeking funding. "We have plenty of capital." (Reporting by Jaspreet Singh in Bengaluru; Editing by Anil D'Silva and Alan Barona)

Wall Street Journal
12 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
U.S. Mid-Atlantic Factory Activity Contracts at Fastest Rate This Year
Manufacturing activity in the mid-Atlantic region this month deteriorated unexpectedly, driven by lower readings for shipments and new orders as trade uncertainty persisted. The Fifth District Survey of Manufacturing Activity's index for July sank sharply to minus 20 from minus 8 in June, the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond said Tuesday. A consensus of economists polled by The Wall Street Journal expected it instead to inch up to minus 6.5.