logo
Stone carving discovered in Qinghai stirs debate

Stone carving discovered in Qinghai stirs debate

The Star23-06-2025
BEIJING: A stone carving that some scholars believe dates back more than 2,200 years and could carry major cultural significance has ignited a heated debate among history enthusiasts, as several university professors have raised concerns that the inscriptions may be modern forgeries.
The controversy began with a June 8 report in Guangming Daily, in which Tong Tao, a researcher at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences' Institute of Archaeology, claimed archaeologists had recently discovered a stone carving linked to Emperor Qinshihuang — the first Chinese ruler to hold the title huangdi, or "emperor" — who founded the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BC).
According to the report, the inscriptions were found near Gyaring Lake in present-day Madoi county, Qinghai province, at an altitude of about 4,300 metres. Photos published alongside the story showed that the characters were clear and in relatively good condition.
Carved in xiaozhuan, a signature script of the Qin era, the inscription was interpreted as describing a team of fangshi (alchemists) led by a wudafu (a minister-level official), who were traveling by wagon to Kunlun Mountain in search of elixirs for immortality. The text claims the group reached the lake in the third month of the 26th year of Qinshihuang's reign, and would travel another 150 li (about 62 kilometres) to reach their final destination.
In ancient Chinese texts, Kunlun Mountain is imbued with mythological importance, akin to Mount Olympus in Greek mythology. It is also believed to be the birthplace of the Yellow River, often referred to as the "mother river" of China. Today, Kunlun refers to a long mountain range in western China, but its precise location in pre-Qin times is still debated among scholars.
"The carving was found by Gyaring Lake, with the Bayan Har Mountains to the south. So the search for elixirs in Kunlun should refer to Bayan Har, which undoubtedly corresponds to the 'Sacred Kunlun Mountain' in pre-Qin classics," Tong wrote. He added that the identification of Kunlun "matches perfectly with pre-Qin geographical texts that pointed to Kunlun as the source of the Yellow River", noting that modern hydrological studies confirm the Gyaring Lake and Bayan Har Mountains as headwaters of the river.
Historical texts state that seven stone monuments were carved to commemorate Emperor Qinshihuang's achievements following his inspection tours across the unified empire between 219 and 211 BC. Only two fragmentary examples have survived, both badly damaged and nearly illegible. Tong called the new find "the only existing Qin Dynasty carving at its original site and the most complete one".
Some online commenters hailed the find as monumental.
"Historical maps will be redrawn and the debate over Kunlun's location will be resolved. Salute to archaeologists who braved the elements," one person wrote.
However, the carving has also drawn skepticism — including from academics — over its authenticity.
"If the inscriptions' meaning was interpreted correctly, then I highly suspect this is a modern forgery. That would mark a new level of falsification," said Xin Deyong, a history professor at Peking University, without elaborating. He repeated his doubts in later social media posts and said he plans to write a book analysing what he called an "unbelievably fake" inscription.
Liu Zongdi, a professor at Beijing Language and Culture University, pointed out logistical inconsistencies in the story. For the team to arrive at the location by the stated time, he said, they would have had to set out the previous autumn or winter — an implausible scenario given the high altitude and harsh climate. He also questioned how the travelers could have anticipated the formal use of the title "emperor", which was proclaimed during the same year as their supposed journey.
Additional doubts have been raised regarding the inscribed date, grammar and terminology, with both supporters and skeptics presenting arguments.
For instance, Liu Zhao, a professor of ancient texts at Fudan University, said the engraving technique — particularly the direction of certain character strokes — aligns with the known calligraphic style of the Qin period. He also noted that a rare way of writing "Kunlun" seen in the inscription matches that on Qin-era bamboo slips unearthed in Hunan province. Because that writing style has only been documented in the past 20 years and is otherwise unknown, Liu argued that it would require "a forger with deep and niche academic knowledge" to replicate it.
Nanjing-based Ziniu News reported that Hou Guangliang, a professor at Qinghai Normal University, first identified the inscription in July 2020 during a field survey. At the time, he said only a few characters — including huang — could be clearly made out. Hou initially suggested the inscription may have been created after the Yuan Dynasty (1271-1368), using Qin-style characters for visual effect.
He also said the harsh conditions around Gyaring Lake make long-term preservation of carvings difficult, and that only from the Yuan period onward did the region come under stable government control, allowing large expeditions to be logistically feasible.
However, Hou has since reconsidered. In a recent interview with Southern Metropolis Daily, he described his earlier comments as "a bit shallow" and said further research is needed.
In a commentary, The Beijing News encouraged the public to see the controversy as a process of "academic refinement" and an opportunity to popularise archaeology.
"The truth will gradually emerge through rigorous research and evidence-based discussion," the editorial said. - China Daily/ANN
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

China urges global consensus on balancing AI development, security
China urges global consensus on balancing AI development, security

Malaysian Reserve

time3 hours ago

  • Malaysian Reserve

China urges global consensus on balancing AI development, security

SHANGHAI — China's Premier Li Qiang warned Saturday that artificial intelligence development must be weighed against the security risks, saying global consensus was urgently needed even as the tech race between Beijing and Washington shows no sign of abating. His remarks came just days after US President Donald Trump unveiled an aggressive low-regulation strategy aimed at cementing US dominance in the fast-moving field, promising to 'remove red tape and onerous regulation' that could hinder private sector AI development. Opening the World AI Conference (WAIC) in Shanghai on Saturday, Li emphasised the need for governance and open-source development, announcing the establishment of a Chinese-led body for international AI cooperation. 'The risks and challenges brought by artificial intelligence have drawn widespread attention… How to find a balance between development and security urgently requires further consensus from the entire society,' the premier said. Li said China would 'actively promote' the development of open-source AI, adding Beijing was willing to share advances with other countries, particularly developing ones. 'If we engage in technological monopolies, controls and blockage, artificial intelligence will become the preserve of a few countries and a few enterprises,' he said. 'Only by adhering to openness, sharing and fairness in access to intelligence can more countries and groups benefit from (AI).' The premier highlighted 'insufficient supply of computing power and chips' as a bottleneck. Washington has expanded its efforts in recent years to curb exports of state-of-the-art chips to China, concerned that these can be used to advance Beijing's military systems and erode US tech dominance. For its part, China has made AI a pillar of its plans for technological self-reliance, with the government pledging a raft of measures to boost the sector. In January, Chinese startup DeepSeek unveiled an AI model that performed as well as top US systems despite using less powerful chips. At a time when AI is being integrated across virtually all industries, its uses have raised major ethical questions, from the spread of misinformation to its impact on employment, or the potential loss of technological control. In a speech at WAIC on Saturday, Nobel Prize-winning physicist Geoffrey Hinton compared the situation to keeping 'a very cute tiger cub as a pet'. 'To survive', he said, you need to ensure you can train it not to kill you when it grows up. In a video message played at the WAIC opening ceremony, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said AI governance would be 'a defining test of international cooperation'. The ceremony also saw the French president's AI envoy, Anne Bouverot, underscore the 'an urgent need' for global action. At an AI summit in Paris in February, 58 countries including China, France and India — as well as the European Union and African Union Commission — called for enhanced coordination on AI governance. But the United States warned against 'excessive regulation', and alongside the United Kingdom, refused to sign the summit's appeal for an 'open', 'inclusive' and 'ethical' AI. — AFP

Amazon shuts Shanghai AI lab amid rising US-China tech tensions
Amazon shuts Shanghai AI lab amid rising US-China tech tensions

Malay Mail

timea day ago

  • Malay Mail

Amazon shuts Shanghai AI lab amid rising US-China tech tensions

SHANGHAI, July 25 — US tech giant Amazon has shut down its artificial intelligence research lab in Shanghai, a source with direct knowledge of the matter confirmed to AFP. News that the lab, part of cloud division Amazon Web Services (AWS), has closed comes with AI at the forefront of a tech race between China and the US. In a screenshot of a WeChat post widely circulated on Chinese social media this week, Wang Minjie, a scientist at the lab, said its disbanding was 'due to the strategic adjustment between China and the United States'. AWS announced job cuts across its operations last week, with some reports putting the losses at hundreds. Amazon declined to confirm the Shanghai lab's closure directly when contacted by AFP. 'We've made the difficult business decision to eliminate some roles across particular teams in AWS,' spokesman Brad Glasser said in a similar statement to the one released in response to the broader job losses. 'These decisions are necessary as we continue to invest, hire, and optimise resources to deliver innovation for our customers.' A dedicated AWS China webpage for the lab seen on Wednesday by AFP was no longer accessible today. According to an archive of the page, the lab was established in autumn 2018, with part of its remit to 'actively foster collaboration with the research community'. Other US tech firms such as Microsoft and IBM have scaled back their research divisions in China recently, as the tech competition between Washington and Beijing shows no sign of abating. — AFP

Amazon closes Shanghai AI lab amid US-China tech tensions
Amazon closes Shanghai AI lab amid US-China tech tensions

The Sun

timea day ago

  • The Sun

Amazon closes Shanghai AI lab amid US-China tech tensions

SHANGHAI: US tech giant Amazon has closed its artificial intelligence research lab in Shanghai, according to a source familiar with the matter. The lab, part of Amazon Web Services (AWS), was disbanded as AI becomes a key battleground in US-China tech competition. A WeChat post by Wang Minjie, a scientist at the lab, stated the closure was due to 'strategic adjustment between China and the United States.' The post circulated widely on Chinese social media this week. AWS recently announced job cuts, with reports suggesting hundreds of positions were affected. Amazon did not directly confirm the Shanghai lab's shutdown when contacted but acknowledged broader restructuring. 'We've made the difficult business decision to eliminate some roles across particular teams in AWS,' said spokesman Brad Glasser. 'These decisions are necessary as we continue to invest, hire, and optimize resources.' The AWS China webpage for the lab, previously accessible, was taken down this week. Archived records show the lab was launched in 2018 to foster research collaboration. Other US tech firms, including Microsoft and IBM, have also reduced research operations in China as geopolitical tensions persist. - AFP

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store