Disabled veteran fights homeowners association lawsuit over flagpole in Florida yard
By Sarah Rumpf-Whitten
Published May 30, 2025
A disabled veteran in Volusia County, Florida, is at the center of a heated dispute with his homeowners association (HOA) over a flagpole installed in his yard.
According to Fox News affiliate WOFL-TV, the Countryside Villas PUD3 HOA has filed a lawsuit against the unnamed veteran, claiming he failed to obtain the required approval before erecting the permanent structure.
Despite the legal friction, community support for the veteran has surged, with neighbors speaking out against what they see as harassment and unnecessary litigation.
"Leave the veteran alone. He hasn't done anything wrong," Frank Johnson, a veteran himself, told the outlet. "He's called me crying that they're harassing him and bullying him. He's served this country. He's paid his dues. They wanted to get him on a flagpole and some weeds in the lawn. It's pathetic. It's really pathetic."
ASSOCIATED PRESS MOVES TO DISMISS DEFAMATION CLAIM FROM VETERAN WHO DEFEATED CNN IN COURT
The HOA maintains that its actions are grounded in procedural compliance.
In a letter sent to the veteran, the association emphasized that it was not denying his right to fly the American flag, but rather enforcing a policy requiring prior approval for permanent flagpoles. The letter noted that the veteran's military service does not exempt him from these rules.
The situation only escalated when the veteran refused to remove the flagpole, accruing $1,000 in fines. The HOA responded by initiating a lawsuit for $8,000 and threatening to place a lien on his property.
Orlando Law Managing Partner Jennifer Englert told WOFL-TV that this action may not be legally defensible. Englert explained that Florida statute says as long as the flagpole is under 20 feet, a homeowner can have a flagpole on their property, even if the HOA has rules against it.
"Why are you fighting about something that you know you have to allow? That is very clear," she said.
MARYLAND SCHOOL SUSPENDS MARINE HOPEFUL AFTER AMERICAN FLAG LAW CONTROVERSY
Concerned neighbors and a caregiver have come forward to condemn the HOA's tactics, describing them as bullying and deeply disrespectful to someone who served the country.
Margaret Murphy, a resident who attended HOA meetings, took the issue to State Sen. Tom Wright, expressing in a letter that her own father's legacy as a Pearl Harbor survivor compelled her to act.
"My father was a survivor in Pearl Harbor. He would be rolling over in his grave if I didn't say something," she told the outlet.
In a statement to WOFL-TV, The Countryside PUD Unit III-B HOA, Inc. Board of Directors said that they never told the veteran homeowner that the "flagpole/flag was prohibited."
"Factually, this has never been about a flag or a flagpole. The resident was told via multiple correspondences that he absolutely can have them. The situation boils down to that he failed to submit an ARC application, which is required for flagpoles by the HOA. That rule has been in place since 1990," they said.
"The resident was given multiple opportunities to remedy the situation including assistance from the American Legion and the Elks. He also was given an opportunity at a hearing that he never showed up for. Florida Statute makes it clear that an HOA resident also needs to follow the governing documents which he has failed to do. This situation is no different than any other architectural guidelines in our docs. As a result, a fine was imposed, and he failed to pay the fine."
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
A pre-trial hearing is scheduled for September.
Fox News Digital has reached out to The Countryside PUD Unit III-B HOA, Inc. Board of Directors for comment.
Sarah Rumpf-Whitten is a U.S. Writer at Fox News Digital.
Since joining in 2021, she's covered high-stakes criminal justice—from the Menendez brothers' resentencing, where Judge Jesic slashed their life-without-parole terms to 50-years-to-life (making them parole-eligible), to the assassination attempts on President Donald Trump's life and shifting immigration enforcement, including her reporting on South Florida's illegal-immigration crisis, covering unprecedented migrant crossings from the Bahamas and ensuing enforcement operations.
Beyond those beats, she reports on crime, politics, business, lifestyle, world news, and more—delivering both breaking updates and in-depth analysis across Fox News Digital. You can follow her on Twitter and LinkedIn. Print Close
URL
https://www.foxnews.com/us/disabled-veteran-fights-homeowners-association-lawsuit-over-flagpole-florida-yard
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Republican Senate candidates seeking to replace McConnell aim to define themselves at Fancy Farm
Republican Senate candidates seeking to replace McConnell aim to define themselves at Fancy Farm FANCY FARM, Ky. (AP) — A renowned Kentucky picnic turned into a rapid-fire Republican political skirmish on Saturday, as three candidates competing to succeed longtime U.S. Sen. Mitch McConnell tried to pick apart one another while seeking early momentum in their 2026 primary campaign. Taking the stage amid milder-than-usual temperatures at the Fancy Farm picnic in western Kentucky, the GOP rivals — U.S. Rep. Andy Barr, former state Attorney General Daniel Cameron and entrepreneur Nate Morris — turned up the heat in vying for the coveted Senate seat. Each tried to define himself and their opponents while speaking before a raucous crowd and a statewide TV audience. Barr and Cameron ripped into Morris' business record as founder of a waste software company and questioned Morris' credibility as a supporter of President Donald Trump's MAGA movement. 'Nate will do anything and say anything to run away from his past,' Cameron said. 'You can't claim to be MAGA when you build a company on ESG subsidies and DEI initiatives." Barr quipped: 'Nate calls himself the trash man, but dumpster fire is more like it.' Morris — who is campaigning as a populist and political outsider — kept up his strategy of harshly criticizing McConnell's legacy and trying to link Barr and Cameron to the venerable senator. 'If you want to know how Andy Barr or Daniel Cameron are going to act in the U.S. Senate – look no further than their 'mentor' Mitch McConnell,' Morris said. 'Both of these guys are very proud to tell you they wouldn't have careers if it weren't for Mitch,' Morris added. "Neither of these guys have built anything, done anything impactful, employed anyone.' McConnell, a Fancy Farm participant for decades, didn't delve into the Senate race during his picnic speech Saturday. But he gave a spirited summary of his Senate career in a speech to a GOP breakfast gathering Saturday. He pointed to his record of steering enormous sums of federal funds to his home state to build or fix infrastructure, support agriculture and military installations and more. McConnell, the longest-serving Senate party leader in U.S. history, revealed in February, on his 83rd birthday, that he won't seek another term in Kentucky and will retire when his current term ends. With Democrats mostly skipping the picnic's political speeches, the crowd was divided among supporters of GOP candidates, cheering their favorite and jeering rival candidates. Speaking at Fancy Farm — where picnic organizers like to say the mouthwatering barbecue is hot and the political rhetoric even spicier — is considered a rite of passage for candidates seeking statewide office in the GOP-leaning Bluegrass State. Kentucky's 2026 primary election is next spring. Beside hurling insults at their rivals, the Senate candidates tried to define themselves at the picnic. Barr portrayed his congressional experience as an advantage setting him apart. He represents a district stretching from central Kentucky's bluegrass region to the Appalachian foothills. Barr said he helped shape and pass Trump's massive tax cut and spending reduction legislation. 'Some politicians like to say 'I'm a Trump guy,' " Barr said. 'They talk about supporting the president. But I'm the only candidate in this race who's actually doing it -- day in and day out in Congress.' Cameron, who is Black, used his speech to rail against diversity, equity and inclusion efforts. Cameron said he and his wife want their sons to 'grow up in a colorblind society, one based on merit and opportunity, not division and handouts. We don't need America built on diversity, equity and inclusion. We need America built on merit, excellence and intelligence.' Morris touted his hard-line stance on immigration. He supports a moratorium on immigration into the United States until every immigrant currently in the country illegally is deported. The three GOP rivals kept to one script they have all shared — lavishing praise on Trump. One of the biggest questions in the campaign is whether Trump will make an endorsement, seen as potentially decisive in determining who wins the primary. Democratic Senate candidate Pamela Stevenson was invited but opted to skip the picnic. Kentucky hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since Wendell Ford in 1992. The lone Democratic candidate who spoke at the picnic on Saturday was congressional candidate John 'Drew' Williams. Bruce Schreiner, The Associated Press
Yahoo
3 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Construction Worker and 'Loving' Father of 3 Dies After Being Buried Under Dirt at a Building Site
"No one goes to work expecting not to come home that night," police said of the tragic incident that claimed the life of Ronald Andrew Baquera TO KNOW A construction worker in Arizona has died after being buried under dirt in an open trench Emergency crews were called to a construction site in Goodyear, Ariz., on July 28, after 44-year-old Ronald Andrew Baquera Jr. became trapped six feet underground and was buried by the dirt 'The problem was, as they pulled dirt out more dirt was collapsing in, which really made this rescue almost impossible,' Goodyear Police Deputy Chief Jose Gonzalez said of the tragic incidentA construction worker in Arizona has died after being buried under dirt in an open trench. According to reports from the Arizona Republic, AZFamily and ABC 15, emergency crews were called to a construction site in Goodyear — a suburb of Phoenix located about 20 miles west of the city — on Monday, July 28, at around 1 p.m. local time. Ruben Real, a spokesperson for the Goodyear Fire Department, told ABC 15 that police, fire officials and Southwest Gas workers arrived at the site, located near Citrus and Lower Buckeye Roads, to find 44-year-old Ronald Andrew Baquera Jr., a father of three, stuck in the hole, about six feet underground. Fire crews began attempting to dig Baquera out from underneath the dirt. 'The problem was, as they pulled dirt out, more dirt was collapsing in, which really made this rescue almost impossible,' Goodyear Police Deputy Chief Jose Gonzalez told AZFamily. 'Our hearts go out to the family of the individual who's trapped, as well as to the partners who are here working with this individual." "No one goes to work expecting not to come home that night," Gonzalez added. The rescue operation was also slowed down due to crews coming close to nearby gas lines, and police said that the operation was eventually transitioned to a recovery effort. Rubicon Companies, which did not employ the worker, told the outlets that its crews assisted in the rescue operation. Crews continued digging overnight, and Baquera's body was recovered at around 2 a.m. on Tuesday, July 29. Baquera's friends and family have opened up about the loss of their loved one. Speaking with ABC 15, Melissa Prado, the mother of two of his children, described Baquera as a great father whose "hobby was his children." "My daughter is really torn up. She spends almost every day with him. She's a little distraught, and my son's angry,' Prado said. "They're not really coping too well." Nate Costly, Baquera's childhood friend who organized a vigil to honor him on Friday, Aug. 1, affectionately called the father-of-three "Ronnie," per the Republic. In an invitation to the vigil, Costly described Baquera as a "loving father and a loyal friend" who was "brutally honest, endlessly caring and unforgettable." Costly wrote that Baquera was survived by his two sons and a daughter, and his vigil was attended by more than 80 people in the local Arizona community. "He will be deeply missed," Costly said. Renisha Williams, a close family friend who said Baquera was like a brother, remembered him as a someone who lived for helping others and was 'always ready to lend a helping hand,' per the Republic. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Arizona's worker-safety agency, Arizona Division of Occupational Safety and Health (ADOSH), told ABC 15 and the Republic that it is investigating whether there were safety violations at the construction site. The agency declined to name the company that was employing the construction workers and said that the safety report could take four to five months to be completed. After the report is finished, ADOSH typically recommends citations and penalties to the state board. Prado said she and her children still have questions about what led to Baquera's accident. 'I'm sure it will come out,' she told ABC 15. 'But I don't care to know right now." Read the original article on People
CBS News
5 minutes ago
- CBS News
New witness leads to arrests in 2003 fatal shooting tied to Arlington nightclub fight, police say
Two men have been arrested in connection with the 2003 fatal shooting of a man found in a bullet-riddled truck after an altercation at an Arlington nightclub, police said. Authorities arrested John Wayne Biddle, 52, on Thursday and Raymond Malone, 55, on Friday on murder charges. Both were taken into custody in Fort Worth and are being held at the Tarrant County Jail, according to the Arlington Police Department. Police say Terrick Rutherford was shot and killed on June 23, 2003, after being confronted by a group of men at a nightclub in the 700 block of North Watson Road. The confrontation between Rutherford and the group escalated into a fight in the nightclub parking lot. Security broke up the altercation, and Rutherford left the scene, driving northbound on North Watson Road. As he approached the traffic light at Six Flags Drive, multiple shots were fired at his vehicle. Rutherford was struck by gunfire and collided with another vehicle at the intersection. A relative, following in a separate car, witnessed the shooting, police said. Later, officers responded to the intersection of Randol Mill Road and Web Street, where they found Rutherford in a pickup truck riddled with bullet holes. His relative had attempted to drive him to the hospital. Rutherford was unresponsive and suffering from multiple gunshot wounds. He was transported to a nearby hospital, where he was later pronounced dead, according to police. Malone and Biddle, identified by police as documented gang members, were named as suspects at the time but weren't charged due to a lack of evidence. Both were previously arrested for engaging in organized criminal activity but were later "no billed," meaning a grand jury declined to indict them on the charges, police said. According to police, a new witness came forward in July with information that aligned with the original investigation. Detectives re-interviewed witnesses from the 2003 case and corroborated the new details. After consulting with the Tarrant County District Attorney's Office, investigators obtained murder warrants for Malone and Biddle. "When someone does the right thing and comes forward with information, that can be the difference between solving a case and it remaining unsolved," Arlington Police Chief Al Jones said in a news release. "I'm grateful these new details came to light. I'm proud of our current detectives for tenaciously pursuing these new leads and following up on the outstanding investigation the original detectives did on this case to put two suspected killers behind bars." Members of the U.S. Marshals North Texas Fugitive Task Force participated in the arrests of the two men.
