Choksi opposes ED's fugitive offender plea, claims constructive custody in Belgium
Through his counsel, Advocate Vijay Aggarwal, Choksi has argued that the legal basis for declaring him a fugitive is fundamentally flawed. He is currently lodged in a Belgian prison following his arrest recently, which was carried out on the basis of a non-bailable warrant issued by an Indian court and under an official extradition request made by the Indian government.
Aggarwal contended that Choksi is, therefore, in the 'constructive custody' of Indian authorities.
'How can someone be considered a fugitive when he has been arrested at the behest of India and is in custody due to Indian proceedings?' Aggarwal told ANI.
He further explained that under the Fugitive Economic Offenders Act, a person must meet two conditions: one is leaving India to avoid prosecution, and the second, refusing to return to face legal proceedings.
'In my client's case, neither criterion is fulfilled,' Aggarwal stated. 'He left India for medical treatment in New York with due police clearance from Mumbai, and at that time, no case had been filed against him. So the allegation that he fled to evade prosecution is baseless.'
As for his alleged refusal to return, Aggarwal pointed to a Dominican court order from 2021, issued after an alleged abduction attempt on Choksi. The order barred him from leaving Antigua, and significantly, it was passed in the presence of the CBI, effectively making it a restriction imposed with the knowledge of the Indian government.
Aggarwal stated that the FEO plea has been pending in the Mumbai court for years without resolution. 'Now that my client has been arrested in Belgium, at India's request, and remains in custody in Antwerp prison in relation to Indian charges, he is effectively under Indian jurisdiction,' he argued. 'Judicial precedents recognise such custody as valid under Indian law. Hence, there's no ground to continue the FEO proceedings.'
Simultaneously, Choksi is also fighting legal proceedings in Belgium. In a recent petition filed before the Belgian Court of Appeal--prepared by Advocate Aggarwal and submitted by his local legal team--Choksi has alleged that his arrest violated Belgian legal procedures and fundamental rights.
The plea claims that Belgian authorities failed to follow due process, infringing on Choksi's basic legal protections and violating principles of natural justice. He has sought immediate release, citing these procedural lapses.
This petition follows the recent rejection of Choksi's bail by a three-judge bench of the Belgian Court of Appeal, which conducted proceedings in Dutch. The court has yet to schedule the next hearing in the matter. (ANI)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
40 minutes ago
- Hans India
Illegal mining under political shield? ED targets Mishra-led syndicate in new filing
Ranchi: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has filed its fifth supplementary prosecution complaint in the Sahibganj illegal mining and extortion case, further tightening its net around the alleged syndicate masterminded by Pankaj Mishra, a close aide of the Jharkhand Chief Minister. The complaint, filed before the Special PMLA Court in Ranchi on June 30, names eight individuals and two companies as fresh accused in the money laundering probe, says the agency's press release issued on Wednesday. With this, a total of 19 individuals and entities have been arraigned across six prosecution complaints — one original and five supplementary — in connection with the case, which involves proceeds of crime estimated at over Rs 1,000 crore. Among the newly named accused is Rajesh Yadav alias Dahu Yadav, allegedly a key enforcer in the network who oversaw the illegal transport of stone across the Ganga river, said the release. According to the ED, Yadav also financed a fraudulent ferry tender to aid large-scale smuggling of minerals. He is currently absconding. Another accused, Heera Lal Bhagat, is alleged to have operated illegal mining activities through his firm M/s Jai Maa Bhavani Stone Works. ED officials recovered over Rs 3.13 crore in unaccounted cash from his premises, believed to be direct proceeds of the illicit operations. The complaint also highlights the role of Nimay Chandra Shil, who allegedly conspired with Pankaj Mishra and his wife to fraudulently secure a mining lease in exchange for a 50 per cent profit-sharing deal. Corporate complicity has also come under the scanner. The ED has named M/s Marine Infralink Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and its director Yash Jalan for allegedly providing the vessel M.V. Infralink-III, used for transporting illegally mined stone, said the release. The company reportedly received Rs 2.75 crore sourced from the syndicate's criminal proceeds. The ED's investigation began after an FIR registered by Jharkhand Police against Mishra and his associates under various IPC and Arms Act provisions. The probe under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) revealed a politically protected cartel monopolising mining and mineral transport in the Sahibganj region. So far, the ED has seized and frozen assets including Rs 5.34 crore in cash, an inland vessel, five industrial stone crushers, multiple vehicles, and bank balances exceeding Rs 13.32 crore.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Bail jumper in 2004 MBBS admission racket held after 20 years
New Delhi: A 63-year-old civil engineer turned fraudster who jumped bail and evaded arrest for two decades was apprehended by Delhi Police's Crime Branch. Rajesh Rajput was part of a gang that lured parents through newspaper advertisements, promising MBBS admissions under management quota in reputed medical colleges. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Rajput, a resident of Saharanpur in Uttar Pradesh, was declared a proclaimed offender in 2006 in a cheating case registered with Economic Offences Wing (EOW) of Delhi Police. "In 2004, he and his associates allegedly duped a doctor from Odisha of Rs 4 lakh on the pretext of securing an MBBS seat for his son through management quota," DCP (crime) Harsh Indora said. The Odisha-based doctor fell into the trap and paid the amount, only to realise he was conned. "A case was registered at Shalimar Bagh police station and later transferred to the EOW for investigation. Rajput was initially arrested but absconded soon after securing bail, failing to appear for court proceedings. He was subsequently declared a proclaimed offender in February 2006," DCP Indora added. Crime Branch team received a tip-off about Rajput's whereabouts. On July 1, the team conducted a pre-dawn operation to Saharanpur and managed to locate Rajput at his home. "Initially, he denied his identity, but during sustained interrogation at Crime Branch office in Delhi, he confessed. His identity was confirmed through cross-checks with police station Shalimar Bagh and the EOW," a senior police officer said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Who is Arun Subramanian, the judge overseeing Sean Diddy Combs' trial?
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Sean "Diddy" Combs was recently acquitted of serious charges including sex trafficking and racketeering but was convicted of a prostitution-related offense. While spared a potential life sentence, Combs still faces up to 10 years in prison. Following the mixed verdict, U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian , who is presiding over the case, is now considering whether to grant Combs who is Judge Arun Subramanian—the man at the center of one of the year's most high-profile trials?Arun Subramanian made history in 2022 when he became the first South Asian judge to be appointed to the Southern District of New York. Nominated by President Joe Biden, Subramanian's background is as impressive as it is in 1979 in Pittsburgh to Indian immigrant parents, Subramanian was raised with strong family values—something he emphasized during his Senate Judiciary Committee hearing. He is known not only for his legal brilliance but also for his humility and sense of his appointment to the bench, Subramanian built a distinguished legal career. He clerked for some of the most respected judges in the country, including:Judge Dennis Jacobs, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second CircuitJudge Gerard E. Lynch, Southern District of New YorkThe late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader GinsburgThese experiences helped shape his legal philosophy and meticulous attention to holds a bachelor's degree in Computer Science and English from Case Western Reserve University, and earned his Juris Doctor from Columbia Law School, where he was named both a James Kent and Harlan Fiske Stone Scholar. He also served as Executive Articles Editor for the Columbia Law a civil attorney, Subramanian played a key role in high-impact litigation. According to his former firm, he helped recover over $1 billion for victims of fraud and corporate abuse. His work wasn't limited to financial victories; he also took on meaningful pro bono his serious responsibilities, Judge Subramanian is known for his approachable demeanor. According to TMZ, he brought a calm and relaxed presence during jury selection in the Diddy trial, helping put potential jurors at ease. He's been spotted walking with earphones in, suggesting a man who balances focus with calm.
