PAC orders special audit of education boards
The decision was taken in a meeting of the PAC which took place in the Sindh Assembly's committee room on Tuesday. PAC Chairman Nisar Khuhro presided over the meeting which was attended by committee members Sadia Javed, Khurram Karim Soomro, and Javed, along with senior officials, including Universities and Boards Secretary Abbas Baloch, and the chairmen of education boards.
The committee expressed dissatisfaction with the management of education boards, citing repeated instances of financial mismanagement.
Chairman Khuhro expressed a lack of confidence in the boards' operations while highlighting growing concerns over the alleged manipulation of exam results. He added that allegations of "paying for marks" have tarnished the reputation of the boards.
"The boards are accused of awarding A+ marks for money, but this practice will only lead to failure when students sit for entry tests," Khuhro warned. He stressed that despite the Sindh government's initiative to provide free education up to the intermediate level, the quality of education and transparency in results had been compromised due to the boards' alleged malpractices. The government allocates Rs2 billion annually for exam fees, yet the credibility of the boards continues to be questioned.
Khuhro stressed that the future of the youth is at stake, and the committee would not tolerate any compromise on education standards. "Just as Gorakh Hill underwent a special audit, we will ensure the same transparency for education boards," he added.
The issue of result manipulation came to the forefront when PAC member Khurram Karim Soomro raised concerns regarding Amir Qadri, the former chairman of the Board of Intermediate Education Karachi (BIEK), who had been removed due to allegations of manipulating first-year results. Soomro asked for an update on the progress of the investigation and sought clarification on the system for awarding marks in the boards.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Sugar price hike: PAC unhappy with FBR, ministry's briefings
ISLAMABAD: The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on Wednesday expressed dissatisfaction with briefings from both the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) and the Ministry of Food Security regarding the recent surge in sugar prices. The committee has now demanded detailed information on the government's decision to import sugar. The committee under the chairmanship of Junaid Akbar received a briefing on the ongoing sugar crisis. During the session, PAC members grilled officials, scrutinising the issues surrounding the availability and pricing of sugar. Sugar price hike: NA panel to identify 'beneficiaries' According to FBR officials, the retail price of sugar in all four provinces is currently Rs 183 per kg. A summary for importing 500,000 tons was sent; 300,000 tons will be imported now, officials stated. Rashid Langrial, FBR chairman said that the matters of food import or export are handled by the Food Ministry. He explained that the cabinet made the decision; the FBR is bound by the decision. He further said that they are directed to abolish the 20 percent customs duty on imports. Sales tax was reduced from 18 to 0.25 percent. The advance tax which is 5.5 percent has been set to 0.25 percent, he added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
A system that breeds fraud
EDITORIAL: In his briefing to the National Assembly's Public Accounts Committee recently, FBR (Federal Board of Revenue) Chairman Rashid Langrial not only acknowledged that the potential volume of tax fraud in Pakistan could be as high as Rs700 billion, with sales tax fraud posing a particularly knotty challenge, he also conceded that its complete elimination remains unlikely. This is, in effect, an admission that there is something inherently wrong with the country's tax administration and overall taxation structure. While the FBR chairman readily owned up to the challenge posed by tax fraud and evasion, there remains within the tax bureaucracy a stubborn refusal to honestly reckon with the root causes of the country's dismal tax compliance. Firstly, there is a need to recognise that such huge levels of tax evasion cannot exist without the incompetence, and in too many cases, outright connivance of those manning the tax bureaucracy. But even more fundamentally, there is the structurally problematic over reliance on excessively high tax rates — rates that are not only steep but subject to frequent and accelerating increases — eroding public trust in and compliance with the system. For large segments of the economy, paying taxes at prevailing high rates has become substantially costlier than bearing the cost for evading them, yet the tax bureaucracy remains unwilling to confront the glaringly obvious truth: the higher the tax rate, the greater the temptation for evasion. The costs of evasion, such as bribing tax officials, are often significantly lower than the burden of full tax compliance in an environment of high rates. The chairman highlights sales tax fraud, yet in a country where the standard sales tax rate is 18 percent, and even higher in some cases, such high rates practically invite evasion. Anyone with even a basic grasp on tax policy can see then that the most effective way to broaden the tax net would be through lowering tax rates, but that understanding remains inexecutable in the absence of political will to tax all incomes irrespective of origin. Then there is the problem posed by a tax structure dependent on minimum tax on turnover, which is inherently punitive towards compliant taxpayers. Under this regime, even if an entity has incurred a loss and so certified by audit, it must still pay the legally mandated minimum tax on its revenue. How such a policy encourages businesses to join the tax net remains a mystery, as loss-making enterprises can easily be driven out of operation under this punishing framework, especially since Pakistani companies have to pay a minimum tax ranging from 0.5 to eight percent on turnover, irrespective of profitability. Essentially, this system penalises businesses for entering the tax net and for fully adhering to tax laws, while also undermining investment and suppressing broader economic activity. Added to this are the complications caused by high withholding tax rates. Not only do these remain exorbitant, but claiming and actually receiving refunds has become an increasingly onerous process. In many cases, businesses and individuals are unable to recover their dues without resorting to paying 'speed money' to relevant officials, creating yet another reason to simply stay out of the tax ambit than to expend effort and resources on documenting receipts, invoices and financial records for countless transactions only to be denied the full refund that is ultimately owed. We thus find ourselves trapped in a vicious, never-ending cycle. Multiple studies have highlighted the enormous cost of complying with Pakistan's complex and punitive tax system. A recent ADB study, for instance, clearly demonstrates the link between high rates, high compliance costs and increased tax evasion. Yet, judging by the prevailing attitude within the tax bureaucracy, there seems little hope that these legitimate concerns will be meaningfully addressed. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
21 hours ago
- Express Tribune
KE agrees to pay Sindh Rs9b electricity duty
Additional concerns were raised over capacity payments to K-Electric's power plants, projected to cost over Rs 82b. PHOTO: FILE The K-Electric (KE) after several years of delay has started payments of electricity duty amounting to Rs32 billion, it has collected from consumers through monthly bills, to the Sindh government. As per the agreement, the power utility has agreed to pay Rs1.25 billion to the provincial government in two installments. This move is part of a broader agreement under which KE has committed to pay Rs9.142 billion out of a total outstanding amount exceeding Rs32 billion. A payment schedule has also been issued. According to the agreed timeline, the power utility will pay Rs4.258 billion to the Sindh government by September 2025. Additionally, the K-Electric will now be required to regularly remit the electricity duty it collects from consumers through monthly bills. The issue of non-payment of electricity duty was taken up by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC). Meanwhile, the Rs25 billion dues between KE and the Karachi Water and Sewerage Board remain unresolved. K-Electric has warned government departments of potential disconnection if bills are not paid on time. The power utility in its letter to the secretary of the Sindh Energy Department referred to the discussion between KE team and PAC members on June 31, during which payment with respect to Electricity Duty (ED) was deliberated upon. As agreed, reconciled electricity consumption dues of the Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation (KWSC) will be held for adjustment against ED accumulated up to August 2024 and the excess amount of ED for the said period shall be paid by KE in line with the agreed installments as reflected in the schedule. Furthermore, KE will also deposit the respective ED amount for the period from September 2024 to September 2025, no later than 30th September 2025, into the respective Government Treasury. Moreover, it was also discussed that payment to KE for electricity dues by Sindh government and its various departments should also be paid on timely basis failing which, KE would be at liberty to take appropriate action including, but not limited to, disconnection of the respective electricity connections albeit in accordance with law.
