YouTube mulls action on Pak court order
The judicial magistrate court's order came after the NCCIA criticised more than two dozen channels in a June 2 report for "sharing highly intimidating, provocative and derogatory contents against state institutions and officials of the state of Pakistan".
YouTube told 27 content creators that their channels could be taken down if they did not comply with the court orders. "If you fail to do so, as per our local law obligations, we may comply with the request without further notice," the popular video sharing platform said in emails to the channel owners.
Digital rights campaigners have said that any ban would further undermine free speech in Pakistan, where the authorities are accused of stifling newspapers and television, and social media is seen as one of the few outlets for dissent.
In their separate statements, the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) and the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) expressed deep concern over the court order, saying the decision was against the fundamental rights of fair trial and freedom of expression.
The judicial magistrate's order is also against journalistic values and principles of justice, SCBA President Mian Muhammad Rauf Atta said in a statement. "A decision cannot be given against anyone without giving them a chance to be heard. This is another example of suppressing the voice of opponents."
In a separate statement, the HRCP said that shutting down entire channels was an excessive and inappropriate measure. "If specific videos contain hate speech or unlawful content, action should be taken against those individual pieces of contentnot the entire channel," it said.
The commission emphasised that the constitutional right to freedom of expression must be protected. "This right is essential not only for individual liberty but also to ensure government accountability and public access to diverse viewpoints," it added.
However, Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry said those content creators would also face criminal charges. "You cannot use these cell phones and the social media to create chaos," he told a local news channel. "There are laws to regulate and they will have to work under these laws," he said.
One of the creators, Asad Toor, said the move was aimed at undermining fundamental and constitutional rights of the people, political parties and other dissident groups. "I have dedicated my platform for these underdogs who have no place to go to and raise their voices against the state oppression," he said.
Digital rights activist Usama Khilji said that the court did not fulfil due process. "What is jarring is the complete lack of legal process," he said. "In this day and age you can't suppress digital media," said Zulfikar Bukhari of the opposition Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PM Shehbaz pledges economic turnaround through structural reforms
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif addresses a delegation of students selected for the government's internship programme, Uraan Pakistan, Summer Scholars, in Islamabad on July 12, 2025. Photo: APP Listen to article Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif said the government was committed to steering the country towards an economic turnaround through structural reforms, institutional changes, and a renewed focus on meritocracy, Associated Press of Pakistan (APP) reported on Saturday. Addressing a group of Pakistani students enrolled in leading international universities under the government's Uraan Pakistan Summer Scholars Programme, the prime minister said the coalition government had assumed office in 2023 at a time when the country was on the brink of default. 'The majority believed Pakistan would default, while a small minority held hope that we might avoid it,' he said, recalling his meetings with the IMF managing director where he assured Pakistan's commitment to stabilising the economy and completing the programme. Read More: Punjab speaker forms committee to address suspended PTI members' references The premier said inflation had surged to 38 per cent and the policy rate stood at 22.5pc at that time, while business sentiment had plummeted. 'The burden was immense, but we moved forward with sincerity and unity. Today, the policy rate has been brought down to below 11pc, and initiatives like Uraan Pakistan have taken off.' He described the path ahead as 'challenging', noting that successive governments had avoided undertaking structural reforms. 'We must now commit to these long-overdue changes through sustained effort,' he stressed. براہِ راست: وزیراعظم کی انٹرن شپ پروگرام اڑان پاکستان-سمر اسکالرز کے طلباء سے گفتگو — Government of Pakistan (@GovtofPakistan) July 12, 2025 Highlighting reforms within the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), he claimed that the government had acted decisively to remove corrupt officials without yielding to political pressure or the culture of sifarish. 'Previously, digitisation efforts were confined to paperwork, manipulated by vested interests,' he said, adding that his government had appointed competent individuals, including a new FBR chairman and expert consultants. 'Today, FBR's operations are increasingly digital, with AI-based tools and faceless interaction becoming the norm.' Also Read: Fazl urges political change in K-P, calls for shift from within PTI ranks As a result of enforcement efforts, he said, revenue collection in one sector alone had increased from Rs12 billion to over Rs50bn in a year, revealing the extent of past tax evasion. 'We face a long and thorny journey, with mountain-like challenges,' the prime minister remarked. 'But we will not shy away from our responsibilities. I believe in teamwork and accountability—those who perform are recognised, and those who don't are shown the door.' He said failure to meet economic goals was not an option. 'Delivery is the name of the game; performance is the name of the game.' Emphasising the importance of youth development, he said investment in young people was an investment in Pakistan's future. Responding to questions from students, the premier recalled launching merit-based scholarships in Punjab for underprivileged students during his tenure as chief minister. On climate change, the prime minister noted that Pakistan had suffered massive economic losses during the 2022 floods—estimated at $30bn—despite contributing only a negligible share to global emissions. Responding to another question, PM Shehbaz addressed recent tensions with India, stating that during May this year, Pakistan responded to 'uncalled aggression' in the aftermath of the Pahalgam incident. Read More: SJC reviews 24 judicial complaints, dismisses 19 He said Pakistan had proposed an international investigation into the matter, but India did not respond. 'As a result of Indian aggression, 55 Pakistanis were martyred. We responded in self-defence by downing six Indian aircraft,' he claimed, adding that on May 9 and 10, Pakistan had retaliated with full force. He lauded the armed forces for their professionalism and reiterated that Pakistan's nuclear programme was solely for peaceful purposes and national defence. The prime minister expressed confidence in the students selected under the Uraan Pakistan programme and extended best wishes for their academic and professional journeys.
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Shehzad Akbar named key accused in £190m reference case
Listen to article Former Asset Recovery Unit (ARU) chief and ex-special assistant to the prime minister on accountability, Shehzad Akbar, has been identified as a central figure in the ongoing £190 million reference case, according to investigative sources. They alleged that Akbar acted as the mastermind behind an illegal scheme that caused significant financial losses to Pakistan. As part of the investigation, it was revealed that Akbar signed a Deed of Confidentiality on November 6 2019, ahead of the formal approval of the ARU's restructuring and a key cabinet meeting — a move investigators cite as evidence of bad faith. According to the findings, the £190 million — part of a civil settlement with the UK's National Crime Agency (NCA) — was diverted to a "designated account" in the name of the Registrar of the Supreme Court. The amount was originally held in the responsibility account of a major private housing society in Karachi. The agreement was also signed by co-accused Ziaul Mustafa Naseem. Investigators stated the funds were falsely portrayed as being transferred to an official account of the State of Pakistan, while in reality, they were redirected to benefit a private entity. Records show that Akbar travelled to the United Kingdom twice in 2019 — from February 4 to 8 and again from May 22 to 26 — where he reportedly met with the UK Home Secretary and the Director General of the NCA. During these meetings, he allegedly negotiated a secret road map for the repatriation of funds. Read More: PTI's Shahzad Akbar departs for Dubai Officials claim Akbar deliberately excluded key Pakistani institutions such as the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), and the State Bank of Pakistan from the decision-making process. This, sources argue, led to substantial financial loss to the Supreme Court and diverted nearly £190 million (approximately Rs50 billion) away from the state. Sources further revealed that even before cabinet approval, criminal proceeds were transferred from the UK to Pakistan in late November 2019. The move came following a high-level meeting on March 2, 2019 involving Akbar, then prime minister Imran Khan, and principal secretary Azam Khan. The discussion reportedly focused on a settlement with the NCA and the repatriation of funds. Akbar allegedly overstepped the jurisdiction of the ARU and, in coordination with the then-prime minister, concealed critical facts from the cabinet. Despite presenting the agreement to the cabinet on December 3, 2019, he had already signed the confidential deed on November 6. According to UK authorities, the NCA had frozen around £120 million before December 14, 2018 under the UK Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. The funds were seized based on suspicion against two Pakistani nationals and related investigations into assets, including the prime London property at 1 Hyde Park Place. The ARU had reportedly reached a settlement with the housing society on March 13 and 21, 2019, under application No 8758. The respondents offered an out-of-court settlement with the NCA and their legal representatives. The Supreme Court, in March 2019, imposed heavy fines and conditionally suspended criminal proceedings related to the case. Investigators say Akbar played a pivotal role in misusing authority, acting in bad faith, and concealing corruption-related funds. As a result, legal action continues, with the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) and other authorities conducting inquiries. Akbar has since been declared a proclaimed offender in the case. What is the £190 million case? The case alleges that Imran Khan and others involved adjusted Rs50 billion—equivalent to £190 million at the time—that was transferred by the UK's National Crime Agency (NCA) to the Pakistani government. As PM, Imran Khan obtained cabinet approval for this settlement on December 3, 2019, without disclosing the confidential details of the agreement. The arrangement had stipulated that the funds would be submitted to the Supreme Court. According to NAB officials, Imran and his wife received land worth billions of rupees intended for the construction of an educational institute. NAB filed the reference on December 1, 2023 against eight accused persons including Imran and his wife. The court on January 6, 2024 declared the rest of six accused proclaimed offenders as they did not face the trial and escaped to foreign countries. Read More: Imran Khan, Bushra Bibi indicted in Toshakhana 2.0 case The court indicted Imran and Bushra on February 27, 2024. The prosecution presented 35 witnesses, whom the defence later cross-examined. Key witnesses in the case included PM's former principal secretary Azam Khan, former defence minister Pervez Khattak and former federal minister Zubaida Jalal. Three different judges presided over the case at various stages of the trial while the final investigative officer, Mian Umar Nadeem, was cross-examined after 38 hearings. The accountability court provided the accused 15 opportunities to complete their statements under Section 342. However, no witnesses were presented by the defence.
Business Recorder
8 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Building digital Pakistan beyond big slogans
The story of transformation begins with a single keystroke, a child's first coding lesson, and a nation's unwavering belief in its future. South Korea's digital transformation began with massive investments in educational infrastructure. Singapore's smart nation initiative started with comprehensive teacher training. Estonia's digital society emerged from a commitment to technological innovation in schools. For decades, successive governments have treated education as an afterthought rather than the foundation of national development. The question isn't whether Pakistan can join the digital revolution or not, the more fundamental worry is whether we have the courage to reorder our priorities and invest in the minds that can lead it? While billions have been invested in the infrastructure and so called e-governance systems, the Pakistani government continued to neglect the education sector. The Digital Pakistan vision focused heavily on connectivity and digital services but failed to adequately address the fundamental challenge of preparing Pakistan's human capital for the digital age (who fundamentally are the users of this infrastructure). With over 60% of its population under the age of 30, Pakistan holds what economists call a 'demographic dividend', a youthful, dynamic workforce capable of driving prosperity. But this advantage is only meaningful if we equip our young people with the right skills, and the vision to use them. The foundation crises The transformation must begin where every great journey starts, in the classroom of a six-year-old. Pakistan's primary education system, serving over 22 million children, needs more than incremental improvements on paper, it demands a complete reimagining. The first pillar of Digital Pakistan lies in universal digital literacy. Every primary school student should have access to tablet-based learning platforms loaded with interactive content in Urdu, English, and regional languages. Countries like Rwanda have successfully implemented one-laptop-per-child programs that cost less than $200 per student annually, a fraction of what Pakistan spends on non-essential government projects. Teacher training represents the most critical investment. Every primary school teacher should receive certification in basic digital pedagogy, not as an additional burden but as an empowering tool. Master trainers from leading universities like LUMS and NUST could develop cascading training programs, creating a network of digitally fluent educators reaching every corner of Pakistan. Certainly. Here's a concise and impactful version: Digital transformation will break down geographical barriers, enabling students and educators from remote villages to access the same high-quality resources, lectures, and expertise that have long been confined to major urban centres. This democratization of knowledge can level the playing field and unlock the full potential of talent across the entire nation. Building digital citizens As students progress to secondary education, the focus shifts from digital literacy to digital fluency. Secondary schools should establish 'Innovation Labs' where students learn coding, robotics, and digital design. What is being taught at colleges should move down to school level. These labs don't require massive investments, they need strategic partnerships with leading tech companies who could sponsor equipment and provide mentorship through rotation programs serving multiple schools per district. The curriculum overhaul must be comprehensive yet practical. Computer science should be mandatory, but equally important are digital literacy modules integrated into traditional subjects. Students could create documentary films about local heritage, develop apps for identifying local flora and fauna, and publish digital magazines showcasing regional writers. Pakistan's linguistic diversity (with over 70 languages spoken) could become a competitive advantage in creating multilingual digital content. Centres of excellence and innovation – blockchain and beyond The final stage of transformation is with the Higher Education in Pakistan. Local universities must transform from knowledge consumers to knowledge creators. The country's 200+ universities vary dramatically in quality, but this diversity can become a strength through strategic resource sharing. Leading institutions like NUST, the University of Punjab and Quaid-i-Azam University should establish 'Digital Knowledge Hubs' that smaller universities can access, providing online courses, virtual laboratory access, and research collaboration platforms. The higher education curriculum needs radical and urgent updating. Engineering programs should integrate artificial intelligence and machine learning from the first year. Business schools should focus on digital entrepreneurship and e-commerce. Medical schools should incorporate telemedicine and digital health technologies. International partnerships can amplify these efforts exponentially through dual degrees, research collaborations, and faculty exchanges. Universities must take the lead in exploring and integrating cutting-edge technologies like blockchain, quantum computing, and the Internet of Things (IoT) into their academic and research agendas. Blockchain, for instance, offers transformative potential for secure digital identities, transparent public services, and tamper-proof academic credentials , innovations that can directly address many of Pakistan's governance and trust deficits. By establishing dedicated research centres and industry partnerships around these emerging technologies, universities can position Pakistan not just as a consumer, but as a creator of next-generation solutions. This academic leadership is essential to ensure the country keeps pace with global innovation and builds a future-ready economy. Economic transformation Digital Pakistan's economic impact extends far beyond education. A digitally literate workforce attracts international investment, creates high-value jobs, and develops innovative solutions to local challenges. Countries like Estonia, Singapore, and South Korea have demonstrated how educational transformation drives economic growth. The IT sector could become Pakistan's largest export industry. With improved education, the country could produce world-class software developers, digital marketers, and tech entrepreneurs. Pakistani firms could compete globally in artificial intelligence, fintech, and e-commerce. The current IT exports of $2.6 billion could grow to $25 billion within a decade with proper educational investment. Traditional industries would also benefit from digital transformation. Agriculture could adopt precision farming techniques, manufacturing could implement Industry 4.0 technologies, and services could leverage digital platforms for growth. Small businesses could access global markets through e-commerce platforms developed by Pakistani entrepreneurs. The social revolution Digital transformation has the power to weave the entire nation into a unified digital golden thread, connecting regions, communities, and individuals through shared platforms for learning, collaboration, and innovation. By breaking down geographical and social barriers, it allows students in Gilgit to access the same quality of education as those in Lahore, and entrepreneurs in Balochistan to connect with global markets just as easily as their counterparts in Karachi. Crucially, it also opens doors for women and girls, especially in conservative or underserved areas, to learn, earn, and lead from within their own homes, reducing gender inequality and empowering a new wave of social mobility. A unified, inclusive digital ecosystem doesn't just modernise Pakistan, it redefines who gets to shape its future. The path forward Beyond big slogans, the journey toward Digital Pakistan requires immediate action across multiple fronts. Infrastructure development comes first, every school needs reliable internet connectivity through expanded fiber optic networks and subsidized access. Funding mechanisms must be innovative and sustainable. The government should establish an 'Education Technology Fund' supported by taxes on digital services and international partnerships. Private companies should receive tax incentives for educational investments, while alumni networks contribute to scholarship funds and infrastructure development. Public-private partnerships can accelerate implementation. International tech companies establishing operations in Pakistan should contribute to educational development. Local companies should adopt schools and provide ongoing support. Diaspora communities should engage as mentors and funding sources. The moment of truth Pakistan possesses unique advantages that other digitally transformed nations lacked. Our large population provides scale for digital solutions. Our cultural diversity offers rich content for educational platforms. Our diaspora community provides global connections and expertise. Our young demographic ensures rapid adoption of new technologies. The timeline for digital transformation is surprisingly short. With dedicated efforts, Pakistan could achieve universal digital literacy in primary schools within five years, comprehensively digitize secondary education within seven years, and bring universities to international standards within a decade. The economic benefits would begin appearing within three years and accelerate rapidly thereafter. The roadmap is quite clear, train teachers, update curricula, and foster innovation. The resources are available through creative partnerships and international cooperation. What's missing is the political will to prioritise education over short-term gains and the social commitment to embrace change. The article does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Business Recorder or its owners
