Grandmother accused of murder says daughter hit grandson
Mrs Ives denied that either she or her husband hit Ethan, but said her daughter "used to smack his hand and smack his bum," and she had seen her "hit him up the back of the head"."If he'd laugh at her, she'd lose her temper," she said.She described Ethan as a "chubby and "bubbly little child" who acted differently when his mum was around, "biting his lip" until it bled or shoving food into his mouth until he choked.
On the night Ethan collapsed, Mrs Ives the colour had drained from his face and she called for Shannon, who was upstairs, and phoned one of her daughters for advice. It was 18 minutes between Ethan's collapse and Mrs Ives calling an ambulance.
Under cross-examination Mrs Ives accepted the way her husband carried Ethan, by his arm, in CCTV footage from August 4 2021, was "cruel".When asked why she had earlier told the jury she had never seen Mr Ives carrying Ethan in that way, she said: "Because I was just staring... that's what I do."She disagreed that Mr Ives was "hard" on Ethan and said he would walk away from arguments if he needed to.
She described Mr Ives, who was also her carer, as being a father who loved his children and grandchildren and was affectionate.She added that Ethan was in the terrible twos phase and would "play up if didn't get own way" and would "scream and throw himself back".She admitted Mr Ives was not mentally well and she was also unwell, living with fibromyalgia and rheumatoid arthritis. Getting emotional, Mrs Ives agreed that Mr Ives and Ethan were close and he would wash the toddler every other day, but denied ever seeing bruises on Ethan. Mrs Ives agreed that the 40 marks to Ethan's face and body, discovered after he was admitted to hospital, were "a lot" and had been "a big surprise".
Mrs Ives agreed that, despite previously telling police she and Mr Ives had been like Ethan's parents, they had not kept him safe and had not taken action when he became "skin and bones".She also agreed that both she, Mr Ives and Shannon had neglected Ethan.The trail continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Travis Decker manhunt shifts to Idaho forest after family potentially spots 'killer dad-of-three' at campground
The desperate search for alleged 'killer dad' Travis Decker escalated on Sunday when a family camping in an Idaho forest reported a sighting of a man who matched his description. Decker, 33, was accused of murdering his three daughters, Paityn, 9, Evelyn, 8, and Olivia, 5, and dumping their bodies in Leavenworth, Washington. His daughters' remains were found on June 2, and despite a massive manhunt, authorities have yet to locate the alleged killer. A potential break in the case came over the holiday weekend when a family camping in the Sawtooth National Forest reported a man who matched Decker's description, according to the US Marshals Service Greater Idaho Task Force. The family was camping in the Bear Creek area, of the vast forest, which spans over two million acres across Idaho and Utah. They said the unidentified man was between 5'8" and 5'10," with black gauged earrings and had a black backpack. They added that he was wearing a black mesh cap, a cream-colored shirt, and black shorts. He had his hair in a ponytail and he had a mustache and an overgrown beard. The description matches Decker's appearance, who is 5'8"and weighs around 190 lbs., according to the Chelan County Sheriff's Office. He also has black hair, brown eyes, and earrings. The sheriff's office released doctored photos of Decker to illustrate what he could look like after being on the run for over a month. Authorities have warned that he could be armed and dangerous. Anyone who believes they've spotted Decker has been warned not to approach him and call 911 immediately. The US Marshals Office has offered a reward of up to $20,000 for any information leading to the suspect's arrest. The potential update comes after an exhaustive weeks-long search that left authorities coming up with dead ends. The nightmare saga began on May 30 when Decker picked his daughters up from their mother Whitney's home. Whitney contacted police later that evening after Decker failed to bring the girls home. She expressed concern to authorities due to her ex-husband's history with mental health and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder from his time in the military. Decker was court-mandated to receive mental health treatment and domestic violence anger management counseling but had refused. Police said he was homeless and living out of his car. Authorities said Decker could look differently than his recent images, releasing doctored images of what he may look like now The following day, police issued an Endangered Missing Person Alert for the three girls. On June 2, Decker's vehicle was found, and authorities made the grim discovery of his daughters' remains. Decker was charged with three counts of first-degree murder and kidnapping, but police never found the alleged killer. Reports swirled two days later that Decker was spotted in Idaho, but authorities later dispelled the rumors. An autopsy then confirmed the horrific cause of death was suffocation and their deaths were ruled a homicide. Authorities later said that there was no evidence that Decker was still alive as the sheriff's office pivoted their search with cadaver dogs. However, some experts, including law enforcement and security analyst Todd McGhee, said that Decker's extensive military background may've enabled him to live in the wilderness. Decker joined the Army in 2013 and served in Afghanistan before transferring to the Washington National Guard in 2021, a communications director for the Washington Military Department previously confirmed to the Daily Mail. The Guard was in the process of a disciplinary discharge due to Decker's absences when his daughters' were killed.
BBC News
36 minutes ago
- BBC News
Sunderland-wide anti-social behaviour hubs a step closer
The creation of an anti-social behaviour (ASB) hub in every part of a city is a step closer after three new facilities were confirmed, a police force has hub scheme is expanding to Hendon and Pennywell in Sunderland and Concord and Sulgrave in Washington after data showed higher levels of ASB follows the project's success in Southwick, Hetton and the city centre, where ASB incidents dropped by up to a third, Sunderland City Council leader Kelly Chequer said the new hubs were expected to open in the late summer or in the autumn. Ch Supt Mark Hall of Northumbria Police said: "Launching these additional hubs means we are one step closer to having hubs that cover every ward area in Sunderland."He said similar projects in other parts of the city had been "extremely successful". The local authority said over the last year, incidences of ASB had dropped by about a third in the city centre and Southwick areas and by a fifth in the Hetton and Easington Lane hub area."Dozens of community protection notices, warnings and acceptable behaviour agreements have also been issued across the three areas," a council spokesman council leader Michael Mordey urged people in the newly identified areas to get in touch about their ASB concerns."Residents have seen real benefits from these projects as the issues that matter to them most are tackled," Mordey added. Each hub will have its own community officers, safety specialists and dedicated police support. Follow BBC Sunderland on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
The Sun
38 minutes ago
- The Sun
Hunt for two men after woman ‘raped' in house near city centre in horror early hours attack
POLICE are urgently searching for two men after a woman was reportedly raped in a home in a shocking late-night attack. Cops launched the investigation after receiving reports of the rape in the home, close to the city centre of Hull, East Yorkshire, at around 1am on Thursday. Officers have now released CCTV images of the two individuals they wish to speak to as they may have "valuable information" to help with their investigation.
