Farm tax is risk to UK food security, says former foreign secretary
The former foreign secretary told reporters at a press conference at the National Liberal Club in Whitehall he feared the Government had not considered a scenario of 'moderate disruption' to food supplies, despite warning signs during the Russian- Ukraine war.
Braintree MP Mr Cleverly spoke after farmers parked two vintage tractors outside the National Liberal Club on Tuesday as part of a protest by Save British Farming against the tax changes.
'I do worry that this Government is really blase about food and farming, because it cannot envisage a circumstance where there is even a moderate disruption of UK accessibility to core foods, particularly carbohydrates,' Mr Cleverly said.
'If they're right, well, I'm not sure I still agree with driving farms out of business. If they're wrong, the stakes are so high it is unconscionable.'
The UK is facing 'serious risks' to its food security as a result of long-term declines in the natural environment and worsening climate change, according to the latest three-yearly government report on the matter published in December.
The Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra) report also noted how geopolitical tensions have impacted the country, with the Russian invasion of Ukraine leaving the UK facing the highest food inflation in the G7, although 'sustained' food item shortages were avoided.
Farmers have argued that Rachel Reeves' inheritance tax hike on agricultural properties worth more than £1 million would undermine national food security in a critical moment.
Speaking to reporters, Mr Cleverly argued policymakers should treat agriculture with the same respect as they do the automotive industry and technology companies and called the Chancellor's measures 'one of the most stupid and counterproductive proposals I have ever seen'.
'One of the problems we've had for a number of decades is we've stopped being scared about things that we should be scared of.
'Because we haven't had food shortages in the UK in living memory, we've kind of convinced ourselves that that can never happen.
'I don't think it will happen. I don't think it's necessarily likely to happen, but it's not something that is helpful to think of as being impossible.
'We had a nasty food inflation spike when Ukrainian grain exports were disrupted, even temporarily.'
Mr Cleverly warned in such a scenario, 'voters will go hungry, and then they'll get angry, and then they will turn on the government'.
He added: 'It will be politically catastrophic for the Labour Party. That's the kind of thing that gets you kicked out of government, not just for one or two political cycles, but potentially permanently.
'The biggest falls come after the biggest victories,' he said, noting how the Conservative's major losses last year followed the successes the party had in 2019.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
28 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Corbyn has a big ego and his new party will fail, claims Reeves
Rachel Reeves has accused Jeremy Corbyn of having a 'big ego' and insists his new Left-wing party does not present a threat to Labour. The Chancellor said voters had resoundingly rejected the veteran socialist twice and 'will have the same reaction' again at the next election. At the Edinburgh Fringe Festival on Saturday, she also acknowledged a 'risk' voters would turn to Reform because of anger with the two main parties. Mr Corbyn, who led Labour to election defeats in 2017 and 2019, is setting up a new populist movement to challenge his old party from the Left. It is also being fronted by Zarah Sultana, a fellow former Labour MP, and is set to campaign heavily on Gaza and calls for more wealth taxes. Ms Reeves, who was interviewed by Iain Dale, the radio presenter, was asked whether she was worried that the new party represented a threat to Labour akin to the problem the Tories face with Reform. She said: 'Jeremy Corbyn had two chances to be prime minister and the country gave their verdict, most recently in 2019 when Labour had its worst result since 1935. 'If he wants to give it another go, be my guest. I think the voters will have the same reaction.' Asked by Dale if she was being complacent, she replied: 'It's not being complacent. He tried to destroy my party, he can have himself his own party. 'The country has rejected him twice. The bloke's got a big ego. He can have another go but I think the country will give the same verdict.' Her remarks came a day after Labour lost its first councillor to the new Corbyn party, which does not yet have a name or official leadership. Grace Lewis, a 22-year-old who sits on Coventry city council, resigned from Labour on Friday to join the rival Left-wing political movement. It has a placeholder name of Your Party, and is expected to hold its founding conference, at which a formal leadership contest could happen, in November. Last month, a YouGov poll found that almost one in three Labour supporters would consider voting for Mr Corbyn's new movement at the next election. Ms Reeves also admitted during the interview that Labour has 'disappointed' people so far and will not 'deserve' to win re-election if it does not improve. She insisted she had the balance right between tax, spending and borrowing but said achieving that had forced her to make unpopular decisions. 'Our job is to deliver on promises' She added: 'Of course you're going to disappoint people. No one wants to pay more taxes. 'Everyone wants more money... and borrowing is not a free option, because you've got to pay for it. 'I think people know those sort of constraints, but no one really likes them and I'm the one that has to sort the sums.' She admitted that there was a possibility that voters who were fed up with both Labour and the Tories would turn to Reform as an alternative. 'That is the risk and so our job is to deliver on the promises we made in our manifesto but also to show when we're making decisions who we're prioritising,' she said. 'That we're always prioritising the ordinary, working person on a modest and middle income who have been battered by cost of living challenges the last few years. 'Who haven't found their wages keeping up with inflation, when they want to see a doctor they can't get an appointment, when they're on a hospital waiting list they're on it for months. 'We need to show that things can be different, and if we don't address those things not only will we not win again, we won't deserve to win again. 'Because people voted for change and it's our job to deliver it.'
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
John Swinney brands Gaza crisis 'genocide' after Fringe show disrupted
Scottish First Minister John Swinney has described the ongoing crisis in Gaza as a "genocide" after a Fringe show he appeared at was repeatedly disrupted by pro-Palestinian protesters. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Police were called to the Stand Comedy Club in Edinburgh after the First Minister was interrupted seven times by six different groups of protesters during a conversation with comedian Susan Morrison . The protesters urged the First Minister to describe the crisis as a genocide and stop state funding for arms companies. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Speaking to journalists after the event, the First Minister said: "It's quite clear that there is a genocide in Palestine - it can't be disputed. "I have seen reports of terrible atrocities which have the character of being genocide. "I've expressed that and obviously it's not reached all those individuals, but that's my feeling." First Minister John Swinney appearing with comedian Susan Morrison at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe | Craig Paton/PA Wire Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish Government has also been criticised for - while not funding directly the manufacturing of munitions - providing money for apprenticeships at firms which build weapons. But the First Minister said the Government's commercial arm Scottish Enterprise has the "strictest assessments imaginable about the purpose and the use of public expenditure in companies who may be related to defence industries". Pushed on providing money for staff who could potentially build munitions, the First Minister added: "We're trying to enable companies to diversify their activities, that's the purpose. "That's why the due diligence checks are applied and they are applied unreservedly." Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Throughout the show, groups of attendees stood up, holding signs which spelled the word "genocide", and heckled the First Minister. As the event continued, the interruptions became more forceful, before two groups stood at the same time, angrily shouting at the First Minister and chanting slogans such as "call it genocide". Members of his security team stood in front of the stage, stopping protesters from approaching the First Minister, before three uniformed police officers arrived at the venue to usher the protesters out. During the tense exchange, which lasted several minutes, a number of the crowd - who were not protesting - appeared to be in tears. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A final disruption came from one woman in the crowd, who asked the First Minister why he had not responded to her letter about heavy metal band Disturbed playing at the Hydro in Glasgow . The band's lead singer David Draiman has been criticised after being pictured signing an Israeli bomb. The woman asked the First Minister why he did not speak out on Disturbed playing at the city's biggest venue, when he said it would be inappropriate for Irish band Kneecap to play the TRNSMT festival after comments members of the band had made about Tory MPs. The First Minister said his comments on Kneecap had come due to questions from the media and he "didn't particularly" want to speak about the band earlier this year, adding that he did not want to choose what art people do and do not consume. The woman became increasingly angry with the First Minister's response and was eventually dragged from the venue by a police officer, whom she branded a "thug".
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Labour does not deserve to win next election without change, Reeves says
Labour does not 'deserve' to win the next election if it does not change the country, Rachel Reeves has said, as she acknowledged some voters were disappointed with the party's record since entering government. The chancellor said she understood the unhappiness felt by some voters towards a government that has U-turned on winter fuel allowance and welfare policies in recent months. Reeves claims she has had to grapple with financial challenges inherited from the Conservatives, while increasing spending to repair public services. Speaking to broadcaster Iain Dale at the Edinburgh festival fringe, she said: 'The reason people voted Labour at the last election is they want to change and they were unhappy with the way that the country was being governed. 'They know that we inherited a mess. They know it's not easy to put it right, but people are impatient for change. 'I'm impatient for change as well, but I've also got the job of making sure the sums always add up – and it doesn't always make you popular because you can't do anything you might want to do. You certainly can't do everything straight away, all at once.' She told the audience at the Edinburgh International Conference Centre that Labour needed to enact the change that voters wanted. She added otherwise the party did not 'deserve' to win the next general election in 2029. Reeves said the government had the balance 'about right' on taxes, in a week where she faced renewed calls from Labour politicians for a wealth tax. Former Foreign Office minister Anneliese Dodds, who briefly held the shadow chancellor position for Labour in opposition, said ministers should consider evidence set out by the Wealth Tax Commission, which she said had 'changed the debate' on the policy. Reeves said: 'Of course you're going to disappoint people. No one wants to pay more taxes. Everyone wants more money than public spending – and borrowing is not a free option, because you've got to pay for it. 'I think people know those sort of constraints but no one really likes them and I'm the one that has to sort the sums up.' The party faces difficulties ahead of the Scottish parliament elections in Holyrood next year. It has slipped backwards into third place, according to opinion polling, a year after it was neck and neck with the SNP. Polling in June showed it on 19%, behind the SNP in 29% and Reform UK on 22%. This is in contrast to a survey carried out a month after Labour's general election win last year, which showed the party just ahead of the ruling SNP, with Reform languishing far behind. There have been some signs of promise, however, as Labour won the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse byelection for the Scottish parliament in June. The closure of the Grangemouth oil refinery before its transition to an import-only terminal caused unpopularity for Labour. About 400 jobs were lost as a result of it shutting in April. The MP who had championed it being kept open, Brian Leishman, has since been suspended by Labour for rebelling over welfare reform. Meanwhile, the Labour government in Westminster's ban on new drilling in the North Sea has been accused of causing 'strangulation' of the economy in north-east Scotland. However, Reeves told the audience in the Scottish capital that the government was further investing in Scotland. She said the £200m investment in carbon capture technology in Aberdeenshire had been welcomed by the industry. She said she also understood Labour's windfall tax on oil and gas were not welcomed by the sector. 'I can understand that that's extra tax that the oil and gas sector are paying but you can't really have one without the other,' she said.
