Decode Politics: In Bihar, why Rahul Gandhi alleged funds meant for Dalits not reaching them
The Congress MP was speaking at an inaugural meeting of the Congress's 'Shiksha Nyay Sanvad' campaign, which will focus on education issues and discuss grievances of students, on Thursday.
The SCSP is the Central government's strategy to ensure a proportionate flow of resources for the development of SCs through the implementation of infrastructure, education, health and other welfare schemes in areas with a substantial Dalit population.
The SCSP was started in 1980 by then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in her bid to reach out to Dalits. The SCSP's funds are channelled through the Union Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, which provides Special Central Assistance. There are three categories of SCSP schemes: fully Centre-funded, fully state-funded, and hybrid schemes split between the Centre and the state in a 60:40 ratio.
As per recent Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) reports, the Bihar government allocated Rs 16,777 crore for its SCSP schemes in 2021-22, but allegedly diverted Rs 10,799 crore to general schemes.
Similarly, Rs 18,450 crore of the Rs 19,688 crore allocated for SCSP schemes was allegedly diverted to non-SC schemes in 2022-23. In 2023-24, the state government allegedly spent Rs 11,796 crore on general schemes from the total SCSP fund of Rs 16,939 crore.
Some of the key SCSP schemes include income-generating initiatives, financial assistance for the construction or upgrade of houses, providing free land for housing, education and skill development schemes such as free distribution of books and school uniforms.
After the latest CAG report on the Bihar government's performance flagged problems in the SCSP funds, as many as nine Bihar legislators, including CPI(ML)(L) MLA Satyadev Ram, questioned the Janata Dal (United)-led state government on the alleged diversion of funds in the Assembly in March.
While the state government did not dismiss the CAG findings, it said the auditor did not use the term 'diversion' but had only described the department-wise allocations of the SCSP fund.
For instance, in 2023-24, the CAG report said, from the Rs 16,939 crore of SCPS funds, Rs 1,447 crore was allocated to the Chief Minister Local Area Development Scheme and for flood control, Rs 3,465 crore went towards the construction of medical colleges, Rs 394 crore for the construction of government buildings, and Rs 212 crore for the construction of state hospitals and health service buildings, among other projects. A Rs 460 crore loan of state electricity companies was also repaid using the SCSP funds.
The Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes submitted a report on social justice to both Houses of Parliament in August 2018 in which it flagged concerns about the use of funds intended for SCs.
'Under the allocation for welfare of Scheduled Castes, diversion of funds is not permissible and the funds are earmarked only for SCs, but due to the general nature of the schemes of some ministries/departments, funds are not utilised fully,' the report said. The Committee also recommended that the NITI Aayog monitor SCSP funds to ensure they are not underutilised or diverted.
Social activist Rajiv Kumar, who has written several letters to the Centre on the matter, said neither the Centre nor the state government had been ready to accept that funds were diverted even though the money was 'blatantly used by other departments'.
Rahul Gandhi sees potential in turning this into a political issue ahead of the Assembly polls later this year, since Dalits account for 19.65% of the state population.
Gandh told the students in Darbhanga, 'You have no place in this country; there is no place for 90% of the people of the country. Right from the senior bureaucracy to the Government of India, high courts and top management of educational and medical (institutions), there is zero representation for 90% of the population. But MGNREGA is full of your people. The SCSP funds meant for SCs are not reaching them. All the riches are with 5-10% of people.'
Though the Congress has raised the alleged diversion of SCSP funds at the national level from time to time, it is for the first time that the party is taking up the matter in Bihar. In the 2020 Assembly polls, the Congress won 19 seats. Four of its MLAs are Dalits.
The BJP-led NDA, however, maintained it was up to bureaucrats to explain the nitty-gritty of the SCSP rules. JD(U) MLC Neeraj Kumar said, 'When the state government has explained the matter in the Assembly, it should not be politicised.'
A senior Bihar-cadre IAS officer said, 'It is true that SCSP funds are used for many purposes, but it is done with due permission from the Centre.'
Santosh Singh is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express since June 2008. He covers Bihar with main focus on politics, society and governance. Investigative and explanatory stories are also his forte. Singh has 25 years of experience in print journalism covering Bihar, Delhi, Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka.
... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
37 minutes ago
- Mint
Pentagon official at center of weapons pause on Ukraine wants US to focus on China
WASHINGTON : Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon's top policy official, wants to refocus the U.S. military on countering China. That has put him at the center of the Trump administration's abrupt moves on providing weapons to Ukraine. It was Colby, a 45-year-old grandson of a former Central Intelligence Agency director, who wrote a memo to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in early June outlining how Ukraine's requests for U.S. weapons could further stretch already depleted Pentagon stockpiles. The memo didn't have a recommendation and was described by a defense official as a tool for assessing how arms deliveries would affect U.S. stockpiles. But some officials in the administration and in Congress say it figured in the Pentagon's decision to suspend some arms shipments to Kyiv, a move President Trump later reversed. The incident exemplifies Colby's push to make good on years of U.S. vows to boost its military position in the Western Pacific, his supporters say. But it also highlights the contrary pressures on an administration that, in its first months in office, has already launched major military operations against Iran and the Houthis in the Middle East while continuing military deliveries to Ukraine. Colby 'has been thinking very deeply about how the United States can best defend itself in an era of constrained resources," said Dan Caldwell, a former adviser to Hegseth. 'A lot of policymakers have refused to accept that reality." Colby has turned down interview requests about his views on helping Ukraine and in urging U.S. partners in Asia and Europe to step up their defense efforts. But in a social-media message Saturday, he said that he would continue to press allies to boost their military spending, even if some 'might not welcome frank discussions." Some of those frank discussions have included pressing Japan and Australia to make clear what military steps they are prepared to take in the event of a Chinese attack on Taiwan, according to a person familiar with the exchanges. Colby's efforts have surprised some officials in the region because the U.S.'s longstanding policy of 'strategic ambiguity" has avoided an explicit statement about what actions Washington might take if Chinese forces moved against Taiwan, and even Trump hasn't spelled out what he would do. Colby's discussions were earlier reported by the Financial Times. In arguing for doubling down on China, Colby is known as a 'prioritizer" who favors limiting U.S. obligations outside Asia to free up resources to counter Beijing. In so doing, he has differentiated himself from 'restrainers" who have urged that the U.S. pull back from overseas commitments, as well as traditional Republican hawks. Though presidents from both parties, starting with Barack Obama, have called for focusing U.S. national security strategy on China, putting the idea into practice has proven difficult, partly due to new threats that have emerged outside Asia and partly due to the Pentagon's longstanding commitments in Europe and the Middle East. Colby's calls to de-emphasize demands on U.S. forces other than in Asia have left him out of step with some Republicans. 'For many years, GOP 'prioritizers' have argued that the United States should not strike Iran or aid Ukraine because it must husband its resources for a possible war with China," said Matthew Kroenig of the Atlantic Council, who was a national security adviser to the 2012 Mitt Romney and 2016 Marco Rubio presidential campaigns. 'President Trump, in contrast, believes 'America First' requires continued U.S. involvement in multiple regions of the world." When Trump nominated Colby to serve as undersecretary of defense for policy in December, the fissures among Republicans over national security came to the fore. Colby received a hearty endorsement at his March confirmation hearing from Vice President JD Vance, who has long been a skeptical voice on providing billions of dollars in weapons to Ukraine and has called Colby a friend. Colby was grilled by Sen. Tom Cotton (R., Ark.) about his past statement that it was feasible to contain a nuclear-armed Iran. Colby amended his stance in that confirmation hearing, saying that Iran cannot be allowed to develop nuclear weapons and that he would provide the president with military options to stop it from doing so. Sen. Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the only Republican to vote against Colby's confirmation, lambasted him for promoting policies that could lead to 'geostrategic self-harm." Colby has deep family connections to the foreign policy establishment through his grandfather, former CIA Director William Colby. 'Bridge," as he is known in Washington, attended school in Japan, where his father worked for an investment bank, before graduating from Harvard University. At Yale Law School he was a housemate of Jon Finer, the former deputy national security adviser to President Joe Biden. Even then, Colby's contrarian foreign policy priorities were evident: He was a rare Republican who opposed the war in Iraq. Colby has written that the 2003 Iraq war and the lengthy U.S. occupation was a 'historic error" that squandered vast resources. He argued in a 2012 article against striking Iran's nuclear facilities, saying it would provide Tehran 'every incentive to reboot the program with greater vigor." As a deputy assistant secretary of defense during Trump's first term, he played a major role in the drafting of the 2018 national defense strategy, which urged a shift from a focus on counterterrorism that the Pentagon adopted after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks to countering China and Russia. Colby's role wasn't without turbulence. Trump's defense secretary at the time, retired Marine Gen. Jim Mattis, was frustrated with Colby's emphasis on defending Taiwan, participants recall. 'I think Bridge did a really good job in managing the strategy formulation process," said Frank Hoffman, a retired Marine colonel who was brought in by Mattis to help draft the strategy document. 'But in making Taiwan the hinge point of our military competition with China, he had a narrower focus than Secretary Mattis on what the strategy needed to do." Colby elaborated on his views in his 2021 book, 'The Strategy of Denial," in which he argued that the defense of Taiwan was vital because of its proximity to China, along with Japan and the Philippines, forming what Pentagon strategists refer to as the first island chain in the Western Pacific. His focus on China, he noted in the book, included arguing that Russia could be a 'potential collaborator" with the U.S. in an anti-Beijing coalition. And he warned against including Ukraine in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization because the country was 'highly exposed" to a Russia attack 'while offering no meaningful advantage to the alliance that is remotely comparable to the costs and risk that their defense would impose on it." But Colby's call for reprioritizing Pentagon strategy was tested after Russia invaded Ukraine the following year and turned to Beijing for help in expanding the Russian defense industry. Instead of dealing with China in isolation, Washington has faced the prospect of simultaneously deterring two geographically disparate adversaries that have been cooperating. Colby is playing a pivotal role in policy debate and the crafting of a new defense strategy that will set spending and force deployment goals for years to come. Some current and former officials who share Colby's goal of boosting American capabilities in the Pacific say he may be better at standing on principle than bringing allies along. Colby has irked Tokyo by urging that it commit to boosting military spending to 3.5% of its gross domestic product, they say. With policy disagreements over military spending and tariffs, Japan put off high-level talks with the U.S. that had been expected in July. A review Colby is conducting of a 2021 agreement—known as Aukus, under which Australia will get nuclear-powered attack submarines from the U.S. while contributing several billion dollars to the U.S. defense-industrial base—has concerned Australian officials. In an interview with Australian television last year, Colby said it would be 'crazy" for the U.S. to provide attack submarines to Australia unless the Pentagon can be assured it would have enough for itself, adding that the U.S. would be 'lucky" to get to the 2030s without a conflict with China. But it was the classified memo that preceded the pause in arms deliveries to Ukraine that especially spotlighted Colby's views. It tallied the numbers of weapons sought by Ukraine along with how many the U.S. has in its stocks for training and warfighting around the world. Trump later told Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky that he wasn't responsible for the pause in shipments that followed, which he has since lifted. Wess Mitchell, a former senior State Department official who once started a policy organization with Colby called the Marathon Initiative, said the Pentagon official's focus on making tough decisions to deter China is driven by concern that the U.S. is overstretched. 'Bridge has put his finger on the real problem and said 'Let's give priority to the main threat even if that means we have to accept trade-offs in the other regions,' " Mitchell said. 'People may disagree with his approach, but it is driven by a legitimate concern, which is we don't currently have the resources for a three-front war." Write to Michael R. Gordon at and Lara Seligman at
The Print
41 minutes ago
- The Print
New RE policy to attract Rs 1.5 lakh cr investment, generate jobs: Bihar Energy Secy
Other key objectives of the policy are promoting new and efficient techniques for development of RE and storage projects, increasing awareness for RE integration, and maximizing stakeholder participation for RE development among others. Launched earlier this week, the policy for 'Promotion of Bihar New and Renewable Energy Sources 2025' aims to harness 23.96 gigawatt (GW) of renewable energy and 6.1 GW of storage by FY 2029-30 through non-conventional sources and energy storage potential of the state. New Delhi, Jul 12 (PTI) Bihar's new renewable energy policy has the potential not only to attract investments worth Rs 1.5 lakh crore but also generate huge employment opportunities across the state, Bihar's Energy Secretary Manoj Kumar Singh said. Sharing his views with PTI, the secretary said, 'This is one of the most progressive policies in the country. Bihar will not only lead in the clean energy sphere but also make significant contributions to India's commitment towards Net Zero. Besides becoming one of the most attractive investment destinations, it will generate huge employment opportunities as the next renewable hub of the country.' Singh said Bihar is offering one of the most attractive policy regimes in the country and assures investors of policy support which will help them with good returns for their investments in the state. When asked about the expected investments and job opportunities, the official said the policy has potential to attract investments of 'Rs 1,50,000 crore and generate 1,25,000 jobs.' Replying to another question on the benefits for investors, the secretary said the policy introduces a highly competitive suite of incentives designed to attract investors and developers from across the country. These include a streamlined single-window clearance system to fast-track project approvals and comprehensive financial benefits such as 100 per cent reimbursement of SGST, land conversion fees, and stamp duty on lease or transfer of land. The policy also grants a 100 per cent waiver on electricity duty for 15 years and provides long-term open access for 25 years along with full exemption from transmission and wheeling charges. State utilities will bear the cost of transmission and distribution infrastructure up to 10 kilometers, with shared responsibility beyond that point. 'I urge national and international investors to invest in the state and avail the benefits of the policy. The entire policy is in the public domain. The government will fully support the investors to address their concerns,' he added. PTI ABI ANU This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Haryana: CM Nayab Singh Saini flags off Kaithal Half Marathon
Haryana Chief Minister Nayab Singh Saini on Sunday flagged off the Kaithal Half Marathon . A large number of people took part in the half marathon, which started from Kaithal, a city in Haryana. Earlier, CM Saini on Saturday heard public grievances at Jan Pratinidhi Sammelan and Jan Samvad programme in Kaithal. According to an official release, CM Saini said that Nagar Parishad, Block Samiti, and Zila Parishad members have a direct relation with people, and citizens have a lot of expectations from them, so public representatives should solve their problems on a priority basis. They should also take full care of the quality of development works going on in their area. CM Saini said that the main objective of organising this programme is to give impetus to whatever development work is going on or is to be done in their area by directly communicating with the public. He said that ever since he became the Chief Minister, he has provided funds for development works for the Gram Panchayat as well as the Zila Parishad so that development works can be accelerated. Recently, an amount of about Rs 700 crore has also been made available for the local body. The Chief Minister urged the public representatives to inspire people to take advantage of the government's flagship programmes and schemes. Public representatives should speed up water conservation , cleanliness campaign, PM Surya Ghar Muft Bijli Yojana and Ek Ped Maa Ke Naam Abhiyan in their respective areas. He said that wherever the construction work of streets is being done, clear instructions have been given that if any pipeline or other work is to be laid anywhere, the concerned agency will ensure that it is done. After the construction of the street, people should not face any kind of problem due to the pipeline or other work. CM told the public representatives present on the occasion that any person in their area, ward or rural area who has completed 70 years of age should be helped in getting an Ayushman card made so that they can get the benefit of this ambitious scheme of the government. Along with this, people must be motivated to install a 2-kilowatt solar energy panel under the PM Surya Ghar Muft Bijli Yojana. On this occasion, Nagar Parishad Chairperson Surbhi Garg and Zila Parishad Chairperson Karmveer Kaul put forth the problems of the area before the Chief Minister through a demand letter. The Chief Minister also heard the problems of the people in detail at the Jan Samvad programme. He went among the people and listened to the problems of each applicant, reassuring everyone that their problems would be resolved on a priority basis. Saini also honoured meritorious students , progressive farmers, and individuals leading in social service by presenting them with letters of appreciation.
