Public Services Card database of millions of Irish people's faces declared illegal
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) said it partially welcomes the findings, but said the decision is "more than a decade late and inadequate".
Advertisement
The Government had previously claimed that the facial records were not biometric data. On Thursday, the DPC found that the Department of Social Protection (DSP) unlawfully collected facial records (biometric data) from 70 per cent of the population of Ireland over 15 years.
In addition, the ICCL said the department failed to tell people why it was collecting their facial records and whether it was legal.
In light of the infringements discovered by the DPC, it reprimanded the Department of Social Protection by issuing administrative fines totalling €550,000.
It also issued an order to the department requiring it to cease processing of biometric data in connection with SAFE 2 registration within nine months of this decision if the department cannot identify a valid lawful basis.
Advertisement
Deputy commissioner, Graham Doyle, said: 'It is important to note that none of the findings of infringement identified, nor the corrective powers exercised by the DPC, pertain to the rollout of SAFE 2 registration by the DSP as a matter of principle.
"The DPC did not find any evidence of inadequate technical and organisational security measures deployed by the DSP in connection with SAFE 2 registration in the context of this inquiry.
"This inquiry was concerned with assessing whether the legislative framework presently in place for SAFE 2 registration complies with the requirements of data protection law and whether the DSP operates SAFE 2 registration in a data protection-compliant manner, and the findings announced today identify a number of deficiencies in this regard.'
'Illegal facial database'
The ICCL said the Data Protection Commission failed to take decisive action on Thursday and said that, after 15 years, its actions are not enough.
Advertisement
The ICCL is insisting on the immediate deletion of the illegal facial data database.
It has also called for the department and the DPC to explain to the Oireachtas and the public how this system was permitted to operate unlawfully for so long.
Executive Director of ICCL, Joe O'Brien, said: 'For many years, ICCL and our colleagues at Digital Rights Ireland, have argued that the PSC's mandatory use of facial recognition technology is unlawful.
'This is a partial win for the privacy and data protection rights of people living in Ireland. It confirms what we have advocated for, for many years - that the Public Services Card, which was estimated to have cost the State €100 million, trespassed upon human rights and infringed EU and Irish law.
'The DPC decision is over a decade late and does not go far enough. The Department effectively created a de facto national biometric ID system by stealth over 15-plus years without a proper legal foundation. This illegal database of millions of Irish people's biometric data must be deleted.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
35 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Man caught with child abuse material claimed he was acting as vigilante
A man who claimed he was 'acting in the capacity of a vigilante' when he was caught with videos of child sex abuse will be sentenced later for possession and distribution of the material. Murilo Dos Santos (36) of North Circular Road, Dublin 1, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to possession of images of child sexual abuse, known in law as child pornography and to distribution of the material on dates between November 18th, 2020 and January 2021. He has no previous convictions. Advertisement Detective Garda Donagh Mannix told Derek Cooney BL, prosecuting, that the then home of Dos Santos, in Christchurch in Dublin city, was searched in connection to an unrelated matter and his phone was seized as part of that investigation. The phone was subsequently analysed and 66 videos were found which were considered to be in contravention of the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act. Dos Santos shared various videos with six other people on dates between October 2020 and November 2020. Det Gda Mannix gave a description of one of these particularly graphic videos which involved a child estimated to be between six and 12 months old. The child was strapped down and unable to move in the footage. This video was five minutes long. The detective outlined further videos of children, most aged between eight and 12 years old, either involved in sexual activity with each other or sometimes sexual activity with an adult male. Advertisement There were also more videos involving younger children, described by Det Gda Mannix as toddlers. Gardaí also discovered that Dos Santos was using a sharing app which allowed him to share and receive links from others. The analysis showed that he was using one sharing app between September 2020 and October 2020. Det Gda Mannix said there were a number of files shared in this application, mainly videos which were of a similarly graphic nature to the others found on the defendant's phone. A Whatsapp account had also been created and gardaí were able to recover conversations between Dos Santos and others, with Dos Santos sharing a link to a folder termed – a MEGA folder. He also told the other users where he lived in Dublin, shared a photograph of his own face and suggested meeting up. Advertisement Det Gda Mannix told Mr Cooney that a large number of videos were sent – this time involving children between 10 and 14 years old, again engaged in sexual activity. The court heard extracts from conversations between various people and Dos Santos including him stating that he had more and they could be sent on later. Dos Santos also used a chat application for chat and file sharing. The court heard more extracts from conversations Dos Santos had on this app. The conversations included chat about 'what are you into?' and what 'kind of stuff' they could get and share before further videos of child abuse material was shared. Advertisement Judge Orla Crowe considered documentation before the court, including refences on behalf of Dos Santos and acceded to a request from defending counsel, Dara Foynes SC, to adjourn the case to allow for the preparation of a report from a psychologist. The judge revoked Dos Santos bail and remanded him in custody until December 1, 2025 for sentence. Det Gda Mannix agreed with Ms Foynes that no one else who conversed with Dos Santos in these apps has been prosecuted. He further agreed that her client was easily identifiable in that he sent a photograph of himself and mentioned where he lived. It was accepted that no person engaging with Dos Santos shared such information. Advertisement Det Gda Mannix agreed that this was a sub culture – on the 'margins of what is deemed normal society'. It was further accepted that at one point during his interview, Dos Santos suggested to gardaí that he was accessing this material because he was 'acting in the capacity of a vigilante'. It was acknowledged that he was 'teetering on the brink of serious self harm' and that he has not come to any adverse garda attention since. Ms Foynes submitted that a report from a psychologist would be of assistance to the court in sentencing her client. She acknowledged that it was 'a very shocking offence' that has 'weighed very heavily on my client', counsel said, before adding that Dos Santos had blocked his ears during some of the evidence in court, such was the level of his shame and remorse. Ms Foynes said it was an offence that is 'very difficult to comprehend' adding that the sharing of such material in this sub-culture is 'heinous'. She said Dos Santos has been in Ireland for 16 years and financially supports his mother.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Acclaimed US journalist Jim Acosta announced for Kennedy Summer School
The Kennedy Summer School has announced that acclaimed American journalist and author Jim Acosta will be a featured guest speaker at this year's event, taking place in New Ross, Co Wexford, from August 28th to 30th. On Saturday afternoon, August 30th, former CNN chief White House correspondent Jim Acosta will take part in a conversation with Dr Stacey Connaughton of Purdue University. Advertisement Renowned for his distinguished career in journalism, Mr Acosta gained national recognition as CNN's chief White House correspondent, where his rigorous questioning and high-profile exchanges with president Donald Trump made headlines worldwide. Mr Acosta joined CNN in 2007 after beginning his career in local radio and television and with CBS News, where he covered issues including the 2004 presidential election, the Iraq War and Hurricane Katrina. He covered Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton's campaigns for the 2008 presidential election at the beginning of his time at CNN before becoming a national political correspondent and covering Mitt Romney's 2012 presidential campaign. He was promoted to senior White House correspondent during Mr Obama's second term as president, then became chief White House correspondent in 2018, during Donald Trump's first term as president. Mr Acosta now hosts The Jim Acosta Show on Substack and YouTube. Advertisement His participation in the Kennedy Summer School will offer attendees a unique opportunity to hear his reflections on journalism, American politics, and the challenges facing democracy today. The 2025 Kennedy Summer School opens on Thursday, August 28th, with a Schools STEM Event at the JFK Arboretum featuring Veronica Campbell, and Ciarán Seoighe, and Dr Charles Larkin moderated by Prof Patrick Prendergast. That afternoon, Seán O'Rourke will host a Tea Party with music by Sharon Clancy, compered by Seán Connick. The official opening that evening at St Michael's Theatre will be led by Eileen Dunne, followed by a screening and discussion of From That Small Island with Prof Bríona Nic Dhiarmada, Prof Jane Ohlmeyer, Brian Murphy, and Colm Mac Con Iomaire. Friday includes a Great Gatsby centenary session with Prof Kirk Curnutt. A "senior government figure will speak at the Speakers' Lunch". Panels follow on local journalism (Alan Corcoran, Brenda Power, Jessica O'Connor, Dave O'Connell, Bill Forry) and the Noel Whelan Interview with Colm Tóibín and Sinéad McSweeney. The day ends with 'President Trump & Us' moderated by Tony Connelly.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
George Gibney expected to return to Ireland to face criminal charges
Former Irish Olympic swimming coach George Gibney is expected to return to Ireland as early as Tuesday to face criminal charges. The 77-year-old was arrested on foot of an Irish extradition warrant in Florida earlier this month. Advertisement Mr Gibney has been charged with 78 counts of indecent assault and one charge of attempted rape against four minor females aged between eight and 15 years at the time of the alleged offences. It is understood that Mr Gibney will be flown back to Ireland tonight and is expected to arrive in Ireland on Tuesday. He is being accompanied by gardaí on the flight. He will be brought before Dublin District Court once he arrives back in the state. It comes almost two weeks after a US judge ordered the extradition of Mr Gibney. Advertisement US magistrate Judge Daniel Irick made the order at a hearing in Florida earlier this month. The decision came after Mr Gibney had agreed to be extradited from the US to stand trial over multiple sex offence charges. In court documents, it stated that Mr Gibney is sought by the Irish Government, which has filed charges against him and obtained a warrant for his arrest. Mr Gibney, who had sex offence charges against him dismissed in the 1990s, has lived in the US for years. Advertisement In 2020, the podcast Where Is George Gibney, produced by Second Captains and the BBC, highlighted allegations of abuse against Mr Gibney and prompted new complainants to come forward.
