logo
Gas is a gamble — and WA just doubled down

Gas is a gamble — and WA just doubled down

The Age4 days ago
Premier Roger Cook says'Gas is good, like it or not.' It's a revealing remark—especially as Woodside's North West Shelf, Australia's largest gas project, has just been approved for a life extension out to 2070. That decision alone will lock in billions in gas-related investment for decades to come, shaping Western Australia's economic trajectory long after most of the world has moved on from fossil fuels.
The message is clear: WA is doubling down on gas. But for many West Australians, this is starting to feel like a gamble with high stakes and few winners. It might be good for energy giants and shareholders, but for households, small businesses, and the state's long-term prosperity, the risks are mounting.
We've been here before. When the mining boom collapsed around 2014, the pain wasn't limited to the Pilbara or Goldfields. Perth's housing market slumped, fly-in fly-out jobs disappeared, and state revenues fell off a cliff. The entire economy had been hitched to global commodities—and when prices crashed, so did WA's growth.
Now, the same pattern is repeating. WA is a gas heavyweight—exporting 47 million tonnes of LNG last year and supplying around 60 per cent of Australia's gas. Yet despite its vast reserves and a 15 per cent domestic reservation policy, local households are still facing higher gas prices, driven not by local scarcity but by exposure to international markets.
Since 2020, wholesale gas prices in WA have tripled, and consumers now face some of the highest retail gas prices in the country. If one of the world's most gas-rich jurisdictions—backed by a domestic reservation—can't deliver affordable gas to its own people, then the system clearly isn't working in the public interest. It's a glaring contradiction: vast local supply, a legislated carve-out, and yet rising costs for the very people the policy was meant to protect.
International energy markets are growing more volatile, not less. Global demand is softening, supply is ramping up, and price swings driven by conflict or speculation are becoming the norm. Key buyers like Japan are cutting back their LNG imports whilst on-selling around half the gas we sell them, a sign that demand is not what it once was. China's LNG imports have fluctuated significantly since 2020.
And yet, instead of planning for a diversified future, WA is entrenching its reliance on gas. The approval of the North West Shelf extension to 2070 isn't just a regulatory tick—it's a signal to markets, governments and financial institutions that WA intends to stay in the gas game for the long haul. That decision will direct capital, infrastructure and political energy toward propping up a sector that faces deep structural risk—not just from climate constraints, but from basic economics.
The danger isn't only environmental. It's economic. Every new dollar committed to gas is a dollar not invested in emerging industries like clean energy manufacturing, critical minerals processing, green hydrogen, green ammonia or green iron. While other states and countries build competitive advantage in renewables and advanced manufacturing, WA is backing an industry that's losing momentum and market certainty.
This is the real missed opportunity. WA has what it takes to lead in the clean economy—land, labour, minerals, world-class ports and skilled workers. But for too long, successive governments have prioritised resource exports over building sovereign capability. The result is a lopsided economy, vulnerable to global shocks, and increasingly disconnected from where the world is heading.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former minister says WA government could easily enact shire takeover
Former minister says WA government could easily enact shire takeover

ABC News

time20 hours ago

  • ABC News

Former minister says WA government could easily enact shire takeover

Former local government minister Tony Simpson says a so-called boundary adjustment could be sealed with the "stroke of a pen", amid concerns from ratepayers about the proposed tie-up of two councils in regional Western Australia. The Shire of Coolgardie in WA's Goldfields is fighting for survival amid debts of more than $27.5 million and a government-led push to merge with its much larger neighbour, the City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder. Representatives from both councils met this week in Perth with Local Government Minister Hannah Beazley, who also has her hands full with the troubled City of Nedlands. The City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder is yet to publicly reveal if it is for or against the proposed tie-up, while the Shire of Coolgardie has threatened possible legal action. "I would think, given their financial situation, they would have better things to spend their money on," Ms Beazley told reporters on Wednesday. The government's language has carefully avoided the words merger or amalgamation, despite the end result being effectively the same, with the Shire of Coolgardie dissolved. Ms Beazley said the process would include public consultation. "They are two very different things; it's just because one entity is adjusting the boundaries, only affecting one other, so it is not affecting multiple local government areas." Under WA's Local Government Act, a merger or amalgamation requires majority support from ratepayers in both local government areas. But Mr Simpson said the boundary adjustment put forward for Coolgardie and Kalgoorlie-Boulder could be accomplished with the "stroke of a pen". "In a merger, local government goes to the polls and if 50 per cent of a community turns up and says no, you've got yourself into a corner where you can't force it any further," he said. Mr Simpson, who is a City of Karratha councillor, said he tried unsuccessfully during his time as minister to reduce the number of Perth councils from 30 to 15. "I failed miserably, for a number of reasons," he said. "Local governments put up a very good battle." Mr Simpson said the combination of the Coolgardie and Kalgoorlie-Boulder councils would make the Goldfields region stronger. "A larger local government has a stronger capacity to deliver more services and keep rates flowing. That is proven over and over, so I think it would be worthwhile," he said. "If the debt is the only issue, we should put that aside in the business case and have a look at the strength of the two local governments coming together." Former Kalgoorlie-Boulder mayor John Bowler, also a former local government minister in the Carpenter government, said there was little incentive for the larger city to take on Coolgardie. Mr Bowler said the Shire of Coolgardie's plan to sell council-owned workers' accommodation should be allowed to play out to see if it could return debt to manageable levels. "I don't think anything's going to happen while there's unrecovered debt," he said. "Why should the ratepayers of Kalgoorlie-Boulder pay for the mistakes of Coolgardie? "First of all, I think we have to let Coolgardie see how they go with the sale of that camp." Mr Bowler said he was approached to play a role in the tie-up, but said he would not consider getting involved until the Shire of Coolgardie's debt was retired. "The trouble is the size of Kalgoorlie-Boulder is about 10 times bigger and it really wouldn't be a joint, equal merger," he said. A long-time resident of the tiny community of Widgiemooltha and former Coolgardie shire councillor, Jan McLeod, said any takeover by Kalgoorlie-Boulder would limit her community's voice. "Any representation on council will be lost by sheer weight of numbers," she said. "It's not good for local government, which is the government closest to the people." Ms McLeod said there would be a loss of identity for residents. "The City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder does not service any regional towns; there will be staffing issues," she said. Ms Beazley denied there would be staffing issues. "That's the solutions and options we're working through at the moment," she said. "There would still need to be local services and a footprint in Coolgardie to ensure that community is well served."

WA spends up on electronics in June but EOFY sales may just be a one-off retail sugar hit
WA spends up on electronics in June but EOFY sales may just be a one-off retail sugar hit

West Australian

timea day ago

  • West Australian

WA spends up on electronics in June but EOFY sales may just be a one-off retail sugar hit

The Reserve Bank of Australia's two rate cuts this year have encouraged WA consumers to take advantage of end of financial year bargains in June, but one expert warns the retail sugar hit may just be a one-off. West Australians spent up on mobile phones, computers and white goods during the mid-year clearance discount season, with Bankwest's latest report showing transaction volume for electric appliances surged 21 per cent month-on-month in June. The bank's monthly analysis crunches the numbers on WA customer credit and debit activity to spot responses to fluctuating economic conditions. Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre director Alan Duncan said cost-conscious shoppers tend to be interested in big-ticket items, like white goods, during any promotional events, whether that's EOFY, Black Friday or Boxing Day sales. 'The quantum of saving appears to be much greater, so if you're spending $1000 rather than $1500 or $2000 on an electrical appliance then of course that's going to seem relatively attractive,' he said. But Professor Duncan said it was too early to tell if the bank data showed a broad recovery in consumer spending, pointing to the slight 2 per cent growth in transaction value in June. 'You are seeing a shift towards appliances, recreation and department stores, but a shift away from other consumptions and I think for that reason it's not necessarily that there is a net substantial increase in spending,' he said. 'You do see people being aware of potential value in sales items and going for those, but then maybe moderating what they spend in other months of the year. 'There are also some risks on the horizon, particularly if . . . rents continue to grow.' Recreation and department stores recorded a 14 per cent and 11 per cent growth in transaction volume, respectively, in June. Discount stores and other services, like courier services and roadside assistance companies, posted a 4 per cent decline. It comes as recent data from property listings platform Domain earlier this month revealed Perth house rents lifted 0.7 per cent, or $5, to a fresh high of $700 a week in the June quarter. Professor Duncan said a weekly rent of $700 would eat up about 62 per cent of the average single person's $1125 disposable income — more than double the threshold that constitutes mortgage stress. Local business owner Frank Beverwijk said sales for computers, laptops and accessories at his Arrow Computers was 'okay' in June and that it had picked up from prior months. Asked if further interest rate cuts would encourage more spending among his customers, Mr Beverwijk: 'Absolutely'. 'Everyone is in survival mode so that would be the case,' he said. 'When the mortgage rates are sky-high even small businesses . . . are very worried about borrowing money to either make money or (just) to have spare cash around.' Investors have upped their bets on an August rate cut after recent data showed Australia's jobs boom stalled in June.

Australian energy giant ditches US plant as Trump attacks green power
Australian energy giant ditches US plant as Trump attacks green power

Sydney Morning Herald

time2 days ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

Australian energy giant ditches US plant as Trump attacks green power

Woodside, the largest Australian oil and gas company, has abandoned plans to build a lower-carbon fuels plant in the United States as energy users and producers reel from Donald Trump's decision to slash tax breaks for green technologies. The Perth-based energy giant told investors on Wednesday it would take a $US140 million ($214 million) profit hit after deciding to walk away from the H2OK liquid hydrogen project it had been planning in Oklahoma, blaming the rising cost of making cleaner hydrogen and weaker-than-expected customer demand. 'We have made the decision to exit the H2OK project, demonstrating our disciplined approach to portfolio management,' Woodside chief executive Meg O'Neill said on Wednesday. Woodside, a producer of oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG), is pursuing the development of lower-carbon hydrogen as part of its climate transition strategy. Because hydrogen emits only water vapour when burned, it is considered by many to be a promising climate-friendly energy source that could eventually substitute fossil fuels and help clean up heavy-polluting industries, as long as it is made using low- or zero-carbon energy sources. Woodside's H2OK would have used an electrolyser, powered by the electricity grid, to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. However, Woodside announced it was pausing the H2OK project in January, shortly after Donald Trump's return to the White House. It also scrapped a separate plan to build a concentrated solar thermal energy facility in California through a partnership with Heliogen, a company backed by billionaire Bill Gates. While not directly attributing those decisions to Trump's energy agenda, Woodside at the time said it needed to consider the implications of the administration's pledge to dismantle support for US clean energy investments, including halting the disbursement of funds from the $567 billion Inflation Reduction Act, which had been offering generous tax breaks for renewable developers. This month, Trump secured the passage of a giant tax and domestic policy bill through Congress, which will make it cheaper and easier for companies to drill and produce fossil fuels, while cutting funding for electric cars and wind and solar farms. Woodside remains committed to one clean energy investment in the US, the Beaumont lower-carbon ammonia project in Texas. The project was 95 per cent completed as of June 30, the company said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store