Now, RJD, Moitra & PUCL move Supreme Court
Mahua Moitra
and
RJD
, have approached Supreme Court against
Election Commission
's special intensive revision (SIR) of Bihar's electoral rolls and told the court that the exercise is illegal and calculated to disenfranchise the state's mobile migrant population which works across India but returns home to exercise their democratic right to vote.
The parties are likely to mention the case before SC on Monday for urgent hearing.
Moitra, in her petition, submitted that the impugned order unlawfully shifted the burden of proving eligibility from the State to the individual elector and arbitrarily excludes commonly accepted identity documents such as Aadhaar and ration cards. Shifting of the burden of voter authentication onto the citizens, and to view every citizen with suspicion until proven otherwise, is a breach of the constitutional spirit, and also is in direct contravention of the statutory scheme to which EC is bound, she said.
PUCL, which moved SC through advocate Talha Abdul Rahman, submitted that the timing of the decision appears "deliberately to disenfranchise Bihar's mobile workforce during crucial electoral periods".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Explained: Why Bihar's electoral roll revision is sparking debate Election Commission
Explained: Why Bihar's electoral roll revision is sparking debate | Election Commission | Election A new controversy has gripped Bihar over the Election Commission's recently announced Special Intensive Revision. Critics argue that the exercise has the potential to exclude lakhs of voters in the state. Opposition parties and civil society groups like PUCL and the Association for Democratic Reforms have even approached the Supreme Court to challenge the move. Watch the video to understand what Bihar's electoral roll revision entails, why the EC believes it's necessary, and what the major criticisms are.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Exclusionary Process": RJD's Manoj Jha Attacks Poll Body's Bihar Exercise
New Delhi: The Election Commission of India (ECI) continues to face criticism from Opposition leaders over its voter list revisions, an exercise which former Chief Election Commissioner SY Quraishi had called the "real soft underbelly" of the institution. As Bihar's monsoon-drenched voter verification drive sparks controversy ahead of the assembly election scheduled later this year, Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha has taken the ECI to the Supreme Court, alleging systematic disenfranchisement of marginalised communities. The Supreme Court is set to hear five petitions, including those from Manoj Jha, Mahua Moitra, Yogendra Yadav, and the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR), on Thursday. The ECI's special intensive revision (SIR) - the first such exercise in Bihar since 2003 - has sparked outrage among Opposition parties, with the RJD leading the charge. Mr Jha told NDTV the process is a "dark spell for democracy," questioning its timing, execution, and intent. "Why was this exercise not undertaken in the last 22 years? What consultations were held with political parties? Did the ECI conduct any feasibility study?" he said, adding there is a lack of stakeholder engagement, especially given that 22 per cent of Biharis work outside the state. "Are you assuming a Bihari working in Surat is a voter of Surat? I got my Delhi voter identity card only after 15 years, despite holding a Bihar voter card throughout," Mr Jha said. With only 14.18 per cent of Bihar's 7.9 crore voters submitting enumeration forms by July 5 - despite 87 per cent form distribution - Mr Jha warned of widespread exclusion. He pointed to the exclusion of Aadhaar and ration cards, widely held by Biharis, from the 11 accepted documents, arguing that this violated the Representation of the People Act. "In the monsoon season, with massive migration and widespread documentation issues, this is an exclusionary and non-inclusive process," he said, highlighting voters' struggles in rural areas like Seemanchal and Nalanda. The Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) estimates that nearly three crore voters, particularly from Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (SC/ST) and migrant communities, may lack the required documents. Mr Jha dismissed the ECI's claim of transparency, calling its dialogue with Opposition parties a "monologue." He questioned the feasibility of the 25-day timeline, noting that the last such revision took 8-11 months. "With only four-five volunteers per booth, has the ECI checked their backgrounds? In elections where margins are 4,000-5,000 votes, even a few deletions can change the outcome," Mr Jha said, and recalled unresolved issues with postal ballots in the Bihar elections in 2020. The RJD has proposed alternatives like accepting Aadhaar and extending the timeline to ensure inclusion without compromising electoral integrity, emphasising that the burden of proving citizenship lies with the State, per the Supreme Court's 1995 ruling in Lal Babu Hussein vs Electoral Registration Officer. Political Motives And Eroding Trust The RJD's suspicions of political bias are fueled by the SIR's timing - six months after the last summary revision and during the monsoon season, when rural access is limited. Mr Jha echoed Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge's claim of a "BJP-RSS conspiracy" to suppress Dalit and minority votes, pointing to the ECI's "collective opacity and confusion." The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, or RSS, is the BJP's ideological mentor. "The ECI claims it's including young voters and removing ghost voters or illegal migrants, but where's the evidence? Why rush this in 25 days unless there's a pre-verified list with official stamps?" he said. Mr Jha lamented what he called the erosion of trust in the ECI, once the "umbilical cord of Indian democracy" under figures like Sukumar Sen. "The ECI must hold a press conference and satisfy public concerns. Speaking through unnamed 'sources' is not what a constitutional body does," the RJD MP said. His party's Supreme Court petition seeks to stop the SIR. Mr Jha expressed hope that the judiciary, which has "shed light before," will intervene to protect voters' rights. He also questioned the ECI's logistics, asking, "Will the ECI provide train tickets for migrants? At least reserve sleeper class? There's a complete lack of understanding of ground realities." Lawlessness In Bihar: Gopal Khemka Murder Beyond electoral concerns, Mr Jha sharply criticised the Nitish Kumar-led government following the murder of businessman Gopal Khemka. "This was not an isolated incident. Hardly a day passes without reports of dacoity, murder, or rape in Bihar. This is more than a breakdown of law and order - it's a collapse of governance," he said. He questioned who truly runs Bihar, pointing to the chief minister's "inaction" and the central government's "silence". "Are BJP and Nitish Kumar partners in governance or partners in crime?" Mr Jha said, adding security is a right for all citizens and not a privilege for the rich. Even with a special investigation team in place, Mr Jha said he doubts justice would be served without systemic reforms. If in power, the RJD would prioritise strengthening police accountability, increasing resources for law enforcement, and ensuring swift judicial processes, he said. "Today, instead of the rule of law, we are seeing the rule of criminals in Bihar." Countering Communal Polarisation Mr Jha also addressed the RJD's stance on controversial calls for a "Hindu Rashtra" by figures like Baba Bageshwar, whom some RJD leaders have likened to divisive figures such as Ram Rahim. "Plurality is the foundation of our existence, of [BR] Ambedkar's vision. Communal polarisation goes against the spirit of the Constitution. We must not give legitimacy to such divisive agendas," Mr Jha said, emphasizing the need to focus on pressing issues like unemployment and healthcare over divisive rhetoric. Language-Based Violence: A Disturbing Trend On the recent incidents of violence under the guise of cultural or linguistic protection, such as the assault on a shopkeeper by MNS workers in Maharashtra for not speaking Marathi, Mr Jha said, "Those unaware of history should remember the suffering of the 1960s. It was through dialogue that we emerged from that phase, but now we're going backwards, fighting over language, religion, food habits, and imagined threats." He said he viewed languages as a "bond of sisterhood," kept alive by people, not governments, and called for rejecting hierarchies that fuel division. Mr Jha criticised the state's lenient response - detaining and quickly bailing out perpetrators - and argued it reflected a troubling political silence. A Call for Action As the RJD awaits the Supreme Court's ruling on the SIR, Mr Jha said he remains steadfast in his commitment to protecting Bihar's democratic and social fabric. "Disenfranchisement on this scale can seriously damage democracy," he said, and asked the ECI to prioritise transparency and inclusion. On governance, he demanded accountability from the Nitish Kumar government and systemic reforms to restore safety. Above all, Mr Jha called for unity, warning that divisive agendas and unchecked criminality threaten Bihar's pluralistic ethos. "Our country cannot afford to regress," he added.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Top news of the day: Supreme Court to hear pleas challenging Special Intensive Revision in Bihar on July 10; Census data will be available early, says Registrar General of India, and more
Supreme Court to hear pleas challenging Special Intensive Revision in Bihar on July 10 The Supreme Court has scheduled an urgent hearing of petitions challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in Bihar on Thursday (July 10, 2025). Almost 2.93 crore voters in Bihar must produce documents establishing the date and place of their own birth as well as of their parents in the case of those born after 1987, as an SIR of the State's electoral rolls began on June 28, 2025. Census data will be available early, residents can self-enumerate: Registrar General of India Census data will be available early as the ensuing Census will be the first digital Census in the country, Census India 2027, the official handle of Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India (RGI and CCI) posted on X on Monday (July 7, 2025). The first digital Census and will be conducted in two phases and 'for the first time technology will be used to collect data and send it electronically to the central server' and 'this will result in early availability of Census data,' RGI said. Modi to have bilateral engagements with several world leaders The BRICS Leaders' Declaration, adopted at the summit in the Brazilian city on Sunday (July 6, 2025), reflected India's key concerns, especially on cross-border terrorism and global governance reforms. Noting that the Global South has often faced 'double standards', the Prime Minister called for a greater role for the developing world in international decision-making, speaking at the BRICS session on 'Peace and Security and Reform of Global Governance'. Espionage case: YouTuber Jyoti Malhotra's judicial custody extended till July 21 A court in Hisar on Monday (July 7, 2025) extended by 14 days the judicial custody of social media influencer Jyoti Malhotra, arrested last month on suspicion of espionage. The Hisar Police arrested Ms. Malhotra, who ran a YouTube channel 'Travel with JO', on May 16. Hailing From Hisar, the YouTuber was arrested at the New Aggarsain Extension and booked under provisions of the Official Secrets Act and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). Kaliganj blast: Deceased girl's mother alleges Mamata not allowing police to conduct probe properly The mother of Tamanna Khatun, who was killed in a bomb explosion during an alleged violent celebration of the Kaliganj bypoll results on Monday (July 7, 2025), alleged that Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee was not allowing the police to conduct a proper investigation into the death of her daughter. 1984 anti-Sikh riots: Court records Sajjan Kumar's statement A Delhi court on Monday (July 7, 2025) recorded the statement of former Congress MP Sajjan Kumar over the violence in Janakpuri and Vikaspuri areas in the capital during the 1984 anti-sikh riots. Special judge Dig Vinay Singh recorded statement of Mr. Kumar, who said he was innocent as there was not an iota of evidence against him. Luggage packed, will move out of official residence: ex-CJI Chandrachud In the wake of the controversy over his stay at the official residence beyond permissible time, former Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud on Monday (July 7, 2025) cleared the air, saying his luggage was packed and he, along with his wife and children, would soon move to a paid government accommodation. Peace time is nothing but 'illusion': Defence Minister Rajnath Singh 'Peace time is nothing but an 'illusion,' and India must remain prepared for uncertainty even during periods of relative calm,' Defence Minister Rajnath Singh said while hailing the armed forces for the valour they displayed during Operation Sindoor. In an address at an event, Mr. Singh said the performance of the indigenously built equipment and platforms in the operation increased the global demand for India-built military products. Pahalgam terror attack: NIA gets custody of two accused for 10 more days 'A special court in Jammu on Monday (July 7, 2025) granted the NIA 10 more days' remand of the two accused arrested for allegedly harbouring Pakistani terrorists involved in the deadly Pahalgam terror attack in April 2025,' officials said. Bangladesh tribunal to decide on charges against Sheikh Hasina on July 10 Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal on Monday (July 7, 2025) set July 10, 2025, to determine whether charges will be framed against ousted Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina and two of her top aides. Ms. Hasina, former Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal and former inspector general of police Chowdhury Abdullah Al-Mamun are accused in the case over alleged crimes against humanity committed during the July uprising last year. Kerala Governor fuelled Bharat Mata row, he must defuse it: Binoy Viswam The Kerala society 'will not accept' Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar, who 'studied in a Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh-run school and became an ideological propagator of the organisation', Communist Party of India (CPI) State secretary Binoy Viswam has said. Winning at Edgbaston will be one of my 'happiest memories' whenever I retire: Shubman Gill Leading India to their first-ever Test win over England at Edgbaston will remain one of his 'happiest memories' whenever the time comes to call it quits, said India captain Shubman Gill, revelling in the resounding series-levelling victory in Birmingham. For the 25-year-old whose captaincy stint began with India losing the series opener at Leeds, Gill underlined an all-round show from the team to make a strong comeback that was also the team's first win over the hosts in Edgbaston.
