Estée Lauder, L'Oréal suffer as China's duty-free spending falls
Fast forward to today, and the travel-retail sector in Hainan is in a 14-month slump with little sign of a turnaround. Duty-free sales dropped 10.8% over the first four months of 2025 compared with a year earlier, according to the latest data from the local customs agency. Both the number of shoppers and the number of products purchased declined by more than 25% so far this year.
Global heavyweights of the beauty industry are also feeling the impact of cratering travel retail in China. Until recently, the likes of Estée Lauder Cos., Shiseido Co., and L'Oréal counted on the lavish duty-free spending of Chinese travelers to drive their earnings growth. However, all three saw their Asia or China travel-retail sales shrink last year and in the first quarter of 2025.
The newfound frugality in duty-free spending follows a similar trajectory to the challenges global luxury brands face in the world's second-largest economy. Exuberant pandemic-era spending emboldened companies to make hefty investments, only to see demand rapidly shrink after consumers pulled back on spending in the aftermath of Covid.
L'Oréal plans to cut as many as 50% of its employees in its travel-retail division—mainly made up of Chinese staff—due to the poor performance of the duty-free sector in the country over the past two years, local media Caixin reported in April.
According to a statement from the company's travel-retail unit, the Paris-based beauty giant is undergoing a transformation to better respond to market shifts and evolving consumer needs. The Caixin report is not accurate; it was added.
The belt-tightening among Chinese shoppers also contributed to a 17.5% decline in first-quarter sales for Beiersdorf AG's luxury skincare brand La Prairie. It has responded by cutting its reliance on China.
'The cosmetics industry has seen the price advantage of travel retail eroded,' said Jacques Roizen, managing director of China consulting at Digital Luxury Group. 'Discounts by global beauty brands—frequent and deep—offered across online and offline platforms have narrowed the gap between the mainland and duty-free prices, diminishing the appeal of travel retail for beauty products.'
Highlighting how Hainan malls have lost their edge on pricing, Sam's Club, Walmart Inc.'s membership chain in China, sells Crème de la Mer facial cream at times for around 20% less than the duty-free outlets. Shoppers who purchase the item on Alibaba Group Holding Ltd.'s Tmall, China's dominant e-commerce platform, don't get a discount but will also receive a selection of free gifts.
The post-Covid resumption of travel to the likes of Japan and Southeast Asia has also eroded duty-free spending in Hainan. According to Roizen, affluent spenders, who supercharged Hainan's duty-free sales during the pandemic, are once again shopping abroad. Adding to the challenges is the rising popularity of domestic beauty brands offering high-quality products at competitive prices, he said.
Beijing's crackdown on resellers taking advantage of the island's duty-free shopping rules has also deflated the boom in Hainan. Known as 'daigou' in Chinese, some went so far as to use other people's duty-free shopping quotas to buy large quantities of goods and resell them in the rest of the Chinese mainland at a profit. A customs campaign against the practice in 2023 seized more than $83 million worth of duty-free goods bought in Hainan and resold elsewhere, according to a report by state-owned newswire China News Service.
The slump has also had an impact on Hainan's economy. At the height of the duty-free shopping frenzy in 2021, it grew 11.2% yearly, well above the nationwide growth rate of 8.6%. In 2024, Hainan's gross domestic product increased by 3.7%, lagging China's overall growth rate of 5%.
In 2022, the Hainan government targeted duty-free sales of 100 billion yuan. In its most recent work report for 2025, the target is just 52 billion yuan.
Unfulfilled hopes
After first introducing an annual duty-free shopping quota for Hainan of 5,000 yuan in 2011, the authorities drastically increased the allowance to 100,000 yuan in 2020. The government's support gave global beauty houses high hopes that Hainan would be a key growth market for years to come. Shiseido inaugurated six dazzling new stores for its premium brands in 2022. Pola Orbis Holdings Inc. opened its first duty-free store in Hainan in 2021.
Property developers are interested in the prospect of tourists willing to spend. Both Swire Properties Ltd. and LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE have teamed up with local partners to build luxury retail developments in Sanya, scheduled to open next year.
Swire and LVMH didn't respond to Bloomberg's requests for comment.
'Hainan's travel retail hasn't shown a strong recovery yet,' said Serena Sang, a consumer analyst at SPDB International Holdings Ltd. 'Per capita spending during this year's May Day holiday continued to decline. We still need time to gauge consumer response as the island pushes for independent customs operations.'
Hainan resident Chen Yushan exemplifies the changing spending habits. Four years ago, the 30-year-old would regularly make the more-than-six-hour round trip from her home in Hainan to buy bagfuls of luxury cosmetics at the duty-free malls. Even though she lives close to the outlets, she has to take the arduous round trip as shoppers need to show proof of travel from the mainland to qualify for the duty-free quota. Now, she only makes the trip once or twice a year as the economy slows and the outlook becomes more uncertain.
'With an economy like this, I'm cutting back on spending on costly skincare products,' Chen said. 'I don't even buy luxury bags anymore. They're useless. Nowadays, I'd rather spend money on a good hotpot meal to treat myself.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
16 minutes ago
- Euronews
France hands Shein €40 million fine for deceptive commercial practices
France handed fast-fashion giant Shein a €40 million fine on Thursday, following a year-long investigation that found the online retailer guilty of "deceptive commercial practices". France's Directorate for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Prevention (DGCCRF) — the regulator in charge of French consumer law — revealed that Shein had misled its customers on price reductions, as well as on the scope of its "commitments concerning environmental claims". In its statement, the DGCCRF confirmed that Shein — a China-based company owned by Infinite Styles Ecommerce Limited (IELS) — had accepted the fine. The blow comes two months after the European Commission found Shein guilty of engaging in illegal commercial practices under EU law in May, following a coordinated investigation with national consumer protection authorities. Through analysing products listed as on sale on Shein's French website from October 2022 to August 2023, investigators found that 57% of products had no price reduction, 19% had a slight discount, while 11% of products actually had a price increase. "These practices, with their profusion of crossed-out prices and permanent promotions, give consumers the impression that they are getting a very good deal", stated the Directorate for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Prevention. Under French regulation, the reference price for discounted goods is a product's lowest price during the 30 days which precede the start of a sale. On top of misleading customers, the French anti-fraud and competition agency found that Shein was "unable to justify the environmental claims made on its website", describing itself as a "responsible company" which limits its environmental impact by "reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 25%." French authorities determined that these statements contradict the firm's business model, which is "based on an abundant supply of textiles at low prices." In 2020, fast fashion was estimated to account for 8-10% of global CO2 emissions. Although Shein may have been hit with a heavy fine, in recent years the company has become somewhat accustomed to public scrutiny. In January, British politicians were outraged when the online retailer refused to provide assurances that its products did not include cotton produced in the Xinjiang region of China, which has been linked to forced Uyghur labour. Meanwhile, an investigation published in 2024 by Swiss advocacy group Public Eye found that some workers at Shein factories were still working 75-hour weeks, despite the company's promises to improve conditions for employees.
Euronews
24 minutes ago
- Euronews
China hits Europe's brandy exports with duties but adds exemptions
French drink manufacturers are bracing for losses as China said it would place a heavy trade duty on brandy exports from the European Union, potentially taking a gulp out of their sales in the coming years. A tariff rate on EU brandy could go up to 34.9% for five years from 5 July. The duty was announced after China's Ministry of Commerce concluded an investigation into European brandy imports, determining that the products threatened its national brandy industry. Cognac, which is heavily exported from France, was a product of concern, although major cognac makers like Pernod Ricard and Remy Cointreau will now be exempted. China's investigation ruled that the EU had engaged in spirit 'dumping', a practice where foreign goods are sold significantly below their normal price. The corrective tariff will be charged in addition to a normal customs duty. Belgium-based trade group spiritsEUROPE, representing EU producers of spirit drinks, said in a statement that it 'regrets today's decision by the Chinese Ministry of Commerce to impose final anti-dumping duties averaging 32.2% on EU wine-based spirits, marc-based spirits, and brandies as of 5 July,' adding that 'the measures will still pose a significant barrier to legitimate trade'. The trade group also said that the EU spirits sector provided 'substantial evidence over the last 18 months, clearly demonstrating the absence of any dumping practices on the Chinese market'. 'The decision originates from a spat around unfair competition and protectionism and it is bad news for European drinks companies who enjoy big sales to Asia,' said Dan Coatsworth, investment analyst at AJ Bell. 'That explains why shares in Rémy Cointreau and Pernod Ricard were weak on the news as drinkers in China might think twice about buying their products if the price is now much higher.' The news pulled down French spirits makers' share prices, with Pernod Ricard slumping 1%, Remy Cointreau down 1.75%, and luxury giant LVMH, the parent company of Hennessy and Rémy Martin, losing 2.1% around 11 CEST in Europe. Closer to midday, share price losses moderated after news broke that China spared major cognac producers from the new duties, provided they sell at a minimum price. Trade group spiritsEUROPE welcomed the partial relief, saying that 'to safeguard their operations and maintain a stable presence in the Chinese market, several affected companies have entered into price undertakings (raising export prices) with MOFCOM (China's Ministry of Commerce)', adding that these will replace anti-dumping duties for these companies. The group urged Beijing to expand this option to all European companies affected. SpiritsEUROPE Director General Hervé Dumesny said 'Beyond its direct impact on our sector, this decision risks fuelling trade tensions at a time when mutual cooperation is more important than ever.' The decision on brandy comes after the EU decided to impose tariffs as high as 45% on Chinese-made electric vehicles last year.
France 24
2 hours ago
- France 24
Second day of travel chaos as French air traffic controllers strike
Paris airports risk being even more severely affected than on the first day of the strike on Thursday, which was called by two minority unions calling for better working conditions and staffing. The timing of the strike is particularly acute with Friday the final day of school in France before the summer holidays, with many families planning an early getaway. France's DGAC aviation authority said 933 flights departing from or arriving at French airports were cancelled on Thursday, some 10 percent of the total number of flights initially scheduled. The proportion of cancellations rose to 25 percent at the main airports in Paris. But on Friday the situation risks being even more severe with the DGAC asking companies to cancel 40 percent of flights to deal with the strike. French Prime Minister Francois Bayrou described the strike as "shocking". "Choosing the day when everyone goes on holiday to go on strike at air traffic control is taking the French hostage," he told BFMTV. 'Unacceptable' The effects of the strike are not limited to France and the stoppage has triggered hundreds of cancellations of flights that fly over the country. The European Airlines for Europe (A4E) association said 1,500 flights would be cancelled on Thursday and Friday in Europe, affecting 300,000 passengers. "French air traffic control already delivers some of Europe's worst delay figures and now the actions of a minority of French air traffic control workers will needlessly disrupt the holiday plans of thousands of people in France and across Europe," said A4E chief Ourania Georgoutsakou. The association said the strikes also caused "almost 500,000 minutes" in delays in Europe on Thursday on nearly 33,000 commercial flights. Ryanair, Europe's largest airline by passenger numbers, said it had cancelled more than 400 flights. "These strikes are unacceptable," said Ryanair CEO Michael O'Leary, urging the EU Commission to protect such overflights by law in case of strikes. "Of these 400 flight cancellations, 350 would not be cancelled if the EU protected overflights over France." At Paris airports, passengers stared at departure boards loaded with cancellations to assess their options. "I came here on holiday to celebrate my wife's 40th birthday, but now I'm stuck at Charles de Gaulle Airport," said Julien Barthelemy, a passenger travelling to Marseille from New York, late Thursday. "I'm currently on the waiting list for three flights and am waiting for a spot on the next one to become available." © 2025 AFP
