
Ship of Theseus director Anand Gandhi reveals he directed Tumbbad, not Rahi Anil Barve: ‘I scrapped what had been shot, reshot it'
Your Ship Of Theseus clocks 12 years. How do you explain its enduring resonance?
I believe Ship of Theseus endures because the fundamental human questions it explores have remained unchanged for millennia and will likely persist for millennia more: Who am I? Where do I come from? Where am I headed? What remains of me after death? How do I find or create meaning? These are questions we ask instinctively as children, yet spend lifetimes as philosophers, scientists, and scholars attempting to answer, often without definitive success. With Ship of Theseus, I aimed to engage rigorously with these timeless questions, drawing from the latest insights in cognitive neurobiology, evolutionary biology, ethology, ontology, and epistemology, while synthesizing these disciplines through my own lived experiences. This combination of disciplined inquiry and personal reflection perhaps explains why the film continues to resonate deeply.
Was it very difficult releasing a film so complex and non-massy?
Initially, releasing the film was challenging. Convincing distributors proved difficult until Kiran Rao came on board, subsequently bringing Disney on board. Aamir Khan also lent his support to the film. Disney needed reassurance that India was ready—not merely for an international arthouse film, but specifically for a film rooted in philosophical and scientific exploration. I was convinced that Indian audiences, historically steeped in metaphysics, rational inquiry, and philosophical traditions, were more than ready. Their maturity surpassed distributor expectations. A community-driven social media campaign demonstrated this readiness, with audiences actively demanding the film's release in their cities. This resulted in screenings across 89 cities and towns throughout India, a truly grassroots triumph.
What was the impetus behind this allegory on life, death, and everything in between?
It emerged from a confluence of my personal philosophical journey and pivotal life experiences. Profoundly influenced by my mentor Abhay Mehta and all those who had sought before me, my inquiries became urgently real during my twenties while nursing my grandparents in the hospital. I felt like the philosopher in that old parable: one who spends the boat ride questioning the boatman about literature and scriptures, only to discover he cannot swim when the boat springs a leak. My philosophical knowledge had not equipped me for life's immediate demands. This realization compelled me to test whether profound questions could yield not just meaningful answers, but purposeful, utilitarian ones that serve people in their actual lives.
Do you think Ship Of Theseus would have done better if released now with so many democratic outlets?
I'm not convinced the film would necessarily perform better or worse now. Ship of Theseus was among the first Indian films Netflix acquired, so we didn't miss that digital wave, we rode its crest. We later converted significant portions of the film's rights to copyleft licensing, enabling community sharing with proper attribution.The real issue isn't the number of platforms available, but their understanding of Indian audiences.
A post shared by Anand Gandhi (@memewala)
Please explain?
Many contemporary outlets systematically underestimate viewers here, defaulting to western remakes or simplified narratives reverse-engineered from old television ratings. This represents a profound misreading of what Indian audiences actually want and deserve. Indians have centuries-deep traditions of philosophical inquiry, metaphysical exploration, and narrative sophistication. Yet these platforms often treat them as if they're incapable of engaging with complex ideas. The result is a self-fulfilling prophecy where diminished expectation leads to diminished commercial returns. These outlets aren't producing a hundredth of the variety their global counterparts do, precisely because they've underestimated the market's actual appetite for substantive cinema and shows.
Why have you not to directed any feature film after Ship Of Theseus, we did see you name as 'Creative Director in Tumbbad?
The big thing I want to clarify about Tumbbad is that I directed the film and this is something that's well known within the industry. My credit on the film says creative director and that's just basically a way to respect the fact that Rahi Anil Barve had started working on the film as a director first before I had to take over as a director.
Are you saying you have ghost-directed the entire Tumbbad?
Yes, I had to scrap the work that had been done and I had to reshoot the film from the beginning and hence I took a 'creative director credit' which is, as you know in films, a credit that does not pre-exist, it does not exist before or after Tumbbad. So in the case of Tumbbad, I said that we'll make up a credit called creative director, a director's job is all obviously the same as that of a creative director but because in this case we had to make a distinction between the role that was committed to Rahi, I took on the title of a creative director which was legally supposed to always come along with Rahi as per the contracts.
But that didn't happen?
But that contract was not honoured on several occasions in the press and in other places by Tumbbad producer Soham Shah. So far I tried to not make that the main key point about the conversation because I try not to get into too much of press about the negative experiences of making a film. I always try to stick to talking about how I made the film, what I was thinking, what my intentions are and that's the kind of thing that always excites me but since you pointedly asked, this needed clarification so I'm clarifying it. When I started the film, when I started Tumbbad, I started as a writer and producer with Rahi supposed to direct it but eventually I directed the film. I had to make the whole film.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
12 minutes ago
- India.com
'Yuzvendra Chahal ki......': Rishabh Pant's funny remark on Chahal and RJ Mahvash dating rumors
'Yuzvendra Chahal ki......': Rishabh Pant's funny remark on Chahal and RJ Mahvash dating rumors New Delhi: Yuzvendra Chahal and Dhanashree Verma's divorce was finalised a few months ago, just before the IPL started. Since then, the buzz started that Chahal is now dating RJ Mahvash. During the IPL, Mahvish was often seen cheering for Punjab Kings in the stadium. She also posted pictures with a special note for Chahal. After this, when the two were seen together in London, these rumours gained further strength. At the same time, now Rishabh Pant jokingly said that Chahal is engaged. Chahal and Rishabh's funny conversation on Kapil Sharma Show All these cricketers had come to Kapil Sharma's show, where Archana Puran Singh shared a BTS vlog during the shoot. Rishabh Pant, Yuzvendra Chahal, Abhishek Sharma and Gautam Gambhir were seen in this episode. Everyone greeted Navjot Singh Sidhu and the rest of the team warmly. Archana asked all the players questions about their life and gave a special welcome to the newcomer Abhishek Sharma on the show. Archana has an interesting conversation with Rishabh and Chahal The vlog begins with Archana complaining about her sore throat, 'How will I laugh on camera today?' She then meets Kapil and praises his suit. As soon as Sidhu arrives on the set, the players come to meet him. Sidhu praises Abhishek Sharma, 'I am proud of him, he is the future of Indian cricket.' Archana says that Abhishek is a 'very handsome boy' and has come on the show because he is from Amritsar. Jokes on Chahal's engagement and rumoured relationship When Archana asks Rishabh about his accident, he says that the experience has given him a new perspective on life. He then tells that he has also started a YouTube channel, which Archana promotes on her channel. During the conversation, Rishabh puts a ring on Chahal's finger and jokingly says, 'I have done this before.' Chahal laughingly replies, 'She has gone too,' hinting at his divorce from Dhanashree. 'Are you okay now?' Archana asks, 'I am fine,' Chahal replies. Archana then invites Chahal to visit her home in Madh Island, but adds that he is probably busy coming to Mumbai. To this, Rishabh jokes, 'It happens here all the time.' Chahal says, 'Saabko bata de tu,' and Rishabh shouts on the set. The joke was a reference to the rumours of Chahal and Mahwish's affair. Chahal laughs and says, 'Cut it out.'


Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kargil Vijay Diwas: Meet the National Award-winning actor who joined Indian Army during Kargil War, was deployed at the border
During the Kargil War in 1999, Bollywood actor Nana Patekar, known for his on-screen portrayals of strong characters, took his patriotism beyond acting. He sought permission to join the military effort, drawing on his prior army training for the film 'Prahaar'. Deployed near the Line of Control, he provided logistical and moral support to soldiers, embodying civilian courage and dedication. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads From Reel Patriotism to Real Action Serving at the Edge of Conflict Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The Larger Battle for the Peaks A Lasting Symbol of Civilian Courage As war clouds loomed over the icy peaks of Kargil in 1999, it wasn't just trained soldiers who stepped up to defend the nation—some civilians, too, felt an unshakable urge to contribute. Among them stood a name not unfamiliar to the public: veteran Bollywood actor Nana Patekar . On the occasion of Kargil Vijay Diwas , it is worth revisiting how this acclaimed performer stepped far beyond the arc lights to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with real-life heroes in one of the most treacherous conflicts of recent for portraying complex, powerful characters in Indian cinema, Nana Patekar had always shown a deep fascination with the armed forces. This admiration didn't remain confined to movie scripts or acting roles. Back in the early 1990s, while preparing for his film Prahaar—which delved into the rigors of military life—he immersed himself in actual army training with the Maratha Light Infantry for three years. This firsthand experience was not just for artistic accuracy; it left a lasting imprint on his values and the Kargil War erupted in May 1999, he was not content to merely support the cause through words or public appearances. Determined to take meaningful action, he approached top army officers with a request to join the military effort at the border. His offer was initially declined. However, his persistent spirit led him to seek the intervention of then Defence Minister George Fernandes. By invoking his earlier military training, he convinced the authorities to allow his participation in the ongoing August 1999, when the main combat had begun to ease but the situation remained volatile, Nana Patekar was finally deployed in the Kargil region. He was attached to a Quick Response Team (QRT) operating near the Line of Control (LoC), the fragile boundary separating Indian and Pakistani military positions. Though not involved in direct combat, he worked alongside soldiers in volatile zones and offered logistical and moral the battlefield, Patekar also extended his services to a military base hospital, where he contributed to the treatment of wounded troops. The harsh environment tested his physical endurance. The bitter cold, rugged terrain, and austere conditions caused him to lose nearly 20 kilograms—shedding light on the taxing physical conditions soldiers endure daily. Despite this strain, he viewed the experience as one of deep emotional Kargil War, fought from May to July 1999, unfolded in the mountainous terrain of Ladakh's Kargil district, then part of the larger Jammu and Kashmir region. The conflict stemmed from the stealthy incursion of Pakistani soldiers—disguised as militants—who occupied key Indian positions along the LoC. This confrontation evolved into a high-altitude war between India and military launched a counteroffensive named Operation Vijay to reclaim the occupied territories. The Indian Air Force also collaborated with ground forces under a parallel mission, Operation Safed Sagar, delivering aerial support and reconnaissance. The combined operations succeeded in pushing back the infiltrators, but the toll on both human life and national morale was choosing to serve amidst conflict, Nana Patekar didn't just honor the spirit of patriotism—he exemplified it. His decision to move from screen heroics to frontline duty stands as a powerful reminder that courage is not bound by profession. His story remains an enduring chapter in India's narrative of unity, sacrifice, and unbreakable resolve.


Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
Thalaivan Thalaivii box office collection day 1: Vijay Sethupathi's Tamil romantic comedy opens strong, earns Rs 4.15 crore
Thalaivan Thalaivii box office collection day 1: Vijay Sethupathi's Thalaivan Thalaivii hit the screens on July 25 much to the delight of the audience. The film opened to a good response at the Indian box office and also received positive reviews from most critics. Thalaivan Thalaivii created a buzz among fans ahead of its release as it features Nithya Menen as the leading lady opposite 'Makkal Selvan'. Thalaivan Thalaivi does well on day 1 Thalaivan Thalaivii, one of the most eagerly awaited films of the month, is off to a good start in India. According to Sacnilk, a trade website, the romantic comedy earned Rs 4.15 crore (nett) on the first day. The overall occupancy was around 47%. The morning shows had an occupancy of 30.14%. The afternoon shows saw an occupancy of 41.95%. The evening (46.54%) and night (69.38%) too fared well on this front. Thalaivan Thalaivii emerged as the top choice of the audience in Trichy, where the occupancy was 81%. It, however, found limited patronage in Kochi (17.75%) and Trivandrum (14%). Thalaivan Thalaivii is a crucial release for Vijay Sethupathi as it comes after Ace, which earned less than Rs 10 crore and bombed at the box office. Thalaivan Thalaivi review Thalaivan Thalaivii has received positive reviews with critics lauding the presentation and the performances. The Times of India gave it a rating of 4 stars out of 5. And praised the film for delving into the seldom discussed issue of life after marriage. 'Thalaivan Thalaivi becomes one of the very few Tamil films that dig into the life after marriage, something after the beginning of the seemingly 'Happily ever after,' and Pandiraj has crafted a fun, frustrating family padam,' read a part of the review. The positive word-of-mouth is likely to help Thalaivan Thalaivii pack a punch over the weekend. About Thalaivan Thalaivi Thalaivan Thalaivii is a romantic comedy drama directed by Pandiraj. The flick centres on the bittersweet relationship between two hot-headed lovers. Thalaivan Thalaivii features Vijay Sethupathi and Nithya Menen as the lead pair. Yogi Babu too is part of the cast. Santosh Narayanan has composed the music.