The fascination with true crime, and why so many women love it
It was the 1930s and the Pyjama Girl mystery was the biggest story in Australia. Everyone wanted to know: who was she and who killed her?
We like to think our obsession with true crime is a modern-day phenomenon, one buoyed by the relentless flow of podcasts, newspaper headlines, television documentaries and true crime special events.
But experts say all that has changed is the way in which we consume dark tales of murder and mayhem.
The Mushroom trial – in which Victorian mother Erin Patterson has been found guilty of murdering three family members and attempting to murder a fourth – is the latest grisly tale and the public, both in Australia and overseas, can't get enough. Patterson pleaded not guilty to all charges and has always maintained her innocence.
During the 10-week trial, there has been not one, but four, podcasts delivering daily updates of the courtroom drama taking place in Morwell, Victoria; media outlets streamed online updates all day long and television news programs led with the key moments morning, noon and night – all for the voracious appetite of the consuming public.
Loading
'The mechanisms for giving us access (to true crime stories) have changed,' says forensic criminologist Xanthe Mallett. 'But if you look at Jack the Ripper, for example, you had those penny dreadfuls, or stories published in weekly parts, that were the precursors to the true crime documentaries and podcasts.
'They've always existed.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Mushroom trial circus packs up after guilty verdicts
Korumburra, Leongatha and Morwell. These humble towns in Victoria's Gippsland region have been caught up in Erin Patterson's decision to serve up a deadly mushroom meal almost two years ago. Over more than 10 weeks, Morwell has been in the spotlight after hosting a trial that has captivated much of the nation and the world. It brought swarms of true-crime fanatics and media to hear blow-by-blow details about the death cap mushroom-laced lunch at Patterson's Leongatha home in July 2023. A jury on Monday unanimously found Patterson guilty of intentionally poisoning her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and his uncle and aunt Ian and Heather Wilkinson, who all lived in Korumburra. Mr Wilkinson, the pastor at Korumburra Baptist Church, was the lone diner to survive after a lengthy hospital stay. Toni Watson from Morwell Newsagency said she felt relief watching news of the verdicts. "There was too many gaps (in Patterson's story)," she told AAP. Towns like Snowtown in South Australia have become indelibly linked to murder cases. Ms Watson, who has spent most of her life in Morwell, said she hoped the triple murder didn't taint the region's reputation. The area has already suffered a degree of stigma from the murder of 14-month-old Jaidyn Leskie, whose body was found at Blue Rock Dam on New Year's Day 1998. "The Jaidyn Leskie case happened in Moe, but it affects the whole La Trobe Valley," she said. Along with a band of reporters, Laura Heller from Jay Dee's Cafe in Morwell made a mad dash for the courthouse after hearing the jury had reached a verdict following seven days of deliberations. The historic nature of the moment wasn't lost on the 31-year-old. "It will be talked about forever and it will always be remembered as one of the craziest stories in Australian history," she told AAP. Ms Heller, a law student who worked at the cafe throughout the trial, said business had been booming in the traditionally quiet winter period. The out-of-towners were a mixture of media, true crime nuts and "oldies" wanting to have a stickybeak. "Not much goes on here, so we were all excited a lot of people from Australia and around the world were coming," Ms Heller said. "I know that sounds crazy." She spoke with a sense of melancholy about life returning to normal in the area, which has faced social and economic problems with the impending closure of job-creating coal-fired power stations. "It's like summer camp coming to an end," she said. South Gippsland Shire councillor Nathan Hersey said the scale of the media attention astounded locals. "In all of this, there has been a lot of publicity. A lot of it's been negative, unfortunately, and it's gained traction in a pop-culture kind of way," he said. "But I don't feel like that has reflected on the region. Anyone who knows Gippsland knows that it's a great place with a lot of fantastic people."
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Mushroom trial circus packs up after guilty verdicts
Korumburra, Leongatha and Morwell. These humble towns in Victoria's Gippsland region have been caught up in Erin Patterson's decision to serve up a deadly mushroom meal almost two years ago. Over more than 10 weeks, Morwell has been in the spotlight after hosting a trial that has captivated much of the nation and the world. It brought swarms of true-crime fanatics and media to hear blow-by-blow details about the death cap mushroom-laced lunch at Patterson's Leongatha home in July 2023. A jury on Monday unanimously found Patterson guilty of intentionally poisoning her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and his uncle and aunt Ian and Heather Wilkinson, who all lived in Korumburra. Mr Wilkinson, the pastor at Korumburra Baptist Church, was the lone diner to survive after a lengthy hospital stay. Toni Watson from Morwell Newsagency said she felt relief watching news of the verdicts. "There was too many gaps (in Patterson's story)," she told AAP. Towns like Snowtown in South Australia have become indelibly linked to murder cases. Ms Watson, who has spent most of her life in Morwell, said she hoped the triple murder didn't taint the region's reputation. The area has already suffered a degree of stigma from the murder of 14-month-old Jaidyn Leskie, whose body was found at Blue Rock Dam on New Year's Day 1998. "The Jaidyn Leskie case happened in Moe, but it affects the whole La Trobe Valley," she said. Along with a band of reporters, Laura Heller from Jay Dee's Cafe in Morwell made a mad dash for the courthouse after hearing the jury had reached a verdict following seven days of deliberations. The historic nature of the moment wasn't lost on the 31-year-old. "It will be talked about forever and it will always be remembered as one of the craziest stories in Australian history," she told AAP. Ms Heller, a law student who worked at the cafe throughout the trial, said business had been booming in the traditionally quiet winter period. The out-of-towners were a mixture of media, true crime nuts and "oldies" wanting to have a stickybeak. "Not much goes on here, so we were all excited a lot of people from Australia and around the world were coming," Ms Heller said. "I know that sounds crazy." She spoke with a sense of melancholy about life returning to normal in the area, which has faced social and economic problems with the impending closure of job-creating coal-fired power stations. "It's like summer camp coming to an end," she said. South Gippsland Shire councillor Nathan Hersey said the scale of the media attention astounded locals. "In all of this, there has been a lot of publicity. A lot of it's been negative, unfortunately, and it's gained traction in a pop-culture kind of way," he said. "But I don't feel like that has reflected on the region. Anyone who knows Gippsland knows that it's a great place with a lot of fantastic people."
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Erin Patterson endured freezing cell conditions during her trial — now she's headed to maximum-security jail
Since the start of her murder and attempted murder trial, Erin Patterson's daily routine had been the same. On Monday mornings, Patterson would board a van at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre maximum security women's prison in Melbourne's western suburbs and make the two-hour journey — more than 170 kilometres — to the Latrobe Valley in south-eastern Victoria. By the time she reached Morwell, where her case was being heard, a waiting contingent of photographers would emerge from the fog near the town's rose garden like a spectre, jostling for the money shot. Patterson would then be taken to the cells at the local police station, her home for the week, before making the journey in reverse. Before the trial began, she'd already been in custody for more than 600 days since her arrest on November 2, 2023. Patterson, who was on Tuesday convicted of murder and attempted murder, had struck a deal with Corrections Victoria that she would be able to be able to take a doona and pillow into her bare concrete cell. Her defence lawyer, Colin Mandy SC, told the Supreme Court of Victoria none of those things were provided. "At some stage she was given a blanket, but she spent the night cold and awake … and she can't operate like that," Mr Mandy said at the time. "Someone who is in police cells for five weeks, facing a murder trial … requires special treatment so that we can do our job properly, so that she can provide us with proper instructions so that she's not uncomfortable," he said. "It won't be fair to her if that situation continues." Patterson would eventually receive a doona, a pillow and a sheet, but according to sources familiar with the cells at the Morwell police station, it still would not have been a comfortable stay. "They're simply not designed for people to live in," said one criminal lawyer. Until now, the Supreme Court has prevented details of Patterson's time in custody from being published to preserve her right to a fair trial. The only public description of Patterson's cell was made by Justice Christopher Beale, who inspected it before the trial started. "I was shown the cell where she is now being held and the bedding is really just a bit of plastic attached to the floor," the judge told the court. Patterson's accommodation in Morwell was a significant shift from what she was used to at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, a maximum-security facility for women that houses 538 prisoners. The Morwell cells often house people who are drunk or high and, by extension, their associated bodily fluids, which are pressure-hosed out before someone else checks in. Legal sources said the cells, which are made of concrete, were not only extremely cold but quite loud, with sound echoing off every surface. Another criminal lawyer was franker in her assessment. "[They're] just old shitty cells," she said. "It's not clean, that's for sure." The second criminal lawyer said clients were brought into a particular area to speak to their legal team. "They're just like these little boxes like you see in the movies where there's a clear plastic screen separating you," she said. By contrast, some prisoners at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, which also houses Melbourne crime matriarch Judy Moran and convicted paedophile Malka Leifer, have access to more creature comforts to help pass their sentences. In some high-privilege units within the prison, inmates have access to a television and couches. Others are allowed to train support dogs during the day. Some prisoners even have microwaves in their cells. But according to one source who has made frequent visits to the women's prison, even those small comforts are not enough to distract prisoners from reality. "Can you imagine waking up in the morning and you don't see the outside world. You see fences all around — that's what it looks like. It's depressing," they said. The source said visitors were usually allowed on weekends. "There's a visitor centre there. They've got the babies there, the playgrounds and stuff for all the kids — it's like a primary school," they said. "When you go through the entry point you get treated like a criminal. You've got to go through the scanner, you've got to get an eye test to ID you," they said. The prison's stringent visitor policy is something Patterson will have to get used to. The 50-year-old is now facing life in prison over the murders of Heather Wilkinson, Don and Gail Patterson and the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson. The beef Wellington used to murder her in-laws has captured global attention, which is no surprise to Brandy Cochrane, a criminologist at Victoria University. "There's a long history of fascination with women who kill," Dr Cochrane told ABC Radio Melbourne. "There are a lot of parallels between the way that the media and the courts treated Lindy Chamberlain and Erin Patterson." She said both Patterson and Chamberlain were criticised for showing no emotion during their verdicts, which was interpreted as "another damning moment for both of them". Kathryn Whitely, a US-based feminist criminologist, has worked with 100 female murderers around the world and conducted an in-depth study of women at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre. "In the US, it'd be termed a mass killing. Very, very rare for a female," Dr Whiteley said. "Women, also as we understand, no matter if it's mass or not in this case, their victims are usually someone that is close to them, someone that they know, and often someone that they love," she said. Dr Whiteley, who closely followed the case, said Patterson had struggled with "self-esteem challenges" and would take years to adapt to prison life. "She will find that it will be hard to adjust," she said. "It takes anywhere from five to seven years for a woman to at least assimilate or adjust to the 'prison way' or prison approach to how we survive inside." It comes as the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, which Patterson will now call home, faces significant issues. In June this year, the ABC revealed the prison has faced unprecedented rolling lockdowns due to a lack of staff. Former prisoners said they were locked away with no interaction, support or even meals for days and nights on end. Since July 2024, confidential government correspondence reveals there have been at least 106 lockdowns. Another lawyer told the ABC its prisoners like Patterson would be facing significant restrictions. "Whatever her life is going to be like in Dame Phyllis, at the moment she's going to be more restricted," he said.
