Scottish Government accused of shutting door on rewilding projects
A meeting with the Scottish Rewilding Alliance, a coalition of more than 20 organisations, and former Minister for Climate Action Dr Alasdair Allan MSP, was scheduled for Wednesday but was cancelled without being rescheduled.
THE Scottish Government has been criticised for cancelling a meeting about beaver restoration and failing to schedule a replacement, with activists warning that the 'door is shutting' on biodiversity.
It was expected to discuss concerns over 'stalled progress' on the recovery of beaver populations and the need for 'courageous' leadership by ministers and government agency, NatureScot, however Dr Allan left government earlier this month.
The coalition warned that biodiversity risked being 'marginalised' ahead of the Holyrood elections in 2026, despite high profile support for a bid for Scotland to become a 'rewilding nation' including from actors Leonardo DiCaprio and Brian Cox.
READ MORE: Palestine Action activist rejects Home Secretary's Glasgow protest claim
In December 2024, Forestry and Land Scotland (FLS), in partnership with rewilding charity Trees for Life, submitted a licence application to NatureScot to release a family of beavers on its land in Glen Affric in the Highlands, after two years of extensive consultations.
Beavers create wetlands, soak up carbon dioxide, purify water and reduce flooding, and can bring in tourism, and polls showed 80% of people think the Scottish Government should support rewilding, according to the charities.
In April, NatureScot delayed a decision on granting a licence for a community-backed proposal to reintroduce beavers, citing concern, despite previously describing engagement as exemplary and the proposal as in line with policy.
Surveys showed that two-thirds of people surveyed support the beaver reintroduction, during two years of research, according to the coalition.
But a Freedom of Information request revealed it was perceived by a NatureScot official as 'novel and contentious' and was referred to ministers, with a decision was delayed after lobbying, the charities claimed.
It was said to have prompted an intervention by local MSP and deputy first minister Kate Forbes, who is said to have raised the case with Mairi Gougeon MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs, Land Reform and Islands, according to a Freedom of Information request from investigative journalism publication the Ferret.
The coalition said it was concerned that NatureScot 'is being hobbled by political game-playing ahead of an election year', and appeasing others, including from National Farmers Union Scotland.
Steve Micklewright, chief executive of Trees for Life, said: 'Beavers have been present in the catchment for 15 years with no issues.
'The Glen Affric community is overwhelmingly in favour of an official reintroduction, and NatureScot officials described the public engagement as exemplary and 'above and beyond'.
'NatureScot also tells us that it fully endorses the environmental case for beaver restoration in Glen Affric. So what is going on?
'This is bigger than a single family of beavers finding a new home on a national nature reserve.
'Why does the government keep marginalising efforts to restore biodiversity to satisfy vested interests? Can NatureScot show leadership and vision on large-scale nature recovery in the face of anti-nature lobbying?'
Karen Blackport, the Scottish Rewilding Alliance's co-convenor and chief executive of Bright Green Nature, said: 'The Scottish Government's approach on beavers is a symptom of a bigger problem. It's failing to take its biodiversity commitments seriously, and there are worrying questions around consistency, fairness and transparency in decision-making.
'Scotland has no need to languish as one of the world's most nature-depleted countries – but we are lagging on nature recovery where we should be leading.'
Kevin Cumming, Rewilding Britain's rewilding director and deputy convenor of the Scottish Rewilding Alliance, said: 'Rewilding offers hope for tackling the nature and climate emergencies, and a wealth of social and economic benefits for communities from jobs to health.
'Large-scale nature recovery should be prioritised not marginalised.
'If the Government is truly committed to protecting 30% of Scotland for nature by 2030 then it needs to stop shutting the door in the face of rewilding organisations.'
NatureScot director of green economy Robbie Kernahan said: 'NatureScot is committed to expanding the beaver population across Scotland for the benefit of biodiversity, in line with Scotland's Beaver Strategy.
'A huge amount of work has been taking place to ensure this, and a lot of progress has been made, with the population of beavers in Scotland expanding and their range increasing accordingly.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Scottish troops set for relocation with high-readiness posting in Cyprus
The soldiers of 4th Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Scotland (4 SCOTS) have been based at Bourlon Barracks at the Catterick Garrison in North Yorkshire for the last 10 years. During that time they have been able to 'put down roots' – building families and friendships, and continuing 'proud' Scottish traditions including the Highland games. The new posting will see them relocate to the British Sovereign Base Area in Dhekelia, Cyprus, with the first flights scheduled for Saturday. Once there the battalion will stand ready to respond at short notice to emerging situations across the Middle East and North Africa. At the same time they will be tasked with supporting peacekeeping efforts and protecting key military infrastructure on the island. Captain Craig Taylor, who has been with the battalion throughout its time at Bourlon Barracks, said the move will be a 'big change' for the troops. 'We've had 10 solid years of stability here in Catterick. It's been a place where soldiers could put down roots, raise families, and grow professionally,' he said. 'Moving to Cyprus will be a big change for us, not just in terms of the climate. 'This is an exciting opportunity that soldiers have been training hard for. It's not a short-term tour or exercise – it's a full overseas posting which gives us the chance to experience new cultures and ways of life. 'Professionally, it sharpens our edge. We'll be held at high readiness to deploy anywhere in the region, and beyond which is of real strategic importance to the UK.' It is not the first overseas posting for the battalion, which has been involved in operations in the likes of Iraq, Afghanistan and Kosovo since its formation in 2006. Closer to home, 4 SCOTS also provided security support for the 2022 Commonwealth Games in Birmingham, provided emergency aid during the 2018 Saddleworth Moor wildfires, and took part in the national Covid-19 response. Despite being more than 2,000 miles from Scotland, the battalion intends to take its traditions with it, with events including regimental competitions and Burns Night celebrations remaining 'firm fixtures' in the calendar. Capt Taylor added: 'We're proud of everything we've achieved here. 'But now it's time to pack up, push forward, and embed our Scottish identity into a new location.'
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
The time Trump reviewed Citizen Kane and revealed too much of himself
Yet there are rare moments when this side reaches the surface, and it can feel quite startling, as if he has maybe revealed too much of himself. Times when he has spoken about his brother Fred, for one, whose alcoholism led to an early death that greatly influenced the trajectory of the younger Trump. Glimpses into his personal grief are fleeting, but they expose a man who, beneath his bravado, is deeply shaped by his fear of being rendered powerless. Read more: Think of all the great art we'll get from a Trump win… But there's an even stranger instance of Trump revealing his vulnerable side, and it's when, in 2002, he reviewed his favourite film – the 1941 Orson Welles-directed Citizen Kane. It's not hard to see why the film resonates so much with Trump. Its portrayal of Charles Foster Kane – a wealthy, ambitious, and arrogant media mogul whose life is marked by power, betrayal, and isolation – has drawn plenty of comparisons with the President. Throughout his review, Trump makes it clear that he sees Kane as a stand-in for himself. 'The wealth, the sorrow, the unhappiness, the happiness, just struck lots of different notes,' he muses. He finds solace in Kane's struggles with the pursuit of success and wealth, rather than the cautionary tale Welles intended, pointing out telling moments like Kane and his wife sitting further apart at the dinner table the more his power mutates and grows. It is transparent that Trump sees parallels to his own personal life in these moments, and he sees Kane as that rare someone who can actually understand him. 'In real life I believe that wealth does in fact isolate you from other people. It's a protective mechanism. You have your guard up much more than you would if you didn't have wealth.' His reading is rather revealing, even if he misses much of the film's subtext. Citizen Kane is a tragedy about a man who sacrifices love and humanity in pursuit of power, only to die alone, lamenting his lost innocence. Yet Trump doesn't recoil from Kane's fate; he relates to it. He recognises Kane's isolation not as a direct result of his actions and mindset, but as a protective mechanism. It is as if Trump sees Kane as a muse, a kindred spirit that he in some way must protect lest it reflect badly on himself. It's a telling inversion, where a critique of wealth and power is instead embraced as a necessary defence against a hostile world. Errol Morris, who directed the segment featuring Trump's review, later remarked on the strange dissonance between the film's intent and Trump's interpretation, the clash between the obvious meaning behind Kane's character and Trump's completely analogous take. 'If I were Donald Trump, I would not want to emphasise that connection with Kane. You know, a megalomaniac in love with power and crushing everything in his path. The inability to have friends, the inability to find love,' the documentarian observed. Read more: Trump film tariff proves Scottish film cannot afford to sell out to Hollywood Trump changes the reasons he loves Citizen Kane over time, and it always runs in sync with his own narrative. When speaking on the film during his 2016 presidential campaign, he focused on the sharp turn the media took against Kane, likening it to his own media onslaught at the time. In that reading, Kane becomes a fellow 'fake news' martyr, unjustifiably persecuted. Like most things with Trump, his reading of Citizen Kane is less about the film and more about himself. He doesn't see a warning; he sees a mirror. And in that reflection, he finds validation – even in the parts that should give him pause. The film explores how fetishising success can become a hollow pitfall in wait, yet to Trump, it just makes Kane a misunderstood man. It is peculiar that through the endless observations of Trump, the millions of words out of his mouth that have been documented and spread, we begin to get closer to how his internal world works through his grasp of a film's meaning and what becomes accidentally revealed through that. His relationship with Citizen Kane speaks loudly about his own relationship with power, where the spectre of tragedy is just an inevitability of that process. Of course, by the end of the review, the Trump we all know returns. Trump's reply when asked what advice he would give Kane, a man of a similar disposition? 'Get yourself a different woman'.
STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Scottish troops set for relocation with high-readiness posting in Cyprus
A Scottish Army battalion is gearing up to relocate to Cyprus for two years, where it will take on a new role as a high-readiness standby formation. The soldiers of 4th Battalion, The Royal Regiment of Scotland (4 SCOTS) have been based at Bourlon Barracks at the Catterick Garrison in North Yorkshire for the last ten years. During that time they have been able to 'put down roots' – building families and friendships, and continuing 'proud' Scottish traditions including the Highland games. The new posting will see them relocate to the British Sovereign Base Area in Dhekelia, Cyprus, with the first flights scheduled for Saturday. Once there the battalion will stand ready to respond at short notice to emerging situations across the Middle East and North Africa. At the same time they will be tasked with supporting peacekeeping efforts and protecting key military infrastructure on the island. Captain Craig Taylor, who has been with the battalion throughout its time at Bourlon Barracks, said the move will be a 'big change' for the troops. 'We've had 10 solid years of stability here in Catterick. It's been a place where soldiers could put down roots, raise families, and grow professionally,' he said. 'Moving to Cyprus will be a big change for us, not just in terms of the climate. 'This is an exciting opportunity that soldiers have been training hard for. It's not a short-term tour or exercise – it's a full overseas posting which gives us the chance to experience new cultures and ways of life. 'Professionally, it sharpens our edge. We'll be held at high readiness to deploy anywhere in the region, and beyond which is of real strategic importance to the UK.' It is not the first overseas posting for the battalion, which has been involved in operations in the likes of Iraq, Afghanistan and Kosovo since its formation in 2006. Closer to home, 4 SCOTS also provided security support for the 2022 Commonwealth Games in Birmingham, provided emergency aid during the 2018 Saddleworth Moor wildfires, and took part in the national Covid-19 response. Despite being more than 2,000 miles from Scotland, the battalion intends to take its traditions with it, with events including regimental competitions and Burns Night celebrations remaining 'firm fixtures' in the calendar. Capt Taylor added: 'We're proud of everything we've achieved here. 'But now it's time to pack up, push forward, and embed our Scottish identity into a new location.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
