Why F1 may benefit from Mohammed Ben Sulayem's V8 push
'Bring back V10s' hissed the voice at the other end of the line: former F1 'ringmaster' Bernie Ecclestone. And, lo, the herd began its charge in that direction, only to crash upon the indifference of F1's engine manufacturers during a crunch meeting ahead of the Bahrain GP.
But FIA president Mohammed Ben Sulayem, one of those who got rather ahead of themselves on that chilly February day in London, still believes in the principle of a return to natural aspiration and set out his stall during a media briefing ahead of the British GP in July.
The new plan accommodates reservations expressed by the majority of the engine manufacturers during the Bahrain summit: that V10s were unsuitable on many levels, not least the road-relevance front; and some form of electrification would have to be included to provide synergies with road car technologies.
It's a debate which has been raging between paddock insiders for many years: should F1 slavishly mirror road car trends or should it adopt a so-called 'set controls for the heart of the sun' policy, focusing completely on noise and power even if it alienates the manufacturers? Many purists espouse the latter but acknowledge the many practical problems, such as what would happen to the manufacturer-based teams and who would actually build the engines.
V8s, as now espoused by Ben Sulayem, are more acceptable to the manufacturers since many of them still have engines of that configuration somewhere in the range. At the same time the idea of internal combustion is undergoing something of a renaissance, owing to new technologies and developments in the global trading picture.
A Ford DFV V8 engine in the back of a Brabham BT49
For a long time the direction of travel in the car industry has been towards full electrification, pushed by government legislation. But a significant proportion of consumers remain resistant, viewing electric cars as too expensive (and, of course, there are those who fear their genitals may fall off if they are seen driving anything other than a car with a loud, noisy and powerful internal combustion engine).
Faced with this and an influx of cheaper, state-subsidised vehicles exported from China, the western car industry is beginning to panic. Former Renault Group boss Luca de Meo admitted as much before he quit.
So there is still room for the internal combustion engine, provided the new generation of synthetic fuels can be produced at scale for a reasonable cost.
Assuming F1 did return to a V8 engine format, there would be details to work out regarding size and the proportion of electrification. Next year the split will be 50:50 but this has proved controversial, and the technical formula has had to be adapted to embrace adaptive aerodynamic devices to mitigate potential power shortfalls on the straights. It's understood that the solution envisioned by the FIA is to move to an 80:20 ratio in favour of the ICU, or even 90:10.
The new format would be introduced when the 2026 technical package has run its course, most likely 2030, though the president has suggested it could be earlier.
"We need to do it soon,' he said at Silverstone. 'You need three years, so hopefully by 2029 we have something there.'
2026 Formula 1 rules
Ben Sulayem has also talked about achieving radical cost savings by standardising components including the gearbox and the hybrid system. Former president Max Mosley tried to drive through something along these lines at the end of 2008, during the global financial crisis, running a tender process for a homologated drivetrain (ultimately won by Cosworth and Hewland). An additional wrinkle of the plan was to open up new grid spots and have those teams using the standard powertrain effectively running in a championship tier of their own, with a budget cap.
But that idea was ultimately too complicated and lost impetus when Mosley stood down. Jean Todt, the next president, let it die entirely.
There is an argument to say gearboxes are expensive to design, develop and build, and are no longer performance differentiators, so having a standardised component isn't necessarily a negative. There may be grumblings about whoever wins the putative tender but F1 has been here before, when McLaren Applied Technologies won the contract to supply the whole grid with homologated Engine Control Units. Fears of inequality and skulduggery proved unfounded.
Standardised hybrid components may be more difficult for the engine manufacturers to digest – but, equally, this is also an 'invisible' system so far as the audience is concerned and if it can be made less expensive, it will find support. The FIA's position is that cost saving remains one of the most important factors even at a time when F1 is thriving commercially – because that situation could change at any time based on geopolitics and the global economy.
'As the FIA we are the moderators during the discussion of the regulations, mindful to contain costs and create a level playing field for all,' FIA single-seater director Nikolas Tombazis told Motorsport.com earlier this year.
'There is some strong resistance at times, as you would expect, from teams or PU manufacturers protecting their interests or investment. Cost-cutting and level of technological freedom are at loggerheads with each other. It is not easy to have both.
'The PU manufacturers came [to discussion regarding the 2026 regulations] with many proposals for cost-cutting on a number of items relating to the engine. They centred on simplification, eliminating certain materials, processes and technologies.
'The amount of cost-cutting we've achieved is not as much as we would all have liked. While we are in a very healthy position as a sport, financially and in terms of popularity, we should never be complacent about that: cost-cutting should always have a high priority.'
The Formula One Championship-winning Power Units: Mercedes-AMG F1 M09 EQ Power+ (2018), Mercedes-AMG F1 M08 EQ Power+ (2017), Mercedes-Benz PU106C Hybrid (2016), Mercedes-Benz PU106B Hybrid (2015), Mercedes-Benz PU106A Hybrid (2014)
'Many of the manufacturers produce V8s in their cars, so commercially it's correct,' said Ben Sulayem at Silverstone. 'How much is it? The target is more than 50 percent [cheaper] in everything.'
This could be achieved not just through standardising parts but also mandating cheaper materials. It's known, for instance, that the FIA wanted to move to aluminium pistons but the engine manufacturers, having initially supported the idea, U-turned en masse.
Another issue F1 faces in its drive towards 'net zero' is the cost of the fully sustainable fuel which will be mandatory next year, said to be in the region of $275-$300 per litre. This reflects both the R&D investment which has had to go into developing these fuels and the energy-intensive means of production. As yet there is no solution to the problem of producing at scale and to a reasonable cost.
Since all the teams have commercial fuel-and-lubes supply deals, the question of who actually absorbs those costs is tricky to unpick – and likely to differ depending on how individual deals are structured. Which is why another of Ben Sulayem's proposals is likely to face resistance: a single fuel supplier.
What goes in the tank is less of a performance differentiator than it used to be – a chemical composition close to pump fuel is now prescribed, as is a sustainable element – but fuel brands still rely on performance for their storytelling. Shell, for instance, has built the identity of its VPower blend around its partnership with Ferrari.
Would the story survive if the Ferrari were to become a mere mobile billboard for the likes of Shell, while the go-juice sloshing around inside had a rather different provenance? Perhaps – after all, we live in an age of profound superficiality.
Ultimately if costs can be reduced as much as the president would like, the grid as a whole will benefit – and few will care whether you have a tiger in your tank or not.
Read Also:
Why F1 drivers don't like Pirelli's wet tyres, and how it plans to fix them
To read more Motorsport.com articles visit our website.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Is Tottenham vs Manchester United on TV? Kick-off time, channel and how to watch Premier League fixture
Tottenham Hotspur host Manchester United in the Premier League today, with the league's two most underwhelming sides set to face off in the capital. Ange Postecoglou's Spurs sat in 14th in the table going into the weekend – with just 27 points – having exited both the Carabao Cup and FA Cup, with questions persisting around the Australian's future at the club. Advertisement And things are not much better at United, with Ruben Amorim's side sitting just two points and one place above Spurs. The Portuguese's start to life at Old Trafford has been underwhelming so far, and while they have taken a place in the last 16 of the Europa League alongside Spurs, it's now a fact that success in that competition is the only potential positive that either club can take from an otherwise disappointing season. Here's everything you need to know ahead of the match. When is Tottenham vs Manchester United? The match kicks off at 4.30pm on Sunday, 16 February at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in London. Advertisement How can I watch the match? The match will be shown live in the UK on Sky Sports Main Event and Premier League, with coverage starting at 4pm. If you're not a Sky customer, you can grab a NOWTV Day Pass to watch without a subscription. Confirmed line-ups Tottenham XI: Vicario, Porro, Danso, Davies, Spence, Bentancur, Bergvall, Maddison, Kulusevski, Son, Tel Man Utd XI: Onana; Mazraoui, De Ligt, Maguire; Dalot, Casemiro, Fernandes, Dorgu; Garnacho, Zirkzee; Hojlund What is the team news? Tottenham welcome back goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario, for his first start since breaking his ankle against Manchester City in November! There is also a return for James Maddison, while Archie Gray and MIkey Moore drop out. Destiny Udogie and Brennan Johnson are back on the bench. Advertisement Amorim indicated Mason Mount, Jonny Evans, Luke Shaw and Altay Bayindir will remain out on Sunday, with their new setbacks seeing some academy players called up for training. Manchester United start both Rasmus Hojlund and Joshua Zirkzee, with Amad Diallo ruled out. Casemiro comes into midfield and partners Bruno Fernandes - that's because there's no Manuel Ugarte or Kobbie Mainoo in the squad. To add to that, Christian Eriksen and Leny Yoro are both ill, leaving Ruben Amorim's squad looking very thin indeed. There are eight teenagers on the United bench: Harry Amass , Ayden Heaven, Elyh Harrison Tyler Fredricson, Jack Fletcher, Sekou Kone , Jack Moorhouse and Chido Obi. Advertisement Odds Tottenham win - 11/8 Draw - 27/10 Man Utd win - 17/10 The Independent vets betting sites for useability, security and responsible gambling tools. You can claim free bets here to use across a range of sports. Please read the terms. Prediction This could well be the Premier League's most difficult match to predict, with neither manager knowing exactly what kind of performance they'll get from their side. The two sides' meeting in the Carabao Cup in December was a comedy of errors and lack of quality, and this could well be the same. Tottenham 2-2 Manchester United. We may earn commission from some of the links in this article, but we never allow this to influence our content. This revenue helps to fund journalism across The Independent.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Opinion: Arsenal signing £62m ‘new Best and Maradona' rolled into one would bring PL title home
Opinion: Arsenal signing £62m 'new Best and Maradona' rolled into one would bring PL title home Arsenal have a lot of work to do in the January transfer window. Mikel Arteta's men are currently sitting six points behind league leaders Liverpool in the table, and the Merseyside outfit have a game in hand on the Gunners. Advertisement Arsenal fans would have expected much more before the start of the 2024/25 season, having pushed Manchester City so close over the past two campaigns. One of the factors behind the Gunners' struggles has been the lack of a potent threat down the left hand side. Sure, there have been some harsh red cards, and Arteta has had to deal with numerous injuries to key players, but Gabriel Martinelli's form has been a real concern. Whilst Leandro Trossard has still chipped in with the odd goal here and there, he hasn't been great overall either. It's time for Arsenal to make a big upgrade in the left wing role, and the perfect player is out there waiting for Arteta to make his move. Advertisement Arsenal need to make a big January statement Arteta simply has to strengthen his ranks at the Emirates this winter, if a charge at the Premier League title is possible. And Khvicha Kvaratskhelia is the perfect man for the job. He could be sold for around £62 million according to a publication in the winger's home country – Georgia Today. The Gunners must go all out to bring the 23-year-old Napoli attacker to north London, in order to solve Arteta's pressing left wing problem. Sky Sports suggest that his playing styles similar to that of iconic duo George Best and Diego Maradona. Kvaratskhelia's dribbling ability is second to none, and the way that he moves with the ball seemingly stuck to his feet like glue is a true joy to watch. Advertisement The Georgia international has five goals and three assists to his name in 15 Serie A appearances for Napoli so far this season. In total, he has 30 goals and 29 assists in 105 games for the Italian giants. The Napoli star is only 23, so he has many more years left to improve and reach even higher levels. In my opinion, Khvicha Kvaratskhelia is on another level to Gabriel Martinelli and Leandro Trossard. If Mikel Arteta manages to bring him to Arsenal in January, it could well be the deal that brings the Premier League trophy to the Emirates for the first time ever. Stats via Transfermarkt.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Wissa leaves Brentford pre-season training camp
Brentford forward Yoane Wissa has left the team's pre-season base in Portugal amid growing uncertainty over his future. BBC Sport has learned the 28-year-old has returned to London from the Bees' training camp. Wissa will now hold talks with Brentford director of football Phil Giles with a trio of Premier League clubs keen on him. Newcastle, Tottenham and Nottingham Forest are among those with a firm interest in the DR Congo international. All three clubs can offer him European football next season and it is understood agreeing personal terms, particularly with either Tottenham or Newcastle - whose efforts to land Wissa have intensified in the last 48 hours - will not be an issue. Wissa is understood to have been unsettled by the speculation regarding his future in recent weeks. He is expected to join back up with the team upon their return to London if he continues to be a Brentford player. The outcome of the meeting is likely to be pivotal towards how Brentford approach resolving Wissa's future. Brentford recently tried to open negotiations with Wissa over a new contract, but he is understood to prefer a move away from the Gtech Community Stadium this summer. Wissa's Brentford team-mate Bryan Mbeumo is set to join Manchester United after the Bees accepted a £65m bid. Brentford initially had no intention of losing both Mbeumo and Wissa this summer. However, with Wissa turning 29 in September the scenario of a depreciating asset – who this summer could command a fee in the region of £40m, if not more - will likely be a consideration. That he has just 12 months left on his current deal, though there is an option to activate by a further year, is another factor to mull over. Wissa joined Brentford from from French club Lorient in August 2021 and has scored 49 goals in 149 games in all competitions for the Bees. He scored 19 goals in 35 Premier League games last season. Brentford face Portuguese Primeira Liga side Gil Vicente at the Estadio Cidade de Barcelos in their first pre-season friendly on 25 July. Latest Brentford news, analysis and fan views Get Brentford news sent straight to your phone