Sebi order reflects misunderstanding of standard hedging practices: Jane Street
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel
Mumbai: US-based Jane Street said the Indian capital market regulator's order accusing the trading firm of manipulative trading in equity derivatives reflects a 'misunderstanding of standard hedging practices and the interrelationships between derivative and underlying markets'.The firm, in an internal communication that ET has accessed, said the Securities and Exchange Board of India's claim that the firm's activity is "prima facie manipulative", disregards the role of liquidity providers and arbitrageurs in markets, while contesting claims that it was uncooperative with Sebi regarding its trading strategies."This just isn't true. It doesn't line up with the facts of how we engaged with Sebi," the communication read.Last week, Sebi banned Jane Street from dealing in Indian securities market and directed it to pay ₹4,844 crore, which the regulator deemed as unlawful gains.The Indian regulator used a specific metric for market impact and trading aggressiveness which is disconnected from actual market dynamics, the trading firm said.The firm said when Sebi asked for information about its trading in August 2024, it promptly provided information and maintained transparent communication throughout follow-up questions. Similarly, upon receiving letters from the Indian stock exchanges in February this year, it immediately "turned off" trading activity to understand their concerns. Senior Jane Street leaders from Hong Kong and New York also flew to Mumbai and based on the conversation, made modifications to its trading, it said. Upon completion of the process, it believed that Sebi was comfortable with its approach."Since February, we have made ongoing efforts to communicate with Sebi and have been consistently rebuffed. The order claims that this is an "urgent" situation, yet Sebi could have responded to any one of our requests to discuss their concerns."Countering Sebi's allegations that it was most active on expiry days of index options, Jane Street said the nature of the Indian market, where participants predominantly engage in cash-settled index options, results in liquidity providers (including themselves and others) accumulating stock price exposure that terminates at options expiry. "Replacing expiring deltas with non-expiring deltas is a standard and well-understood practice in markets throughout the world," the firm said.On the Sebi order emphasising examining the first eight minutes of trading on January 17, 2024, as crucial for understanding the intent and design of its options strategy, which the regulator termed as intra-day index manipulation, Jane Street explained that those eight minutes illustrate basic index arbitrage trading, a standard financial market mechanism that maintains the prices of related instruments in line."One can easily observe that there was a large divergence between the Bank Nifty index price shown in the options markets and the price implied by the stock levels. Jane Street (presumably alongside other participants) traded in a direction consistent with closing that gap and bringing the two markets more in line with one another," the firm said. Such synchronisation, Jane Street said, was "unambiguously good for the health of financial markets".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kolhapur among 59 districts in India with huge export potential:Exim study
Kolhapur: Kolhapur is among 59 districts in India with untapped potential for exports, said Deepali Agarwal, deputy managing director, Export-Import (Exim) Bank, citing a study by the bank. She was speaking at a programme organised by Shiroli Manufacturers Association in Kolhapur. Agarwal said that Exim Bank data showed that major exported products from Kolhapur in 2024-25 were textiles, machine gears, auto components, jewelry, refined sugar, rice, and casting. "According to a study undertaken by Exim Bank, less than 2% of the districts in India contribute to around 40% of India's exports, and hence there remains significant scope of tapping the 'missing middle export districts. "The study identified 'missing middle export districts' whose exports are between US$ 1 billion and US$ 5 billion. In fact, there are around 59 districts in India out of 750 plus districts that fall under the bracket of 'missing middle export districts', one of them being Kolhapur," said Agarwal. Kolhapur, one of the agriculturally advanced districts in Maharashtra, is today a front runner in manufacturing engineering products, refined sugar, and textiles. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Why seniors are rushing to get this Internet box – here's why! Techno Mag Learn More Undo In 2021-22, the exports from Kolhapur amounted to Rs 95.1 billion, and in 2022-23, they increased to Rs 93.7 billion. "The exports from Kolhapur saw a decline after the export ban on sugar; however, Kolhapur's exports increased from Rs 58.9 billion in 2023-24 to Rs 61.8 billion in 2024-25. The data showed that exports from Kolhapur witnessed diversification. In 2024-25, the major exported products from Kolhapur were textiles, machine gears, auto components, jewelry, refined sugar, rice, and casting articles. Together, the top 10 products constituted about 42% of Kolhapur's total merchandise exports, amounting to Rs 25.7 billion during 2024-25," said Agarwal. She mentioned that silver jewelry from Hupari in Kolhapur is also in huge demand in India and abroad. The Kolhapuri Saaj is a specialty of Kolhapur and is exported along with other silver ornaments and idols in silver to countries like the US and Australia. The top official of Exim Bank said that the bank has designed a grassroots initiative and development (GRID) programme to harness the export potential of tier-II cities like Kolhapur. She said that under the programme, the bank supports artisans, craftsmen, weavers, clusters, self-help groups, farmers' producer organisations, and micro-enterprises. Exim Bank also provided assistance to SMAK to set up precision 3D scanning solution and casting simulation technology facility at the common facility centre at SMAK, which will tremendously help small-scale manufacturing units.
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Aircraft with high-speed internet to debut in Kol-Abu Dhabi sector
Kolkata: Flyers from Kolkata will be the first among 100 cities in over 40 countries on the Etihad Airways network to witness in-flight high-speed WiFi facility across all classes. "The international flying experience will change from Sept 26 when we service the Kolkata-Abu Dhabi sector with a new A321LR aircraft instead of the A320 now,"said Etihad chief revenue and commercial officer, Arik De. The brand new narrow-body Airbus A321LR will offer first-class suites, lie-flat business seats, and an economy cabin with 4K touchscreens and high-speed WiFi. "The WiFi facility will enable flyers to not only work online on their laptops but also view or stream their content from OTT accounts," said De, who will take delivery of the first of 40 A321LR aircraft in two weeks. All flyers can access the free chat feature on WhatsApp, Messenger, Instagram and WeChat. Web-based calls and viewing content online is complementary for first-class passengers but fee-based for others. You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata There is a regulatory issue: Indian govt policy on satellite coverage needs to be clarified before the airline can offer internet services on board flights in Indian airspace. The Etihad announcement comes days before rival carrier Emirates Airlines is set to introduce premium economy on four of its 11 flights between Kolkata and Dubai from July 18. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like An engineer reveals: One simple trick to get internet without a subscription Techno Mag Learn More Undo Etihad has twice daily flights on Friday and Sunday and a daily flight on Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Saturday between Kolkata and Abu Dhabi. Though it does not have a service on Tuesday, sister airline Air Arabia operates on Tuesday. In the absence of direct flights to Europe or the US, Etihad, Emirates, and Qatar offer connections to the West via Abu Dhabi, Dubai and Doha. While aviation analysts argued that the lack of business class travellers and low yields have discouraged Indian, European, and American carriers from starting direct flights, Etihad is confident of filling up its premium seats. "There are many successful people from Kolkata settled in the US or Europe who want to ensure that their parents travel in comfort," Etihad VP (global sales & distribution) Javier Alija said, adding that around half of the business class passengers were leisure travellers.
Fibre2Fashion
28 minutes ago
- Fibre2Fashion
Understanding the latest US tariff updates from a T-shirt price POV
In a significant move reshaping global trade dynamic, US President Donald Trump has announced a new wave of potential tariffs targeting 14 countries—including key textile and apparel exporters like Bangladesh, Cambodia and Indonesia, in addition to Myanmar, Tunisia, Japan, South Korea, and seven other nations. These countries have been given until August 1, 2025 (extended from the earlier July 9 deadline) to finalise new trade deals with the US or face steep increases in import duties. We consider four top textile and apparel manufacturing countries—China, India, Bangladesh and Vietnam, and in today's context analyse the average import unit price of a T-shirt into the US, based on the latest tariff rates. The 2025 average import unit price is calculated based on the United States' reported import trade values and quantities. These figures reflect CFR (Cost and Freight) terms. Table 1: Understanding the latest US Tariff from a T-shirt price POV *Subject to change with the anticipation of a trade deal announcement. (The above values are indicative cost prices based on the import trade data analysis) Following President Trump's tariff announcement on April 2, various countries responded in different ways. Some, such as China, imposed retaliatory tariffs, while others like India and Vietnam initiated discussions to explore potential trade deals and agreements. A deadline of July 9, which was recently extended to August 1, was set for these negotiations. During this period, tariffs were temporarily suspended, and a universal 10 per cent tariff was applied across all countries. China: Following the reciprocal tariffs announced by the US on April 2, 2025, a period of intense escalation ensued, with US tariffs on Chinese goods rising from an initial 34 per cent to as high as 245 per cent. Subsequently, with trade negotiations, both countries reached a temporary agreement in Geneva last month. Under this accord, the US reduced its tariffs on Chinese imports to 55 per cent, while China lowered its retaliatory tariffs to 10 per cent, marking a significant de-escalation from the previously imposed triple-digit rates by both sides. India: After being included in the US tariff list in April 2025, India has actively pursued a trade agreement. Negotiations are reportedly in the final stages, and a deal could soon be announced. In case a deal is not materialised, Indian products will attract a duty of 26 per cent in the US from August 1. Bangladesh: On July 7, Bangladesh received a formal notice from the US about the impending tariff hike. The new rate of 35 per cent (slightly down from the earlier 37 per cent, announced on April 2) is currently one of the highest among major apparel exporters. Vietnam: Despite securing a trade deal, Vietnam will face a 20 per cent tariff on its exports to the US—a reduction from the previously proposed 46 per cent, but still double the current 10 per cent rate, which is applicable equally to most countries. Observations from Table 1 While India currently has a high tariff of 26 per cent, with the positive developments of a trade deal with the US, it is poised to offer the most competitive pricing and may become even more attractive with a lower price point if a trade deal with tariff of 10 per cent or lesser is finalised. Bangladesh, despite a slight tariff reduction, faces one of the steepest duties among major exporters. Vietnam, even with a trade deal, ends up with the highest T-shirt price due to its elevated base cost and 20 per cent tariff. China could face a substantial impact on final import prices to the US, given its position as the highest-tariffed among key apparel-supplying countries. Nevertheless, it remains relatively competitive with Vietnam, largely due to its low base price, which helps offset the elevated tariff burden. Fibre2Fashion News Desk (AP)
