‘Please be careful.' There are risks and rewards as crypto heavyweights push tokenization
'Tokenization is going to open the door to a massive trading revolution,' said Vlad Tenev, the CEO of the trading platform Robinhood at a recent James Bond-themed tokenization launch event in the south of France.
Advocates say tokenization is the next leap forward in crypto and can help break down walls that have advantaged the wealthy and make trading cheaper, more transparent and more accessible for everyday investors.
But critics say tokenization threatens to undermine a century's worth of securities law and investor protections that have made the U.S. financial system the envy of the world. And Robinhood's push into tokenizing shares of private companies quickly faced pushback from one of the world's most popular startups.
What is tokenization?
The basic idea behind tokenization: Use blockchain technology that powers cryptocurrencies to create digital tokens as stand-ins for things like bonds, real estate or even fractional ownership of a piece of art and that can be traded like crypto by virtually anyone, anywhere at any time.
The massive growth of stablecoins, which are a type of cryptocurrency typically bought and sold for $1, has helped fuel the appetite to tokenize other financial assets, crypto venture capitalist Katie Haun said on a recent podcast.
She said tokenization will upend investing in ways similar to how streamers radically changed how people watch television.
'You used to have to sit there on a Thursday night and watch Seinfeld,' Haun said. 'You tune in at a specific time, you don't get to choose your program, you couldn't be watching a program like Squid Games from Korea. Netflix was market-expanding. In the same way, I think the tokenization of real-world assets will be market expanding.'
Growing momentum
Robinhood began offering tokenized stock trading of major U.S. public companies for its European customers earlier this month and gave away tokens to some customers meant to represent shares in OpenAI and SpaceX, two highly valued private companies.
Several other firms are diving in. Crypto exchange Kraken also allows customers outside the U.S. to trade tokenized stocks while Coinbase has petitioned regulators to open the market to its U.S. customers. Wall Street giants BlackRock and Franklin Templeton currently offer tokenized money market funds. McKinsey projects that tokenized assets could reach $2 trillion by 2030.
Crypto's golden age
The push for tokenization comes at a heady time in crypto, an industry that's seen enormous growth from the creation and early development of bitcoin more than 15 years ago by libertarian-leaning computer enthusiasts to a growing acceptance in mainstream finance.
The world's most popular cryptocurrency is now regularly setting all-time highs — more than $123,000 on Monday — while other forms of crypto like stablecoins are exploding in use and the Trump administration has pledged to usher in what's been called the 'golden age' for digital assets.
Lee Reiners, a lecturing fellow at Duke University, said the biggest winners in the push for tokenization could be a small handful of exchanges like Robinhood that see their trading volumes and influence spike.
'Which is kind of ironic given the origins of crypto, which was to bypass intermediaries,' Reiners said.
Trump bump
Interest in tokenization has also gotten a boost thanks to the election of President Donald Trump, who has made enacting more crypto-friendly regulations a top priority of his administration and signed a new law regulating stablecoins on Friday.
'Tokenization is an innovation and we at the SEC should be focused on how do we advance innovation at the marketplace,' said Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman Paul Atkins.
Is it legal?
Securities law can be complex and even defining what is a security can be a hotly debated question, particularly in crypto. The crypto exchange Binance pulled back offerings of tokenized securities in 2021 after German regulators raised questions about potential violations of that country's securities law.
Under Trump, the SEC has taken a much less expansive view than the previous administration and dropped or paused litigation against crypto companies that the agency had previously accused of violating securities law.
Hilary Allen, a professor at the American University Washington College of Law, said crypto companies have been emboldened by Trump's victory to be more aggressive in pushing what they can offer.
'The most pressing risk is (tokenization) being used as a regulatory arbitrage play as a way of getting around the rules,' she said.
However, the SEC has struck a cautionary tone when it comes to tokens. Shortly after Robinhood's announcement, SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce, who has been an outspoken crypto supporter, issued a statement saying companies issuing tokenized stock should consider 'their disclosure obligations' under federal law.
'As powerful as blockchain technology is, it does not have magical abilities to transform the nature of the underlying asset,' Peirce said.
All eyes on private companies
One of the most closely watched areas of tokenization involves private companies, which aren't subject to strict financial reporting requirements like publicly traded ones.
Many hot startups are not going public as often as they used to and instead are increasingly relying on wealthy and institutional investors to raise large sums of money and stay private.
That's unfair to the little guy, say advocates of tokenization.
'These are massive wealth generators for a very small group of rich, well-connected insiders who get access to these deals early,' said Robinhood executive Johann Kerbrat. 'Crypto has the power to solve this inequality.'
Monday Mornings
The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week.
'Please be careful'
But Robinhood's giveaway of tokens meant to represent an investment in OpenAI immediately drew pushback from the company itself, which said it was not involved in Robinhood's plan and did not endorse it.
'Any transfer of OpenAI equity requires our approval—we did not approve any transfer,' OpenAI said on social media. 'Please be careful.'
Public companies have strict public reporting requirements about their financial health that private companies don't have to produce. Such reporting requirements have helped protect investors and give a legitimacy to the U.S. financial system, said Allen, who said the push for tokenized sales of shares in private companies is 'eerily familiar' to how things played out before the creation of the SEC nearly a century ago.
'Where we're headed is where we were in the 1920s,' she said. 'Door-to-door salesmen offering stocks and bonds, half of it had nothing behind it, people losing their life savings betting on stuff they didn't understand.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
24 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘We'll see where things land,' Carney says amid ‘intense phase' of ongoing U.S. negotiations and looming tariff deadline
The American administration reached a trade deal with the European Union, but negotiations with Canada continue. CTV National's Colton Praill has the latest. Prime Minister Mark Carney says negotiations with the U.S. are at an 'intense phase,' as U.S. President Donald Trump's deadline to increase tariffs on Canadian goods to 35 per cent fast approaches. 'It's a complex negotiation,' Carney told reporters on Monday, when asked what message he's sending to the industries that are anxious about the U.S. threatening higher levies. 'You see with the various trade deals that have been agreed by other jurisdictions — European Union yesterday, Japan before, Indonesia, etc., the United Kingdom — that there are many aspects to these negotiations.' 'We're engaged in them, but the assurance for Canadian business, for Canadians, is we will only sign a deal that's the right deal, that's a good deal for Canada,' Carney also said, echoing statements he made last week that his government is prioritizing 'the best deal' over a timely one. Carney made the comments on P.E.I. Monday following an announcement the federal government is cutting the toll to use the Confederation Bridge. Still looming, meanwhile, is Trump's threat to increase tariffs to 35 per cent on Friday, the date by which Carney has said the Canadian government is aiming to hash out a new economic deal with the United States. The new levies will not apply to goods that are covered by the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA), the White House has confirmed. Still in place, however, are steep tariffs on steel and aluminum, and autos, with Trump also signalling he plans to impose higher duties on copper as of Friday. While the protracted trade war and the status of negotiations have dominated discussions among Canadian lawmakers — namely during last week's meetings between Carney and the premiers, and as Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc met with several U.S. senators both in Ottawa and Washington last week — Trump on Friday said his administration hasn't 'been focused' on Canada. 'Aug. 1 is going to come, and we will have most of our deals finished, if not all,' Trump told reporters at the White House. 'We haven't really had a lot of luck with Canada. I think Canada could be one where they'll just pay tariffs. It's not really a negotiation.' Today, the prime minister dismissed the president's comments as a negotiating tactic. Still, LeBlanc has said Canada is still working toward an Aug. 1 target date to reach a deal, and to that end he is set to return to Washington this week. Asked Monday whether he should have kept the controversial digital services tax (DST) to earn the revenue from it, Carney said that's 'a hypothetical on a hypothetical.' Carney dropped the tax late last month after Trump said he'd end negotiations with Canada 'effective immediately' over the issue, with the president calling it 'a direct and blatant attack' on the U.S. and its technology companies. 'We'll see where things land in terms of negotiation,' Carney said Monday. 'There are pros and cons of that tax, as there are with any tax.' 'It may seem like it's a long way from a trade discussion at the end of this week,' Carney also said, pointing to other efforts his government has made to reduce the impact of the trade war on Canadians. 'What we're really spending the vast, vast part of our time on is what we can control, and building the country together, bringing the country together, and then building out the country.'
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Clubs in Europe's top division in rugby league vote to add more teams from 2026
HEADINGLEY, England (AP) — Clubs in the Super League, the top-tier of European rugby league, have voted to increase the number of teams in the competition to 14 from next season. The future structure of the league was discussed during a meeting at Headingley, north England, on Monday, with a proposal agreed to immediately open up two additional places, provided certain conditions are met. 'The 12 existing Betfred Super League clubs have today voted to extend the competition to 14 teams for the 2026 season, subject to conditions,' a statement from Super League (Europe) Limited read. 'This would be done by combining the Club Grading System introduced to determine Super League membership as part of the sport's long-term strategic partnership with IMG in 2022, with an independent panel to be chaired by Lord Jonathan Caine, who was recently elected as a member of the Rugby Football League Board, and the Strategic Review Sub-Committee. 'The top 12 clubs under grading at the conclusion of the 2025 domestic season will therefore be joined by two clubs recommended by that panel — provided the panel judges there are two applications of sufficient merit against the set criteria. 'Further details of the composition of the panel and the timing of the process will be confirmed in due course.' The Super League currently includes eleven teams from England and one side based in France — Catalans Dragons. The new proposals could see Championship teams such as Toulouse Olympique, Bradford Bulls, York Knights and London Broncos considered for a place in the expanded 14-team top-flight. Salford Red Devils, meanwhile, could see their Super League spot for 2026 reviewed given the club's ongoing financial issues.
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Trump vows tariffs for ‘the rest of the world.' Where does Canada stand?
The United States will impose a tariff for 'essentially the rest of the world' instead of making individual trade deals, U.S. President Donald Trump told reporters Monday. 'We're going to be setting a tariff essentially for the rest of the world, and that's what they're going to pay if they want to do business in the United States, because you can't sit down and make 200 deals,' Trump said during a joint media event with U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer. Trump's remark comes a day after he announced a trade deal with the European Union, which will see a 15 per cent tariff imposed on most European goods being exported to the U.S. The deal with the EU looks very similar to the one Trump announced with Japan, which would have a 15 per cent tariff on most Japanese exports to the U.S. Story continues below advertisement While Trump has said negotiations with other nations and trading blocs were progressing towards a deal before Aug. 1, he has singled out Canada as a country with which he was not making progress. Last week, Trump said his administration hasn't 'had a lot of luck with Canada' in its trade negotiations. He added that there may not be a deal with Canada. 'I think Canada could be one where there's just a tariff, not really a negotiation,' he told reporters. 'We don't have a deal with Canada; we haven't been focused on them,' he said. Prime Minister Mark Carney on Monday said he would only sign a deal that was 'a good deal for Canada.' 'The negotiations are at an intense phase,' Carney told reporters in Prince Edward Island. Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "The negotiations are at an intense phase," Carney told reporters in Prince Edward Island. Canada and the EU have both similarities and differences when it came to their respective commercial relationships with the U.S., Carney said. 'We have some similarities with the European Union in terms of our commercial relationships with the United States. We're one of their most important trade partners,' he said. 4:59 Canada – U.S. trade negotiations ahead of deadline 'He does not like Canada' These deals don't portend well for Canada, said Concordia University economist Moshe Lander, especially considering some recent threats Trump made against Canada's economy. Story continues below advertisement 'Trump's getting his way. He's menacing countries, big and small, and putting the world economy back to the 1930s,' Lander said. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Trump's statement on Monday seems to indicate that he would rather settle on a flat tariff rate for his trading partners, said Sal Guatieri, director and senior economist at BMO Capital Markets. 'For countries that run a trade surplus with the U.S. goods, they most likely will need to settle for something in that 15 per cent range,' he said. Earlier this month, Carney said it was 'unlikely' that a zero-tariff trade deal could be reached in August. Carney told reporters there was 'not a lot of evidence' for any country to have a tariff-free agreement and it was unlikely Trump would agree to one with Canada. Where does Canada's trade stand with U.S.? Canada's balance of trade with the U.S. is not like that of the EU. Story continues below advertisement Excluding oil, gas and energy, Canada runs a trade deficit with its neighbour. However, Guatieri said Trump was likely to only look at the overall balance of trade. 'Unfortunately, I don't think the White House is making much of a distinction with respect to Canada's trade with the U.S.,' he said. 'It's just saying basically in total, Canada is running a surplus with the U.S. and needs to pay a higher tariff. The main message from these six trade deals (that Trump has signed recently) is that basically no country will be unscathed. Everyone will end up with higher tariffs than was the case a year ago under the new White House,' he said. Trump has been ratcheting up his threats against Canada as the trade talks intensify. Last month, he said Canada was a 'a very difficult country to trade with' and threatened to scrap the talks altogether if Canada did not withdraw its Digital Services Tax. Last month, he raised the stakes of his trade war. In a letter to Carney posted to Truth Social, Trump threatened a 35 per cent tariff on 'Canadian products sent into the United States, separate from all Sectoral Tariffs.' 'If for any reason you decide to raise your Tariffs, then, whatever the number you choose to raise them by, will be added onto the 35 per cent that we charge,' the letter adds. Story continues below advertisement 'He does not like Canada,' Lander said. 'Canada is not going to get any sort of favourable treatment in whatever deal comes out,' he added. 2:04 What Trump's EU trade deal reveals about talks with Canada Autos, steel, aluminum hardest hit Those threats come as the steel and aluminum sectors continue to face steep U.S. tariffs. Story continues below advertisement 'Unfortunately, it doesn't look like any country so far is able to get their 50 per cent duty on steel and aluminum down to a smaller number,' Guatieri said. He added, 'One partial save for Quebec is that the U.S. really does need Canadian aluminum. They have limited capacity to increase their aluminum production or buy foreign-made aluminum from countries other than Canada.' Both Japan and the EU managed to get their tariff rate on automobiles reduced from 25 per cent to 15 per cent. Guatieri said Canada is likely to get a similar deal on autos. 'We would still be somewhat competitive in selling our vehicles to the U.S., especially when you consider that there is an exemption for U.S. content in Canadian-made vehicles. That would help (but) not fully shield Canada's auto industry,' he said. According to BMO, Canada's effective tariff rate for trade with the U.S. is currently around six per cent. This is because Trump's tariffs on Canada do not include goods that are CUSMA-complaint. This would be 'manageable' for the broader economy, Guatieri said, but added that the auto, steel and aluminum industries could see some serious pain, including potential layoffs. 'We think most of the rest of the country is somewhat insulated from this trade war, but unfortunately Ontario and Quebec are not,' Guatieri said.
