Pictured: The 'small' knife teen was carrying when he was detained by police officer later sacked over 'aggressive' arrest
The double-bladed 8inch weapon had a Stanley blade on one end, with a retractable serrated blade on the other.
The weapon fell out of a 15-year-old boys waistband on January 27, 2024, while PC Castle was arresting him for two alleged assaults in Bournemouth town centre.
The ex Dorset officer was dismissed by the force after an independent disciplinary tribunal found he had committed gross misconduct in relation to the arrest.
A video clip of the arrest, released by the force on Tuesday, showed the officer tackling the boy, who claimed he needed the knife 'for work', to the ground.
In a moment of anger, Mr Castle is seen taking hold of the teenager's face and throat while repeatedly swearing and shouting at him.
The boy can be heard shouting and crying 'what have I done' and 'what did I do' before the officer shouts 'stop screaming like a little b****, do you understand that? Shut up'.
However, retired chief inspector Chris Amey, who is backing PC Castle, said the weapon shows the presence faced by officers on a daily basis, quipping he was 'embarrassed to have ever worn their uniform.'
Referring to the knife, Mr Amey posted: 'Here's the "SMALL" knife that just happened to fall out of a "boy's" waistband whilst being detained for assaulting two members of the public.'
Mr Amey said he described it as 'small' because this is how it was detailed by Dorset Police's barrister as well colleagues.
'If we are lucky to catch someone with a knife actually on them whilst committing an assault on two members of the public, we'll let him go and sack the officer for finger pointing and calling him hurty words,' he wrote.
'You literally couldn't make it up. Embarrassed to have ever worn their uniform.'
He added: 'The boy could have quite conceivably used that knife and what's to say he would not have gone on to use that knife if Lorne had not discovered it.
'This is driving junior rank and file mad because they have seen their colleague take a knife off the street and how he has been treated by their leaders.
'I've been told by a serving officer that last Friday and Saturday night in the town centre officers were approached by youths who said 'there is nothing you can do to us because we'll get you sacked.''
Just months before making an over-zealous arrest that led to his sacking, Mr Castle had thrown himself into the River Avon in the middle of the night.
A vulnerable elderly lady clinging to a tiny parcel of land needed his help so he stripped off his stab vest and threw himself into the icy water to save her in the line of duty.
PC Castle knew regulations were clear that he should not enter the river - but without much thought he went in carrying a life ring as her terrified family watched on.
'Do you know what was going through my mind at that time? If I hit her with the ring, or she attempts to get it and gets dragged away I'm up for manslaughter because professional standards will tell me 'you weren't supposed to go in. You were trying to be a hero'', he said today.
'That is the world we operate in', he told the Telegraph.
However, despite the risk of his own arrest, he did it anyway and would later win a national bravery award for saving the woman.
The ex-police constable had since admitted misconduct in relation to the arrest.
He confessed to breaching the standards of professional behaviour relating to authority, respect and courtesy, conduct and use of force, but denied gross misconduct.
Following the hearing, Dorset Police said he acted 'inappropriately' as he detained the teenager after receiving reports of two assaults in the seaside town.
It is understood that he intends to appeal the decision to sack him for gross misconduct.
The married father-of-two said: 'I've got a phenomenal family and everyone knows that, but people are asking that question now 'am I some sort of abuser?' because I attempted to arrest someone who was potentially violent.'
During the incident in question, the teenager was also heard screaming: 'My f****** neck, get off me, I don't want you on me', while Mr Castle is on top of him.
The officer later shouted: 'Stop resisting or I'm gonna smash you, do you understand?' and says the boy is being arrested on suspicion of assault.
A force spokesperson said: 'PC Castle was seen to use unnecessary and inappropriate words towards the boy and place both his hands on his throat.
'The panel found that PC Castle failed to act with self-control, did not treat the boy with courtesy or respect.
'His shouting, swearing, finger pointing, taking hold of the boy's face and throat, and suggested use of leg restraints was not necessary, reasonable or proportionate.'
Speaking on LBC radio, Mr Castle said the suspect, who had been wearing a mask, had been 'an unknown risk' and was found to be in possession of a knife during the arrest.
The 46-year-old added: 'If I'd have known on those circumstances that he had a knife, that would have probably been a firearms incident.
'The real danger is the unknown. We knew he was potentially violent, but we didn't know how violent.
'Now, the risk for any police officer is the moment you go to detain someone, until you know you've got them safely detained.'
He explained it was a 'scary situation' because he was on the ground with the offender with other people nearby.
Mr Castle, who previously received a bravery award from the Humane Society, said he had received thousands of messages of support but felt people were questioning his nature despite previously having '10 years of exemplary service'.
In a statement, Dorset Police Federation criticised the force's decision to release the footage, saying it had done so 'without also providing context or balance'.
'Our view is that the showing of selective clips of an officer's body-worn video is not a useful or responsible way to properly inform the public about an incident, and only serves to entice the public into making judgements without having the benefit of all the facts', the body said.
'This is not fair or just.'
It added its members were still in limbo over how much force they should use in an arrest situation, and following PC Castle's sacking, it called on force commanders to provide 'urgent clarification' to frontline officers on the issue of force.
But the federation said no such clarification has been forthcoming.
Meanwhile, a distinguished former police and crime commissioner of Dorset Police said his former force has gone 'woke'.
Martyn Underhill said he found it 'scary' how Dorset Police behaved, calling it an 'overreaction'.
He said that while he deserved to be interviewed and disciplined, they were wrong to dismiss the 46-year-old officer without notice for gross misconduct.
He also slammed their 'questionable' decision to release footage of the arrest and said he was one of the 2,500 people who have so far donated to a GoFundMe campaign.
A campaigner for frontline police officers said the force had 'scored one of the biggest own goals ever' by sacking PC Castle.
Dorset's Deputy Chief Constable Rachel Farrell said: 'We are sharing body worn video to address concerns about misinformation and to reassure the public that, while tackling crime in Dorset, our officers will continue to be proactive and robust - but by using their powers proportionately and with respect.'
The Home Secretary, Yvette Cooper, has been asked to intervene in the case and reinstate PC Castle.
A spokesperson for the Home Office declined to comment and said it was a matter for Dorset Police.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
6 minutes ago
- The Independent
Gang murdered tourist after following him from party mansion made famous by Bonnie Blue
A gang of robbers have been found guilty of fatally stabbing a Greek tourist after following him from outside a multimillion-pound party mansion. Antonis Antoniadis, 26, was targeted after he left 32 Portland Place nightclub, in Marylebone, west London. Following an Old Bailey trial, Shian Johnson, 26, Sofian Alliche, 20, his brother Amin Alliche, 18, Joshua McCorquodale, 20, and Alfie Hipple, 18, all from Camden, north London, were found guilty of murder and conspiracy to rob. The defendants were taken down from the dock after one of them reacted with an angry outburst, accusing the jury of 'ruining' his life. The jury had deliberated for more than 14 hours to reach its unanimous verdicts, with one of them leaving court in tears. Judge Rebecca Trowler KC adjourned sentencing until October 3. The court heard how Greek printing firm office worker Mr Antoniadis had come on holiday to London for a week with two friends called Maria and Tia. They ended up at the 32 Portland Place nightclub in Marylebone in the early hours of July 7, jurors were told. The venue, owned by Edward 'Fast Eddie' Davenport, came to public attention when it hosted OnlyFans personality Bonnie Blue in her attempt to sleep with more than 1,000 men in 12 hours. On the evening before the murder, the robbers followed a yellow Lamborghini and a Mercedes car before fixing on the victim, who was carrying a Lacoste man bag and wearing a designer Versace watch. Mr Antoniadis and his two female friends did not leave Portland Place until after 8am and had booked an Uber to get back to a friend's address in New Cross, south-east London, where they were staying. Prosecutor Bill Emlyn Jones KC said the tourists had no idea that the young men hanging around outside the nightclub in a stolen car were on the lookout for someone to rob. He said: 'It seems that when that group of five saw Antonis come out of the club, those robbers thought they had found a suitable target. 'So when they saw him come out and get into his Uber, they, in their stolen car, followed him.' The defendants trailed the Uber car for more than half an hour to its destination on the opposite side of London, the court heard. As one of Mr Antoniadis's friends struggled to find the door key upon arriving at the address, he was approached by four figures in hoods and balaclavas. The fifth member of the gang acted as the getaway driver, jurors were told. Mr Antoniadis managed to hit one of the robbers with a brandy bottle as the group tried to grab his man bag. Mr Emlyn Jones said: 'Tragically, whether it was brave or whether it was just an instinctive response, that reaction was to cost him his life.' The victim was punched and kicked and then stabbed in the chest and thigh, severing his femoral artery. The attackers, at least two of whom were carrying large knives, then fled the scene in the getaway car, leaving the victim bleeding heavily. Mr Antoniadis was treated at the scene and taken to hospital where attempts were made to save his life, but he died from his injuries on July 21 last year. The car used by the robbers – a stolen Kia Sportage with false number plates – was captured on CCTV and the defendants were also linked through cell site data. Jurors heard McCorquodale had convictions in 2022 for conspiracy to rob and robbery relating to mobile phone snatching and trying to take an electric bicycle with an accomplice. When police searched his home they found a machete, a Zombie knife and two balaclavas. Both McCorquodale and Johnson denied being present at the time of the murder, saying they left earlier that evening. Within days of the murder, Johnson and his girlfriend had taken a flight to Cancun in Mexico and booked into an all-inclusive hotel resort and spa. They failed to return on their scheduled flight back to Gatwick on July 24. Four days later, police were waiting at Gatwick airport and they boarded a flight that arrived from Madrid to arrest Johnson on suspicion of murder. Johnson had a conviction for possessing a knife in Camden High Street in 2015, and a machete and balaclava were found at his home. The court heard Sofian Alliche had a previous conviction for robbing a man on Regent's Canal towpath in 2019. In a search of the Alliche brothers' home, officers seized two balaclavas, a Louis Vuitton man bag, a large sword and drug paraphernalia. Amin Alliche admitted being the driver but claimed he did not leave the car at the scene of the murder, as did his sibling Sofian. Hipple admitted leaving the car in New Cross but claimed to be unaware of the robbery and had only taken a mobile phone in an opportunistic theft. Jurors heard he had a conviction in 2022 for possessing an offensive weapon in public relating to a police stop in which he was found with a knife in a sheath tucked into his waistband. Detective Chief Inspector Kate Blackburn, Specialist Crime South, said: 'Antonis had been visiting from Greece with friends. Very tragically he never made it home to his family. 'This was a particularly challenging and complex case given the lack of CCTV at the scene and the movement of the vehicle, which had been driven by the defendants continuously throughout the night of July 6 and into the following afternoon. 'I would like to thank in particular Antonis' friends, who had witnessed his brutal murder and returned to the UK to give their evidence. 'I would also like to thank the witnesses who came forward and helped us to understand what had happened to Antonis. 'I am pleased our concerted efforts to find those responsible has enabled us to achieve justice for Antonis' loved ones, family, and friends.'
Telegraph
7 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Labour's Civil Service proposals are unfair and misguided
That the Civil Service is in dire need of a shake-up is accepted, at this point, across much of Westminster. The frustrations are justified. The public sector is, as George Staunton found Imperial China, felt to be staffed by those who feel that 'everything is excellent' and 'proposals for improvement would be superfluous'. This agreement stretches only as far as the sense that something must change, however. The proposals on the table for reform are deeply contested, and potentially harmful. Labour's proposal to limit Civil Service internships to those from ' lower socio-economic backgrounds ' is a retrograde step which would impoverish the pool of talent available to ministers by restricting entry based on family circumstance, and would represent another blow to the idea that parents should work for their children's futures. The Government would be better advised to hark back to the Northcote-Trevelyan report, which attempted to address a Civil Service which attracted the 'unambitious', 'indolent' and 'incapable' who did not fancy 'the competition of their contemporaries', but were attracted by 'the comparative lightness of the work'. The solutions put forward included, among other things, entrance examinations open to all, merit-based promotion, and ensuring that civil servants were fully employed to the full extent of their abilities. Such an embrace of meritocracy would surely be morally and practically preferable to further clumsy attempts at social engineering.
The Sun
7 minutes ago
- The Sun
I forgave my partner for affair with my best pal eight years ago – but I still can't forget it or move on
DEAR DEIDRE: A BLACK lace bra was all the evidence I needed that my wife was having an affair with my best friend. His wife told me what was going on after she found the underwear stuffed down the side of her bed. When she told me the bra size, my blood ran cold as I realised it was the same size my wife wore. This was eight years ago but I still can't forget it or move on. I'm a man of 42 and have been with my partner for 15 years. She's 37. Our relationship was great until I got a job where I worked in the US for several months of the year. When I was in Los Angeles, the time difference made it hard for us to communicate, and my partner told me she felt lonely in the evenings. She started going out with her friends more — at least, that's what she told me. At the time, I trusted her. But a few weeks before I returned home, I got a message from my best friend's wife asking me to call. When we FaceTimed, she was in bits. She said my wife had been spending a lot of time with her husband. My partner hadn't told me about this — which seemed suspicious in itself. Then my friend's wife said she had been changing their bed when she found a lacy black bra tucked under the mattress. Spotting the signs your partner is cheating She said my partner was the only woman who had visited her house and told me the bra size. When I came home, I confronted my partner and my best friend individually. They both said I was paranoid. Soon after, my best friend's marriage broke up. Our friendship has never been the same. I have tried to forget what happened, to forgive my partner and carry on with our life together but it still troubles me to this day. What do you advise I should do? DEIDRE SAYS: The evidence was circumstantial but your gut told you the two people closest to you had cheated. As they both denied it, you chose to try to forgive and forget. Unfortunately, eight years later, it's clear that you haven't been able to do that. Try talking to your partner again. Ask her to be honest so you can put this issue to bed once and for all. First, think about how you will react if she finally admits to an affair, and whether you would want to break up or simply need the truth for closure. Having couples counselling would be wise, so you can deal with this in a safe environment. Contact (020 7380 1975) for an appointment. My support pack, Cheating, Can You Get Over It?, should help. THANK YOU FOR HELPING AS LOAN LEFT ME SUICIDAL DEAR DEIDRE: AFTER I took out a loan that I couldn't afford to pay back, I became scared to open my front door in case debt collectors turned up. When I first saw the loan advertised online, it seemed like the answer to my prayers. But the interest rate was high and when my circumstances changed, I couldn't keep making the monthly repayments. I'm a 53-year-old single woman. I was so stressed, it was making me ill. I couldn't sleep or eat and sometimes I felt suicidal. You told me that no amount of money owed was worth ending my life over and gave me details of the Samaritans ( 116 123). You praised me for asking for help and advised me to see my GP. You suggested I read your support packs, Solving Debt Problems and Family Finances, and recommended I contact the charity Step Change ( for debt solutions. I took your advice and made an appointment with my doctor. She told me not to look at my bank account every day, to help with stress. I also got advice from a debt charity. Six months on, I have finally finished paying my loan. I won't ever take out another one again! Thank you for supporting me through a stressful time. Well done on paying off your loan. It must be a huge relief for you not to owe any more money. I'm glad I could help. DEAR DEIDRE: EVEN though I've been with my husband for 20 years, he still talks about his teenage sweetheart – and I can't compete. They had a child together when they were 18, but my husband had no contact with his son or the boy's mother for almost four decades. In the meantime, we met, married and had two children. I'm 49 and he's 57. However, a few months ago, his son got in touch out of the blue to say his mother had died. Since then, my husband has become obsessed with his dead ex. He plays 'their song' – the track they danced to at a school party – looks back through old photos, and has even told his son his mum was the love of his life. They were, he says, just too young for it to work. He doesn't seem to care what impact this is having on me. It really hurts. It feels like our whole life together has meant nothing to him, that I'm second best. He says I'm being ridiculous and he loves me. But I'm on the brink of leaving because it's all too painful. Why is he acting like this? DEIDRE SAYS: It sounds like your husband is finding it difficult to deal with the death of his first love, and the reappearance of his son. He may be feeling a complicated combination of emotions – grief, regret, guilt, nostalgia for his youth – feelings he has never dealt with, which he is now trying to work through. That's not an excuse for his selfish behaviour towards you, but it might explain it. Be patient with him. It doesn't mean he doesn't love you. Try to be supportive and give him time to deal with this, but be honest about how hard this is for you. Encourage him to seek bereavement counselling. My support pack, Coping With Bereavement, has details of how to go about this. TEENAGE TROUBLES DEAR DEIDRE: I MOVED to Scotland to be with my boyfriend but now I miss home so much I'm having doubts about our relationship. We met in London but he's got a job in Edinburgh. We didn't want to be apart, so I agreed to go with him. He's 21 and I'm 19. I love him but after six months here, I'm so lonely and isolated, away from all my friends and family. We're arguing a lot and I'm scared we'll end up splitting. But it's too far for a long-distance relationship. DEIDRE SAYS: Building a life in a new place is hard. Tell him how you feel. You moved for him, so he needs to make an effort to help you make friends. Check out local groups and meet-ups. My support pack, Feeling Lonely?, should help, too. Also, invite your friends and family to stay and plan regular trips back home. NO DESIRE TO ROMP WITH WIFE DEAR DEIDRE: SEX with my wife is a total flop – even though I have no problem keeping an erection when I'm pleasuring myself. For some reason, I just have no desire to be intimate with her any more. We're both upset about it. Now I'm wondering if I should find another woman online to test out what happens if I try to have sex. I'm 56, my wife is 48, we have been married for 20 years and have three children. Until last year, I had a high sex drive and we made love frequently. But my libido has gradually disappeared to the point that I can't get or maintain an erection when we want to get physically intimate. Even taking Viagra didn't help. But masturbating isn't a problem. Trying sex with another woman would clarify if the issue is with my relationship. But I'd feel guilty. I love my wife and don't want to cheat. How can I resolve this? DEIDRE SAYS: Finding another woman for sex is not the answer. The guilt could well affect your ability to perform – and it's wrong to use a person to diagnose your issue. If you can masturbate to climax, it seems likely your problem is psychological. And the more you worry about your erections disappearing, the more likely this is to happen. My support pack, Solving Erection Problems, has more information on this, and how to get help. You and your wife need to discuss what's happening and find if there is a deeper, perhaps unacknowledged, problem in your relationship. Couples counselling may be worth pursuing. See my support pack, How Counselling Can Help.
