‘You'll be a rich little girl'; Sydney woman sues parents over real estate empire promise, loses in court
A long-running family dispute over a real estate business and home ownership in Sydney's eastern suburbs has been settled in court, with the daughter losing her legal claim. Paula-Marie Penya took her father, Paul Penya, to the NSW Supreme Court, arguing that she was promised by her father and mother, Therese, the family's real estate agency, and their Eastlakes home in return for working unpaid for over 20 years. She told the court she relied on repeated assurances she would end up a "rich little girl."
Also Read: Why do we really get wrinkles? Scientists finally explain it's not just age or sun exposure, it's physicsHowever, in Penya v Penya [2025] NSWSC 805, Justice Kate Williams found no evidence of a 'clear and unequivocal' promise that either asset would be transferred to her during her parents' lifetimes. The court ruled the statements amounted to inheritance hopes, not a binding agreement. Paul Penya sold the business to Century 21 in 2018, and Paula-Marie received $5,000 from the sale. The legal dispute began when Paul later moved to sell the Eastlakes home he co-owns with Therese to fund his retirement.
Paula-Marie, who lives in the house with her partner and children, opposed the sale. She said she couldn't afford to buy him out and argued she had been promised the property. But the court allowed the sale to go ahead under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW).
Justice Williams dismissed Paula-Marie's claims of proprietary estoppel, common intention trust, and joint endeavour. The court noted that although she had worked for years at the family business, she had not shown a concrete agreement that gave her legal rights over the assets.
Also Read: She was smart, popular, and different; so why was Tiffany Salmond let go? The judge also pointed out that Paula-Marie had declined or postponed taking over the business before it was sold, despite her father's requests.Paula-Marie and her partner were able to purchase multiple investment properties over the years, aided by the fact they lived rent-free at the Eastlakes home. The court saw this as significant and inconsistent with claims of financial sacrifice.As reported by news.com.au, Paul Penya revoked his earlier will, which left his estate to Paula-Marie, and instead named his long-term partner, Irene, as beneficiary. In court, he said, 'I made them millionaires; they were useless.'
Also Read: Widespread rainfall to drench Southeast Australia, heaviest in over two years to last until Thursday The court ruled that Paula-Marie and her family must vacate the Eastlakes home at least seven days before the property's sale. Trustees will be appointed to carry out the sale as permitted by law.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
2 hours ago
- Economic Times
Only 20-25% of India's 850 mn internet users shop online, shows untapped potential: McKinsey Report
Synopsis A McKinsey & Company report indicates significant growth for India's e-commerce sector. Currently, only 20-25% of Indian internet users shop online, but this is expected to rise substantially. E-commerce accounts for 7-9% of total retail sales, projected to more than double by 2030, driven by new business models, expansion into new categories, and rising demand from tier-two and tier-three cities. ANI Representative image. India's e-commerce sector is set for significant growth in the coming years, according to a report by McKinsey & report noted that only 20-25 per cent of India's 850 million internet users shop online. This is much lower as compared with mature markets like the United States and China, where over 85 per cent of internet users make purchases report said, "Out of the country's 850 million internet users, only about 20 to 25 per cent shop online".The report also highlighted that India has seen a strong rise in e-commerce activity over the past few country is not just catching up as a fast adopter of online shopping but is also emerging as an innovator in the field. This is especially visible in the rapid growth of quick commerce platforms that deliver goods in a very short time. However, e-commerce still accounts for only 7 to 9 per cent of India's total retail sales as of fiscal year 2023. This share is expected to more than double to between 15 and 17 per cent by 2030, showing the huge potential for business models are changing the shape of the e-commerce industry in India. Quick commerce and social commerce together make up more than 15 per cent of the e-commerce market today. Their share is expected to exceed 25 per cent by 2030.E-commerce companies are also finding new ways to serve consumers. They are expanding into new categories such as instant bookings for domestic services, professional help, and even medical next wave of growth in Indian e-commerce is likely to come from two main factors. One is the increasing entry into new segments like B2B (business-to-business) commerce and building materials. The other is the rising demand from tier-two and tier-three cities are seeing faster income growth than metro and tier-one cities. Monthly incomes in tier-two cities grew by 18 per cent between 2023 and 2024, which is higher than the growth seen in bigger report suggested that e-commerce in India will go beyond simply disrupting traditional retail. It is expected to reshape the entire retail system, including areas like last-mile delivery and logistics.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Earthquake of magnitude 4.0 hits Pakistan
Islamabad [Pakistan], July 28 (ANI): An earthquake of magnitude 4.0 hit Pakistan in the early hours of Monday, as reported by the National Centre for Seismology (NCS). According to the NCS, the earthquake took place at 02:06 AM IST ( Indian Standard Time ) at a depth of 10 kilometres. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Degree PGDM Operations Management Public Policy Cybersecurity MCA Finance Others Product Management Healthcare CXO Management Project Management Data Analytics healthcare Design Thinking Leadership Data Science Technology Data Science Artificial Intelligence MBA Digital Marketing others Skills you'll gain: Data-Driven Decision-Making Strategic Leadership and Transformation Global Business Acumen Comprehensive Business Expertise Duration: 2 Years University of Western Australia UWA Global MBA Starts on Jun 28, 2024 Get Details The location was Latitude 33.46 N and 71.19 E. NCS reported that it was recorded 173 kilometres west of Islamabad. Shallow earthquakes are generally more dangerous than deep earthquakes. This is because the seismic waves from shallow earthquakes have a shorter distance to travel to the surface, resulting in stronger ground shaking and potentially more damage to structures and greater casualties. Live Events Pakistan is one of the most seismically active countries in the world, being crossed by several major faults. As a result, earthquakes in Pakistan often occur and are destructive. Pakistan geologically overlaps both the Eurasian and Indian tectonic plates . Balochistan, the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Gilgit-Baltistan provinces lie on the southern edge of the Eurasian plate on the Iranian Plateau. Sindh, Punjab and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir provinces lie on the northwestern edge of the Indian plate in South Asia. Hence, this region is prone to violent earthquakes as the two tectonic plates collide.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
5 hours ago
- First Post
‘Easy as I settled India-Pak': Trump claims ended Thailand-Cambodia clash using trade pressure
Trump has once again claimed credit for helping end hostilities between India and Pakistan, this time while discussing rising tensions between Thailand and Cambodia. Drawing a comparison, Trump said he used trade pressure to de-escalate both situations read more US President Donald Trump on Sunday once again reiterated his claim of helping broker a ceasefire between India and Pakistan by using trade pressure—this time while drawing a parallel with the ongoing tensions between Thailand and Cambodia. Speaking about Southeast Asia, Trump said the United States maintains strong trade ties with both Thailand and Cambodia. He claimed he personally called the prime ministers of both countries and warned them that no trade deal would move forward unless they de-escalated their conflict. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'We do a lot of trade with Thailand and Cambodia. Yet I'm reading that they're killing each other,' Trump said. 'I say this should be an easy one for me because I settled India and Pakistan. I called the Prime Ministers of each (Thailand and Cambodia) and I said, 'We're not going to make a trade deal unless you settle the war.' By the time I got off the phone, I think they want to settle now.' #WATCH | US President Donald Trump says, "We do a lot of trade with Thailand and Cambodia. Yet I'm reading that they're killing each other... I say this should be an easy one for me because I settled India and Pakistan... I called the Prime Ministers of each (Thailand and… — ANI (@ANI) July 27, 2025 He went on to reference the India-Pakistan standoff, saying 'India and Pakistan were really getting ready to go at it. So getting those things settled—and if I can use trade to do that—then it's my honour.' Trump's constant claims of de-escalating the conflict Trump has made similar claims before, crediting himself for de-escalating the India-Pakistan conflict by instructing his administration to cancel all trade deals with both nations. He believes that pressure forced both sides to back down. 'We did some great work—India and Pakistan. That was close to being nuclear. We handled it. We did a lot,' Trump had told reporters earlier at the White House. 'I don't know if any president has done more.' Earlier, Trump also cited a similar approach in other global flashpoints. 'Serbia and Kosovo were going to go at it. I said, 'You go at it, there's no trade with the United States.' That's what happened with India and Pakistan. I told (Treasury Secretary) Scott (Bessent) and (Commerce Secretary) Howard (Lutnick), 'Cancel all deals with India and Pakistan. They're not trading with us while they're at war.'' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD However, India has consistently rejected Trump's assertions. According to Indian officials, the ceasefire agreement reached on May 10—after four days of intense cross-border drone and missile strikes—was the result of direct military-to-military communication between the Directors General of Military Operations (DGMOs) of both nations. Officials also clarified that the dialogue was initiated at Pakistan's request. In a recent phone conversation with Trump, Prime Minister Narendra Modi reiterated India's long-standing position that all matters with Pakistan are strictly bilateral and that New Delhi does not and will never accept third-party mediation.
