Flipping farm land for cash? ITAT's ruling may close India's oldest black money trick
Live Events
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
Mumbai: The old trick of flipping farm land to white-wash cash is in the crosshairs of the taxman.Buying agricultural land way below the market value in a predominantly cash deal, and subsequently selling the land at the actual value in an official transaction has been used for decades by babus, businessmen, politicians, and cine stars to legitimise undisclosed funds.Now, a recent tax tribunal ruling threatens to throw a spanner in this well-oiled machine. While the views of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) pertain to an otherwise innocuous case of alleged tax evasion and are not linked to any dodgy deals, its observations strike at the heart of this laundering machine that thrives on buy-sell of farm lands. ITAT is a quasi-judicial authority and hears disputes before matters are challenged before the High Court.Consider this: a person with unexplained cash cuts a deal with an agriculturist to purchase land, having a market value of ₹10 crore.Here, the official land value in the sale deed is quoted as ₹2 crore while the balance ₹8 crore is paid in cash. The seller, probably a farmer who pays no tax and is not tracked by the I-T department, has no qualms in accepting cash. Besides, he may have genuine use of the cash for paying labourers, buying seeds, fertiliser etc. A few years later, the buyer of the land sells the land for ₹10 crore (its true value) receiving the entire money as cheque or bank transfer, with the registration documents recording the sale at the fair market value.The two transactions-first buying the land and later selling it-enables the original buyer of the land to convert cash or 'black money' of ₹8 crore (the difference between ₹10 crore and ₹2 crore) into 'white'.How? By virtue of the asset being agricultural land, no tax is paid for purchasing the land at a price much lower than the ready reckoner value-unlike a transaction involving any non-farm, urban land where the buyer must pay tax on the difference between the market price and transaction price. Again, no 'capital gains tax' is paid by the seller when the land is later sold at the full value of ₹10 crore because agricultural land is excluded from the definition of 'capital asset'.While the Ahmedabad bench of ITAT has endorsed the exemption of capital gains tax on sale of farm land, it has questioned the non-payment of tax on the first leg of the transaction (where a ₹10 crore worth asset is bought for ₹2 crore).Under Section 56(2)(x) of the I-T Act, full income tax is levied on the difference between the market value and transaction price of such "immovable property" (among other assets). The ITAT in its May 27 ruling said, "The term 'immovable assets' has not been defined in section 56(2)(x) or in any other section in the I-T Act. This renders the word to be used in general parlance. In general understanding of the term, the word 'immovable asset' means an asset which cannot be removed without destroying or altering it. Therefore, going by the general definition, 'immovable property would, in our view, include any rural agricultural land, in absence of any specific exclusion in section 56(2)(x)."If this view is upheld by the High Court, buying-selling farm land to launder bribes and cash payments would run into a serious hurdle.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Buying farm land to legitimise undisclosed funds? New Tax tribunal ruling a big blow; here's how these deals work
Tax authorities are now scrutinising the often used practice of using agricultural land transactions to conceal unaccounted money. A recent verdict from the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) could potentially disrupt this established practice. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now According to an ET report, though the ITAT's observations stem from a routine tax evasion case unrelated to these questionable transactions, its implications directly affect this property-based money conversion mechanism. ITAT, which functions as a quasi-judicial body, addresses disputes before they reach the High Court. How do these deals work? For instance: an individual with unexplained funds negotiates with a farmer to acquire land valued at ₹10 crore in the market. In this scenario, the land transaction shows an official value of ₹2 crore in documentation, whilst an additional ₹8 crore changes hands unofficially. The seller, typically a farmer exempt from tax monitoring by Income Tax authorities, readily accepts cash payment, which serves practical purposes like wages, agricultural inputs and other farming necessities. Subsequently, when this land is resold at its actual worth of ₹10 crore, the entire sum is processed through official banking channels, with proper documentation at market value. These sequential transactions enable the initial purchaser to legitimise ₹8 crore of undisclosed funds, representing the gap between ₹10 crore and ₹2 crore. According to the report, for years, influential individuals including babus, entrepreneurs, political figures and entertainment personalities have employed this scheme of purchasing agricultural property at understated values through cash payments, later selling these at actual market prices through official channels to convert their undeclared wealth. Tax Loophole The mechanism works because agricultural land enjoys special status. Unlike urban property transactions, where buyers must pay tax on differences between market and transaction values, farm land purchases below ready reckoner rates attract no such levy. Also Read | Furthermore, when the land is sold at ₹10 crore, its full value, no capital gains tax applies as agricultural land falls outside the scope of 'capital asset' classification. Farm land classified as 'Immovable Asset' The Ahmedabad ITAT bench has confirmed the exemption of capital gains tax for farm land sales, whilst raising concerns about untaxed portions of the initial transaction (involving a ₹10 crore asset purchased for ₹2 crore). According to Section 56(2)(x) of the I-T Act, the difference between market value and transaction price of "immovable property" (and other assets) is fully taxable. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now In its May 27 judgement, the ITAT stated, "The term 'immovable assets' has not been defined in section 56(2)(x) or in any other section in the I-T Act. This renders the word to be used in general parlance. In general understanding of the term, the word 'immovable asset' means an asset which cannot be removed without destroying or altering it. Therefore, going by the general definition, 'immovable property would, in our view, include any rural agricultural land, in absence of any specific exclusion in section 56(2)(x). " If the High Court endorses this interpretation, it would create significant obstacles for those attempting to utilise agricultural land transactions as a means of money laundering and undisclosed cash dealings. Also Read | Ashish Karundia, founder of CA firm Ashish Karundia & Co, was quoted as saying: "It is a well-settled principle that the nature of income for the recipient does not necessarily depend on the nature of the source from which it is derived. Likewise, it is also recognized that the characterization of income arising from a transaction need not be the same between the parties involved. Based on this principle and considering that the difference between stamp duty value and actual transaction value is explicitly included as income, such difference can be taxed as income in the buyer's hand, regardless of the land's classification or the tax treatment in the seller's hand. ' 'However, if it can be established that the difference in these values of agricultural land qualifies as income or revenue derived from agricultural land, it can be considered agricultural income. Once the income qualifies as agricultural income, tax cannot be levied since tax on agricultural income falls within the domain of the state legislature. It would, therefore, be very interesting to see how the higher courts interpret the nature of such a differential amount, especially given that agriculture is a state subject,' he said.
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Big shift brews in India's neighbourhood: Pak, China prepare ground for an alternative to SAARC
SAARC falls out of favour Live Events Decoding the proposed new arrangement (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel In a significant diplomatic development with big likely implications for India's immediate neighbourhood, Pakistan and China are reportedly advancing plans to establish a new regional organisation aimed at enhancing cooperation in South Asia , PTI reported on June 30. This initiative comes as a response to the prolonged stagnation of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation ( SAARC ), which has been inactive largely due to tensions between India and Pakistan, the report cited Pakistan's Express Tribune newspaper to report that discussions between Islamabad and Beijing are progressing, with both nations recognising the necessity for a fresh platform to boost regional integration and the new situation develops, the implications for regional politics and economics could be significant. If realised, this new initiative may redefine the landscape of South Asian cooperation, fostering closer ties among member nations while providing an alternative to the now-defunct SAARC framework, the report coming months will be crucial as discussions progress and the vision for this new entity takes shape, it which includes India, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka, has not convened since its last summit in Kathmandu in 2016 summit scheduled in Islamabad was cancelled after India withdrew its participation following the terrorist attack in Uri. This incident led Bangladesh, Bhutan, and Afghanistan to also decline attending, effectively placing SAARC in a state of proposed new organisation aims to fill this void, providing a space for dialogue and collaboration among South Asian recent trilateral meeting involving Pakistan, China, and Bangladesh in Kunming was a pivotal moment in these Bangladesh's interim government has dismissed the notion of a formal alliance, saying that the meeting was not political in nature, sources indicate that the proposed organisation would extend invitations to other South Asian countries previously involved in India is expected to be included, along with Sri Lanka, the Maldives, and Afghanistan. The new organisation is being seen as a potential vehicle for enhancing trade and connectivity across the region, addressing the current gaps left by SAARC.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
NFO Alert: JioBlackRock Money Market Fund opens today, offers low interest rate risk and moderate credit risk
Jio BlackRock Mutual Fund has launched the Jio BlackRock Money Market Fund, and the NFO of the fund is open for subscription until July 2. The investment objective of the scheme is to generate regular income through investment in a portfolio comprising money market instruments with a residual maturity of up to one year. The fund is an open-ended debt scheme investing in money market instruments, with relatively low interest rate risk and moderate credit risk. Also Read | JioBlackRock Liquid Fund NFO to open on June 30. A safe bet for regular income? Best MF to invest Looking for the best mutual funds to invest? Here are our recommendations. View Details » by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like War Thunder - Register now for free and play against over 75 Million real Players War Thunder Play Now Undo The scheme is suitable for investors seeking regular income over the short term and who want to generate income by investing in money market instruments, according to the Scheme Information Document (SID) of the fund. The scheme will be benchmarked against the NIFTY Money Market Index A-I and will be managed by Vikrant Mehta, Arun Ramachandran, and Siddharth Deb. Live Events Also Read | JioBlackRock Mutual Fund announces launch of investment management platform Aladdin The scheme will offer only direct plans and will provide solely a growth option. The minimum application amount for lump sum investment is Rs 500 and any amount thereafter. The minimum amount for switch-in to the scheme is Rs 500, and any amount thereafter. The minimum amount for weekly, monthly, and quarterly Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) is Rs 500 and in multiples of Re 1 thereafter, with a minimum of six installments each. The exit load on this money market fund is nil. Investors may avail themselves of the SIP Top-up facility, which allows them to increase their SIP installments at predefined intervals. This feature enhances investors' flexibility to invest higher amounts during the SIP tenure. Investors can use the Top-up facility to increase their SIP installment amount by a minimum of Rs 50 and in multiples of Rs 50. Alternatively, they can opt to increase the SIP installment amount by 10% and in multiples of 5%. The scheme will allocate 0–100% to money market instruments having a residual maturity of up to one year. The investment strategy aims to generate regular returns through a portfolio of money market instruments, seeking to capture term and credit spreads. The scheme will endeavor to develop a well-diversified portfolio of money market instruments. Every investment opportunity in money market instruments will be assessed for credit risk, interest rate risk, liquidity risk, derivatives risk, and concentration risk, according to the Scheme Information Document (SID) of the fund. The principal invested in the scheme will carry low to moderate risk, as indicated by the scheme's riskometer. Also Read | JioBlackRock Mutual Fund launches website, unveils leadership team and early access initiative According to a release by ICRA , the provisional rating assigned to the fund is [ICRA]A1+mfs. The rating agency further mentioned that as the scheme is launching, the provisional rating is based on the indicative/allocated portfolio of the scheme with the credit score being comfortable at the assigned rating level. The provisional rating for the JioBlackRock Money Market Fund will be finalised upon the launch of the scheme, and analysis of the credit score of the scheme for at least three months, post launch, and its meeting the benchmark score for the assigned rating, the ICRA release said. In addition to the JioBlackRock Money Market Fund, the fund house is also launching an overnight fund and a liquid fund as well. The new fund offer (NFO) of overnight fund and liquid fund are open for subscription now and will close on July 2. ICRA has assigned [ICRA]A1+mfs rating to the JioBlackRock Liquid Fund and the JioBlackRock Overnight Fund as well. According to the Sebi mandate, money market funds make investment in money market instruments having maturity upto one year.
