Chief accused of ‘half-hearted' defence of review body after Malkinson case
Karen Kneller, chief executive of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) which investigates potential miscarriages of justice, insisted she and her colleagues were the right people for the job as she faced questions from MPs on Tuesday.
It comes as chairwoman of the body, Helen Pitcher, eventually resigned from her role in January following Mr Malkinson's case, but claimed she had been scapegoated.
Giving evidence to the Commons' Justice Committee, she appeared alongside the CCRC's casework operations director Amanda Pearce.
Chairman of the committee Andy Slaughter said: 'I'm afraid I found your defence of what is to us a hugely important organisation, I'm sure it's hugely important to you, has been pretty half-hearted, and has been really a reflection that things are going pretty well, apart from one or two difficult cases.
'And where that leaves me, comment or not as you wish, to ask whether you really feel now, given everything that's happened, that you are the right people to lead this organisation forward.'
Ms Kneller said on behalf of herself and Ms Pearce that 'I think we are absolutely the right people to lead this organisation'.
During the hearing, the legal boss urged the committee to judge the CCRC's performance across all its casework, and 'not only those cases which get into the headlines, which is a tiny, tiny minority of our casework'.
The independent body, currently tasked with reviewing the convictions of serial child killer Lucy Letby, was heavily criticised for its handling of Mr Malkinson's case, one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history.
Mr Malkinson served 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit, and was knocked back twice by the CCRC until his legal team carried out crucial DNA testing that was then repeated by the commission and led to his release.
A review found that he could have been released 10 years earlier if the CCRC had obtained new DNA evidence as early as 2009, and thousands of cases are being reviewed in the wake of the bungled handling of the case.
Before Ms Pitcher's resignation, she had apologised to Mr Malkinson in April 2024, nine months after his conviction was quashed by the Court of Appeal in July 2023.
The committee heard from the CCRC chiefs that they did not know when they would be getting an interim chairperson as they are not involved in the process.
On Tuesday, Ms Kneller also personally apologised to Mr Malkinson for the first time during the hearing.
Asked whether she would like to apologise, she said: 'Without doubt, we got that case wrong. Mr Malkinson was failed.
'We made mistakes in that case. We apologised, the organisation apologised.
'I think the decisions made then around when to apologise are probably decisions that would not be made today.
'So absolutely, I extend my apology to Mr Malkinson. Everyone in the organisation deeply regrets what happened on that case.
'I can't begin to think of the impact that this has had on him.
'I mean the double impact of, you know, serving a sentence, suffering miscarriage of justice, and then the way we handled his case.'
At 2.30pm today, we will hold our evidence session on the work of the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
You can watch it on Parliament Live: https://t.co/sR61XRXYxE https://t.co/8gd85f1UdI
— Justice Committee (@CommonsJustice) April 29, 2025
Following the evidence, Mr Slaughter also told the CCRC chief he was 'quite shocked' by the remote working structure of the organisation.
Ms Kneller had told the committee the CCRC is no longer an office-based organisation which has boosted its ability to recruit for specialist roles from across the UK.
Instead she spends one or two days in the Birmingham-based office every two months.
But Mr Slaughter said: 'But given what's happened with your previous chair, the Malkinson case and other matters that have come to light, if I were the chief executive here, I would be in every day when there's issues, I'd be asking my staff to be there, I'd be working with those staff.
'I'd be trying to rebuild the organisation so that the commissioners and the board had a much more hands on role in that way.
'And that doesn't seem to have happened at all.'
But Ms Kneller defended the move, saying without remote working the CCRC would not be doing the amount of casework needed to make referrals because the vacancies would not have been filled.
Ms Pearce added: 'There is no magic to working in the office. Our staff are connected. They can speak to each other at any time.
'We discovered that it is perfectly possible to do a good job working remotely. That has allowed us to attract talent from across the UK.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
Inside Ghislaine Maxwell's New Texas Minimum-Security Prison
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Ghislaine Maxwell, the 62-year-old British socialite convicted of trafficking underage girls for Jeffrey Epstein, was moved to Federal Prison Camp Bryan, a minimum-security facility in Texas, earlier this week. Newsweek contacted Maxwell's attorney for comment via email on Saturday outside of regular office hours. Why It Matters President Donald Trump has been under intense pressure over the Epstein case since July 6 when the Department of Justice and FBI released a joint statement asserting he had "no incriminating 'client list'" and died by suicide. Conspiracy theorists, including a section of Trump's Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement, have long maintained that Epstein was murdered to cover up the involvement of prominent figures in his abuse. The Wall Street Journal later reported Trump had been told his name appeared "multiple times" in the so-called Epstein files by Attorney General Pam Bondi, which the White House dismissed as "fake news." Trump also said he would be "allowed" to pardon Maxwell, though he added that "it's something I have not through about" as the issue continues to cause a rift between the president and some of his supporters. What To Know In 2022, Maxwell was sentenced to 20 years in prison after being found guilty of child sex trafficking, though she continues to maintain her innocence. Prosecutors said the offenses were carried out in cooperation with Epstein, the New York financier and convicted sex offender who committed suicide in a New York federal jail in 2019. Maxwell initially served her sentence at the Federal Correctional Institution in Florida, a low-security prison, but, this week, the Bureau of Prisons told Newsweek that she has been transferred to Bryan. This was confirmed by David Oscar Markus, Maxwell's attorney, though he declined to comment further. In total, 635 inmates are held at Federal Prison Camp Bryan, the vast majority of which are women convicted of nonviolent offenses, according to the facility's official website. Other detainees include Elizabeth Holmes, the billionaire founder of Theranos, who was convicted of fraud; and former Real Housewives of Salt Lake City star Jen Shah. Overall, the site covers 37 acres, with inmates housed in dormitories. A prison handbook for the Bryan prison, seen by the BBC, indicates Maxwell will be required to wear khaki-colored shirts and pants and get up at 6 a.m. each day. File photo: Signage is displayed near the entrance to Federal Prison Camp Bryan on August 1, 2025 in Bryan, Texas. File photo: Signage is displayed near the entrance to Federal Prison Camp Bryan on August 1, 2025 in Bryan, Texas. Brandon Bell/GETTY Prisoners are primarily housed in two person cells in dormitory-style facilities, according to Pink Lady Prison Consultants, an advocacy group led by former prisoners. All prisoners are expected to work, earning between 12 cents and $1.15 per hour. A range of educational programs are also available, including classes on business skills and foreign languages. The handbook says inmates can also play sports, attend religious services and access televisions. Visitors are allowed during the weekend and holidays, though with limited physical contact. Prisoners can be sanctioned if they break a number of rules, including not keeping their cells clean; leaving an area during one of the five-a-day roll calls; and sleeping past the designated wake-up time. For each meal, prisoners are allotted one hour, with the menu compiled by the Federal Bureau of Prisons, including macaroni, tacos, hotdogs and hamburgers. British newspaper The Daily Telegraph reported that facilities available at the Bryan prison include a gym, yoga classes and a 'puppy program,' which involves prisoners training service dogs in collaboration with Canine Companions. What People Are Saying In a statement released on Friday the Bureau of Prisons said: "We can confirm Ghislaine Maxwell is in the custody of the Federal Bureau of Prisons at the Federal Prison Camp (FPC) Bryan in Bryan, Texas." The family of Virginia Giuffre, one of Epstein's victims who died by suicide earlier this year, expressed their "horror and disgust" at the move, which they said was made "without any notification to Maxwell's victims." The family added: "This is the justice system failing victims right before our eyes. The American public should be outraged by the special treatment afforded to a pedophile and a criminally charged child sex offender." Speaking to The Daily Telegraph Julie Howell, a Bryan prisoner, said the facility is "nothing like you see on TV or in the movies because it's a camp, which only houses nonviolent offenders." Maxwell's move came after she was interviewed by Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche on July 25 about Epstein's activities and who else was involved. What Happens Next Trump is likely to continue facing pressure from some of his supporters to release more information about the Epstein case. Maxwell could be offered a pardon or reduced sentence in exchange for giving more details about Epstein's associates, but such a move would almost certainly be highly controversial.
San Francisco Chronicle
3 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Rival anti-migrant and anti-racism protests face off outside a hotel housing migrants in London
LONDON (AP) — Anti-immigrant and anti-racism demonstrators faced off in London on Saturday in the latest in a series of protests outside hotels housing asylum-seekers. Several hundred protesters waving Union Jacks gathered outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in central London, calling for it to be closed as housing for migrants. Chants including 'Scum' and 'Britain is full' were directed at the hotel. Police separated the demonstrators from a larger group of counter-protesters chanting 'refugees are welcome here,' as people inside the hotel watched from windows. Protests against migrants have taken place in recent weeks in Epping, a town on the outskirts of London where an asylum-seeker was accused of sexual assault, and in a smattering of other towns in England. Protesters say they are concerned about the safety risk posed by the migrants, many of them young men who have recently arrived in Britain in dinghies across the English Channel. The demonstrations have drawn local people, but have also been attended, and in some cases organized, by far-right groups. The protests come a year after several days of anti-immigrant rioting across England and Northern Ireland. Crowds in more than two dozen towns attacked hotels housing migrants, as well as mosques, police stations and a library. Some rioters targeted non-white people and threw bricks and fireworks at police. The summer 2024 violence was sparked when three girls were stabbed to death at a summer dance class in the town of Southport, and online misinformation identified the attacker as a recently arrived migrant. In fact, killer Axel Rudakubana was a British-born 17-year-old. Experts and community groups warn that the mix of anger, fear, misinformation and political agitating that fueled that violence could erupt again, though protests this summer have been small and largely peaceful.
3 hours ago
Rival anti-migrant and anti-racism protests face off outside a hotel housing migrants in London
LONDON -- Anti-immigrant and anti-racism demonstrators faced off in London on Saturday in the latest in a series of protests outside hotels housing asylum-seekers. Several hundred protesters waving Union Jacks gathered outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in central London, calling for it to be closed as housing for migrants. Chants including 'Scum' and 'Britain is full' were directed at the hotel. Police separated the demonstrators from a larger group of counter-protesters chanting 'refugees are welcome here,' as people inside the hotel watched from windows. Protests against migrants have taken place in recent weeks in Epping, a town on the outskirts of London where an asylum-seeker was accused of sexual assault, and in a smattering of other towns in England. Protesters say they are concerned about the safety risk posed by the migrants, many of them young men who have recently arrived in Britain in dinghies across the English Channel. The demonstrations have drawn local people, but have also been attended, and in some cases organized, by far-right groups. The protests come a year after several days of anti-immigrant rioting across England and Northern Ireland. Crowds in more than two dozen towns attacked hotels housing migrants, as well as mosques, police stations and a library. Some rioters targeted non-white people and threw bricks and fireworks at police. The summer 2024 violence was sparked when three girls were stabbed to death at a summer dance class in the town of Southport, and online misinformation identified the attacker as a recently arrived migrant. In fact, killer Axel Rudakubana was a British-born 17-year-old. Experts and community groups warn that the mix of anger, fear, misinformation and political agitating that fueled that violence could erupt again, though protests this summer have been small and largely peaceful.
