Wimbledon call is wrong because the electronic system wasn't on during a Centre Court match
And, because the replay review procedure that used to be in place also has been scrapped, the chair umpire decided to have a do-over on the point at 4-all in the first set — much to the dismay of Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova, the player who would have won the game if the proper call had been made originally.
Pavlyuchenkova wound up getting broken there to trail Sonay Kartal, but she eventually did manage to come back to win the match 7-6 (3), 6-4 and reach the quarterfinals at the All England Club for the first time since 2016.
'You took the game away from me,' 2021 French Open runner-up Pavlyuchenkova told chair umpire Nico Helwerth at the changeover after the game ended.
She was serving and had a game point when Kartal hit a backhand that landed beyond the opposite baseline — clearly out, TV replays showed. But there was no sound of one of the recorded voices being used for the first time at Wimbledon to reflect when the technology being used in place of human officials determines that a ball landed out.
Kartal said she couldn't see where her shot went.
'That situation is a rarity. I don't think it's really ever happened — if it has. It's tough. What can you do? The umpire's trying his best in that situation, and he handled it fine,' Kartal said. 'I think the system just malfunctioned a little bit, and the fairest way was what he did: replay the point.'
Helwerth delayed play while he made a phone call from his stand. Eventually, play resumed, Pavlyuchenkova missed a forehand on the replay, then lost the game a few points later.
The explanation offered by an All England Club spokesman: 'Due to operator error, the system was deactivated on the point in question. The chair umpire followed the established process.'
The French Open is now the only Grand Slam tournament that still uses line judges instead of electronic calls.
From 2007 through last year, players were allowed to challenge in-or-out calls at Wimbledon; a video review was employed to decide whether a line judge's — or chair umpire's — ruling was correct. That challenge system was removed for the current tournament, but there immediately were demands on social media from some tennis fans or observers to bring that back to aid chair umpires.
Taylor Fritz, who reached the quarterfinals with a win at a different court Sunday, didn't see what happened. But when it was explained by a reporter, his biggest question was why the chair umpire didn't just make the call himself if it was so clear what actually happened on Kartal's shot.
'The chair umpire has to make the call,' 2024 U.S. Open finalist Fritz said. 'Why is he there if he's not going to call the ball?'
___
More AP tennis: https://apnews.com/hub/tennis
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
International boat race held in Pembrokeshire celebrates 10th anniversary
An international water sports event held in Pembrokeshire celebrated its 10th anniversary this summer with top class racing in sometimes tricky conditions. Fishguard Bay Ocean Race (FBOR) began in 2016 as the brainchild of local resident Benjamin Edom, the race has evolved into the Welsh Surfski National Championships and a GB team selection race for events such as this year's World Championships, South Africa. Advertisement 'After spending 10 years in Australia where surfski is a major sport with hundreds of competitors, I wanted to highlight Fishguard Bay's ideal surfski environment and invited some top GB paddlers to give it a go.' says Ben. (Image: Julia Moffett) 'The ski paddlers were captivated by our coastal scenery and the clean, deep ocean at our doorstep –and they came back the next year. Many paddlers now call it their favourite race of the season' The ocean race kept going through the covid years and the event is now the only regatta in the UK spread over an entire weekend. (Image: Julia Moffett) Saturday's race is exclusively for Elite paddlers seeking selection for the GB team on a challenging 17 km course of open ocean from Goodwick, to Newport Sands. Advertisement Sunday's race is open to known competent intermediate and advanced paddlers capable of safely finishing a shorter, more accessible, course from Goodwick to Newport Sands. (Image: Julia Moffett) Also included is the mixed double ski class which enables elites from Saturday to race a second time, again for selection, but in a more fun and relaxed event. New at Goodwick this year, FBOR hosted Fishguard's first AquaPaddle, a water sport equivalent of a park run, where there is no winner and every level of paddler is welcome. Saturday dawned almost still, and the early mist soon turned to fog, blotting out the view of Dinas head from Goodwick Beach. Advertisement (Image: Julia Moffett) However, the race went ahead, with the Safety Officer monitoring everyone via their GPS trackers the restricted visibility was overcome and there was some first-class racing. The Dolphin Wave for first boat across the line went to Jordan Roberts, First Lady to Brynde Kreft for the second year. The Big Dragon Welsh National Ski Championship trophy for fastest Welsh paddler was lifted high by Mat Rowlands of Rhoose for the fourth time, and the Dragon Girl for Welsh female champion was claimed by Liv Geddes of Margam for the fourth time. Trophies were handed out at a splendid ceremony and dinner at Tregroes Pantry. (Image: Julia Moffett) The forecast Sunday was not at all friendly with winds over 20 knots expected. Advertisement The race safety officers assessed the conditions and decided that it was safe to go ahead. In fact, the winds gave prime conditions for a magnificent race Mat Rowlands smashed the course record down to 52 mins 51 secs, with first double ski of Toby Peyton-Jones and Brynde Kreft finishing in 54:36 over a slightly longer course. 'Everyone had a magnificent and really enjoyable paddle with no safety concerns at any stage, either for competitors or the very professional support fleet of local volunteers,' said Ben. The class winners were: Single Open Mat Rowlands Double open: Toby Peyton-Jones and Brynde Kreft Single Masters (over 35): Simon Philpot Single Veterans (over 55): Paul Kingman. Full results can be seen at linked above.
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Djokovic wary despite Wimbledon form, dominant Sinner faces Dimitrov
Novak Djokovic and world number one Jannik Sinner face their stiffest tests of the tournament on Monday as they aim to take another step towards a blockbuster semi-final face-off at Wimbledon. Djokovic, who has a record 25th Gland Slam singles title in his sights, meets Australia's Alex de Minaur while Sinner faces the talented Grigor Dimitrov. Advertisement Five-time Grand Slam winner Iga Swiatek is the main attraction in a wide-open side of the women's draw as she takes on Clara Tauson. 'Complete' De Minaur concerns Djokovic Djokovic was in supreme form as he demolished compatriot Miomir Kecmanovic 6-3, 6-0, 6-4 to the delight of his seven-year-old daughter Tara, who enjoyed a post-match celebratory dance with her dad. But the seven-time champion is wary of the threat that lies ahead of him in the second week, even before potential meetings with Sinner and Carlos Alcaraz, who has beaten Djokovic in each of the past two finals. De Minaur was forced to pull out of a quarter-final meeting at Wimbledon with the Serb last year due to injury but gets another shot at glory against one of the sport's all-time greats. Advertisement A two-time winner of grass court titles, the world number 11 has dropped just one set on his way to the last 16. "He's playing the tennis of his life. He's definitely knocking on the door of the final stages of Grand Slams," said Djokovic. "You're not super excited to play Alex de Minaur on grass, that's for sure, because he's so quick and he's a complete player." Dimitrov not stressed by dominant Sinner Jannik Sinner does not have the Wimbledon track record of Djokovic or Alcaraz, but the Italian has been the most dominant player in the men's draw in the opening week. Advertisement The US Open and Australian Open champion has matched the men's Open Era record at Wimbledon for fewest games lost -- 17 -- in reaching the fourth round, set by Jan Kodes back in 1972. Sinner is also yet to lose his serve this year at the All England Club, not that his next opponent appears daunted by that prospect. "We're in the second week of Wimbledon. Let's have fun," said 34-year-old Dimitrov, who knows his days on the show courts at Grand Slams are numbered. The Bulgarian appeared destined to be a future Wimbledon champion when he made the semi-finals in 2014, but has never progressed beyond the fourth round since. Advertisement 'Smooth' Swiatek finds feet on grass A rare defeat at the French Open has helped Swiatek finally feel at home on the grass as the former world number one eyes just a second Wimbledon quarter-final on Monday. Aryna Sabalenka beat Swiatek in the semi-finals at Roland Garros after the Polish player won four titles there in five years, but a slightly earlier exit gave her more time to adjust to the grass. Swiatek reached her first grass-court final in Bad Homburg last week, after which she said there is "some hope" for her on the surface. "This year on grass I had some moments where I just felt comfortable and I didn't have to think much. It was just pretty smooth." A flurry of early exits for all of the top six seeds other than Sabalenka also means Swiatek could make the final without having to play another top-10 player. kca/jw
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
PHOTO COLLECTION: Best of Wimbledon Tennis Fourth Round
Aryna Sabalenka of Belarus uses an ice pack to keep cool during a change of ends break as she plays Belgium's Elise Mertens during a fourth round women's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Sunday, July 6, 2025. (AP Photo/Alastair Grant) (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
