The Fast Retailing paradox: while Uniqlo grows, the group's French labels are wiped out
The letter, signed by Managing Director Yoshihiro Kunii, outlined the company's two-pronged approach: 'The procedure is expected to, on the one hand, speed up the overhaul of [the company's] business model, in order to continue to adapt its brands to the new market situation and, on the other, rationalise its store fleet by reducing the number of addresses and favouring larger, hybrid and combined stores, as well as introducing corners by both brands within Uniqlo stores.' No concrete measures have yet been taken, but the letter indicated that the rationalisation will involve some 30 stores of the 100 currently open.
It would be the fourth downsizing operation in seven years for Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princesse tam tam, whose assortment has also been streamlined to align with Uniqlo's, as lamented by industry specialist Frédéric Biousse in an exclusive interview to FashionNetwork.com. Biousse was the president of Comptoir des Cotonniers when the Fast Retailing group acquired the chain 18 years ago. 'It would be a real shame to see more closures. What would be the point? Incorporating both brands within Uniqlo stripped them of their aspirational value. Lowering prices completely misses the point,' said Biousse, who pointed the finger at the Japanese management's failure to understand the brand culture of Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princesse tam tam.
In its letter, the group promised 'a socially responsible reorganisation plan,' but this new blow for the two chains is a challenge for employees, the unions and fashion industry observers. Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princesse tam tam's difficulties are undeniable, but the strategic and financial approach adopted by their owner Fast Retailing since 2007 has sparked much debate. Notably because the Japanese giant is enjoying extremely good financial health.
Indeed, Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princess tam tam's trajectory is the reverse of Uniqlo's. In 2023, the French chains were restructured, and redundancy plans introduced at both (nearly 180 jobs were cut), following similar operations carried out in 2018 and 2021. Two years ago, fashion industry experts expressed their reservations to FashionNetwork.com. And questions are again being asked about the running of both chains, as 'unwise strategic decisions' were taken in Japan, and 'French executives were replaced by Japanese staff' unfamiliar with the French market. Creating a gap between the changing expectations of local consumers and the foreign masterminds' vision.
Biousse is not alone in thinking that the two brands' creativity has been somewhat curtailed over the years by the effort of rationalising their style as demanded by Fast Retailing, mimicking the pared-down designs that led to Uniqlo's success. When, for example, imagination, attractive details and patterns have historically been Princess tam tam's distinguishing traits.
Nevertheless, Fast Retailing has poured money into the two chains' transformation. Fast Retailing France, the company that operates the chains, has regularly been the recipient of loans from its parent company, to enable Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princess tam tam to stay afloat despite significant losses. In fiscal 2023-24, closed on August 31, Fast Retailing France received a loan of €43.3 million from its parent company, according to documents officially filed. Commercial strategy-wise, last year the chains applied a generalised price reduction of the order of 30% to try to attract new customers.
But Fast Retailing has now decided to no longer support the chains, which have filed for suspension of payments.
A source close to the matter has said that the suspension of payments 'is entirely fictitious, since [Fast Retailing France] is not indebted with banks or other investors but only with [Fast Retailing Group], which is currently generating huge profits.'
In H1 of fiscal 2024-25, profit for the Japanese group as a whole rose 19.2% and revenue increased by 10.7%, driven by Uniqlo's performance.
However, what Fast Retailing is doing isn't illegal. A union representative active in the retail sector has zeroed in on the behaviour of large groups, calling it abusive. 'We're trying to ensure that job protection plans introduced by major corporations take into account the groups' entire corporate structure. [Large groups] often isolate the companies they want to restructure, so that these can be liquidated without having to redeploy workers or give the latter proper financial support,' said the representative. She cited the job protection plan introduced at French restaurant chain Flunch in 2024, which was soon modified since its provisions were rather feeble, given the financial power of the chain's owner, the Mulliez family.
Fast Retailing Group has not yet made an official statement about the receivership proceedings and its further plans. According to documents seen by FashionNetwork.com, it seems the group wants to continue to operate Comptoir des Cotonniers and Princess tam tam, deploying a turnaround plan focused on larger joint stores for the two brands, and their greater presence within Uniqlo stores.
With some 60 stores left after a rationalisation effort that, according to various sources, will be 'quick, effective and as cheap as possible,' what will remain of the brand identity of these two former French retail gems?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
4 hours ago
- LeMonde
Why Japan is accepting a 15% tax rate with the US
After Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam, US President Donald Trump announced on Tuesday, July 22, on his Truth Social platform that he had reached a "massive [deal]" with Japan, which would be subject to a 15% customs tax – lower than the 25% rate he had initially floated. Tariffs will remain, however, at 50% for steel and aluminum. Trump said he had secured a commitment from Tokyo to invest $550 billion in the US, notably in a natural gas site in Alaska, which he claimed would "[create hundreds of thousands of jobs]." Trump also pointed to increased access to the Japanese market for US cars, rice and other agricultural goods. "We believe it is a major achievement to have obtained the largest reduction [in tariffs] among countries with a trade surplus with the United States," responded Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, in a measured statement. Asia's second-largest economy is a diplomatic ally of the US and a bulwark against Chinese dominance in the region. Japan managed to negotiate a 15% US tariff on car exports, compared to the 25% rate applied to the rest of the world. The sector is strategic for the archipelago, accounting for about 30% of its exports to the US and 8% of all jobs in the country. The stock prices of automakers Toyota and Honda closed up 14.3% and 11.1% respectively at the Tokyo Stock Exchange on July 23.
Fashion Network
5 hours ago
- Fashion Network
Luxury's split between winners and losers is only getting wider
One striking example of the sector's divide is LVMH versus French peer Hermes International SCA. Sales at LVMH's key Fashion & Leather Goods division are expected to have dropped 7.8% in the second quarter, according to analyst estimates. The company reports after the bell on Thursday. Hermes, which has been an example of how companies can thrive on selling the highest-end items, is expected to report revenue growth of 12% at its leather goods division. Its results are due on July 30. In the case of the Louis Vuitton and Tiffany & Co. owner, the stock has lost roughly half of its value over the past two years, losing its crown of Europe's biggest stock, with investors increasingly worried about an unprecedented demand slump in China. Hermes shares, on the other hand, are weathering the broader industry pullback. After a 160% jump since the end of 2020, the stock is little changed this year versus a 7% drop in Goldman Sachs Group Inc.'s basket of luxury shares. In the current economic context, pricing power is critical, said Helen Jewell, Europe, Middle East and Africa chief investment officer at BlackRock Fundamental Equities. 'The challenge for investors has been some of the names that we thought had greater brand strength, and it turned out they actually didn't,' she said, adding that there could be some buying opportunities after the selloff in the sector 'but you do need to be selective.' For the sector as a whole, the difference is stark between now and the 2021 to 2023 boom times, when investors were rushing to snap up any European luxury shares as they reaped the profits from shoppers on a post-pandemic spending spree. But with China's sluggish economy putting a dent into demand for pricey handbags and watches, investors are buying shares in the brands that can captivate consumers and selling the ones that can't. Among this year's winners, shares in Burberry have surged more than 30%. The UK fashion brand is gaining traction with its turnaround plan and winning new customers through its outwear push. To some investors, luxury valuations are still too high overall even after this year's plunge in a number of stocks. The industry has an average forward price-earnings ratio of 27, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. That's a near 85% premium to the broader market and above the long-term premium from the past 10 years. 'This is a sector that is fully exposed to tariffs and fully exposed to the weaker dollar,' said Roland Kaloyan, head of European equity strategy at Societe Generale SA. 'It's going to be quite difficult, so I stick to my underweight.'
Fashion Network
5 hours ago
- Fashion Network
Luxury's split between winners and losers is only getting wider
For Europe's luxury stocks, this earnings season will hammer home the widening gulf between the winners and the losers. The industry got off to a promising start with robust earnings from British trench coat maker Burberry Group Plc that sent its stock up as much as 9% and better-than-expected sales at Cartier owner Richemont. But upcoming reports from LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE, Kering SA and Salvatore Ferragamo SpA look less promising. If sales at these companies undershoot already weak forecasts, the shares may extend this year's drop that has wiped out market value of as much as 175 billion euros (205 billion dollars). While the outlook for luxury shares is crucial for Europe's stalled equity market rally given the weight of these companies, investors have to be more selective about the stocks they pick. 'It's not going to be one-tide-lifts-all-boats for the sector,' said Stefan-Guenter Bauknecht, a senior portfolio manager at DWS. 'It really depends on the category and how the brand is perceived in the category. And the VIP certainly helps.' One striking example of the sector's divide is LVMH versus French peer Hermes International SCA. Sales at LVMH's key Fashion & Leather Goods division are expected to have dropped 7.8% in the second quarter, according to analyst estimates. The company reports after the bell on Thursday. Hermes, which has been an example of how companies can thrive on selling the highest-end items, is expected to report revenue growth of 12% at its leather goods division. Its results are due on July 30. In the case of the Louis Vuitton and Tiffany & Co. owner, the stock has lost roughly half of its value over the past two years, losing its crown of Europe's biggest stock, with investors increasingly worried about an unprecedented demand slump in China. Hermes shares, on the other hand, are weathering the broader industry pullback. After a 160% jump since the end of 2020, the stock is little changed this year versus a 7% drop in Goldman Sachs Group Inc.'s basket of luxury shares. In the current economic context, pricing power is critical, said Helen Jewell, Europe, Middle East and Africa chief investment officer at BlackRock Fundamental Equities. 'The challenge for investors has been some of the names that we thought had greater brand strength, and it turned out they actually didn't,' she said, adding that there could be some buying opportunities after the selloff in the sector 'but you do need to be selective.' For the sector as a whole, the difference is stark between now and the 2021 to 2023 boom times, when investors were rushing to snap up any European luxury shares as they reaped the profits from shoppers on a post-pandemic spending spree. But with China's sluggish economy putting a dent into demand for pricey handbags and watches, investors are buying shares in the brands that can captivate consumers and selling the ones that can't. Among this year's winners, shares in Burberry have surged more than 30%. The UK fashion brand is gaining traction with its turnaround plan and winning new customers through its outwear push. To some investors, luxury valuations are still too high overall even after this year's plunge in a number of stocks. The industry has an average forward price-earnings ratio of 27, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. That's a near 85% premium to the broader market and above the long-term premium from the past 10 years. 'This is a sector that is fully exposed to tariffs and fully exposed to the weaker dollar,' said Roland Kaloyan, head of European equity strategy at Societe Generale SA. 'It's going to be quite difficult, so I stick to my underweight.'
