Sean 'Diddy' Combs gets standing ovation from inmates after court victory, his lawyer says
'They all said: 'We never get to see anyone who beats the government,'' attorney Marc Agnifilo said in a weekend interview days after a jury acquitted Combs of sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy charges.
Combs, 55, remains jailed after his Wednesday conviction on prostitution-related charges and could still face several years in prison at an upcoming sentencing after being credited for 10 months already served.
After federal agents raided his homes in Los Angeles and Miami in March 2024, the lawyer said he told Combs to expect arrest on sex trafficking charges.
'I said: 'Maybe it's your fate in life to be the guy who wins,'' he recalled during a telephone interview briefly interrupted by a jailhouse call from Combs. 'They need to see that someone can win. I think he took that to heart.'
Blunt trial strategy works
The verdict came after a veteran team of eight defense lawyers led by Agnifilo executed a trial strategy that resonated with jurors. Combs passed lawyers notes during effective cross examinations of nearly three dozen witnesses over two months, including Combs' ex-employees.
The lawyers told jurors Combs was a jealous domestic abuser with a drug problem who participated in the swinger lifestyle through threesomes involving Combs, his girlfriends and another man.
'You may think to yourself, wow, he is a really bad boyfriend,' Combs' lawyer Teny Geragos told jurors in her May opening statement. But that, she said, 'is simply not sex trafficking.'
Agnifilo said the blunt talk was a 'no brainer."
'The violence was so clear and up front and we knew the government was going to try to confuse the jury into thinking it was part of a sex trafficking effort. So we had to tell the jury what it was so they wouldn't think it was something it wasn't,' he said.
Combs and his lawyers seemed deflated Tuesday when jurors said they were deadlocked on the racketeering count but reached a verdict on sex trafficking and lesser prostitution-related charges. A judge ordered them back to deliberate Wednesday.
'No one knows what to think,' Agnifilo said. Then he slept on it.
Morning surprise awakes lawyer
'I wake up at three in the morning and I text Teny and say: 'We have to get a bail application together," he recalled. 'It's going to be a good verdict for us but I think he went down on the prostitution counts so let's try to get him out.'
He said he 'kind of whipped everybody into feeling better' after concluding jurors would have convicted him of racketeering if they had convicted him of sex trafficking because trafficking was an alleged component of racketeering.
Agnifilo met with Combs before court and Combs entered the courtroom rejuvenated. Smiling, the onetime Catholic schoolboy prayed with family. In less than an hour, the jury matched Agnifilo's prediction.
The seemingly chastened Combs mouthed 'thank you' to jurors and smiled as family and supporters applauded. After he was escorted from the room, spectators cheered the defense team, a few chanting: 'Dream Team! Dream Team!' Several lawyers, including Geragos, cried.
'This was a major victory for the defense and a major loss for the prosecution,' said Mitchell Epner, a lawyer who worked with Agnifilo as a federal prosecutor in New Jersey over two decades ago. He credited 'a dream team of defense lawyers' against prosecutors who almost always win.
Agnifilo showcased what would become his trial strategy — belittling the charges and mocking the investigation that led to them — last September in arguing unsuccessfully for bail. The case against Combs was what happens when the 'federal government comes into our bedrooms,' he said.
Lawyers gently questioned most witnesses
During an eight-week trial, Combs' lawyers picked apart the prosecution case with mostly gentle but firm cross-examinations. Combs never testified and his lawyers called no witnesses.
Sarah Krissoff, a federal prosecutor in Manhattan from 2008 to 2021, said Combs' defense team 'had a narrative from the beginning and they did all of it without putting on any witnesses. That's masterful.'
Ironically, Agnifilo expanded the use of racketeering laws as a federal prosecutor on an organized crime task force in New Jersey two decades ago, using them often to indict street gangs in violence-torn cities.
'I knew the weak points in the statute,' he said. 'The statute is very mechanical. If you know how the car works, you know where the fail points are.'
He said prosecutors had 'dozens of fail points.'
'They didn't have a conspiracy, they just didn't,' he said. 'They basically had Combs' personal life and tried to build racketeering around personal assistants.'
Some personal assistants, even after viewing videos of Combs beating his longtime girlfriend, Casandra 'Cassie' Ventura, had glowing things to say about Combs on cross examination.
Once freed, Combs likely to re-enter domestic abusers program
For Combs, Agnifilo sees a long road ahead once he is freed as he works on personal demons, likely re-entering a program for domestic batterers that he had just started before his arrest.
'He's doing OK,' said Agnifilo, who speaks with him four or five times daily.
He said Combs genuinely desires improvement and 'realizes he has flaws like everyone else that he never worked on.'
'He burns hot in all matters. I think what he has come to see is that he has these flaws and there's no amount of fame and no amount of fortune' that can erase them," he said. 'You can't cover them up."
For Agnifilo, a final surprise awaited him after Combs' bail was rejected when a man collapsed into violent seizures at the elevators outside the courtroom.
'I'm like: 'What the hell?'' recalled the lawyer schooled in treating seizures.
Agnifilo straddled him, pulling him onto his side and using a foot to prevent him from rolling backward while a law partner, Jacob Kaplan, put a backpack under the man's head and Agnifilo's daughter took his pulse.
'We made sure he didn't choke on vomit. It was crazy. I was worried about him,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
4 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Nearly half of America's murderers get away with it
Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Louisville is representative of a national issue. In the United States, people often get away with murder. The clearance rate -- the share of cases that result in an arrest or are otherwise solved -- was 58% in 2023, the latest year for which FBI data is available. And that figure is inflated because it includes murders from previous years that police solved in 2023. Advertisement In other words, a murderer's chance of getting caught within a year essentially comes down to a coin flip. For other crimes, clearance rates are even lower. Only 8% of car thefts result in an arrest. Advertisement Compared with its peers, America overall does an unusually poor job of solving killings. The murder clearance rates of other rich nations, including Australia, Britain and Germany, hover in the 70s, 80s and even 90s. Several issues, including a lack of resources, the sheer volume of cases and a distrust of the police, have converged to make the jobs of American detectives much more difficult. 'It's a serious problem,' said Philip Cook, a criminal justice researcher at Duke University. The lack of legal accountability emboldens criminals, leading to more crime and violence. 'It's a vicious cycle,' Brian Forst, a criminologist at American University, told me. 'When the bad guys see that the police are not there to deter crime and catch criminals, they remain on the streets to do more bad stuff. And the rest of the community is less deterred from crime. They think, 'Why not? I'm not going to get caught.'' Building Deterrence Many things lead someone to commit a murder, but one factor is whether murderers are caught after the act. First, a locked-up killer can't kill more people, which is what criminologists call an incapacitation effect. Second, the act of catching a murderer deters would-be killers. In the 18th century, Italian criminologist Cesare Beccaria devised the deterrence theory that criminal justice systems worldwide have depended on since. He cited three primary principles to deterrence: the severity of a punishment, the speed at which someone is captured and the certainty he or she will be found. American policy often focuses on severity. In recent decades, lawmakers responded to spikes in crime by increasing the length of prison sentences. They paid less attention to the certainty and swiftness of punishment. Yet those two other factors may matter more to deterrence, some experts say. If people don't believe the police will catch them -- and quickly -- then the length of their punishment won't really matter. Empty threats won't deter them. Advertisement 'The certainty of being caught is a vastly more powerful deterrent than the punishment,' concluded the National Institute of Justice in its review of the evidence. The experience of communities with unchecked violence, which are often poor and Black, is instructive. The reality of daily robberies, shootings and killings forces people to take a harder view of the world to survive, as journalist Jill Leovy documented in her book 'Ghettoside: A True Story of Murder in America.' John Skaggs, a retired detective from Los Angeles, told her that the gang members he dealt with were often 'regular guys' who joined gangs and acted violently for self-protection. When the justice system is unlikely to catch criminals, people feel they can act with impunity, experts argue. They might even feel that they have to commit a crime -- such as killing someone who threatens them -- to protect themselves. 'Take a bunch of teenage boys from the whitest, safest suburb in America and plunk them down in a place where their friends are murdered and they are constantly attacked and threatened,' Leovy wrote. 'Signal that no one cares, and fail to solve murders. Limit their options for escape. Then see what happens.' What Went Wrong Why does America solve so few crimes? Experts point to five explanations. 1. A lack of attention and resources: We can solve difficult cases. Indeed, studies show that police departments solve more murders and shootings when they spend more time and money on them. One program in Boston, which revised procedures and boosted resources for homicide investigations, led to a 23% increase in clearance rates. The New York Police Department has one of the best-funded and staffed police departments in the country, and it consistently reports higher clearance rates than other major cities. Advertisement But departments and lawmakers have for decades focused on proactive strategies, such as flooding neighborhoods with police officers, that emphasize stopping crime before or as it happens. Those strategies can work to combat crime, studies have found. But they don't have to come at the cost of the other side of policing: catching criminals after the act. 2. Guns: America has more firearms than any other country in the world, and these weapons make it easier to get away with murder. A drive-by shooter can ride off before anyone sees his face, making it easier to kill anonymously. Killing another person with a knife, on the other hand, 'is a pretty intimate act that is likely to generate more and different kinds of evidence,' Cook, the Duke researcher, said. 3. The types of crime: The United States has more gang crime than other rich countries, and it's harder to solve. A personal crime involves people with more history. A husband who kills his wife has a legal relationship with her, easily found in court records. Family members know the killer and victim intimately. That is less likely for gang crimes; a gang member who kills a stranger in a carjacking gives the police less to work with. Gang members also work together to get away with crimes, and potential witnesses are often scared to testify against them. Advertisement 4. Volume: The United States has far more murders and fewer police officers, after controlling for population, than other rich countries. The number of cases overwhelms the police. A detective who deals with only one murder per year gets much more time on the case than a detective who deals with one murder per week. 'We've gotten swamped over the years,' said Emily McKinley, a deputy police chief in Louisville who previously worked as a homicide detective. 'Violent crime, we've lost control of it.' 5. Distrust of the police: High-profile deaths and protests have exposed abuses in police departments across the country. Detectives rely on witnesses to solve crimes. But 'ordinary citizens are not going to want to cooperate with the police when they see the police as alien storm troopers,' Forst said. They also are less likely to cooperate if they believe that the police can't or won't protect them from a crime suspect's retaliation. Potential Solutions Some of these problems are hard to solve. Lawmakers and jurists have wrestled with the abundance of guns for decades. And while killings in America have plummeted since the 1990s, the murder rate remains much higher here than it is in other rich countries. These ingrained problems will probably prevent the United States from matching Australia's or Germany's high clearance rates. Still, some policies could help. Experts point to two ideas. First, lawmakers and the police could commit more resources to solving murders. Some members of Congress want more funding for the police -- and detectives in particular -- but those proposals haven't gone anywhere. Police departments could also shift existing resources to solving more crimes, as the Boston study suggested, but that would require prioritizing the issue over others. Advertisement Second, the police could make greater use of modern technology. Cameras helped catch a suspect in the case of the UnitedHealthcare executive Brian Thompson in New York City. The police department used facial recognition software and widely shared photos and videos of the suspect. Within days, a fast-food worker in rural Pennsylvania tipped them off. In recent years, more police departments have embraced Flock cameras, named after the company that makes them, that can automatically read license plates and detect gunfire. Departments have also installed more traditional cameras. But the devices aren't ubiquitous, even in the biggest cities. And while private cameras are often around, police officers can't always gain access to them. Not everyone is on board with widespread use of cameras. Civil libertarians have raised privacy concerns; they worry that the government could abuse the technology to spy on or harass Americans. 'We have to have conversations about how to use the technology responsibly,' said Jennifer Doleac, the executive vice president for criminal justice at Arnold Ventures, a public policy philanthropy group. 'But these tools can help us.' Back in Kentucky, policymakers have taken some steps. Louisville's police department has released a new anticrime plan, installed more cameras around the city and increased recruitment. State lawmakers, meanwhile, passed a law in 2023 that made it easier for police departments to rehire retired officers to help with staffing shortages. Still, the changes have not yet produced results. From 2023 to 2024, the murder clearance rate in Louisville actually declined. 'I want someone to be held accountable for taking my son's life,' said Delphine Prentice, the mother of Damion Morton, who was shot and killed in 2017. But after eight years, she added, 'I'm about to give up hope.' This article originally appeared in
Miami Herald
5 hours ago
- Miami Herald
‘Go back to Haiti!' Florida company pays $1.4 million to end lawsuit over racism
While a Florida garbage company denies 'intentional wrongdoing,' they're shelling out $1.4 million to settle a lawsuit that alleges management allowed Black and Haitian-American workers to be hit with racist slurs and imagery from co-workers. Waste Pro of Florida is based out of Longwood, but the accusations in an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission lawsuit involve what did or didn't happen at Waste Pro's Jacksonville office, 2940 Strickland St. Specifically, the lawsuit in Jacksonville federal court concerns what did and didn't happen to welder Fednol Pierre after he transferred there in October 2021. The $1.4 million will go to a ground that includes Pierre, 25 co-workers named in the consent decree and any of Waste Pro's Black and/or Haitian-American Jacksonville employees 'who were subjected to a hostile work environment based on their race, color, or national origin, from February 2021 through Dec. 31, 2023.' The consent decree also requires Waste Pro to hire a racial discrimination expert as a compliance officer to investigate race discrimination complaints and claims of retaliation for such complaints in Waste Pro's Northeast region for the next 18 months and oversee those investigations throughout the company for the next three years. A statement from Waste Pro corporate communications says: 'Waste Pro has always been committed to fostering a productive and healthy work environment for its employees that is free of harassment and discrimination. This case stems from events alleged to have occurred in 2022, and while Waste Pro did not find evidence of intentional wrongdoing, a settlement was reached to avoid lengthy litigation and refocus on our commitment to our employees and the people we serve. Waste Pro has proactively enhanced our existing training for all company managers, our internal reporting mechanisms, and our company-wide communication regarding our robust anti-harassment and discrimination policy.' The consent decree says Waste Pro denies it violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and, officially, admits no liability. READ MORE: Miami plastic surgery company discriminated against worker with breast cancer, EEOC says 'Go back on the banana boat!' The lawsuit says Pierre, a certified welder, worked for Waste Pro in Port St. Lucie for two years and three months before transferring to Jacksonville in October 2021. Another welder, the lawsuit said, welcomed him with 'there is no need for you here,' and dropped a racial slur. This continued over the succeeding days, the EEOC suit said, from two different welders with 'Go back to Haiti, (n-word);' 'Y'all don't belong here;' 'Go back on the banana boat;' 'This is Trump country;' and other pieces of verbal racist aggression. 'The comments and slurs were ubiquitous, frequent, and occurred openly, including in the presence of...a technician, and other similarly aggrieved Black and/or Haitian-American coworkers,' the lawsuit said. Pierre and a maintenance supervisor told the maintenance manager what was happening and, eventually, an investigation commenced March 29, 2022. After the investigation, the regional human resources manager planned to hold a staff meeting to talk with maintenance workers about race discrimination. 'Before the staff meeting, [Pierre] and another Black employee discovered a stuffed monkey carrying an American flag in Mr. Pierre's work area,' said the lawsuit, although the photo in the lawsuit appears to show a gorilla. (Images and statements likening Black people to monkeys or gorillas long have been used in attempts to dehumanize Black people.) The two welders who had been spewing racist epithets at Pierre, the lawsuit said, began retaliating. They 'refused to communicate with Mr. Pierre about auto-repairs, and they often left him with the least desirable, most difficult welding tasks to complete at night,' the lawsuit said, which also claimed they 'locked the best welding equipment in their personal lockers so that [Pierre] could not access it.' Believing nothing substantive had been done, Pierre resigned May 12, 2022. The next day, the lawsuit said, the regional maintenance manager told a maintenance manager 'to incorrectly note in Mr. Pierre's termination paperwork that he was not rehireable because he had twice walked off the job.'
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Cowboys All-Pro KaVontae Turpin arrested on weapon, marijuana charges
Cowboys star KaVontae Turpin was arrested Saturday in Texas on misdemeanor drug and weapon charges, according to online records from the Allen Police Department. Turpin posted a $1,500 bond Sunday and was released from Collin County Jail. He was charged with possession of marijuana (less than two ounces) and unlawful carrying of a weapon. 3 KaVontae Turpin's mugshot. Collin County Jail Texas is one of the 26 states where recreational marijuana possession remains illegal. The legalized amount varies from state to state among the other 24 but as much as six ounces – more than three times Turpin's amount – is legal in New Jersey. The drug charge in Texas is punishable by up to 180 days in jail and a fine of up to $2,000. The nature of the weapons charge is unknown. The Cowboys declined comment. 3 Dallas Cowboys wide receiver KaVontae Turpin runs after making a catch during the second half of an NFL football game against the Washington Commanders, Jan. 5, 2025, in Arlington, Texas. AP Turpin, 28, signed a three-year, $18 million contract earlier this year after being named an All-Pro as a kick returner last season. He also had 31 catches for 420 yards and two touchdowns. He made his first Pro Bowl as a rookie in 2022 and his second last season, when he led the NFL with 33.5 yards per kickoff return and scored touchdowns as a receiver, a kickoff returner and a punt returner to become the first player in Cowboys history to complete that single-season trifecta. Turpin was kicked off the team at TCU as a senior in 2018 after two domestic violence allegations against him. Both cases involved the same woman. 3 KaVontae Turpin catches the football during practice at NFL football minicamp at the Cowboys' facility, Wednesday, June 11, 2025, in Frisco, Texas. AP It was three years before Turpin played football again. He joined the Fan Controlled Football League, The Spring League, the European League of Football and the USFL – where he was the MVP of the 2022 season while playing for the New Jersey Generals – before signing with the Cowboys. Turpin could be subject to discipline under the NFL's Personal Conduct Policy, though those penalties typically are not handed out until after the legal process is complete.
