Player ratings: how Tipperary and Kilkenny fared in their All-Ireland semi-final thriller
RHYS SHELLY
His strategy of going short to go long with the return pass was central to Tipp's initial comeback while he was solidity personified in all defensive tasks; it might be overshadowed by more spectacular plays that were part of Tipp's last power surge but he initiated it by taking a Cian Kenny shot off the crossbar that would have put Kilkenny three up. 8.5
ROBERT DOYLE
When Shelly wasn't there to be the last man standing, Doyle was, his goalline save from John Donnelly at the death ensuring that if his name wasn't that well known in Tipp before today, it will be now and for decades more, especially along the Kilkenny border. After a ropy opening quarter, continuously came out with the ball thereafter. 7
RONAN MAHER
Moved from his customary no 6 spot to man-mark TJ Reid and for the most part, it worked; TJ was held to just a point from play and Tipp were held goalless. 7
EOGHAN CONNOLLY
Titanic. First, scored a couple of long-range points, then bettered them with a third point from half-time after playing a series of give-and-gos up the pitch. Also attended to his defensive duties, subduing Eoin Cody. 8.5
CRAIG MORGAN
Like most of the Tipp halfback line, was under the cosh early but weathered it, breaking out with his share of ball. 6.5
BRIAN O'MARA
Switching him onto John Donnelly was one of the pillars of Tipp's comeback. And even when Kilkenny got on top again early in the third quarter, he helped stem the tide, sweeping up a pile of ball. 7.5
MICHAEL BREEN
Was shipping water early on and while he coughed up some ball late on, more than compensated with his manic intensity and being a constant outlet for Shelly. 6.5
WILLIE CONNORS
Put in a serious shift in the engine room, especially in the second quarter while delivering some fine ball into the Tipp inside line, but was fading when he was called ashore on 57 minutes. 6.5
CONOR STAKELUM
One of the men that kept Tipp in the game when there was a danger they would never get into it. Scored both of their first two points, won a dirty ball to set up a boomer from Connolly and had managed a third point from play before halftime. 8
JAKE MORRIS
Had a quiet start but showed his resilience and adaptability when moving to the inside line where he caused mayhem to finish with 0-4 from play. Also showed his leadership; the first point Tipp got after going down to 14 men, he Eoin-Kelly-like gave the lion's roar to the Tipp crowd and teammates. 8
ANDREW ORMOND
Got into the game once he was switched to the wing. The one Tipp starting forward who failed to score but still contributed with some hard running, like when winning a key late free for Jason Ford to convert late on. 7
SAM O'FARRELL
Was largely peripheral though did score a lovely point out on the wing minutes before he was called ashore. 6
DARRAGH McCARTHY
A rollercoaster. Shot the first wide of the game. Then scored a goal and brilliantly set up another. Missed two give-me frees either side of nailing a really testing one. And then was put off. Call that second yellow card harsh but you'd still have thought after Páirc Uí Chaoimh he wouldn't allow a ref to even entertain the thought of showing him the line again. Could have cost Tipp the game but he could be the winning of the All Ireland the next day. 7
JOHN McGRATH
Hard to think of a greater and more unexpected renaissance since Kieran Donaghy's in 2014. Where would Tipp have been only that the one score they got of the game's opening eight scores was his rocket to the net? 7
JASON FORDE
The rest of the inside line might have caught fire before he did but it was Forde who burned brightest when the need was greatest. Clare and Portlaoise is now erased from the memory bank after how brilliantly he did upon resuming all free-taking responsibilities while his go-ahead point from play out on the touchline was comparable to the Joe Canning one that foiled him in 2017. Not to mention his brilliant first-half finish. Class. 8
THE BENCH (7.5)
ALAN TYNAN (8) made two of the finest hustle plays of the game, first with a key blockdown in his first-half blood-sub cameo, and then with a key interception that led to that wonder goal from OISIN O'DONOGHUE (8). Noel McGrath (7) also put the shoulder to the wheel, winning a key late that triggered a defiant celebration in the mode of his namesake Ken's in 2004.
Read More
GAA confirm scoreboard error in Tipperary v Kilkenny semi
KILKENNY
EOIN MURPHY
Will be disappointed that he didn't stop McCarthy's goal, though he did compensate somewhat for it with a fine save from Jake Morris shortly thereafter. 6
MIKEY BUTLER
Has starred in previous All Ireland semi-finals as Tony Kelly knows well but was part of a fullback line overwhelmed here from the second quarter on. Second best to Forde. 6
HUW LAWLOR
After he pulled down another high ball early on, he looked on course for another stellar performance but thereafter he even succumbed to the Kilkenny malaise and Tipp onslaught. Was uncomfortable having to deal with lower ball and McGrath coming out the field while was part of a defensive mix-up when he was one of two men going for the one ball, resulting in a Tipp goal. 6
SHANE MURPHY
Struggled with the movement of the Tipp inside line and was duly replaced at halftime. 5
MIKEY CAREY
Recovered brilliantly to block Andrew Ormond early on after initially allowing him run through on goal, indicative of the work he'd continue to do. Came out with a pile of ball, but will now question why he shielded that ball in the lead up to O'Donoghue's match-winning goal. 7.5
RICHIE REID
Ultimately didn't offer the kind of protection that was needed from a No. 6 on the day, while will also regret a tough shot that he took on out on the wing and a couple of attempted passes in the closing minutes. 6
PADDY DEEGAN
Was dominant in the opening quarter, winning several puckouts and laying on the pass for a couple of Billy Ryan points. Kilkenny though robbed Peter when paying this Paul to go back into the fullback line where he was off thereon in, including with that 'tackle' on Ormond that could and should have earned a red. 6.5
CIAN KENNY
Helped make this one of the most intense and intriguing midfield battles Croker has known since the likes of Shane McGrath were going hip to hip with Rice and Fennelly. Got his foot and hurl to assist a couple of key scores before coming up with a couple of fine points himself but should have made it a third only to allow Shelly take a casual shot of his off the crossbar. 7.5
JORDAN MOLLOY
Finished with four points from play, reflective of the relentless energy he brought to this battle. 8
JOHN DONNELLY
A big part of Kilkenny's early dominance with his movement and vision, but was quietened once Bryan O'Mara tagged him. 6.5
EOIN CODY
One of a couple of big-name forwards Kilkenny needed more from. Even allowing for his layoff, few could have envisaged him being outscored by Eoghan Connolly. 6
BILLY RYAN
Started off on fire but gave away a couple of unnecessary frees in and out of possession in the third quarter marred the massive effort he put in. 7
ADRIAN MULLEN
Hard to know if he was shaking his head over his performance or his substitution when finally called ashore; it's hard not to think it was him Stephen Donnelly was set to come on for only for him to finally get a score and get into the game after 45 minutes. Could argue he had got to the pace when he was finally subbed off but the reality is Kilkenny needed more from him and sooner than they got here. 6
TJ REID
Fought as hard as ever against the dying of the light, conjuring that late goal chance for John Donnelly, but for all the frees he won and converted here, he was well marshalled by Ronan Maher. We could be wrong, but after a seventh straight year losing either an All Ireland semi-final or final this was likely his last tilt at that seventh Celtic Cross. 7
MOSSIE KEOGHAN
If Kilkenny had prevailed here would have been in man of the match territory. Had three points from play after just 20 minutes, six by the 70th. 8.5
THE BENCH (5):
Clearly Derek Lyng didn't trust it, opting to use just three subs, and all but one of them (David Blanchfield, 6) after the 65th minute.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Inside Liam Cahill's life beyond hurling including wife with famous Tipperary GAA family ahead of All-Ireland final
LIAM CAHILL is Tipperary through and through - and his wife's family comes from legendary GAA stock. Cahill will be leading the Premier into 4 Liam Cahill will be leading Tipperary into battle against Cork in the All-Ireland hurling final Credit: Ben McShane/Sportsfile 4 His father-in-law is Len Gaynor, right Credit: Seb Daly/Sportsfile 4 Gaynor won two All-Irelands with Tipperary Credit: Ray McManus/Sportsfile 4 His daughter Ciara, Liam Cahill's sister-in-law, won five All-Ireland camogie titles with the county Credit: Pat Murphy/Sportsfile Tipp will be looking to get their hands on Liam MacCarthy for the first time since 2019 but will be up against a Rebels side aiming to end a 20-year wait for glory. Cahill and his crew will be bolstered by their manager's His sister-in-law and father-in-law both hold special places in the And here, SunSport will take a look at the family seeking to bolster the current Premier boss. Read More on Tipperary How old is Liam Cahill? Liam Cahill was born on October 17, 1977, making him 47 years of age - one year younger than his counterpart on Sunday: Pat Ryan. Originally from Ballingarry, he won three South Tipperary hurling titles with his hometown club before transferring to Thurles Sarsfields in 2007. Two years later, he won a county title with his new club, making him a four time champion. Cahill made his senior inter-county debut in 1996, winning an All Star in his debut year. Most read in GAA Hurling That was recognition for being part of a Tipp side that got to the Munster hurling final - losing to In 1999, he won his first senior medal with the Premier in the form of the National Hurling League. 'Easiest interview I've ever had' jokes RTE GAA host after pundits go back and forth before Meath vs Donegal And two years later, Tipperary clinched a coveted double of Munster and All-Ireland honours. How long has he been Tipperary manager? Liam Cahill was appointed as Tipp boss in July 2022, having previously served as manager of their minor and under-20s sides. He was He is yet to win senior medals at the helm of his home county, but did win All-Ireland and Munster honours with the minors and U20s. Is he married? Liam Cahill is married to wife Eimear, and the pair have three kids together. As mentioned, Eimear Cahill - born Eimear Gaynor - comes from legendary stock herself. Her dad is Len Gaynor, who won two All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championships as a player with Tipperary. He would later manage his home county between 1996 and 1998, meaning Gaynor oversaw a side containing his future son-in-law. In addition to this, Liam's sister-in-law - Eimear's sister - is Ciara Gaynor. A hugely decorated camogie player, Gaynor won FIVE All-Ireland medals with Tipperary - in 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, and 2004. Her individual excellence on the way to the latter saw her recognised with an All-Star in 2004.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Confident Cork fan shows off 'All-Ireland Senior Hurling Champions' tattoo
For some, the result is written in the stars. But for one die-hard rebel, it's tattooed on one of his arms. Cork fan Michael John Murphy is so confident about the outcome of Sunday's historic first meeting of Cork and Tipperary in an All-Ireland hurling final, he's had his forearm inked with the words: Cork All Ireland Senior Hurling Champions 2025. 'I won't need to change it,' he said confidently. Excitement is building across the city and county ahead of Sunday's final, with unprecedented demand for tickets prompting warnings to fans to be aware of scammers and dodgy ticket offers online. Michael John, 37, a member of the Irish Defence Forces, originally from Waterford but who lives in Mayfield, on the northside of Cork city, is sorted though. He, his wife, Annette, and their children, Paul and Ciara, are all season ticket holders, and will watch the final from the Lower Cusack stand. He grew up in a mixed home in Rinn — his father from Youghal, Cork, his mother from Waterford — but he followed in his father's footsteps and has been a lifelong Cork GAA supporter. 'We're 20 years without an All-Ireland title so I was always going to get something to commemorate the win this year,' he said. 'I already have four or five other tattoos, including one of a hurler on my left shoulder, with a flash of red going through the helmet, for Cork, along with the names of my son, daughter and grandson, so it's only natural I'd get this one.' 'We're 20 years without an All-Ireland title so I was always going to get something to commemorate the win this year'. Picture: Larry Cummins Darragh Murphy, of Skint Tattoo Studio, offered to do GAA-inspired tattoos for Rebel fans before the final, and Michael John put his arm up, literally. Darragh said: 'I was happy to offer it for free as a bit of fun leading up to the final. 'I can see Cork winning but we can never be too cocky. A grain of rice could really tip the scales, especially in a final. 'Confidence is key. The 2025 is an easy fix to 2026 for next year anyway in case anything goes pear-shaped on Sunday — but I doubt it.' Michael John, a soldier, is sticking to his guns — Cork to win on Sunday. 'As I said, there won't be any hiding the tattoo if the unthinkable happens, I won't be changing it. I'd have no interest in changing it to be honest. And I'll have a funny story to tell about it.' Ciara also got a small tattoo of two crossed hurleys above a sliotar, with the family names on either side, and Annette has several tattoos too, but none with a GAA theme. 'I don't think she'll get one either. She's seen the circus around my tattoo,' Michael John said. Meanwhile, up at Cork Airport, tensions soared and hurleys were drawn under the statue of Christy Ring as dozens of staff in their red and white jerseys found themselves in a spirited scuffle with the only Tipp woman in the terminal over a replica of the Liam MacCarthy Cup, which landed there for the day. Sue Crowley bravely displays her Tipp jersey on 'Red and White Day' at Cork Airport. Picture: David Creedon Brave Sue Crowley, who's originally from Toomevara but living near Clonakilty in West Cork for over 20 years, came to work on 'red and white day' proudly wearing her Tipp jersey. 'I know where my loyalties lie. It's Tipperary,' she said. 'But Cork has been absolutely wonderful to me. There has been some great banter and craic here the last few days, but I think it'll be Tipp on Sunday.' The airport's terminal building has been decorated in red and white from one end to the other, with red uplighting bathing its outside in red light. For passengers travelling on Sunday, the airport's Craft Bar and Restaurant will show the game live, while other large TVs in departures and arrivals areas are also showing live coverage. Cork Airport managing director Niall MacCarthy said: "The countdown has really begun now, and whoever wins on Sunday, we'll respect long as it's Cork." Cork fan Karen Mullaney of Aer Lingus and Tipp fan Sue Crowley of Cork Airport battle for the Liam MacCarthy Cup. Picture: David Creedon Meanwhile, free tickets for Sunday's family-friendly alcohol-free Rebel Fanzone event in SuperValu Páirc Uí Chaoimh are being released at 7.30am on Thursday via with a five-ticket per person limit. The final will be shown on big screens, with entertainment from Cork's RedFM before and after the game. Read More Inside the Cork hurley workshop behind Patrick Horgan's scoring success
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Liam Cahill and Tipp have previous with upsetting Cork in All-Ireland finals
Strong underdogs in an All-Ireland final against a Cork team that has already wiped the floor with you earlier in the year? Liam Cahill has been here before. Moreover, so have several of his Tipperary players - and a large number from Cork that he will plot against this Sunday. Much like with the senior grade now, in 2018, Cork had gone 20 years without an All-Ireland under-21 title but the overhaul of their underage system was beginning to bear fruit as they romped to the Munster title that year, their first since 2007, beating Tipperary by 13 points in the provincial final. READ MORE: Who will be on RTE commentary duty for Sunday's Cork-Tipperary All-Ireland hurling final? READ MORE: GAA Palestine cancels Ireland trip after visa rejection In the last year of the under-21 grade at inter-county level, however, the four provincial finalists in Munster and Leinster crossed over for the All-Ireland semi-finals. Cork hardened their status as Championship favourites by beating Wexford by 22 points, while Tipperary got past Galway to set up a rematch with them in the All-Ireland final. 'This is one of the best underage teams to come out of Cork and that's well known and well documented,' said Cahill ahead of that final. 'It's very obvious with 10 senior panellists on their starting 15 with the massive exposure that they've got in the last two years, they're really ahead of their time.' On the same afternoon that the late Pope Francis was saying Mass before a rather sparse crowd in the Phoenix Park, Tipp stayed in the game and were level with six minutes to go when Stephen Nolan netted. Cork hit back with points to go one ahead but another goal from Conor Stakelum meant that the 1/5 favourites were beaten. There was probably a bit of 'building them up' in Cahill's pre-match comments, but look at the players from that game that are backboning Cork's senior team now. Niall O'Leary, Mark Coleman, Darragh Fitzgibbon, Tim O'Mahony and Declan Dalton all started the All-Ireland semi-final romp over Dublin earlier this month and that game seven years ago. Robbie O'Flynn, Shane Kingston, both of whom came off the bench against Dublin, and Jack O'Connor, were mainstays in that under-21 side's attack. Ger Millerick, who has plenty of senior experience though has been injured for much of the summer, was an unused sub against Dublin but was introduced in that final seven years ago. So, up to nine of the 17 players that featured for Cork that day could see action again next Sunday. Despite bettering them, Tipp have less. Two players - Eoghan Connolly and Jake Morris - that started that day were on the team that beat Kilkenny in the semi-final, though it would surely have been three but for Dillon Quirke's tragic passing in 2022. Stakelum and Craig Morgan, however, also came off the bench seven years ago and are starting for the seniors now, so that makes four. Goalkeeper Barry Hogan lost his place to Rhys Shelly during the Munster Championship while Brian McGrath was an unused sub against Kilkenny. Tipperary manager Liam Cahill celebrates at the final whistle after beating Cork in the 2018 All-Ireland under-21 final. (Image: ©INPHO/Tommy Dickson) The counties met again in the following year's All-Ireland under-20 final when Tipperary, with Cahill still as manager, crushed Cork by 5-17 to 1-18 in the All-Ireland final having squeezed past them by one in the Munster decider. Five players from that team will likely start on Sunday - Morris, Connolly, Morgan, Bryan O'Mara and Andrew Ormond, while Cork will have Robert Downey, with Millerick and O'Connell set to be on the bench. Those Tipperary defeats were particularly damaging to the Cork psyche at a time when the senior squad was showing no great signs of bridging the gap to 2005 and their famine at underage level went back even further. A turning point came with a pair of under-20 All-Irelands within weeks of each other in 2021, following the Covid-delayed season of 2020, with current senior boss Pat Ryan at the helm. They won another under Ben O'Connor in 2023. Players from those sides have now supplemented the 2018-19 crop, but the way that those under-21/20 campaigns played out means that Cahill and at least a cohort of his players won't be hung up by a 15-point beating that they suffered with 14 men earlier in this Championship, much less the 10-point loss in the League final. They've clipped several of these Cork players' wings against the odds before. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email alerts.
