
Moncton manslaughter trial full of 'what ifs,' defence tells jury in closing statements
Gilles Lemieux delivered his closing arguments in the Moncton manslaughter trial on Friday morning. Glaspy is charged with manslaughter in the death of Frenette, who was the food and beverage manager at Casino New Brunswick.
"Here you have what I've come to believe is a constellation of what ifs … of things that were either not investigated or just left hanging," Lemieux said, standing at a podium before the 12-member jury in Moncton's Court of King's Bench.
Video surveillance played for the jury showed the two men getting into a struggle in the early morning hours of March 4, 2023, and Frenette hitting his head on the floor of the pub inside the casino. A pathologist previously testified Frenette died of a traumatic brain injury and a stroke 24 days later.
Both the defence and the Crown reminded the jury of the evidence they've heard over the past three weeks ahead of deliberations which are set to begin Tuesday.
In his roughly 45-minute statement, Lemieux began by asking the jury to imagine how the events that set off this case — the altercation between Glaspy and Frenette — could have gone differently at the Hub City Pub inside the casino.
"What if Mr. Glaspy and Miss MacDonald hadn't decided to go out on that Friday night?" he pondered. Felicia MacDonald, Glaspy's fiance who was with him at the casino that night, also sat in court.
"What if he wasn't quite so large? What if he just kept on walking with a coat in his hand? What if he hadn't drank so much and he had not become unstable on his feet?"
Lemieux went on to question why Frenette's roughly 400-page medical records were not disclosed in court, even though Frenette signed a waiver, giving police access to them before he died.
Lemieux previously used them to disclose that Frenette had fallen in the hospital on March 16. The pathologist who performed Frenette's autopsy later testified he wasn't aware of that incident.
Security made 'bad choices,' defence said
Lemieux said security officers working at the casino that night made "bad choices regarding the handling of somebody that should have been handled differently."
"He was just drunk," he said, referring to Glaspy, who admitted during his own testimony earlier in the trial that he had too much to drink.
Lemieux also pointed to surveillance footage shown to the jury that showed several casino staff members intervening in the altercation.
"Where was security? They had been called three times."
Lemieux ended by reminding the jury to consider any reasonable doubt in the case.
"In the end, I feel certain that you'll come to the conclusion that Mr. Michael Glaspy is not guilty of manslaughter."
Crown blames Glaspy for poor decisions
The Crown's closing statement, which lasted about 15 minutes, focused on both Glaspy and Frenette's behaviour on March 4.
"Mr. Glaspy made a deliberate decision not to leave," Crown prosecutor Marc-André Desjardins said. "Mr. Glaspy was annoyed at being told he had to leave the pub. Mr. Glaspy made the conscious decision to confront Rodney Frenette."
It was an altercation that "lasted 30 seconds but forever changed multiple lives," Desjardins said to the jury, as Frenette's wife and daughter looked on from the gallery.
Desjardins suggested that while Frenette can be seen shoving Glaspy first on the surveillance video, he was merely putting space between the two of them because Glaspy was "too close for comfort."
"Ask yourself: does that seem like the actions of someone who wanted to fight or argue with the accused?"
He finished by telling the jury they'll be responsible for determining whether Glaspy's intentions were to cause harm to Frenette.
He told the 12-member jury they should consider whether Glaspy is guilty of manslaughter "or, alternatively, of aggravated assault."
Justice Christa Bourque told the jury they will be brought back Tuesday, when she intends to deliver instructions on what constitutes manslaughter and how to apply the law to the evidence they've heard.
Bourque said when deliberations begin, the jury will be sequestered and will stay in a hotel without their phones until deliberations are complete.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
26 minutes ago
- CTV News
City hall candidates making the most of Stampede week
Calgary Watch The Stampede can also double up as a political rodeo as city hall candidates want to connect with potential voters. The signs and billboards are going up...


CTV News
42 minutes ago
- CTV News
Mother of the Kelowna woman allegedly murdered by estranged spouse speaks out
The B.C. Conservatives are calling for a coroner's inquest into the brutal attack that killed a Kelowna mother Friday. Karen Fehr hadn't heard from her 32-year-old daughter, Bailey McCourt, for over a decade when she called in May. McCourt was amidst a family court battle with her estranged husband, James Plover. 'She reached out to me on Mother's Day crying 'I need you mom, I need help. No one is listening to me, nobody cares, nobody's doing anything',' Fehr recounted in an exclusive interview with CTV News. McCourt was in the process of moving into a home in Kelowna, B.C., with her mom and two daughters last Friday when she learned Plover had been convicted by a judge of four counts of assault by choking and uttering threats in a domestic violence case. 'They sent her the judgment that he was guilty on all counts, so she was happy,' said Fehr. That same afternoon, McCourt and a friend were beaten with a hammer in a Kelowna parking lot. After a brief pursuit, James Plover was arrested and charged with second degree murder for allegedly killing his estranged wife. Fehr can't stop thinking about her daughter's last moments. 'When I read she was able to run and tripped, I can't imagine the fear. I watched that fear every day,' said Fehr through tears. 'And falling to ground and knowing that's it. That's it.' McCourt's mom doesn't understand why Plover wasn't held in custody after his convictions. She says her daughter had feared for her life for months, and the courts didn't protect her. 'This is not the first time something like this has happened. It has happened way too many times,' Fehr said. 'It's absolutely sickening, should never have happened,' said Elenore Sturko, the B.C. Conservative Public Safety and Solicitor General critic. 'They were convicted of a violent crime, not just charged, and not innocent until proven guilty. They were guilty. This is absolutely horrific. It's unacceptable.' The Conservatives are calling for a coroner's inquest into the circumstances leading up to McCourt's murder. 'It's just clear that there were so many gaps that ultimately led to this brutal murder,' Sturko said. 'As British Columbians, we can't let this just be another file that gets swept under the rug.' CTV News requested an interview with Attorney General Niki Sharma and was emailed a statement from Parliamentary Secretary for Gender Equality Jennifer Blatherwick in response. It read, in part: 'Like many British Columbians, I was horrified to learn what happened and I understand the grief and anger people are feeling. Cases like this highlight the need for continuous improvements in how we identify risk, support survivors, and ensure all parts of the justice system are working together.' Blatherwick said the province is working to implement recommendations from Dr. Kim Stanton, who recently wrote a bipartisan report on domestic violence. 'We're also working with the federal government to strengthen bail and sentencing laws, as well as issues that have long been overlooked at the national level, like stronger protections against intimate partner and gender-based violence, and the need to re-evaluate risk in cases involving repeat sex offenders,' the statement said. Fehr also wants changes to the law, as she mourns a daughter who was ripped from her life just months after re-entering it. 'I'm just going to spend my days just remembering who she was,' she said, as she clutched her daughter's childhood teddy bear.


CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Police vehicle involved in highway collision near Lumsden, Sask.
A police vehicle was involved in a highway collision near Lumsden, Sask. on Tuesday night. According to a release from Saskatchewan RCMP around 7:20 p.m., Lumsden RCMP officers were on the scene of a two-vehicle collision at the intersection of Highway 11 and Highway 734. The officer in the police vehicle was assessed by EMS at the scene and the three occupants in the second vehicle were taken to hospital by EMS with 'non-threatening' injuries, RCMP said. RCMP said motorists may experience delays in the area, noting that investigation into the collision continues.