Some Manitoba school divisions cancelling field trips to U.S. due to tension over gender issues
The Seven Oaks School Division in northwest Winnipeg is among the divisions changing their travel plans this year to prioritize values involving inclusion, equity and diversity.
Their decision follows an executive order by U.S. President Donald Trump that terminated a range of policies aimed at protecting 2SLGBTQ+ rights, fulfilling a campaign promise he described as " restoring biological truth." Trump says the U.S. will recognize only two sexes — male and female.
"That is definitely a consideration — that we pay attention to when there are executive orders to the point of only recognizing certain people and essentially cancelling others," Seven Oaks superintendent Tony Kreml told reporters at a news conference on Friday. "That can certainly provide for an unsafe situation both for a student and staff member."
Since making the decision to pause education-related trips south of the border, he says he's heard "comments of appreciation" from people regarding concerns for their safety, Kreml told reporters at West St. Paul School on Friday.
Kreml says he doesn't have specific details about the school field trip, but he said its cancellation won't have a significant impact. The unpredictable cost of travel was also a factor in the decision, ensuring opportunities for families are equitable, he says.
Kreml touts Winnipeg's local attractions including The Forks, saying students can learn so much by travelling within the province, which further contributes to supporting the economy.
The decision to cancel the trip was not meant to be adversarial, he says.
Troy Scott, assistant superintendent at Pembina Trails School Division, sent out an email on Friday to parents, legal guardians and staff, saying the division is pausing all student field trips to the U.S. for the remainder of the school year, effective immediately.
"This decision prioritizes student safety and reaffirms our commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion," Scott said.
Pembina Trails, which serves communities in southwest Winnipeg, says it will re-evaluate this decision at the start of the 2025-26 year.
Pausing any trips to the U.S. aligns with the division's commitment on anti-racism, diversity and creating an inclusive learning environment where all students feel supported and valued, Scott said.
Tracy Schmidt, minister for education and early childhood learning, told reporters she is encouraging school divisions across the province to follow suit and focus on learning opportunities involving travel excursions in their own backyard.
The Louis Riel School Division has not issued any specific guidance to schools in their division regarding travel to the U.S., superintendent Christian Michalik said in an email statement on Thursday.
Glenlawn Collegiate had a trip to Florida in January that was cancelled due to Hurricane Milton, Michalik said, but none of the schools within the division have scheduled trips to the U.S. during this school year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
NDP's rules for leadership race include requirements for youth, regional support
The NDP released the official rules for its leadership race on Friday, which include requirements that candidates gather specific numbers of signatures from supporters across regional, racial and 2SLGBTQ+ groups. At least 10 per cent of a candidate's signatures must come from New Democrats aged 25 years or under. Candidates must also collect at least 50 signatures from five different regions in Canada — the North, the Atlantic provinces, Quebec, Ontario and the Prairies and B.C. A new permanent leader to replace Jagmeet Singh will be chosen through a ranked ballot, allowing party members to list candidates in order of preference. The party announced earlier this month that candidates will be required to pay a $100,000 entry fee.
CBC
5 hours ago
- CBC
MAGA musician permit revocations spark public space debate
Social Sharing The decision to revoke a controversial MAGA-supporting performer's permits to hold events on public property has sparked a debate about who should be allowed to perform in public spaces. Sean Feucht is a religious singer from the U.S. who has expressed anti-diversity, anti-2SLGBTQ+ and anti-women's rights views on his platforms. He was scheduled to perform at the York Redoubt National Historic site in Halifax on Wednesday, but amid backlash from the public Parks Canada cancelled his permit, citing safety concerns. Soon after, Feucht's permits for events on public property in Charlottetown, P.E.I., Moncton, N.B., and parts of Quebec were also cancelled. Cameron Cassidy, the executive director of Pride P.E.I., said the City of Charlottetown "absolutely did the right thing by revoking that permit. I think that just shows a lot of respect for the queer community on their end." But not everybody agrees. James Turk, the director of the Centre for Free Expression at Toronto Metropolitan University, said the decision to remove a permit raises a red flag. "I think we should all be concerned whenever there is a demand that somebody's right to speak is taken away, a permit withdrawn, a booking in a venue cancelled," Turk said in an interview on Thursday. Amplifying messages Turk said the price of democracy is living with viewpoints that we don't like or agree with as well as ones we do like. "In Canada, generally, we recognize the foundation of democracy is an ongoing public discourse about what's legitimate, what's not legitimate," Turk said. "And that means we tolerate a wide range of perspectives and views, and we sort things out in our heterogeneous society by listening to different views, arguing against them or ignoring them or boycotting them, but not by censoring them." Turk said attempts to censor someone like Feucht could end up amplifying his message. "I never heard of this guy. I suspect 99.99 per cent of your listeners never heard of him. But now we're talking about it. He could be on national news. He's being covered. So he's gotten publicity out of this that he could never afford to buy. So whoever was objecting to him has done him a huge favour," Turk said. Matthew Taylor, a senior Christian scholar at the Institute for Islamic, Christian and Jewish Studies who has written about Feucht, agrees. "He's been doing these provocative, in your face, intentionally trying to draw a response from local officials, even trying to get barred or banned. And then he presents that as persecution, that he is the victim of anti-Christian bias," Taylor said. Feucht did end up performing in Nova Scotia on Wednesday. The event was held on property in Shubenacadie, N.S., belonging to Christine and Neil Barr. Both are pastors affiliated with a religious group called Lighthouse Ministries. "He was here and had no political agenda, just the gospel and his love for Canada," Christine Barr told CBC News. Leading up to the performance, the Barrs said they received hundreds of messages from people who opposed the Feucht show. "A lot of very hateful emails, texts to say that we were allowing a fascist on our property and that we should know better and the Christianity that we were showing was not love, it was hate and that we were racists. Some people even cursed ill health upon us," Christine Barr said. The Barrs said some people showed up to protest the show. In response to the backlash, Feucht put out a statement. "Here's the hard truth: If I had shown up with purple hair and a dress, claiming to be a woman, the government wouldn't have said a thing. But to publicly profess deeply held Christian beliefs is to be labelled an extremist and to have free worship events classified as 'public safety risks.'" Opponents of the Feucht show at York Redoubt had voiced opposition to it because they said it went against Parks Canada's guiding principles of inclusion and safety for all visitors. Turk said while some people may not feel safe having someone like Feucht performing in their community, there is no protection for "subjective feeling of safety." "We have an absolute obligation of society to make sure people are physically safe. In other words, not subject to violence or threats of violence, but because somebody says something I find hateful is not a justification for silencing that person," Turk said. "I can argue with them. As I say, I could ignore them, I can encourage people to have nothing to do with them, but I don't have a right to silence them."
National Post
a day ago
- National Post
All six Canadian venues cancel Christian musician Sean Feucht's shows
'They can cancel our permits across Canada but they cannot steal our joy,' Feucht posted to X along with a video of people dancing to music in the field. 'See you tomorrow PEI and Moncton!' The City of Charlottetown, also citing 'evolving public safety and security concerns,' had already cancelled a Thursday morning scheduled for Confederation Landing. Feucht, however, had already secured a new location at the home of the Faithworks Centre Church, a Christian church in North Wiltshire, just outside the capital. A day earlier, the city had initially said there was little it could do 'from a legal standpoint,' but made it clear they stand with the '2SLGBTQ+ community' as it began Pride Fest 2025 celebrations this week. Liberal MP Sean Casey had also called for the show to be cancelled. 'While I fully respect the right to freedom of expression, I do not believe this event reflects the values of inclusivity and respect that define the City of Charlottetown or the Government of Canada,' he wrote on Facebook. Feucht's Thursday show at Moncton's Riverfront Park was also cancelled the day prior after the city deemed it didn't comply with its facilities' code of conduct and represented a 'potential risks to the safety and security of community members, event attendees, and organizers.' Feucht's social media plea for 'any bold pastors/churches' willing to host the evening concert was answered by Bar None Camp in Taxis River, almost 200 kilometres northwest of Moncton in the middle of the province. Also axed on Wednesday were Feucht's scheduled performances in Quebec City and at the Jacques-Cartier Park North in Gatineau, overseen by the National Capital Commission, who cited 'concerns about public safety and security' in a statement to National Post. Meanwhile, François Moisan, Quebec City's director of public relations, specified in an email to National Post that the contract to perform at ExpoCité on Friday evening was cancelled because 'the presence of a controversial artist was not mentioned when the contract was signed.' Feucht hasn't publicly stated if he will seek out new venues to replace the remaining cancelled concerts, but did issue a statement on social media following the P.E.I. show. 'Here's the hard truth: If I had shown up with purple hair and a dress, claiming to be a woman, the government wouldn't have said a word,' he wrote. 'But to publicly profess deeply held Christian beliefs is to be labelled an extremist — and to have a free worship event classified as a public safety risk.'
