NHI is fiscally impossible, says the Health Funders Association
The Health Funders Association (HFA) has described the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act as fiscally impossible and has tabled a hybrid funding model that will enable private healthcare providers to provide services in tandem with the NHI.
The HFA, accounting for 46% of the private healthcare market and representing 21 medical schemes and three administrators, this week became the latest entity to legally challenge the NHI for undermining the right of medical aid members to choose how to access health services.
HFA commissioned an independent study released this week which found the NHI required substantial tax far beyond South Africa's fiscal capacity.
'What's more, the proposed model offers no guarantee of improved outcomes, while restricting the mechanisms that currently drive quality and innovation in health care,' said the FHA.
Commenting on the report, HFA CEO Thoneshan Naidoo said South Africa needs a healthcare system that delivers equitable, quality care for all.
'However, in its current form, and without private sector collaboration, the NHI Act is fiscally impossible and operationally unworkable, and threatens the stability of the economy and health system affecting everyone in South Africa,' he said.
Naidoo said the NHI Act centralises control of all healthcare financing in a single, state-run fund, removing the ability of medical schemes to offer cover for healthcare services reimbursable by the NHI.
'We continue to advocate for a more inclusive, hybrid funding model that incorporates medical schemes in NHI. We believe such a model would expand access to care while protecting the rights of all South Africans,' said Naidoo.
The NHI, which introduces universal health coverage, has been challenged in court by Solidarity, the Board of Healthcare Funders, the South African Private Practitioners Forum, the Hospital Association of South Africa and the South African Medical Association.
Foster Mohale, the health spokesperson, on Friday confirmed the department had received court papers.
'This is case number six. We have an evolving court process and we'll allow that process to take its course,' said Mohale.
FHA commissioned a report by Genesis Analytics, which showed that personal income tax will need to increase from the current average rate of 21% to an average of 46% of income, pushing marginal tax rates in the lowest income bracket from 18% to 41%, and in the highest bracket from 45% to 68%.
The Genesis model also considered a scenario of pooling existing healthcare expenditure, citing that personal income tax would need to increase from its average of 21% to 31%. At the same time, medical scheme members would face a 43% reduction in the level of healthcare services relative to what they currently received.
'In simple terms, the equation for medical scheme members therefore becomes 'Pay 1.5 times more tax for 43% less healthcare'. Such tax increases are fiscally impossible, particularly given South Africa's narrow personal income tax base of 7.4-million tax payers,' said the FHA.
TimesLIVE
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
a day ago
- TimesLIVE
Media must help reposition the promise of NHI
South Africa stands at the threshold of the most consequential health reform in its democratic history: national health insurance (NHI). Its promise? A society where healthcare is not a privilege of the wealthy but a guarantee for all. Yet, what dominates headlines and talk shows is not the vision of equity NHI represents but a stream of narratives steeped in distrust, dysfunction and fear. The phrase 'If it bleeds, it leads' has long held sway in media circles, and when applied to NHI, it has too often bled perspective dry. Coverage tends to centre on stories of mismanagement, fears of a collapsing private healthcare system, and projected costs. These deserve attention. But they cannot be the whole story. What is equally, if not more, newsworthy is this: millions of South Africans live without consistent access to primary care, quality hospitals or affordable medication. That inequity should lead to action, not fearmongering. NHI is not just a bureaucratic policy — it is a moral reckoning. It seeks to right the deep structural injustices in our health system, many of which still mirror apartheid-era geography and class divides. The child in Mthatha should have the same chance at survival as the child in Sandton. That is the essence of NHI. As we approach the Finance for Development Conference in Sevilla, Spain, this Monday and the Brics Leaders Summit in Brazil shortly after, there will be high expectations of our health financing narrative as the Group of 20 presidency. In the wake of the dramatic withdrawals in official development assistance, leading policymakers have emphasised the need to sustain the gains towards the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) 3 target — universal health coverage — through state-led health financing as guided by the evidence-based policies of normative bodies such as the World Bank and the World Health Organisation. The world will be looking to us to lead by example: not just rhetoric. NHI is not just a bureaucratic policy — it's a moral reckoning. It seeks to right the deep structural injustices in our health system, many of which still mirror apartheid-era geography and class divides. The child in Mthatha should have the same chance at survival as the child in Sandton. That is the essence of NHI. We are not naive about the challenges ahead — governance, financing and implementation must be watertight. But scepticism must not become sabotage. South Africa has defied the odds before. We built the world's largest HIV/Aids treatment programme when many said it could not be done. We led globally on Covid-19 vaccine equity. We know how to turn a national crisis into a national triumph — when the narrative fuels solutions, not cynicism. That is where the media comes in. You are not just storytellers. You are story shapers. You can hold policymakers accountable while also giving voice to the underserved, platforming progress, and illuminating the moral argument behind reform. You can ask: 'What's broken?' — but also, 'What's possible?' NHI will not succeed without the public's understanding and engagement. And the public cannot engage with what they do not hear or see. So, I invite you — editors, journalists, broadcasters, producers — to reposition and reclaim its role. Tell the truth, but tell the whole truth — frame narratives, which can either build trust or fuel scepticism, amplify voices, especially those often excluded — such as marginalised communities. In essence, your role isn't just to report on reforms like NHI — you can influence whether society embraces or resists them. In the end, what will define us is not how loudly we argue but how we see our common humanity — and whether we act on it.
TimesLIVE
a day ago
- TimesLIVE
Media must help reposition the promise of the NHI
South Africa stands at the threshold of the most consequential health reform in its democratic history: the National Health Insurance (NHI). Its promise? A society where health care is not a privilege of the wealthy but a guarantee for all. Yet, what dominates headlines and talk shows is not the vision of equity the NHI represents but a stream of narratives steeped in distrust, dysfunction and fear. The phrase 'If it bleeds, it leads' has long held sway in media circles, and when applied to the NHI, it has too often bled perspective dry. Coverage tends to centre on stories of mismanagement, fears of a collapsing private healthcare system, and projected costs. These deserve attention. But they cannot be the whole story. What is equally, if not more, newsworthy is this: millions of South Africans live without consistent access to primary care, quality hospitals or affordable medication. That inequity should lead to action, not fearmongering. The NHI is not just a bureaucratic policy — it's a moral reckoning. It seeks to right the deep structural injustices in our health system, many of which still mirror apartheid-era geography and class divides. The child in Mthatha should have the same chance at survival as the child in Sandton. That is the essence of NHI. As we approach the Finance for Development Conference in Sevilla, Spain, this Monday and the Brics Leaders Summit in Brazil shortly after, there will be high expectations of our health financing narrative as the G20 presidency. In the wake of the dramatic withdrawals in Official Development Assistance, leading policymakers have emphasised the need to sustain the gains towards the SDG 3 target — universal health coverage — through state-led health financing as guided by the evidence-based policies of normative bodies such as the World Bank and the World Health Organisation. The world will be looking to us to lead by example: not just rhetoric. The NHI is not just a bureaucratic policy — it's a moral reckoning. It seeks to right the deep structural injustices in our health system, many of which still mirror apartheid-era geography and class divides. The child in Mthatha should have the same chance at survival as the child in Sandton. That is the essence of NHI. We are not naive about the challenges ahead — governance, financing, and implementation must be watertight. But scepticism must not become sabotage. South Africa has defied the odds before. We built the world's largest HIV treatment programme when many said it couldn't be done. We led globally on Covid-19 vaccine equity. We know how to turn a national crisis into a national triumph — when the narrative fuels solutions, not cynicism. That is where the media comes in. You are not just storytellers. You are story-shapers. You can hold policymakers accountable while also giving voice to the underserved, platforming progress, and illuminating the moral argument behind reform. You can ask: 'What's broken?' — but also, 'What's possible?' The NHI will not succeed without the public's understanding and engagement. And the public cannot engage with what they do not hear or see. So, I invite you — editors, journalists, broadcasters, producers — to reposition and reclaim its role. Tell the truth, but tell the whole truth — frames narratives, which can either build trust or fuel scepticism, amplify voices, especially those often excluded — such as marginalised communities. In essence, your role isn't just to report on reforms like the NHI — you can influence whether society embraces or resists them. In the end, what will define us is not how loudly we argue but how we see our common humanity — and whether we act on it.
The Herald
2 days ago
- The Herald
'My eyes were burning': woman hospitalised after lash extension nightmare
Refilwe Motiang, a 31-year-old woman from Midrand, recently had a harrowing experience that almost left her blind. What was meant to be a pampering session at the salon turned into a nightmare. Last Thursday she went to the salon to get her eyelash extensions done in preparation for a trip to the North West. During the process she felt an intense burning sensation in her eyes, which she described as unbearable. 'My eyes were burning,' Motiang said. Despite informing the technician, she said she was told it was normal and the glue was strong to make the lashes last longer. However, the pain persisted and she soon found herself struggling to open her eyes, with excessive tearing and difficulty lifting her eyelids. 'I started feeling cold and shivering, then I asked to go outside. Next thing I was struggling to open my eyes. My eyes were tearing up and I was struggling to lift up my eyelids. That's when I realised something was bad.'
