DA posing a challenge to GNU internal resolution body
Image: Itumeleng English/ Independent Newspapers
The Government of National Unity's (GNU) Clearing House Mechanism, established to resolve policy disagreements within the 10-member coalition, has been questioned over its effectiveness by the DA and Rise Mzantsi.
Despite the mechanism's efforts to address disputes, the DA has continued to raise issues separately, including its latest challenge to the Expropriation Act, specifically the issue of nil compensation.
Recently DA federal council chairperson Helen Zille described the GNU clearing house mechanism as a "waste of time," stating that it does not work and "everyone acknowledges its ineffectiveness".
"What we need is a mechanism in the GNU to implement clauses 19 and 18 (in the terms of reference). We do not need to renegotiate the laws of the game or anything; what we need is mechanisms that implement the statement of intent," Zille said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
The DA has launched several court challenges since its inclusion in the GNU, including a challenge to the Employment Equity Amendment Act (EEAA) and the Expropriation Act.
The party argues that these laws are unconstitutional and will negatively impact the economy.
The DA's lawyers will appear in the North Gauteng High Court to challenge the EEAA, which the party believes will repel investors and discriminate against certain races.
The party has reaffirmed its firm rejection of expropriation without compensation, vowing to defend private property rights through both legal and legislative means.
The party's Federal Council has passed a motion supporting Section 25 of the Constitution, which states that compensation for expropriated property must be "just and equitable" as determined by a court of law.
The DA will pursue a constitutional challenge to the Expropriation Act in the High Court, arguing that it poses a direct threat to the rights enshrined in the Constitution and undermines the country's investment climate.
Rise Mzansi spokesperson Mabine Seabe said his party would like to see the Clearing House Mechanism terms of reference finalised, so that the body has full effect.
'The body is only as good as the terms of reference and the goodwill of the signatories to the Statement of Intent. We will continue working through all fora to ensure that South Africa is a better place in 2029 than it is today,' Seabe said.
The Good Party's Brett Herron said the Clearing House had only dealt with one substantive dispute - on the implementation of the BELA Act - which was raised by the DA in the first Clearing House meeting.
'Although we dealt with the BELA Act it was not, in our view, a matter that was appropriately brought to the Clearing House. The dispute should've arisen in the GNU cabinet or between the Party Leaders and then be referred to the Clearing House as a dispute resolution mechanism,' Herron said.
'The Expropriation Act has already been passed by the last parliament and signed into law by the President. It's a product of another election mandate.
'If the DA wants to persuade the GNU parties to amend policy on expropriation it should raise the issue in the cabinet or the GNU party leaders forum and if their proposal leads to a dispute or cannot be resolved there, then it could be referred to the Clearing House,' he said.
Herron further said the Clearing House was not the place for the DA to reopen debate on policies and laws that it had already lost.
'I think the Clearing House could be more effective as a structure if it was properly used by the GNU parties. That hasn't really happened yet,' Herron said.
Despite the parties' skepticism, the GNU Clearing House Mechanism, led by deputy president Paul Mashatile, has made efforts to address disputes within the GNU.
The mechanism held its inaugural meeting on October 16, 2024, where it welcomed the draft Terms of Reference and agreed to finalise them in the next meeting.
The meeting was convened by Mashatile, who emphasised the importance of resolving policy disagreements within the GNU.
Political analyst Dr John Molepo said the effectiveness of the GNU Clearing House Mechanism remains to be seen.
'While this mechanism has provided a platform for discussion and resolution of disputes, the DA's continued court challenges raise questions about its ability to address the complex issues at hand,' he said.
Mashatile's acting spokesperson was unavailable for comment on Tuesday.
mashudu.sadike@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
South Africa's proactive approach to finding new trade partners as US tariffs loom
Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen says the country was working on minimising the impact of the looming US 30% tariff hike on its exports. Image: Henk Kruger / Independent Newspapers South Africa is quickly expanding its global trade partners as a solution to the United States of America's 30% tariff on its exports, said Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen. Steenhuisen made the statement as the US tariff increase on South Africa is expected to come into effect on August 1. 'The real solution lies not just in playing defence, but in going on the offensive. This is why we are doubling down on market access expansion,' said Steenhuisen, who is the leader of the DA in the Government of National Unity. The tariff deadline will come as the country waits for the outcome of the proposed US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act of 2025, which seeks to impose sanctions against some ANC leaders accused of, among others, supporting China, Russia, and Iran, and mismanaging state resources. Delivering a keynote address at the RSA Group Stakeholder Dinner in Muldersdrift outside Johannesburg on Thursday, Steenhuisen said his department was reaching out to other countries looking for markets to sell the country's agricultural products. He called on the country not to waste time by being overly reliant, but to be productive. He said the country was already strengthening its trade alliances with the likes of Chile, Peru, and New Zealand 'to jointly lobby for fair and stable trade treatment of fresh produce' through the Southern Hemisphere Association of Fresh Fruit Exporters. 'Over the past six months alone, we have finalised new phytosanitary protocols for the export of avocados to China; table grapes to Vietnam and the Philippines; and maize to India,' he said. Steenhuisen said there were trade negotiations with Indonesia, Thailand, and Bangladesh. 'Our goal is simple — to ensure that no South African fruit producer is ever left dependent on the goodwill of a single trading partner.' He said the country was also strengthening its plant health systems, expanding traceability capabilities, and digitising its export certification platforms to align with the European Union's Green Deal and Asia's growing demand for sustainability-linked imports as part of 'investments that are not just defensive; they are the launchpad for new growth'. He said the country's agriculture has always been one of ingenuity, grit, and partnership. 'We have overcome political transitions, trade embargoes, droughts, pandemics, and port crises. We will overcome these current headwinds (tariff increase) too,' he said. Steenhuisen said that to avert the effects of new tariffs more quickly and effectively, the country must be united and pull together. 'My department is open for business, open for reform, and open for ideas,' he said. Steenhuisen said the tariffs will damage the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), which is set to expire in September and is already under threat of not being renewed due to strained relations between South Africa and the US. 'Let me be clear: South African agriculture did not deserve this treatment. We do not dump, we do not distort, and we do not play geopolitical games with food,' he said. He said the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (DTIC) was leading the country's formal engagement with the United States. 'And we continue to work hand in hand with Minister Tau and his team to ensure that the full impact on the agricultural sector is well understood,' he said. Soon after taking over the US presidency for the second time, Donald Trump came down heavy on South Africa by signing an Executive Order alleging that the country was mistreating its Afrikaner community by enabling genocide and passing oppressive policies. He also accused the country of being aggressive towards his country and its allies, 'including accusing Israel, not Hamas, of genocide in the International Court of Justice, and reinvigorating its relations with Iran to develop commercial, military, and nuclear arrangements'. 'The United States cannot support the government of South Africa's commission of rights violations in its country or its undermining of United States foreign policy, which poses national security threats to our Nation, our allies, our African partners, and our interests,' read the order. In reaction, Ramaphosa led a delegation, which comprised Steenhuisen and influential businessman Johann Rupert, to correct misinformation about Afrikaners' treatment and straighten the relationship with Trump's administration. However, the first phase of passing the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act of 2025, which, according to its author, US Congressman Ronny Jackson, seeks to punish ANC leaders, raised eyebrows. The act, which is now awaiting tabling at the full House of Representatives, accused the ANC's government leaders of undermining human rights by having a military and political relationship with the Russian government, which is at war with Ukraine. It accused the country of having allowed a US-sanctioned Russian cargo ship, the Lady R, to dock and transfer arms at a South African naval base in December 2022. 'The ANC published an article in their newspaper, ANC Today, in October 2024, promoting Russian propaganda about the war in Ukraine,' read the proposed act, which also accused ANC leaders of mismanaging Eskom and Transnet, and enabling the cholera outbreaks. University of South Africa's Thabo Mbeki African School of Public and International Affairs' international affairs expert, Dr Bongiwe Ngcobo, said the US actions were designed to force South Africa to abandon the International Court of Justice case against Israel on the Gaza conflict. She said South Africa's BRICS membership was also a concern for the US. 'If BRICS strengthen and grow, then it means they will have a challenger, and it means they will have less control over smaller countries like South Africa and other countries from the Global South,' she said. [email protected]
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Nomusa Dube-Ncube: a journey from KZN premier to deputy minister amid controversy and challenges
From holding MEC positions to becoming the first female premier of KwaZulu-Natal, Nomusa Dube-Ncube is now the new Deputy Minister of Higher Education and Training after Cyril Ramaphosa axed Nobuhle Nkabane and promoted Buti Manamela as Minister of Higher Education. KwaZulu-Natal's first female premier, Nomusa Dube-Ncube, takes over as new Deputy Minister of Higher Education and Training – despite her name appearing on the controversial list of Sector Education and Training Authority (Seta) board chairs that led to the removal of Nobuhle Nkabane as Higher Education and Training Minister. President Cyril Ramaphosa swore in Dube-Ncube as deputy minister and Buti Manamela as minister in Parliament on 22 July. Just a day before Dube-Ncube's appointment was announced on 21 July, her home in the suburb of Kloof in Durban was gutted by a fire. The Sunday World reported that the fire also damaged three cars belonging to her. Her family was unharmed. KZN born and bred Dube-Ncube was born and bred in KwaZulu-Natal (KZN); her political career bloomed in the province, and she holds a doctorate in administration from the University of KwaZulu-Natal. Before achieving her PhD – with a doctoral thesis titled 'Legislative and institutional arrangements for poverty alleviation in iLembe District Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa' – Dube-Ncube was actively involved in politics. She served as the mayor of the North Central council before it was merged into the eThekwini Metropolitan Municipality in 2000. She then served as chief whip of the eThekwini council until she was appointed ambassador to the Czech Republic. During her rise through the ranks, she was supported by the ANC Women's League. She was elected to the KZN legislature in May 2009 and appointed by former premier Zweli Mkhize as the MEC for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta). During this period, Dube-Ncube was very involved in governance matters; and encouraged councillors in KZN to use every budgeted cent, bearing in mind that accountability was the ultimate goal. Rotating through departments, she was appointed MEC for Economic Development, Tourism and Environmental Affairs in May 2019 by the newly elected premier, Sihle Zikalala. On 17 November 2020, Dube-Ncube was appointed MEC for Finance, replacing Ravi Pillay. Issues with the DA When she was still Cogta MEC, the Democratic Alliance (DA) demanded that Dube-Ncube be suspended, alleging Dube-Ncube awarded Brand Partners a communications tender at the Nkandla municipality in December 2017. The letter issued by the DA's Zwakele Mncwango said the contract was worth more than R7.5-million. In a Timeslive article, it was mentioned that Sibusiso Justin Ncube, her deceased husband, was a director of the Brand Partners and had allegedly raked in millions in contracts and tenders. Dube‑Ncube sued Mncwango for R1.5-million for defamation, over his allegation that the Brand Partners tender constituted 'massive corruption'. Then the EFF wasted no time firing shots at Dube-Ncube when she was appointed as KZN premier following Zikalala's resignation after he lost the contest for provincial ANC chair. The EFF's Vusi Khoza reminded Dube-Ncube that under her leadership as Cogta MEC, municipalities collapsed and traditional leaders went unpaid. He also criticised her stint as economic development MEC, pointing out that youth unemployment remained high. Khoza demanded answers about R250-million in drought-relief funds that went missing under her watch. The Hawks and NPA have been probing the matter since 2019, with Dube-Ncube reportedly under investigation. She has, however, dismissed these allegations. When she was premier, Dube-Ncube faced backlash over a collapsing R2.1-billion programme meant to feed more than 2.4 million learners in KZN. Supply delivery was so poor that it triggered a special inquiry into provider accountability and distribution processes. In 2023, Mail & Guardian reported that former ANC KZN chair Siboniso Duma upstaged Dube-Ncube by lifting the Rugby World Cup trophy during the Springboks' victory tour. After her appointment as premier, Duma frequently appeared on government platforms, subtly reminding everyone that he, not Dube-Ncube, was elected as ANC provincial chair. The ANC Women's League stepped in, criticising Duma and triggering a tense clash with the provincial ANC leadership – a conflict many saw as inevitable. Dube-Ncube appeared unfazed. Dube-Ncube was succeeded as premier by Thami Ntuli of the Inkatha Freedom Party following the 2024 provincial election. The Seta list The controversial Seta board chair appointments included the likes of Gwede Mantashe's son Buyambo and former ANC KZN deputy chairperson Mike Mabuyakhulu. Dube-Ncube was listed as the chair for the banking sector Seta (BankSeta). Former minister Nkabane was pressured to withdraw the appointments after MPs labelled them 'corrupt' and amid a public outcry. Spokesman for the Presidency, Vincent Magwenya, told Newzroom Afrika that Dube-Ncube could not 'be held responsible for being proposed and suggested to be appointed to the Seta board. The fact that she is a member of the ANC does not necessarily disqualify her in terms of her leadership experience and the prerequisite qualifications that are required. She has a long government experience, having served in various provisional executive portfolios and having been the Premier of KwaZulu-Natal, and so the President does have a great deal of confidence in her ability to discharge her duties.' ANC Chief Whip Sedukanelo Louw said the party welcomed Dube's appointment, recognising her as a committed servant of the people. 'It is important for us to refrain from criticising her appointment, as we must acknowledge that she possesses the necessary skills and experience to perform her duties effectively. […] Throughout her career, she has demonstrated a strong commitment to improving the lives of our community members, advocating for their needs, and addressing the challenges they face,' Louw said. DM
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Letter to Mahlamba Ndlopfu — this week you finally found your backbone
Ah, Chief Dwasaho! We do, indeed, live in interesting times, my President. This week, you finally found your backbone, possibly somewhere under the presidential mattress at Phala Phala Game Reserve, and 'removed' someone from your bloated Cabinet. Hhawu, Matamela! You? Fire someone? And not just anyone – uGal herself! Minister Dr Nobuhle Nkabane, once the proud guardian of our nation's knowledge factories, is now reduced to a political footnote without a farewell bouquet. Did you not know, my leader, that 'Brand' Nkabane was a lifetime in the making? A carefully curated blend of ambition, gloss and Instagrammable grace. But alas, what the ancestors giveth, live television taketh away. I cannot unsee that fatal moment: the Honourable Minister's jaws in motion, chewing bubble gum with the vigour of a teenager bunking maths class, right there in Parliament's sacred halls. I am still flabbergasted. No song, no victory dance Sadly, my leader, the people of South Africa aren't exactly ululating in praise. No victory songs are being sung in taverns or taxi ranks. They murmur that you did not act with the urgency that the moment required. Clearly, they don't know you; Brand Matamela! Let's talk about Andrew Whitfield of the Democratic Alliance (DA), shall we? You took four full moons – yes, four – to remove him from the position of deputy minister of trade, industry and competition after he went AWOL overseas, armed with nothing but a passport and without your presidential blessing. That's right; there was no leave, no permission, just right-wing vibes. And yet, you dithered like a man trying to remember where he last saw his iPad. Seta saga But when it comes to former minister Dr Nobuhle Nkabane – a whole black woman with a hard-earned doctorate – you moved her faster than a Gupta jet fleeing from Air Force Base Waterkloof en route to Dubai. Why the haste, Matamela? What did she do that was so egregious? They say her great crime occurred last month when her panel, appointed to oversee the selection of 21 chairpersons and board members for the Sector Education and Training Authority (Seta) boards, wobbled under relentless public scrutiny. And yes, the 'panel' disappeared quicker than bubble gum dissolving under parliamentary questioning. But really, was that her fault? All she did was remain on brand: deploy cadres and flood the state with African National Congress (ANC) acolytes. In that regard, she followed the sacred text. Just like the Gauteng Department of Health, which has transformed hospital boards into halfway houses for ANC Youth League (ANCYL) 'leaders' with the so-called requisite experience – which, in plain British English, means they once handed out flyers at a branch general meeting four years ago. Whitfield, who? My leader, I hadn't heard of former deputy minister Whitfield before you pulled the trigger. I had to Google the poor chap to ensure he wasn't a backup flyhalf for the Stormers. But Nkabane, now she caught my attention. Not her policies, her speeches, but her honourable reference to Brand Nobuhle Pamela Nkabane after the sirens muted and the blue lights dimmed. I must admit that line stuck with me. It turns out she worked hard for her 'Brand'. A brand built, not on competence or clean governance, but on chewing gum, cadre deployment and curated photo ops. But hey, that is the core of the ANC Brand, right? At least, my President, there's a little cheer in the room. The DA applauded your axing of Dr Nkabane and hastily announced their support for your 2025/26 Budget proposals. What a relief, neh? Baas John Steenhuisen finally gave you the thumbs-up – for now. Perhaps this is what it takes: sacrifice a gum-chewing comrade on the altar of fiscal stability, voilà, and Budget passed. While you're at it, my leader, please send more moola to Tembisa Hospital. It appears comrades there need urgent funds, not for scalpels or syringes, mind you, but for legal fees. Word on the street is some need money for protection from the 28s in prison. Kubi. Theatre of the absurd But what truly baffles me, Comrade Leadership, is the theatre of the absurd now playing out in Parliament's far-left corner – the uMkhonto Wesizwe party caucus. His Worship – sorry, my bad, he now prefers the minimalist title, Dr Mandlakayise John Hlophe – is lobbing fireballs from the backbenches. He's throwing everything but the Nkandla kitchen sink, demanding your removal as if you'd misplaced your oath of office behind the Phala Phala wildlife sofa. And why? Because you had the gall to discipline a minister who got caught being clumsy. I mean, how dare Nkabane get caught? The problem was never the panel; it's that she failed to make it disappear properly. Meanwhile, Honourable Hlophe, a man well versed in being removed, has resurfaced with fury. He wants to know why you haven't also thrown the 'on-leave' minister of police, Senzo Mchunu, to the wolves. He said axing Minister Nkabane was nothing more than appeasing your favourite fiscal gatekeeper, DA leader Baas John Steenhuisen. Is this what we've become, Matamela? A democracy of musical chairs? You remove me, I remove you, and then we all fall. A festival of removals, funded by taxpayers and staged in press briefings and parliamentary plenaries? The poisoned chalice My leader, tell me – did another black woman with a doctorate sip from the poisoned chalice this week? Or shall we say, benefit from it? Was she not mentioned in the great Seta Saga not too long ago? The optics, Matamela, are terrible – like fishnet stockings at a funeral. You removed a black woman, Minister Dr Nobuhle Nkabane, ostensibly for deploying ANC acolytes to the Seta boards. Yet, you turned around, straight-faced, and did the same, just with different comrades and newer name tags. Of sins, PhDs and Buti Manamela And the real kicker? You replaced a woman who had curated an entire political 'brand' with a man with a funny name, Buti Manamela, a wannabe communist. If his ancestors wanted him to be minister, they could have given him a better name, like Manamela Manamela. See, it got groove. But not just any man – a black man, yes – but then you tossed in Nomusa Dube-Ncube, a doctorate-wielding woman, red regalia and all, into the role of Deputy Minister. Are you for real, Matamela? A whole PhD holder who reports to a minister, who answers to a Cabinet, that you only occasionally control? What is this? A Game of Thrones spinoff sponsored by National Treasury and shot in downtown Johannesburg? You axed one for alleged sins and rewarded another despite the same allegations clinging to their robes like stubborn chewing gum. So, who's fooling whom here, Comrade Leadership? Murder scene mentorships Honestly, my leader, you've had a far better week than the self-styled Sushi King, Patriotic Alliance deputy president Kenny Kunene. The former prisoner turned 'businessman' turned politician found himself – wait for it – not in the Johannesburg Council Chamber, not on a panel, but at the plush Sandton residence of one Katiso 'KT' Molefe, the alleged mastermind behind the murder of DJ Sumbody, real name Oupa Sefoka. The timing couldn't have been better: as Kunene arrived, the police swooped in to rearrest Molefe. Netflix dreams and empires Now, you'd think most public figures would have the good sense to socially distance themselves from murder suspects. But not Comrade Kunene. No, he embarked on an unbothered, unrepentant media tour, armed with a bold story that deserves a Netflix deal. According to him, he was accompanying a young journalist – a prodigy, no less – who's set to inherit his entire publishing empire, African News Global. This bright-eyed scribe, we are told, needed to interview Molefe, who, by the way, is awaiting trial in another murder case. The goal? To give 'Mr Sandton Businessman' a fair chance to respond to the allegations. I must confess: I, too, hope to have a mentor like Kenny Kunene one day. A man of means, morals and murder-scene meet-and-greets. A comrade who will hold my hand as I interview alleged killers. How tender. Not my chommie And to be clear, Kunene doesn't know Molefe. They're not friends, not associates, not comrades. Sound familiar? Just strangers in a lounge where the bloodstains are still fresh in the air. Nothing to see here, folks. Aah Leadership, July is the longest year since the Gregorian calendar was invented. Till next week, my man. Send me to Sandton to interview a murder suspect. DM
