Ohio's HB 6 utility scandal gets true-crime treatment in HBO film
Last week, HBO released a documentary that covers the long, sordid saga, which led to the federal criminal convictions of a former speaker of the Ohio House of Representatives and a former head of the Ohio Republican Party.
'The Dark Money Game: Ohio Confidential' follows the story of how utility companies used roughly $60 million in bribes to public officials to secure more than $1.5 billion in ratepayer subsidies for aging, uneconomical coal and nuclear plants.
Canary Media contributing reporter Kathiann Kowalski has spent more than a decade covering the House Bill 6 saga and Ohio utilities' other efforts to get ratepayer-funded bailouts. Dan Haugen, a senior editor at Canary Media, recently spoke with Kowalski about her reactions to the new film.
The following transcript has been edited slightly for length and clarity.
Haugen: So, you watched this new HBO documentary "Ohio Confidential" the other day. What about it is still on your mind today?
Kowalski: I was struck by the focus they used of how dark money and gerrymandering undermined voters' will in the wake of a 2010 Supreme Court case that opened the door for unlimited corporate spending on political campaigns, subject to few conditions.
Haugen: Was there any factual information that wasn't previously reported by you or others?
Kowalski: A lot of it was very familiar, given the fact that I had read through most of the exhibits, read Neil Clark's book, gone to part of the trial, and been following this for years. There was an interesting scene where they were able to get footage of the FBI observing a private detective that former Ohio GOP Chair Matt Borges and company had apparently retained to follow Tyler Fehrman, who was a witness in the federal criminal case.
Haugen: Did the film change your understanding of the HB 6 story in any way?
Kowalski: They did a decent job connecting some dots. I had not thought through how former Ohio House Speaker Larry Householder's actions also enabled a far-right coalition in the Legislature to push through an anti-abortion law in 2019. It gave me a broader perspective on the anti-democracy angle of the public corruption, but my understanding of the basic story did not change.
Haugen: Where did the abortion legislation appear on the timeline?
Kowalski: The way that the filmmaker presents it is that once Householder helped these people get the anti-abortion legislation passed, he then had people who felt they owed him something. I looked at the timing, and Gov. Mike DeWine signed the anti-abortion legislation the day before House Bill 6 was introduced.
Haugen: One of the biggest unknowns still today is what, if any, role the governor's office had in all this. You and others have reported on a December 2018 dinner with FirstEnergy executives, DeWine, and Jon Husted, just weeks before the latter two took office as governor and lieutenant governor. Neither has been charged nor accused of any wrongdoing. Does the film shed any new light on their connections?
Kowalski: The filmmakers include an allegation of $5 million going from FirstEnergy to help elect DeWine. And they note a disclaimer from DeWine's office that it was all within the confines of what was allowed under the law. That's basically about all they did. It was not a deep dive into the governor's actions or Husted, who was recently appointed to fill Vice President JD Vance's U.S. Senate seat. I think maybe they wanted to keep their story tightly focused on the Legislature and what has been proven in the first federal criminal case. That also avoids having to include more disclaimers about how nothing's been proven against others, everybody denies wrongdoing, etc., etc.
Haugen: Did anything in this film make you smile or laugh?
Kowalski: A couple things. First, it starts off with actor Michael Imperioli reading an excerpt from lobbyist Neil Clark's tell-all book, which was published after Clark, who had been criminally charged for his role in the HB 6 scandal, died by suicide in 2021. The fact that Imperioli is famous for roles in Goodfellas and The Sopranos just struck me as a wonderful bit of filmmaking irony. There were also some scenes about whistleblower Tyler Fehrman meeting with the FBI or Matt Borges. The locations included Graeter's Ice Cream and a Starbucks, and so the film has scenes of people working in those places. It made me think, well, gee, if you had included Dewine and Husted's dinner with the FirstEnergy executives, you could have shown the inside of the Athletic Club of Columbus or its menu or storefront or something.
Haugen: So is this something you would recommend that your readers watch?
Kowalski: Yes. It's compelling storytelling. It does a good job of explaining things in plain terms. There's a limited cast of characters, and you can follow the story. If House Bill 6 is new to you, it's definitely worth watching. And it's certainly important now as we're looking at not only the continued use of dark money in politics through either nonprofits or limited liability corporations, but also, with technology, likely more ways to cover up potential bribes. So, yes, people should be aware of this.
The Dark Money Game: Ohio Confidential is streaming now on MAX. For occasional HB 6 updates from Kathiann Kowalski, subscribe to our Ohio Utility Watch newsletter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
7 hours ago
- USA Today
Detective on 'Yogurt Shop Murders' is 'confident' he'll solve 34-year-old cold case
In 1991, four teenage girls were killed at a frozen yogurt shop in Austin, then roughly half the size the booming city is now. Eliza Thomas, 17, Amy Ayers, 13, and sisters Jennifer Harbison, 17, and Sarah Harbison, 15, were fatally shot at I Can't Believe It's Yogurt!, formerly located in North Austin. The girls were then set on fire. Nearly 34 years later, the case remains unsolved, and the person(s) responsible walk free, if they're even alive. The grizzly crime, its impact on the victims' families and the decades-long search for the perpetrator(s) are chronicled in HBO's four-part docuseries, 'The Yogurt Shop Murders,' that premiered Aug. 3 (weekly Sundays, 10 ET/PT). Academy Award-winning actor Emma Stone and her husband Dave McCary are executive producers of the project directed by Margaret Brown. Reese Price, the shop's manager recalls the horror of identifying the girls so their families wouldn't have to. Price was just 24 at the time. 'There wasn't anything there to identify,' she remembers in the docuseries. 'Fire is very destructive. It's not forgiving.' Archival footage puts viewers at the yogurt shop on the night of the killings, and Brown says there are 'characters in our show (who) have never talked to anyone else, and we have some facts in our show that have never been explored.' She adds, 'These people went through something so specifically awful, but I do think there's something in that for everyone. We're all going to experience pain, and I felt like for me, this was a way to look at this fascinating case, at the same time an exploration of how do people deal with something this hard (and) what can we learn from that?' Brown remembers when she moved to Austin in the late '90s when she says billboards asking for information on the case plastered the sky. One of the reasons she signed on for the project is 'because a lot of my friends who are crime reporters said this is the most interesting crime that exists,' Brown says in an interview. 'There's not one with more rabbit holes. This is the mothership of interesting crime.' Rumors linger in the city like Texas summer heat, Brown says. 'Before I talked to you, some woman wrote me on Instagram (saying) she solved it,' Brown says. 'I think that people are obsessed with it.' In 2022, Detective Dan Jackson was assigned the case on his first day with the Austin Police Department's cold case unit. The 45-year-old who was raised about 30 miles southwest of Austin in San Marcos remembers hearing about the murders as a child. 'It's such a huge case,' Jackson tells USA TODAY. 'I sort of knew at that point I would be with it forever.' When asked about why the case remains open today Jackson points to the crime scene and potential evidence scorched by fire and drenched by hoses to extinguish the blaze. Two men were previously found guilty in connection to the crimes. Robert Springsteen received a death sentence in 2001 for killing Ayers, and Michael Scott was sentenced to life for the death of Ayers the following year. But their convictions were overturned. Scott and Springsteen declined to be in the docuseries, Brown says. But Springsteen is captured in footage previously filmed for another project around 2009. Springsteen shocks a sales associate helping him find clothes for an interview and court when he says, 'I'm sure you probably think it's really funny, but we're doing a documentary because I just got off death row.' A DNA sample from the crime scene belongs to neither Scott nor Springsteen. Jackson is hoping to build a profile from the sample that leads him to a suspect. 'One of the things that we want the public to know is that this case is active,' he says. 'It's constantly worked on.' And Jackson remains optimistic as forensic technology continues to improve. 'If I didn't think I could solve it then why get up every day?' he says. 'I think that with new technology, new information that we have − that I can't go into − even since I've taken the case over, the ability to do more with less when it comes to forensics is light years ahead than it was a few years ago. When I started, we needed a certain amount (of DNA). We weren't even close to it, but that amount that you need is so much less now.' He adds, 'I am confident that I will solve this.' He's also hopeful that the docuseries could lead to the tip that cracks open the case. 'Somebody out there knows something,' he says. 'That's one of the things with cold cases is that you do get people overtime that, for whatever reason, may not have been willing to come forward years ago that now feel more comfortable. Or they thought it was something small and didn't ever say anything and they're like well, maybe I should call in this time and mention it. Who knows? It could be the break we need.' If you have any information about the case, visit or send an email to yogurtshop@
Time Magazine
9 hours ago
- Time Magazine
What to Know About The Yogurt Shop Murders on HBO
Thirty-three years ago, what was meant to be a sweet trip to a frozen yogurt shop in Austin, Texas, turned into a tragedy when four girls were fatally shot on Dec. 6, 1991. Amy Ayers, Jennifer Harbison, Sarah Harbison, and Eliza Thomas, all teenagers between the ages of 13 and 17, were killed and stripped of their clothing in a room in the back of the shop, before the place was set on fire. The case, which has remained unsolved for decades, is the subject of a new HBO documentary, The Yogurt Shop Murders, directed by Margaret Brown. In four episodes, premiering Sundays starting Aug. 3, the series explores all of the possible theories about who murdered the girls. It features interviews with investigators—and their interviews with the suspects—the victims' family members, and rare footage of the suspects filmed by a local Austin documentary filmmaker, Claire Huie. Exactly why these four girls were murdered is still unknown. 'I would be at parties, and people would just start talking about the yogurt shop murders,' Brown, an Austin native, says. 'It's part of the mythos of Austin, part of the collective memory, the fabric of the city. Everyone has a theory.' Here's what to know about the first episode of The Yogurt Shop Murders. A key arrest The first episode of The Yogurt Shop Murders opens with Huie's footage of a man named Robert Springsteen going shopping for a suit at a Macy's. He tells the salesperson he's just gotten off death row and is looking for sharp clothes for an interview with CBS's investigative show 48 Hours and various court appearances. The scene teases that viewers will learn how Springsteen became a free man in the next episodes. He was named about a week after the shooting, when police arrested his friend, Maurice Pierce, 16, who was carrying a loaded pistol in the waistband of his jeans in the Northcross Mall Plaza near the I Can't Believe It's Yogurt! shop. It was the same type of gun that police were looking for since they found a bullet in a sink at the yogurt shop. When Pierce was questioned, he did not admit guilt, but he gave up the names of other guys he had been hanging out with the night of the shooting: Michael Scott, Springsteen, and Forrest Welborn. Pierce said Forrest asked to borrow his gun and came back sweaty and smelling of hairspray. The next day, the four boys stole a car and drove to San Antonio to see a girl, and when they returned, Maurice said Forrest asked for the gun again. When Maurice asked why, he said Forrest told him that he wanted to kill more girls like he did the night before. Viewers will hear a police recording of Maurice asking Forrest point blank if he killed the girls, and Forrest claiming he was joking and assuring him, 'I wouldn't lie to you.' Police also never found evidence to prove he killed the girls. The mess at the crime scene is one key reason why this case remains unsolved. Police did not have physical evidence to link these four boys to the crime, though they did make sure they got swabs from the girls for future DNA testing. There was no video footage at the store, and the crime scene was covered in water from extinguishing the fire, making it difficult to find fingerprints and evidence that are not contaminated. And while police could track credit card transactions at the store, they couldn't track people who paid in cash. The leading theory about the yogurt shop murders among law enforcement is that it was a robbery gone wrong. Families still traumatized In the first episode, the families of the victims recall Dec. 6, 1991, like it was yesterday. Eliza Thomas's sister Sonora recalls her teeth chattering uncontrollably when she heard the news and having to put her hand in her mouth to stop her teeth from chattering. She remembers vividly the awkwardness of telling her divorced parents the news of their daughter's death. Sonora remembers nervously cleaning the house while her mother locked herself in her bedroom, refusing to even come out and talk to the police. During her first night sleeping without her sister nearby, Sonora Thomas recalls thinking, 'I've never woken up on a day when my sister wasn't alive.' Shawn Ayers misses his sister Amy every day, saying, 'not one day that I don't think of her.' Pam Ayers thinks of her daughter Amy every time she sees kids and animals, as Amy and the three other girls were part of Future Farmers of America. Barbara Ayres-Wilson, mother of Jennifer and Sarah Harbison, has been speaking publicly about the murders since losing her daughters, hoping it would help law enforcement solve the case sooner. She recalls that Jennifer and Sarah were in such a good mood the day they died, excited to go to the yogurt shop, where Jennifer worked. She saw them off and got a hug from each of the girls and reminded them to be careful. And yet, she still wonders if there is anything she could have done differently, stating, 'You just have all of these regrets of not protecting [them]...How could someone be and then not be?'
New York Post
12 hours ago
- New York Post
How to watch new HBO true crime doc ‘The Yogurt Shop Murders': Time, release schedule
New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you click or buy through our links. Featured pricing is subject to change. A new documentary series shedding new light on a still-unsolved 1991 quadruple homicide is heading to HBO and HBO Max. 'The Yogurt Shop Murders,' which will air over four weeks beginning tonight, Aug. 3, 'explores law enforcement practices and raises complex questions about press coverage and the power of suggestion on memory,' per an HBO release. The doc covers the brutal murders of four teenage girls in an Austin, Texas frozen yogurt shop in December 1991. Four teenage boys were questioned and arrested, with confessions obtained from two of the young men leading to convictions. New DNA evidence got them released on bond after serving nine years and charges were dropped. Advertisement News coverage and archival footage of the families and suspects will help 'recognize the importance of storytelling to help in healing and explore the fragility and the resilience of the mind – in preserving memories, coping with loss, and remaining convinced of one's own innocence.' 'the yogurt shop murders': what to know When: Aug. 3, 10 p.m. ET Aug. 3, Channel: HBO HBO Streaming: HBO Max The new docuseries comes to HBO from A24 and Fruit Tree, the production company founded by Emma Stone and her husband, Dave McCary. What time does 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' come out on HBO and HBO Max? Advertisement 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' comes out at 10 p.m. ET tonight, Aug. 3, on HBO. The episode will release at the same time on HBO's HBO Max streaming service. 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' episode guide and release schedule: 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' is a four-part documentary series, with the episodes airing over the next four weeks. Episode 1: 'Fire and Water' – Aug. 3, 10 p.m. ET – Aug. 3, 10 p.m. ET Episode 2: 'The Fifth Victim' – Aug. 10, 10 p.m. ET – Aug. 10, 10 p.m. ET Episode 3: 'Mental Evidence' – Aug. 17, 10 p.m. ET – Aug. 17, 10 p.m. ET Episode 4: 'In Your Own Time' – Aug. 24, 10 p.m. ET How to watch 'The Yogurt Shop Murders': If you don't have HBO through a cable provider, you'll need a HBO Max subscription to watch 'The Yogurt Shop Murders.' Advertisement HBO Max is available to subscribe to via Prime Video starting at $9.99/month with ads. It costs $16.99/month if you want to go ad-free. That's not the only way to subscribe, though. Sling TV offers some of the best value for money among live tv streaming services, thanks to some great offers. You'll need Sling's Blue plan with a HBO Max add-on to watch HBO live (and you can still stream on-demand with HBO Max). Plus, when you subscribe to HBO Max through Sling, the money-saving never stops! You'll get 50% off your first month, plus $5 off your bill every month after that. 'The Yogurt Shop Murders' trailer: Why Trust Post Wanted by the New York Post This article was written by Angela Tricarico, Commerce Streaming Reporter for Post Wanted Shopping, Page Six, and New York Post's streaming property, Decider. Angela keeps readers up to date with cord-cutter-friendly deals, and information on how to watch your favorite sports teams, TV shows, and movies on every streaming service. Not only does Angela test and compare the streaming services she writes about to ensure readers are getting the best prices, but she's also a superfan specializing in the intersection of shopping, tech, sports, and pop culture. Prior to joining Decider and The New York Post in 2023, she wrote about streaming and consumer tech at Insider Reviews
