Fans slam the AFL for naming the first women to the league's Hall of Fame - but NOT because of their gender
Phillips - who won three AFLW premierships and three All-Australian nods in her time with the Crows and Power - provided the highlight of Tuesday night's ceremony with an emotional acceptance speech.
Pearce - who now works for Channel Seven in addition to coaching West Coast's women's side - won an AFLW premiership and became a three-time All Australian with the Melbourne Demons.
Fans voiced their shock at their induction as Pearce only retired from playing in 2022, with Phillips doing the same in 2023.
The AFL's guidelines on the Hall of Fame state that 'players are only eligible after they have been retired from the game for at least five years'.
However, an exception was made for AFLW players in June last year that makes them eligible after just one year in retirement.
Footy supporters couldn't deny Daisy Pearce (pictured) is a giant of the women's game - but had issues with the fact she was inducted after only retiring as a player in 2022
Some fans went online to slam the AFL when Phillips and Pearce's inductions were made official.
'I would never deny her impact on the women's game, but hasn't she been retired for 5 minutes? It took Gary Ablet Sr 8 years to be inducted, Erin less than 2 years? Over 1000 goals vs 50. 250 games vs 50 odd?' one wrote.
'Congrats to her on her induction. But didn't she only retire last year & isn't the criteria 5 years retired?' another added, referring to Phillips.
'Well I expect Dusty to be in next year and made a legend the year after if this is how quick it's going to be inducted,' wrote a third, referring to Richmond great Dustin Martin, who retired last season.
'Someone correct me if I'm wrong but… aint the whole AFLW too early for hall of famers?' another commenter said.
'66 games makes you a first ballot HOF'er? Have a look at the players from the 80s and 90s who have played 300+ games, multiple premierships and other accolades, and they will probably never get a guernsey,' one fan said, referring to Phillips.
'Let the league develop more... it started in 2017 and there's already people getting into a HOF? Relax and bit and pull the hand brake up,' another wrote.
Some reactions to Pearce's honour questioned why she was being inducted given she is still employed in the game as Eagles coach, with comments like, 'Genuine question, is an active head coach allowed to be inducted?'
Other fans questioned whether Pearce and Phillips met the criteria for making the Hall of Fame - which they both did courtesy of a change to the rules in June last year
Phillips (pictured at Tuesday night's Hall of Fame ceremony) is the most honoured player in women's footy history
However, Simon Goodwin was inducted as a player in 2017, when he was coaching the Melbourne Demons, and Sam Mitchell was inducted in 2023 when he had already started coaching Hawthorn.
Phillips' father Greg is a Port Adelaide legend and her words to him during her speech were a high point of the ceremony.
'To Dad, I can't imagine how hard it would have been to tell your 13-year-old daughter that she couldn't play the game she loves anymore,' she said, her voice breaking.
'And 27 years later, she's standing next to you in the Hall of Fame.'
In her speech, Phillips also thanked the 'incredible women' who made the AFLW possible and singled out trailblazer Debbie Lee.
'You kicked down this door so others could walk through,' she said. 'I'm so proud to be by your side and I can't wait to kick down more doors with you Deb.'
Pearce's last AFLW game was the Melbourne 2022 grand final victory and she called it the best day of her life, even though her twin children Sylvie and Roy were in the room, hamming it up for the TV cameras.
'It's controversial to say this, as a mother ... don't get me wrong, they're the best thing that's ever happened to me, but on a technicality, the day itself is not that good,' she said.
'Give me grand final day every day of the week.'
Phillips was Adelaide's inaugural captain and the first women's best and fairest winner, playing in three Crows flags despite needing a knee reconstruction.
She then switched to Port Adelaide when they joined the league in 2022.
When the women's league started in 2017, marquee players such as Pearce and Phillips were crucial for its profile and credibility.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Animal rights activists PETA target footy WAGs with demand for bizarre clothing ban
Animal rights activists have called for a complete ban on feathers on the red carpet ahead of the AFL's Brownlow Medal ceremony in September. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) recently penned an open letter to Daniel Pendergast, the Senior Event Executive at the AFL to make the demand. The glamour social event is often dubbed the 'Gownlows' due to the focus on the eye-catching outfits worn by the partners of the country's biggest footy stars. Mimi Bekhechi, PETA's Senior Campaigns Advisor, doesn't want to see any gowns featuring feathers or fur at this year's footy night of nights. 'The Brownlow Medal awards the fairest and best, but there's nothing remotely fair about birds being live plucked, factory farmed and killed for their feathers,' Bekhechi said in a statement. 'We urge the AFL to make real birds' feathers as unwelcome on the Brownlow red carpet as cheating is on the field.' It comes after PETA called on the Western Bulldogs to retire their mascots and change the club's name last September. PETA's complaint pointed to the AFL club's 'deformed' mascots, Caesar and Sunny, who attend every home game dressed in Bulldogs attire. Bekhechi issued a letter to Bulldogs president Kylie Watson-Wheeler in which she urged the club to recognise health issues with the bulldogs breed, suggesting the club should change their name to the 'Western Mutts' to promote animal wellbeing. PETA believe the use of bulldogs Caesar and Sunny 'normalises and advocates for the breeding of breathing-impaired breeds of dogs who suffer severe health problems and deformities.' 'Extremely short snouts spell suffering,' Bekhechi said in the letter. 'By showcasing Caesar and Sunny at games and events and promoting their breeder, the team is – however unwittingly – supporting the intentional breeding of dogs with painful and debilitating deformities.' PETA offered to contribute to rebranding costs, arguing by changing its name the club would promote homeless animals. 'We have a suggestion that will modernise the Western Bulldogs' image: retire Caesar and Sunny and rename the club the "Western Mutts",' PETA said in the letter. The animal welfare group said the Western Bulldogs should not use 'deformed' Caesar (pictured) as a mascot at home games in Melbourne 'By not promoting breathing impaired dog breeds (BIB)...you would avoid normalising their suffering and instead help champion loveable and unique mixed-breed dogs, who typically live longer and are healthier than their flat-faced cousins. 'By relinquishing Caesar and Sunny's mascot duties to your willing human costumed mascots and renaming the team the 'Western Mutts', you would be taking a stand against the 'pedigree' dog–breeding industry while championing the adoption of wonderful mixed breeds and other homeless animals.' At the time, the Western Bulldogs chose not to comment on the matter.
Reuters
12 hours ago
- Reuters
Piardi call in Australia-Lions test should be accepted, Erasmus says
July 29 (Reuters) - South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus believes the decision to award the British & Irish Lions a series-winning try in last weekend's 29-26 win, opens new tab over Australia was "touch-and-go" but World Rugby's explanation of the contentious call should be accepted. The Lions won the test with a try from Hugo Keenan in the final seconds but Australia believe a ruling from referee Andrea Piardi at a ruck immediately beforehand was incorrect. Australia coach Joe Schmidt said the call was an error in his post-match press conference, suggesting Jac Morgan's clear-out of Carlo Tizzano was dangerous, and Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh said he would seekg "accountability" from World Rugby over it. But Erasmus, who received a two-month ban from World Rugby for a 62-minute video that was critical of Australian referee Nic Berry after the first Lions test in South Africa in 2021, said he could see both sides of the argument. "I had Australia (winning) by four points in the game, so I lost our internal (coach's competition) on that one," Erasmus told reporters with a smile on Tuesday. "It's such a tough decision. World Rugby has come out to say it was the right decision. It was a very tough call for the referee to make. "If I was Joe, I would be really disappointed, and if I was (Lions coach) Andy (Farrell), I would be really happy. I think it was touch-and-go, so I can understand both sides of what each coach sees. "But World Rugby has ruled on it and that is what everybody has to accept." World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin backed the call from Piardi earlier on Tuesday. "We do share with Joe and the coaching team why the match officials made that decision," he said. "Joe's got a view about what was wrong with that decision and there'll be a debate so that Joe and his players can go into the next test understanding how that game's going to be officiated." South Africa will host Australia in two Rugby Championship tests in Johannesburg and Cape Town next month. Italian Piardi will officiate the defending champion Springboks' final match in the competition against Argentina in London in October.
Telegraph
13 hours ago
- Telegraph
Joe Schmidt hits back at Carlo Tizzano ‘dive' critics: ‘He suffered a high-magnitude impact'
Joe Schmidt has hit back at critics of Carlo Tizzano by claiming the Australia flanker suffered a 'high-magnitude impact' as a result of Jac Morgan's controversial clear-out in the second Test. The Australia head coach was speaking just hours after he was admonished by World Rugby for his initial comments about the incident. Australia were incensed that Morgan was not penalised for his clear-out on Tizzano, the replacement Wallabies flanker, in the ruck preceding Hugo Keenan's winning try in the second Test. HUGO KEENAN WINS IT FOR THE LIONS! 🦁 — Sky Sports (@SkySports) July 26, 2025 Referee Andrea Piardi reviewed the clear-out but deemed it was a 'rugby' incident, which effectively clinched a series victory for the Lions. That prompted Schmidt to not only criticise Piardi's decision but to allege that it undermined World Rugby's messaging on player welfare. While Schmidt will escape any formal sanction, his comments drew short shrift from Alan Gilpin, World Rugby's chief executive, who called on coaches to remember the impact their actions have on officials. 'While, from a World Rugby perspective, we always say we do not publicly comment on match officials' decisions, given the nature of the commentary surrounding last weekend, we just want to express our support for the match officials involved,' Gilpin said at an event for the 2027 Rugby World Cup ticketing launch. 'There is no other position on the field that is under the scrutiny our match officials are under, and yet they do an incredible job under that pressure in a live environment. I think it is fair to say that when the refereeing groups review decisions, they review them with the coaches and across the game. We are always proud to support our officials in that review process and that is what we are doing now and in the coming days with our colleagues from Australia and the Lions.' The Lions always felt confident in the legality of Morgan's clear-out and many felt Tizzano exaggerated the impact of the collision by dramatically collapsing to the floor holding his head. However, Schmidt hit back at accusations that Tizzano dived by revealing that his instrumented mouthguard registered a significant force from Morgan's clear-out. 'Talking about the instrumental mouthguards, with Carlo when he was hit, I feel sorry for him because I think he's copping a lot of flak, but that impact was almost double what they determine as a high-magnitude impact,' Schmidt told Stan Sports. 'So that's the degree of force that he had to wear, and that in itself is enough to force someone to recoil as he did. He's had a pretty sore neck for the last 24-48 hours, but he's back, he's resilient, and he's looking forward to the weekend.' Despite Schmidt's complaints – which were endorsed by Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh – World Rugby are understood to be confident that Piardi made the right decision. The wider issue, in their view, is the heightened scrutiny officials are placed under for making marginal decisions. In the last Lions series, referee Nic Berry received death threats as a result of South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus's extraordinary deconstruction of his decisions in the Springboks' first Test defeat. Wayne Barnes also received death threats following the 2023 World Cup final. 'You'll all recall four years ago in the last Lions series in South Africa, when the match official in the first Test was very heavily criticised, which brought mental health challenges,' Gilpin said. 'Wayne Barnes has talked about it [after the 2023 World Cup], we've got match officials who, when they're criticised publicly, having their families targeted outside the school gates, that's not good, that's not fair, and that's not right, so we've got to support these guys.' Lions challenged to match 1974 'Invincibles' with Farrell to select fully loaded team The British and Irish Lions have been challenged to match the achievements of the 1974 'Invincibles' as coach Andrew Goodman confirmed they intend to go fully loaded for the third Test against Australia. Centre Garry Ringrose has been ruled out of Saturday's match in Sydney after reporting concussion symptoms in training last week but otherwise the Lions have a clean bill of health with centre Sione Tuipulotu, wing Mack Hansen and lock Joe McCarthy back in contention. History now awaits the Lions who – notwithstanding their defeat by Argentina in Dublin – are seeking to complete the first unbeaten tour on foreign soil since the 1974 trip to South Africa, and the first clean Test sweep since 1927 in Argentina. In that context, Goodman says that the Lions coaching staff will have no thoughts of resting players or rotating the squad for the sake of it and will approach the match as if the series was tied 1-1. 'Exactly, the best team available to win the series,' Goodman said. 'That might look like some changes, that might look like consistency. We will see how the boys go through their recovery process over the next couple of days and whatever 23's picked will go out there and do the best for the team. 'You've got to reward form when guys have been playing well and are match-hardened in those Test matches. It is a balance and I'm sure we'll have some good discussions as we always have around selecting the best 23 for the group. '[Winning 3-0] is huge. It's everything for us as a group to get excited about. It was 1974 the last time a Lions team went through the Test series unbeaten, so there's huge motivation for the group. It's one of those weeks where after two hard physical Tests it's about getting the battery filled up and making sure we're good to go by the end of the week. 'Faz has been massive on that since the start, his expectation not just of the players but us as management and coaches, to be the most successful team. It has been driving us, not just as players, but as a management group every day to get better every day and push each other forward.' Being self-reporting his own concussion symptoms, Ringrose, the Ireland centre, is likely to never become a Test match Lion. The 30-year-old, who missed out on selection for the 2017 and 2021 tours, was ruled out of the first Test after suffering a concussion in the warm-up match against the Brumbies. However, Goodman says that Ringrose has remained a positive influence within the camp. 'He's disappointed as you can imagine,' Goodman said. 'Garry was playing some amazing rugby through this tour and someone you know who it's been a dream of his for so long to represent the Lions and he's managed to do that. But he wanted to be a Test-match Lion, so it's been devastating for him. 'To his credit he's been good around the group. As you can imagine, anyone that knows Garry, he's a great lad and a team man so the boys have all been disappointed for him. Obviously he's disappointed for himself but he's getting around everyone and making sure he helps prepare everyone as much as he can. 'He's a real leader for us in terms our back line in particular, so he's been great.' Squid Game challenge for Lions Lions players were welcomed back from two days of partying to training in Sydney with a special version of Squid Game arranged by head coach Andy Farrell. After securing a series victory in the 29-26 win over Australia at the MCG on Saturday, the Lions squad were given dispensation to let their hair down over the course of Saturday and Sunday nights with several members of the touring party spotted looking slightly worse for wear in Sydney on Monday. With Farrell targeting a 3-0 whitewash of the Wallabies, a gentle reintroduction to training was administered by John Fogarty, the scrum coach, who at Farrell's bequest set up the 'green light, red light' game from the Netflix series where contestants are allowed to sneak forward on the green light signal but are eliminated if they move when the light is red. 'Andy's always on having fun as a group, today we got down to training and he'd sent Fogs down early to set up the Squid Game mini-team challenge, the whole field was covered in equipment,' Goodman, the assistant coach, said. 'The staff were dressed up in all that kit, the speakers were all set up, a bit of fun, stuff like that to get a bit of energy back in the group. It was green light, red light, the whole field was covered in different things they could hide behind, and they had people in the top tier keeping an eye on people. It was a good craic.' According to Goodman, Thomas Clarkson, the Leinster prop, was the first player eliminated in the game but the fun element of the game underlines Farrell's ability to mix business with pleasure. 'Every week we've done things like that,' Goodman said. 'All part of touring, isn't it? Even with Ireland it's a part of his week to make sure there's fun involved. The mini-team stuff, the little challenges he'll have at the start of meetings, there's always a bit of craic, a bit of a laugh involved. It keeps the boys engaged and fresh and it's not just going into a meeting where it's rugby all the time. There are little bits like that that make it enjoyable as well.'
