Amici Curiae object to erection of steel wire rope fencing in Thondamuthur to prevent human-elephant conflicts
A special Division Bench of Justices N. Sathish Kumar and D. Bharatha Chakravarthy had called for the response of the amici curiae T. Mohan, Chevanan Mohan, Rahul Balaji and M. Santhanaraman to a counter affidavit filed by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests-cum-Chief Wildlife Warden Rakesh Kumar Dogra.
Waking to the call OF THE WILD: India's rich wildlife heritage is under threat as human-animal conflicts intensify
Responding to a case filed by activist S. Muralidharan, the PCCF-cum-CWC had on June 20, 2025 told the court the Forest Department had initially proposed to erect steel wire rope fence in Coimbatore forest division for a distance of 30 km but financial sanction was accorded only for 10 km.
'Coimbatore forest division was spread over 693.48 sqkm and shared a boundary with habitations for a length of about 350 km where it was vulnerable to HEC. Elephants had strayed out 9,710 times in this division in the past three years and 147 deaths had occurred during 2011-2022,' the officer said.
The government had to pay a compensation of ₹11.35 crore to the families of the dead. He added traditional methods of digging elephant proof trenches and erecting solar fences had proved to be ineffective with the pachyderms that indulge in crop raiding and house breaking.
'Hence, it was decided that elephant proof steel wire rope fencing could be done on a pilot basis in Thondamuthur. Accordingly, Chief Minister M.K. Stalin made the announcement on November 6, 2024 and a Government Order sanctioning ₹5 crore was issued on February 4, 2025,' he said.
Amici curiae's report
Filing their response to the PCCF-cum-CWC's counter affidavit, the amici curiae told the court the area where the steel wire rope fencing had been proposed marks an abrupt shift from forest to private lands. They said, the terrain was slopy and there was no buffer zone for elephants to navigate.
'The steep slopes and the fence together will lock the area with no other solution for the elephants but to either circumnavigate the hills or try to force themselves through the fence. In both cases, the risk of mortality will be increased,' the amici curiae said by relying upon certain studies undertaken in the area.
'As the fence covers 10 km, elephants coming into the private from the adjacent forests will be prevented from accessing the forests on the other side and it may lead to more conflict. Closing off forests completely will solve problems locally but shift the conflict elsewhere,' they added.
The lawyers also said: 'A scientific study must be undertaken to understand the impacts before fencing... The Forest Department is in the process of notifying elephant corridors across Tamil Nadu. Until the corridors in Coimbatore region are consolidated and notified, the fencing may be held off.'
After taking the report of the amici curiae on file, the judges adjourned the hearing to July 25, 2025 and ordered maintenance of status quo till then.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Karnataka petitions Centre again on pending approvals and funds for Yettinhole, Kalasa-Bhanduri, Upper Bhadra projects
The Karnataka government has again petitioned the Centre regarding the approvals for three of its major water projects — Yettinahole and Kalasa-Bhanduri (drinking water projects) and Upper Bhadra (to irrigate the arid central parts of the State — and notification of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal-II award. A meeting of all Members of Parliament from the State is also likely to be scheduled ahead of the Monsoon session to seek their support to exert pressure on the Centre on the issues. Roadblocks for projects While the Yettinahole project in the Western Ghats of Hassan district has hit a roadblock over forestland acquisition, the Kalasa-Bhanduri project has been opposed by the neighbouring Goa. Karnataka has also been seeking funds to complete the Upper Bhadra project, and the Centre is yet to notify the Krishna tribunal-II award that could help irrigate large tracts of land in north Karnataka. 'We briefed Union Minister for Environment Bhupendra Yadav on the technical difficulties in the Yettinahole project and our plan to provide revenue land in lieu of forestland. We have replied to the objections raised by the Environment Ministry regarding forestland acquisition. He has promised us on clearance of obstacles for the project,' the Deputy Chief Minister told presspersons in Delhi. Forestland issue Asked about the objections to the use of 423 acres of forestland, he said, 'We have provided alternative revenue land by paying compensation to farmers who had been using the forestland for 40 to 50 years. The Forest Department has raised objections to this, stating that the land belongs to it. More than half the work has been completed at the site. The Forest Department has raised objections to the dumping of soil in forestland, and we have agreed to remove it. We have already spent ₹24,000 crore on the project.' After meeting Jal Shakti Minister C.R. Patil, the Deputy Chief Minister said the Kalasa-Bhanduri project was discussed. Goa does not have the right to object to the project, he said. 'We have called for a tender for this project after the court ruling. The Centre has to take a stern stand on the objections and allow construction. We will explore a legal response after consulting Union Minister Pralhad Joshi. The Centre has been urged to gazette the notification on the Krishna tribunal award.' Money not released Regarding the Upper Bhadra project, Mr. Shivakumar said though the Centre allocated ₹5,300 crore in the Union Budget of 2023-2024, the money has not been released yet. 'We appealed to the Minister to issue instructions to release the funds under the PMKSY-AIBP scheme.' The ₹21,473-crore Upper Bhadra project, once completed, will irrigate 2.25 lakh hectares in Chikkamagaluru, Chitradurga, Tumakuru, and Davangere districts, he added.
The Hindu
3 hours ago
- The Hindu
Trains won't be allowed to move if 42% BC quota is not approved by Centre: Kavitha
HYDERABAD President of Telangana Jagruthi and Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) MLC K. Kavitha has cautioned that the Jagruthi will not allow even one train to move if the Centre fails to approve the Bill granting 42% reservation to Backwards Classes (BCs). She announced a 'Rail Roko' protest on July 17 demanding Presidential assent for the BC reservation bill passed by the Telangana Assembly. Addressing a press conference in New Delhi on Tuesday, she insisted that the Revanth Reddy government in Telangana issue a Government Order (GO) implementing the enhanced reservations in accordance with provisions under Article 243(D) of the Constitution, as an interim measure. 'Trains from Deccan to Delhi will be stopped. If the Bill is not approved, we'll go for an indefinite Rail Roko,' she said and asserted that the 2.5 crore BC population in Telangana would teach the BJP a lesson, if the due quota was denied. Ms. Kavitha sought to know why AICC leader and Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi was not advising the Telangana Chief Minister to issue such a GO. She requested Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who identifies himself as an OBC, to ensure justice for BCs by taking steps for Presidential approval to the Telangana BC reservation Bills.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
Top news of the day: Three students killed as train rams into school van in T.N.'s Cuddalore; X contradicts government on Reuters handle blocking, and more
Three children killed, two others injured in Cuddalore train-school van accident At least three school children were killed and two others including the driver sustained serious injuries after a school van carrying four students was rammed by a passenger train at a manned gate at Semmankuppam in Cuddalore district on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) around 7.45 a.m. X says government had ordered blocking of Reuters handle Contradicting a Union government statement, X (formerly Twitter) said in a statement on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) that the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology had indeed requested the firm to block access to the handles of newswire agency Reuters, in addition to over 2,000 other accounts. U.S. trade deal: India targeting July 8 deadline but can extend to August 1 if deal specifics don't suit The August 1 deadline for U.S. tariffs is for countries that have received letters from U.S. President Donald Trump, and so India is still operating under the July 8 deadline, according to Indian government sources, who added that a mini deal with the US could be announced 'in a day or two'. However, they also said that India will not push ahead if the deal specifics do not suit India. China says U.S. is in 'no position' to point fingers over Tibet issues China's Foreign Ministry said on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) that the United States was in 'no position' to point fingers at the country on Tibet-related issues, urging Washington to fully recognise the 'sensitivity' of the matter. Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning made the remarks when asked to comment on U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio's statement on the Dalai Lama's 90th birthday on Sunday (July 6, 2025), after a week of celebrations by his followers. Iran says it has not requested U.S. talks since war Iran said on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) it has not made any request for talks with the United States after President Donald Trump said Tehran was seeking negotiations following last month's war with Israel. Madras High Court grants bail to actors Srikanth and Krishna in drug case The Madras High Court on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) granted bail to Tamil film actors T. Srikanth, 45, and Krishna alias K. Krishnakumar, 47, in a case registered against them by the Greater Chennai City Police under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act of 1985. Jio BlackRock to disrupt India's funds sector with low-cost strategy: sources The Kremlin said on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) that it would take time to clarify what weapons the United States is supplying and will supply to Ukraine after President Donald Trump said Washington would have to send more arms to Kyiv. Mr. Trump said on Monday (July 7, 2025) that the United States would send more weapons to Ukraine, primarily defensive ones, to help the war-torn country defend itself against intensifying Russian advances. 'Anti-constitutional': Farooq Abdullah on revision of electoral rolls in Bihar National Conference president Farooq Abdullah on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) termed as 'anti-Constitutional' the decision of the Election Commission to undertake special intensive revision of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar. 'More than 1.50 crore Biharis are working outside their State. How will they fill the form (for enrolment)? How will they vote? Where will they get the certificates for their deceased parents?' Mr. Abdullah asked. Delhi High Court orders crackdown on counterfeit Birkenstock sandals The Delhi High Court has ordered an extensive crackdown on the manufacture and sale of counterfeit sandals imitating the global footwear brand Birkenstock's iconic products, directing raids and seizures at multiple locations across the country. The court also passed an interim order restraining several firms from producing or distributing fake 'Birkenstock' sandals, after the German shoe manufacturer alleged a network of manufacturers and sellers based in rural areas around Agra, Uttar Pradesh, were engaged in large-scale production of counterfeit goods. Terrorists' attempt to draw sustenance from society should be foiled, says J&K LG Manoj Sinha Jammu and Kashmir Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha said on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) that ordinary citizens were taking a stand against Pakistan-backed terrorism through street protests which was a good sign for establishing peace in the Valley. Stressing that the development of the tourism sector is possible only in a peaceful and secure environment, he said the people of Jammu and Kashmir should ensure that terrorists' attempts to draw sustenance from society are foiled. Marathi-Hindi row: Nod was given for rally, but MNS sought specific route, says Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis on Tuesday (July 8, 2025) said permission had been granted for a rally in neighbouring Mira Bhayander in which MNS leaders had planned to participate, but the party insisted on a specific route which posed law and order challenges. SFI protesters breach Kerala University headquarters during Statewide agitation Kerala University witnessed unprecedented scenes on Tuesday (July 8) as activists of the Students' Federation of India (SFI) stormed the university headquarters, escalating the ongoing standoff between the Governor and Vice-Chancellor on one side, and the University Syndicate and Registrar on the other. Virat Kohli says tennis players regularly handle pressure comparable to India-Pakistan World Cup games Drawing parallels between on-field pressure situations in two vastly different games, former India captain Virat Kohli says what tennis players endure week after week can only be compared to the less frequent 'intimidation and pressure' that an Indian cricketer faces in World Cup knockouts and clashes against arch foes Pakistan.
