No harmony as Micheál and Simon express differing views on next budget
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said economic forecasts the Government received last weekend were 'sobering' – but Tánaiste Simon Harris told reporters he wanted an 'expansionary' Budget.
A row between the two Government parties over the student contribution charge blew up over the weekend after Higher Education Minister James Lawless appeared to confirm the charge would revert to €3,000 this year once cost-of-living measures ended.
This led Fine Gael to launch an attack on Minister Lawless and say they wanted to continue to reduce the cost of the student contribution charge over the lifetime of this Government. Speaking in Tokyo yesterday, Mr Martin moved to dampen expectations ahead of the October Budget. James Lawless. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos
Mr Martin said he had received stark warnings about the state of Ireland's macroeconomic factors, including the potential impact of tariffs from the US. Mr Martin met with Mr Harris, Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers about Budget 2026 and the National Development Plan over the weekend.
He said: 'It was a sobering enough meeting to be frank in terms of the challenges that lie ahead, given the backdrop of [US] tariffs and uncertainty in trade.' Mr Martin added that another factor of concern related to 'warnings we have received' in relation to 'certain corporation tax revenues.'
'It's challenging, and expenditure has been rising very significantly in Ireland, and that has to be factored into the equation.' However, Mr Harris appeared to have a different approach. Simon Harris. Pic: Stephen Collins/Collins Photos
Asked about Mr Martin's comments, the Tánaiste said: 'Our Budget in Ireland will be expansionary… will have an ability to do more, and we'll be doing more to actually to invest in our economy and our society, to reduce the cost of running the cafe, to reduce the cost of running the restaurant, to reduce the cost of education, because we know the security of our economy depends on investing in the ingenuity of our people.'
Asked how he squared the political circle of global economic headwinds with an expansionary Budget, Mr Harris said they were not contradictory objectives.
'It's all about balance and context. We will continue to put money aside in the funds for the future of our country, both in the Nature and Climate Fund and in the Future Ireland fund.'
He said the Government would run budget surpluses, adding: 'But we will also be working our way through our Programme for Government. I don't think that's a shock.'
He said both Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil had flagged economic headwinds during the general election, adding: 'We're not going to not try to help people where we can, but we're going to do it in a balanced way.' Jack Chambers. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
Mr Harris also played down a rift over the student contribution charges. He and Jack Chambers warned that the threat of US tariffs has brought uncertainty to the economy which would be taken into account in Budget negotiations.
Controversy over future student contribution fees began last Sunday after Mr Lawless said fees would 'reset' to €3,000 – what they were three years ago. On Monday he said he currently does not have the funds to reduce fees but would 'fight' his case as part of budgetary negotiations.
Asked if there was a rift in Cabinet, Mr Harris said 'certainly there is not'. He said fees would not go up in September as those fees are covered under Budget 2025.
He said most families pay the fee in instalments, in September and the new year, so the second instalment of the upcoming academic year would come under Budget 2026. Minister of State Thomas Byrne said: 'I think we are at one on this.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
3 hours ago
- Extra.ie
US pharma deal can be 'creative' but Harris admits 10% tariffs are new norm
Simon Harris has said the US is open to 'creative solutions' on a pharmaceutical trade deal with the EU, sparking hope that the industry may escape Donald Trump's tariffs. While the Tánaiste conceded that US tariffs of 10% will be the 'new normal' regardless of any deal reached in the coming days, he indicated that the US is now recognising its 'interdependence' with Ireland and the EU in relation to pharmaceuticals. The comments came as EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic travelled to Washington to meet with his US counterpart, with just six days left to agree on a trade deal before President Trump imposes 50% tariffs on European imports. Maros Sefcovic. Pic: Getty Images Tánaiste and Foreign Affairs Minister Harris told the Government trade forum yesterday that despite EU efforts, 'the new normal' will be a baseline tariff of 10% on all goods being shipped to the US. But he did acknowledge ongoing negotiations to 'maximise' the number of sectors where there is a zero-for-zero tariff situation, citing aviation and pharma as two key sectors for Ireland. Irish medicinal and pharmaceutical exports were valued at €99.8billion in 2024 and accounted for almost half of our total goods exported. Of this, €44.3million was exported to the US, with many economists warning that the inclusion of the pharma sector in any tariff war would significantly damage the Irish economy. Mr Harris said he had been assured by US trade representative Jamieson Greer that the Trump administration was open when it comes to the place of pharma in an EU trade deal. Simon Harris. Pic: Pool Via 'He made it clear that he was open to creative solutions when it comes to pharma and I think that's an important recognition that actually pharma between the US and the EU, the US and Ireland, is much more interdependent than perhaps people were led to believe in certain quarters at the start of this process,' he said. Mr Harris added that while a brief extension to the July 9 deadline is something that can be considered by the EU and US, it would be preferable to, at the very least, deliver a framework agreement to provide certainty to businesses. Mr Harris and Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe also sought to reassure trade representatives that the Irish economy will continue to grow next year, even with an additional 10% US tariff. However, this growth will come at a 'lower rate than we would otherwise have expected'. Fine Gael leader Simon Harris, Helen McEntee, and Paschal Donohoe. Pic: Rolling News Mr Donohoe said: 'Our scenario for this year and for next year, on the basis of what we currently know, is that we will still have public finances that will be in surplus, that will be performing well. But as we approach the budget and conclude our work on Budget 2026, it is very likely that those levels of surpluses will be revised. They will be adjusted, but they will still be surpluses.' Asked how the global economic uncertainty might impact the country's finances, Mr Donohoe said that the Government is 'clear that if we find ourselves confronting an economic shock, we would reprioritise how we maintain capital investment, how we can invest in energy, create and build more homes'. 'That is why the work that is underway at the moment to stabilise the global trade environment is so important, and we are pushing for that work to conclude in a way that recognises and protects national interests that we have,' he said. Mr Donohoe also said that the Coalition's position will be reflected in October's budget, which will 'prioritise the creation and retention of jobs and keeping our public finances safe while investing in our future'. He said this approach will come with sacrifices. 'We will make decisions closer to the time regarding what is the way in which we will do that. And clearly, if the Government does decide to make investments and decisions in particular areas, we will then decide there are other things that we cannot do. That's the right thing to do. And we'll make the case for that on budget day,' he said. Separately, Mr Harris confirmed that a decision to defer warning labels on alcohol will be made later this week. The controversial measure was due to come into effect in May 2026; however, there have been rumblings that the plans will be shelved. Mr Harris said the policy 'came up quite a lot at the trade forum. I'm very much of the view that we need to defer the implementation. It will be a matter for the Minister for Health [Jennifer Carroll MacNeill]… but I expect we'll be able to bring clarity to this in the coming days.'
Irish Post
4 hours ago
- Irish Post
Fine Gael councillor Ray McAdam elected new Lord Mayor of Dublin
FINE GAEL councillor Ray McAdam has been elected the new Lord Mayor of Dublin. He becomes the city's 358th Lord Mayor, succeeding Councillor Emma Blain, who held the post from December 2024. The Co. Cavan native, who was raised in Co. Fermanagh assumed the role on June 30 at a meeting of Dublin City Council in City Hall. The newly elected Lord Mayor of Dublin Ray McAdam receives his. chain (Pics: Dublin City Council) Educated at St. Michael's College in Enniskillen, Mr McAdam moved to Dublin in 2002 to study Philosophy and Political Science at Trinity College. Before entering elected office, he worked in sales and later as a Political Aide to Minister Paschal Donohoe in the Oireachtas. He was first elected to Dublin City Council in 2009, to represent the North Inner City and has been re-elected at every subsequent local election. Lord Mayor of Dublin Ray McAdam pictured wth the former mayor Emma Blain (Pics: Dublin City Council) 'Dublin is a city I love deeply,' Mr McAdam said. 'But like many Dubliners, I know it can do better,' he added. Mr McAdam has confirmed the theme of his term will be 'celebrating Dublin', which he describes as 'simple but powerful'. 'To celebrate Dublin is not to ignore its problems, it's the opposite,' he explained. 'It's about lifting our city up and asking it, and ourselves, to live up to the best of what it can be.' Mr McAdam pictured with his wife Niamh, their son Iarlath and party colleague, Finance Minister Pachal Donohoe (Pics: Dublin City Council) Mr McAdam currently serves as Chair of the Council's Protocol Committee. He has served as Leader of the Council's Fine Gael group for seven years. The Lord Mayor confirmed that he will launch a Lord Mayor's Commission on Dublin 2050 to develop a long-term vision for the capital's city centre. 'Cities across the world are being reshaped by post-pandemic life, changing how we shop, move, gather, and live,' he said. 'Dublin can't drift - it must lead,' he added. 'This Commission will bring people together from every part of city life to ask one central question: what should Dublin's city centre feel and look like by 2050?' Councillor John Stephens has been elected the Deputy Lord Mayor of Dublin. See More: Fine Gael, Lord Mayor Of Dublin, Ray McAdam
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Starmer backs ‘excellent' Rachel Reeves after chancellor's tears in House of Commons
Britain's prime minister Keir Starmer said he did not appreciate how upset Rachel Reeves was in the House of Commons, because he was focused on answering prime minister's questions (PMQs). The prime minister said all people could be caught 'off guard' by their emotions, but the chancellor had to deal with it while on camera in parliament. He said she was doing an excellent job, would remain in place beyond the next general election, and that they were both absolutely committed to the chancellor's 'fiscal rules' to maintain discipline over the public finances. UK Government bonds rallied and the pound steadied on Thursday, after reassurances from the prime minister about the chancellor's future. READ MORE The sight of Ms Reeves in tears on Wednesday, and the £5 billion black hole in her public spending plans as a result of the welfare U-turn, had spooked the markets, triggering a sharp sell-off of bonds, with the yield seeing the sharpest increase since US president Donald Trump's tariff plans shook up financial markets in April. Mr Starmer told Virgin Radio he had spoken to the chancellor on Wednesday evening and she was 'fine', and her tears were as a result of a 'purely personal' matter rather than the 'ups and downs of this week'. Ms Reeves was visibly upset as she sat beside Mr Starmer in the Commons on Wednesday, but he said: 'I actually personally didn't appreciate it was happening in the chamber, because I came in, I've got questions being fired at me in PMQs, so I'm constantly up at the despatch box and down. 'I think we just need to be clear, it's a personal matter, and I'm not going to breach Rachel's privacy by going into what's a personal matter for her.' He said that 'in politics, you're on show the whole time, there's no hiding place'. Ms Reeves was a 'great colleague, she's a friend of mine and I'll be working with her for a very long time to come'. 'But like all human beings, we're also personal. 'There are moments that catch us off guard and if you're in front of a camera for large periods of your life, unfortunately, that could be caught on camera in a way, if it had been anybody else at work, it would have not really been noticed.' The sight of the Chancellor in tears on the front bench and Mr Starmer's initial lack of public support for her caused jitters about the government's borrowing plans, as Ms Reeves's commitment to her rules to control spending are a key reassuring factor for the bond markets. Mr Starmer said: 'She is an excellent chancellor, she will be chancellor for a very long time to come, into the next election and beyond it. 'She and I are absolutely committed to our fiscal rules and the economic stability that is so important to this country, and that is the rock on which we build everything else. 'On that issue, Rachel and I are in lockstep, and have been for years.' – PA
