Prevent civil servants imbalance: Only 5.4pct are Chinese
LETTER | The low representation of Chinese Malaysians in the civil service is a cause for concern.
The government must take proactive measures to encourage greater participation from young Chinese Malaysians in national administration, ensuring governance reflects the voice of all citizens.
Few applicants, but highest interview success rates
According to the data from the Human Resource Management Information System (HRMIS), as of Dec 31, 2024, Malaysia had 1,302,429 civil servants (excluding the Royal Malaysia Police and armed forces), with only 5.4 percent being Chinese Malaysians.
In the 2024 and 2025 intake for administrative and diplomatic officers, only one of over 120 recruits was Chinese Malaysian, despite around 1,000 Chinese Malaysians applying. In comparison, over 90,000 Malays applied, 4,000 for Indians and Sabahans, while 3,000 Sarawakians and other ethnic groups applied.
Despite the low application numbers for Chinese Malaysians, the interview success rate for this group stood at 85 percent, the highest among all groups, demonstrating their capability to perform in civil service roles.
Diversity strengthens policies and social unity
Civil servants are key to implementing government policies. A civil service with diverse representation ensures decisions reflect the interests of all communities.
Increasing Chinese Malaysian representation will strengthen community ties and promote governance cohesion. Chinese Malaysian participation at all levels is crucial for inclusive policy development.
While some believe contributing to national development requires political elections, the real drivers of policy are administrative institutions. The Chinese Malaysian community must not be absent from this leadership structure.
Breaking stereotypes
The recent armed forces' promotion of Johnny Lim from major general to lieutenant general, the first Chinese Malaysian three-star general in Malaysia's history, highlights how merit and service drive promotions. This milestone should inspire all ethnic groups to participate in public service.
Public service is a valuable career for young Chinese Malaysians. The government should use this success story to raise awareness, showing that careers in government, police, or military are open platforms where individuals can thrive regardless of their ethnic roots.
The civil service offers opportunities for cross-departmental rotations and diverse training, allowing officers to gain broad experience and enjoy stable career paths with strong benefits.
As prime minister's political secretary Chan Ming Kai has stated, the government must do more to encourage Chinese Malaysian participation in the public sector. Given the high success rate of Chinese Malaysian applicants, outreach efforts such as school talks, targeted training, scholarships, and internships should be expanded.
The government should regularly publish HRMIS data on applications and intake across ethnic groups, set diversity targets, and strengthen performance standards to ensure equal opportunities for career advancement.
Chinese Malaysians are fully capable of serving the nation in the civil service. A diverse civil service brings new perspectives, creating stronger connections between the public and private sectors.
The government must work to bridge the gap between Chinese Malaysian youth and public administration, allowing more talent to contribute to national progress.
LAWRENCE LOW is MCA vice-president and MCA Economic and SME Affairs Committee chairperson.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Focus Malaysia
5 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Avoid racial speculations in merit-based military promotions: Saifuddin
HOME Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail emphasised that appointments in the Malaysian Armed Forces and Royal Malaysia Police are based on merit, discipline, and a thorough process, not on race or political views. 'Recently, when an individual was promoted to the rank of two stars, speculative statements emerged. 'The narrative given was as if, if this situation continues, one day the Prime Minister of Malaysia could be Chinese,' Saifuddin said on Saturday. He was addressing recent comments from a PAS grassroots leader, Zaharudin Muhammad, who sparked controversy with a Facebook post suggesting it was 'not impossible' for Malaysia to have an ethnic Chinese prime minister in the future. The post included a photo of Johnny Lim Eng Seng, commandant of the Malaysian Armed Forces Defence College, receiving a third-star promotion. Saifuddin criticized narratives that question racial representation in leadership roles. The Home Minister urged avoiding racial perspectives, especially regarding the military, which follows a rigorous promotion process overseen by the Armed Forces Council. 'Not every issue needs to be commented on from a racial perspective, especially regarding the military institution, which is well-versed in the promotion process with screenings and evaluations through the Armed Forces Council,' he said. He also supported a decree by Yang di-Pertuan Agong, Sultan Ibrahim, discouraging the use of religion for political purposes and efforts to divide racial unity. —June 29, 2025 Main image: New Straits Times
Malay Mail
2 days ago
- Malay Mail
From Sandhurst to stars: Johnny Lim and the breaking of Malaysia's military glass ceiling — Phar Kim Beng and Luthfy Hamzah
JUNE 27 — In an era when the question of unity in diversity remains a perennial national debate, Malaysia has quietly marked a historic milestone: for the first time in its 62-year military history, an ethnic Chinese officer has risen to the coveted rank of lieutenant general. Lieutenant General Johnny Lim Eng Seng's recent promotion is not just a personal triumph. It is a deeply symbolic moment for Malaysia — a nation that continues to wrestle with balancing ethnic representation across its key institutions. In Lim's elevation, we see the promise of a more inclusive national identity, one that can be rooted in meritocracy, professionalism, and unity, rather than race, religion or origin. Breaking the mould in a Malay-dominated institution The Malaysian Armed Forces (MAF) have long been viewed — rightly or wrongly — as a bastion of ethnic Malay dominance. With more than 86 per cent of its senior officers from the Malay-Muslim majority, the upper echelons of the military have remained relatively closed to minorities, despite the country's multiethnic composition. That Lieutenant General Johnny Lim has now become the first ethnic Chinese to attain the rank of three-star general among an estimated 113,000 active Chinese servicemen — who make up just 0.13 per cent of Malaysia's armed forces — represents a significant breakthrough not only for the Chinese Malaysian community, but also for other long-underrepresented groups in national defence, including Indians (1.4 per cent), the Orang Asli, and other non-Malay communities (12 per cent). It is a reminder that the military, above all, is a national institution — not a communal one — and it is the collective duty of all Malaysians to serve and be represented in it. A career forged in discipline, loyalty and dedication Lim's journey is nothing short of exemplary. He joined the Malaysian Army in 1984, during the tail-end of the Communist insurgency — a time when national security was still very much at risk. Rising through the ranks, he served in various field and staff commands, including as Brigade Commander of the 31st Infantry and later as Army Inspector-General. A proud alumnus of the prestigious Royal Military Academy Sandhurst in the UK, he also pursued graduate studies at the University of Canberra and Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. His strategic acumen was further sharpened by training at Korea's National Defence University, where he mastered Korean — an extraordinary feat, showing cultural discipline alongside martial professionalism. Lim's current role as Commandant of the Malaysian Armed Forces Defence College, where he oversees the education of future military leaders, is a fitting testament to a career defined not by ethnicity but by sheer competence and contribution. Major-General Johnny Lim (centre) was promoted to the rank of lieutenant-general, making him the first Malaysian Chinese officer to attain the three-star rank. — Picture via Facebook Symbolism and substance This promotion could not have come at a more critical time. With Malaysia facing an increasingly complex strategic environment — from great power rivalry in the South China Sea to rising cyber threats and terrorism — national unity and resilience cannot afford to be superficial. Diversity in the ranks, particularly among leadership, enhances operational cohesion, cultural sensitivity and even diplomatic soft power. Yet, the road ahead remains challenging. While Lim's rise is a watershed moment, it is not yet a trend. Systemic barriers and unspoken biases still hinder wider minority recruitment into Malaysia's military. Cultural misconceptions and economic disincentives also continue to dissuade many non-Malays from choosing a career in defence. Indeed, even Lim's promotion did not escape the undercurrent of Malaysia's ethnic fault lines. A grassroots leader from the Islamist party PAS questioned the implications of a non-Malay holding such a senior position — a comment that triggered backlash and prompted the party to distance itself from the remark, labelling it as 'racist' and 'regrettable'. The episode serves as a cautionary tale of how quickly even national achievements can be reframed through sectarian lenses. From tokenism to transformation For Lim, the significance of his achievement lies not in the title but in what it could inspire. 'I'm proud to be the first,' he said, 'but I hope I'm not the last.' His call should resonate loudly across Malaysia: representation must never stop at symbolism. It must translate into institutional transformation — where all Malaysians, regardless of ethnicity, feel ownership of and belonging in the nation's defence, governance and future. This moment must also compel the government to revisit and renew its efforts to make military careers attractive and accessible to all communities. Scholarships, public outreach, inclusive recruitment drives and clear career progression pathways must be institutionalised across the Ministry of Defence and the MAF. The goal should be not just tolerance, but full integration. Malaysia's true strength Lieutenant General Johnny Lim Eng Seng is not merely a figurehead. He is the embodiment of a Malaysia that can be. One that affirms, as our Rukun Negara proclaims, 'courtesy and morality,' but also meritocracy and multiracialism. His journey from the jungles of 1980s counterinsurgency to the strategic halls of the Defence College offers a living lesson: that national strength lies not in exclusion but in inclusion. In a world increasingly shaped by fragmentation and fear, Malaysia's example — if it can be sustained — could serve as a quiet but powerful counterpoint. A nation secures not because it suppresses differences, but because it celebrates them. Let us then salute not only a soldier but also a scholar whose achievement marks a defining step in the nation's long march toward a more just, equal and united Malaysia. * Phar Kim Beng is Professor of Asean Studies at International Islamic University Malaysia, a Cambridge Commonwealth Fellow, and former Harvard Head Teaching Fellow. Luthfy Hamzah is Senior Research Fellow at Strategic Pan Indo Pacific Arena, Kuala Lumpur. ** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Malaysiakini
2 days ago
- Malaysiakini
Is DAP gunning for non-Muslim armed forces chief, PAS leader asks
In a bizarre turnaround, PAS supreme council member Zuhdi Marsuki accused DAP of stoking racial sentiments over the promotion of a non-Malay to lieutenant-general in the armed forces. Congratulating Johnny Lim on his new post, Zuhdi questioned if DAP is looking to have a non-Muslim lead the armed forces in the future. 'Because DAP made an issue out of the matter, I want to ask...
