logo
This ‘Trial of the Century' Is 100. Its Lessons Could Save the Democrats.

This ‘Trial of the Century' Is 100. Its Lessons Could Save the Democrats.

New York Times10-07-2025
In July 1925, John Scopes faced a jury in a stifling courtroom in Dayton, Tenn. A 24-year-old teacher, Scopes stood accused of violating the Butler Act, a recently enacted state law that forbade teaching the theory of evolution because it contradicted the Bible. He was convicted, fined $100 and basked in the renown of the case for the rest of his life.
Despite its rather genial outcome (the Tennessee Supreme Court even overturned Mr. Scopes's conviction on a technicality), echoes from the 'trial of the century' still resound in American culture and politics a full century later. The Scopes trial was a momentous clash between modern science and traditional Christianity, represented by two of the most famous attorneys in the country: William Jennings Bryan for the prosecution, Clarence Darrow for the defense. Broadcast on the radio, it exposed the horror many urban liberals felt toward people they deemed dogmatic and uneducated. H.L. Mencken, the eloquent if arrogant critic of unrefined America, attended the trial and hissed to his many readers that Bryan was 'deluded by a childish theology, full of an almost pathological hatred of all learning' — 'a peasant come home to the barnyard.'
A hundred years on, many voters in rural areas still feel that the cosmopolitan politicians and advisers who run the Democratic Party look down on them. Because those voters have an outsize influence on the makeup of the Senate, Democrats will have to reckon with that perception, accurate or not, if they hope to dominate American politics again.
While teaching evolution has been legal in every state for decades, the larger antagonisms revealed by the Scopes trial persist. Americans in rural areas are more likely to identify as Christian than their urban counterparts. Those who are white overwhelmingly back politicians like House Speaker Mike Johnson, who says he takes his 'worldview' from the Bible, and President Trump, who claims he was 'saved by God to make America great again.' Americans with a strong rural identity are also more likely to bear a grudge against experts and intellectuals, heirs of the evolutionists who came to Scopes's defense.
Who should decide what schools teach remains as intensely disputed as a century ago. Bryan believed that 'the people,' not teachers, had 'the right to control the educational system which they have created and which they tax themselves to support.' If they wanted to ban the teaching of evolution with a bill like the Butler Act, they should be able to. A similar logic drives the contemporary crusade by Moms for Liberty and other right-wing groups to ban courses infected by D.E.I. and to toss books about L.G.B.T.Q. people out of school libraries.
Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation's compendium of conservative ideas, called for parents to decide what students would learn. It even favored publicly funding private schools, including religious schools, that could teach children to doubt the existence of climate change, the persistence of racism and, yes, the theory of evolution.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Silver's hot streak gathers pace; market at highest since 2011
Silver's hot streak gathers pace; market at highest since 2011

Yahoo

time19 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Silver's hot streak gathers pace; market at highest since 2011

By Polina Devitt and Sherin Elizabeth Varghese (Reuters) -Silver prices surged to their highest in almost 14 years on Wednesday, aided by worries about U.S. tariff policy, signs of tightness in the spot market and growing investor interest in alternatives to gold. Spot silver was up 0.3% at $39.40 per troy ounce as of 1354 GMT, its highest level since September 2011. Silver, both a precious and industrial metal, is up 36% this year, outperforming gold's 31% growth and coming within a whisker of the key $40-per-ounce mark. The metal hit a record high of $49 in 2011. U.S. President Donald Trump's plan to impose 50% import tariffs on copper from August 1 and the U.S. import tariffs for Mexico widened the premium of the U.S. futures for silver and other metals against the London benchmarks in July, leading to a growth in lease rates in the spot market. Gold, silver, platinum and palladium were excluded from Trump's April reciprocal tariffs, but "the broader market isn't trading it that way and is taking a page out of Comex copper's handbook", Nicky Shiels, head of metals strategy at MKS PAMP. Spot silver prices may hit $42 per ounce this year, according to Shiels. Analysts also noted that industrial demand for silver, heading for the fifth year of structural market deficit, remains solid, while investment demand is gaining momentum as a more affordable alternative to gold. Silver's recent rally has improved its ratio with gold to the strongest level in seven months. It currently takes 87 ounces of silver to buy an ounce of gold, compared with 105 ounces in April. "It is the copper tariff that sent some spinning off at odd tangents that captured the other metals," said a precious metal trader based in London, adding that the lease rates in the spot market should fall once the borrowing activity caused by the U.S. tariff fears subside. The current momentum could be hot enough to take silver over $40/oz in the short term, said Nitesh Shah, commodity strategist at WisdomTree. "But with positioning stretched, we would not be surprised if it fell back to $35/oz, before it starts its march higher to $45/oz next year," Shah added. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Trump Just Dropped His AI Action Plan. Here's What's In It
Trump Just Dropped His AI Action Plan. Here's What's In It

CNET

time21 minutes ago

  • CNET

Trump Just Dropped His AI Action Plan. Here's What's In It

The Trump administration on Wednesday laid out the steps it plans to take in a bid for "global AI dominance," including reducing regulations to speed up the development of artificial intelligence tools and the infrastructure to power them. Other components of President Trump's AI Action Plan include steps to encourage open-source and open-weight AI models, ensure AI "protects free speech and American values" and promote the use of AI in the Department of Defense. "The Action Plan's objective is to articulate policy recommendations that this Administration can deliver for the American people to achieve the President's vision of global AI dominance," the report said. President Trump is expected to speak on AI priorities later Wednesday during a forum with the hosts of the All-In Podcast. Ahead of the plan's release, a coalition of advocacy groups and tech critics urged the administration to ensure the government would hold large tech firms accountable as AI grows. "We can't let Big Tech and Big Oil lobbyists write the rules for AI and our economy at the expense of our freedom and equality, workers and families' well-being, even the air we breathe and the water we drink -- all of which are affected by the unrestrained and unaccountable roll-out of AI," the People's AI Action Plan coalition said. This is a developing story.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store