New investigation into killing of Clodagh Hawe and her children finds missed evidence
A
garda review
has uncovered the new information not known at the time of the inquests into
their deaths in 2017
.
The serious crime review team - or Garda cold case - investigation was established in 2019 and the family of Ms Hawe have been briefed on its findings.
It concluded the initial inquiry also conducted some interviews without the use of interviewers trained to the highest standard for an investigation into murders.
READ MORE
In addition a phone believed to be owned by Alan Hawe, that was not discovered during the first inquiry, was found. It was used to access pornography, including material considered under law as child abuse imagery.
The details are set out in a new book titled Deadly Silence, by Ms Hawe's sister Jacqueline Connolly, which was published this week.
Ms Connolly is very critical of the initial Garda investigation into the killings of Ms Hawe (39) and her sons Liam (13), Niall (11) and Ryan (6), with the subsequent serious crime review team examination finding a series of shortcomings with that first inquiry.
[
Garda Commissioner job advertised, candidates from non-policing backgrounds eligible
Opens in new window
]
Ms Connolly believes the report drawn up by the serious crime review team, which the family was not given a copy of but were briefed on in 2024, should be published so society can learn more about such cases.
In reply to queries, Garda Headquarters said that 'in general' those reports are not published 'for operational reasons'. However, it said the findings of reviews conducted by the Garda's serious crime review team 'are incorporated into senior investigative training'.
The initial Garda investigation team compiled their findings for the Coroner's inquest process. A consultant forensic psychiatrist told the inquest he believed Alan Hawe had 'a long-standing depressive illness with anxiety and somatic concerns'. This progressed 'to a severe depressive episode with psychotic symptoms'.
However, the inquest process is only designed to conclude how people died, or were killed, rather than establishing motives for homicides. The 2017 Hawe family inquest
concluded
Mrs Hawe and her sons were unlawfully killed while Alan Hawe had died by suicide.
Neither the initial Garda investigation, nor the subsequent Garda review, reached any conclusions around why Alan Hawe killed his family. Garda investigations progress in a manner that establishes how killings are carried out, and gathers proof about who was responsible. Often in murder investigations carried out by the Garda, motives are not established or are not raised as a part of the prosecution's evidence in cases that go to the courts.
The murders and suicide occurred at their home in Ballyjamesduff the night before school teacher Alan Hawe (40), his wife Clodagh - who was also a teacher - and their children were due to start the new school year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
22 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Man (23) remanded in custody charged with assault causing harm to garda on Capel Street in Dublin
A man has appeared in court accused of launching an unprovoked knife attack on a garda in Dublin city centre earlier this week. Abdullah Khan is accused of stabbing the garda, who was on a high visibility foot patrol, a number of times during the incident on Capel Street just after 6pm on Tuesday. The garda was treated in hospital and later released. Mr Khan (23) appeared at Dublin District Court on Thursday morning dressed in dark trousers and a black t-shirt. He did not address the court. READ MORE He is charged with assault causing harm to the garda on Capel Street on July 29th, 2025. He is also charged with production of a 'Tactix' knife with intent to cause intimidation or harm on the same date. The court heard he made no reply when both charges were put to him on Wednesday night. Gardaí objected to bail and applied for a remand in custody. Defence solicitor Colleen Gildernew, with KID Lyons solicitors, said there was no application for bail. She asked that Mr Khan's address not be published 'due to the nature of the case' and noted that gardaí had no objection to this. She also applied for legal aid and for Mr Khan to receive medical attention in custody. Judge Treasa Kelly agreed to the defence applications and imposed reporting restrictions on Mr Khan's address. A statement of means for Mr Khan will be produced at the next hearing, the solicitor said. Judge Kelly remanded the accused in custody in Cloverhill Prison until next Wednesday.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí investigating murder of missing Fiona Sinnott begin new search in Co Wexford
Gardaí investigating the disappearance and murder of Fiona Sinnott in 1998 have commenced a search operation in Co Wexford . Ms Sinnott, the mother of an infant daughter, lived at Ballyhitt, Broadway at the time of her disappearance and had been socialising in Butler's pub on February 8th with friends. The 19-year-old left the pub at around midnight, which is the last confirmed sighting of her. A motorist said the saw a man and a woman on the road near Kisha Cross, a short distance from the pub, at around midnight. There were also two males in their late teens or early 20s close by. READ MORE None of these four people have ever come forward and gardaí said they are 'anxious to trace them or anyone who was in the vicinity who did not, or could not, come forward at the time'. A renewed appeal for witnesses was made in February 2023, on the 25th anniversary of Ms Sinnott's disappearance. Gardaí on Thursday said a search operation on open ground was set to begin at a location in Co Wexford. The area will be subject to excavation, technical and forensic examinations over the coming days. Road closures will be in place, and local diversions will be in operation, the force said. Gardaí in Wexford and Wicklow have over the last 27 years worked to establish Ms Sinnott's whereabouts and investigate the circumstances in which she disappeared. Extensive searches have been carried out and six people were arrested and questioned in connection with this investigation. In 2005, gardaí arrested and detained a male on suspicion of the murder of Ms Sinnott. At the same time, three women and two men were arrested and detained in connection with the investigation into the disappearance of Ms Sinnott. However, no person has been charged in connection with the investigation to date. Gardaí said thousands of documents, reports and taken in excess of 500 statements of evidence have been collated throughout the course of the investigation. Investigating gardaí continue to appeal to any person with any information in relation to the disappearance and murder of Fiona, who has not spoken to gardaí, to come forward. Any person who may have previously come forward who felt they could not provide gardaí with all the information they had in relation to this matter is urged to contact the investigation team at Wexford Garda station on 053 9165200, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111 or any garda station.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man due in court over stabbing of garda on Capel Street in Dublin
A man is due to appear in court on Thursday charged in connection with the stabbing of a member of An Garda Síochána in Dublin on Tuesday. The incident happened on Capel Street on Tuesday evening. The officer, who was on routine patrol in the city, suffered puncture wounds to his side. He was taken to hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. In a statement on Thursday, An Garda Síochána said the man had been charged and would appear in court later. READ MORE More to follow ...
