Federal Judge Blocks Trump Bid to Kill Ed Dept., Orders Fired Workers Reinstated
Judge Myong J. Joun of the District Court in Boston wrote in the preliminary injunction that the Trump administration had sought to 'effectively dismantle' the Education Department without congressional approval and prevented the federal government from carrying out programs mandated by law.
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
Trump administration officials have claimed the March layoffs of more than 1,300 federal education workers were designed to increase government efficiency and were separate from efforts to eliminate the agency outright, claims that Joun deemed 'plainly not true.'
'Defendants fail to cite to a single case that holds that the Secretary's authority is so broad that she can unilaterally dismantle a department by firing nearly the entire staff, or that her discretion permits her to make a 'shell' department,' Joun, a Biden appointee, wrote.
Related
Combined with early retirements and buyouts offered by the administration, the layoffs left the Education Department with about half as many employees as it had when Trump took office in January. That same month, Trump signed an executive order calling on Education Secretary Linda McMahon to 'take all necessary steps to facilitate the closure of the Department of Education.'
The Trump administration has acknowledged it cannot eliminate the 45-year-old department — long a goal of conservatives — without congressional approval despite layoffs that have left numerous offices unstaffed. Yet there is 'no evidence' the Trump administration is working with Congress to achieve its goal or that the layoffs have made the agency more efficient, Joun wrote. 'Rather, the record is replete with evidence of the opposite.'
'A department without enough employees to perform statutorily mandated functions is not a department at all,' he said. 'This court cannot be asked to cover its eyes while the Department's employees are continuously fired and units are transferred out until the Department becomes a shell of itself.'
The White House didn't respond to requests for comment. The Education Department said it plans to appeal.
In a statement, Education Department spokesperson Madi Biedermann blasted the court order and called Joun 'a far-left Judge' who overstepped his authority and the plaintiffs who filed the lawsuit to halt the layoffs — including two Massachusetts school districts and the American Federation of Teachers — 'biased.' Also suing to stop the layoffs is 21 Democratic state attorneys general.
'President Trump and the Senate-confirmed Secretary of Education clearly have the authority to make decisions about agency reorganization efforts, not an unelected Judge with a political axe to grind,' Biedermann said. 'This ruling is not in the best interest of American students or families. We will immediately challenge this on an emergency basis.'
Related
Cutting the federal education workforce in half — from 4,133 to 2,183 — undermines its ability to distribute special education funding to schools, protect students' civil rights and provide financial aid for college students, plaintiffs allege. They include the elimination of all Office of General Counsel attorneys, who specialize in K-12 grants related to special education, and most lawyers focused on student privacy issues. Plaintiffs also allege the cuts hampered the agency's ability to manage a federal student loan program that provides financial assistance to nearly 13 million students across about 6,100 colleges and universities.
The Office for Civil Rights was among those hardest hit by layoffs, with seven of its 12 regional offices shut down entirely. The move has left thousands of pending civil rights cases — including those that allege racial discrimination and sexual misconduct — in limbo.
Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, called the temporary injunction the 'first step to reverse this war on knowledge.' Yet the damage is already being felt in schools, said Jessica Tang, president of the American Federation of Teachers Massachusetts.
'The White House is not above the law, and we will never stop fighting on behalf of our students and our public schools and the protections, services and resources they need to thrive,' Tang said in a media release.
In interviews with The 74 Thursday, laid-off Education Department staffers reacted with cautious optimism. It remained unclear if, or when, they might return to their old jobs — or if they even want to go back.
Keith McNamara, a laid-off Education Department data governance specialist, said he's 'tempering my enthusiasm a bit' to see if Joun's order is overturned on appeal. But he said he was ' a lot more hopeful than I was yesterday' about the potential for the department to return to the way it operated prior to the cuts.
For federal workers, he said the challenges have been ongoing and monumental, saying the last few months without work have 'been very chaotic.'
Related
'It's been very difficult to look for other work because tens of thousands of us are all pouring into the job market at the same time,' he told The 74. 'It's been very stressful.'
Rachel Gittleman, who worked as a policy analyst in the financial aid office before getting terminated, called the court order on Thursday 'a really broad rebuke on the administration's attempt to shut down this critically important department.'
'But in many ways, the damage has already been done' as fired employees begin to find new jobs, Gittleman said, and Education Department leadership works to push people out.
McNamara said it was unclear Thursday whether the department would order fired employees back to work. Nearly his entire team was eliminated, he said, so it was uncertain what work he might do if he returned to the job. Asked if he was interested in doing so, he responded 'I'd have to really think about that.'
'Quite frankly, I don't think this administration is taking the job that the Education Department is supposed to be doing very seriously,' he said. 'I'm not sure I'd want to work for an agency that — from the very top — is hostile to the work that the department does.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Brazil sees 35.9% of exports to US facing steeper tariff, sources say
By Marcela Ayres BRASILIA (Reuters) -Brazil estimates that 35.9% of its exports to the United States, by value, will be hit by a steep 50% tariff under an executive order issued on Wednesday by the Trump administration, two sources familiar with the matter told Reuters. According to the sources, who spoke on condition of anonymity, the Ministry of Development, Industry, Trade and Services, which is leading trade negotiations with the U.S., is expected to unveil the figure later in the day. Trump slapped the 50% tariff to fight what he has called a "witch hunt" against former President Jair Bolsonaro, but softened the blow by excluding sectors such as aircraft, energy and orange juice from heavier levies. The Brazilian government will also report that another 44.6% of local products will be subject to the preexisting 10% tariff, while the remaining 19.5% will fall under tariffs the U.S. applies globally, ranging from 25% to 50%, added the sources. The MDIC did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
New York Times
21 minutes ago
- New York Times
Trade Deadline
President Trump has a big deadline this week. He announced tariffs in April, suspended them, and plans to reimpose them tomorrow. In the meantime, he has been trying to bend trade partners to his will with sweeteners, threats and the occasional ultimatum. After months of chaos and hype, he notched much-needed victories this week when he announced trade deals with the European Union and South Korea. But the saga isn't over yet. Today, I'll walk through where Trump's trade agenda has succeeded, where it hasn't and what we still don't know. The wins Trump has already delivered on some of his central trade promises. Raising tariffs: The president loves tariffs and has made them a totem of his second term. He has earned a reputation for bluffing, but overall duties have increased. America spent generations building — and benefiting from — a global free-trade consensus. Now, Trump has coaxed major players, including the European Union, South Korea and Japan, to accept 15 percent tariffs, the highest in decades. This piece by Ana Swanson, who covers trade, explains the shift. Boosting businesses: Trump has pushed several nations to buy more from American companies as part of their trade deals. The European Union and South Korea agreed to purchase hundreds of billions in U.S. fossil fuels before the end of Trump's term. Deals with half a dozen countries include orders for hundreds of Boeing jets. (This week, Boeing reported its strongest revenue in six years.) The losses Trump's tariff war has also meant some pain. Shuffling trade alliances: Nations have started seeking trade partners that are more reliable than the United States, writes Jeanna Smialek, who covers Europe. The E.U. is pulling closer to Britain, Canada, India and South Africa. Canada is courting Southeast Asia. Brazil and Mexico are building a rapport. They're redrawing the global trade map — minus the U.S. Roiling industries: Carmakers including Volkswagen and General Motors said import duties erased billions from their profits in the first half of the year. American farmers may have to splurge on fertilizers imported from Russia. Trump's E.U. tariffs may cost pharmaceutical companies billions, making drugs more expensive for Americans. Sydney Ember, who covers the U.S. economy, wrote about a Maine coffee company that raised prices after tariffs eroded its profits. The TBDs As my colleague Ben Casselman explained, economic growth has wobbled this year as tariff uncertainty upended business plans and scrambled consumer spending. With nations racing to negotiate new trade deals, there's still so much up in the air. Finalizing deals: Trump wants to win concessions, but trade talks aren't finished yet. Canada and Mexico remain empty-handed; as does China, which got a later deadline. Trump said yesterday that he would hit India with tariffs partly because it imports oil from Russia. He also punished Brazil with a tariff for prosecuting its former leader, his ally. (Here's a map tracking tariffs for every country.) And any new pact will likely be just a blueprint, since Trump's trade deals don't get into the nitty-gritty details that usually make up formal trade agreements. Lowering prices: Trump hopes that tariffs will boost the economy with lower prices and more jobs. But it's unclear whether that will work, Ana explains in a new story. Tariffs have a cost — borne by the businesses exporting goods or the consumers buying them. Although some businesses choose to absorb costs for a while, research shows that Americans eventually bear the brunt. Last month, inflation inched up as tariffs started to bite. More on the economy Trump ended a rule that exempted imports worth under $800 from tariffs. Small imports have ballooned in recent years because of online shopping. The Federal Reserve held interest rates steady, despite Trump's demand to cut them. Two Fed governors voted against the decision. That's very unusual, as this chart shows: Canada's prime minister said yesterday that his country would recognize Palestine as a state this fall. The move echoed similar ones by Britain and France over the past week. These are the first close allies of Israel and the United States to take such a step. So while this recognition is symbolic, it's a sign of a shift in global sentiment. Timeline: The Palestine Liberation Organization officially declared a Palestinian state in 1988, but the U.S. has consistently blocked the U.N. from granting it full member status. In 2012 Palestine got 'nonmember observer state status,' which allowed it to join various U.N. bodies and the International Criminal Court. Today, most nations recognize Palestine. Two states: Canada, Britain and France, like the United States, have long supported a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But they had resisted recognition while the two sides continued to disagree on some basics, such as security, borders and the status of Jerusalem. What changed? Leaders are outraged by the mass starvation gripping Gaza. Instead of seeing recognition as a carrot to encourage Palestinians to participate in a peace deal, the three nations will try to use it as a stick to pressure Israel to end the war. For more Gaza's looming famine is a familiar challenge for a U.S. president. Crises in the Balkans, Rwanda, Darfur and Syria, to name a few, haunted presidents' consciences — sometimes moving them to act, but often leading to excuses, Michael Crowley writes. A sack of flour costs $300 in Gaza. Read the latest on the food crisis. Trump Administration Brown University struck a $50 million deal with the government to restore research funding. The school promised to comply with President Trump's position on transgender athletes. Senate Democrats have slowed the confirmation process for presidential appointments to a trickle, creating a bottleneck by insisting that every vote be recorded. While running for president, Trump promised oil executives a windfall. Six months into his presidency, they're getting one. Senate Democrats invoked an obscure law to try to force the release of the Epstein files. More on Politics Texas Republicans unveiled a new gerrymandered map for the state's House districts. They're proposing to carve up five Democratic seats so that Republicans would be likely to win them in 2026. Former Vice President Kamala Harris will not run for California governor next year. A Senate committee advanced legislation that would bar members of Congress, the president and the vice president from trading stocks. House Democrats sued ICE for barring them from entering detention centers. Brazil The U.S. imposed sanctions on the Brazilian Supreme Court justice presiding over the prosecution of Jair Bolsonaro, the former Brazilian president. Bolsonaro is accused of orchestrating a coup attempt; Trump has called the case a 'witch hunt.' Brazil's president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, spoke with The Times about his outrage over what he says is Trump's meddling in his country's politics. Click the video below to watch. Public Health Measles cases in Canada have far surpassed those in the United States. The Food and Drug Administration's top vaccine and gene therapy official resigned after a public campaign against him led by the right-wing influencer Laura Loomer. Other Big Stories Russian missiles and drones struck Kyiv, killing at least seven people. An instrument issue may have misled the pilots of a Black Hawk helicopter about their altitude before it collided with a passenger jet near Washington in January. The gunman who killed four people in a Manhattan office building bought his assault rifle from his boss at a Las Vegas casino. Why did the big undersea earthquake yesterday produce a relatively small tsunami? 'There's big,' said one expert. 'And then there's really, really big.' Israel bears the greatest responsibility for starvation in Gaza. It needs to let Palestinians eat, the Editorial Board writes. Here's a column by Michelle Cottle on redistricting. Summer streets: New Yorkers are looking cool despite the heat. Our photographer captured their style. Always late? It may be a part of your personality, scientists say. Ultrarich Pac-Man: Palm Beach billionaires keep demolishing perfectly good beachfront mansions. Your pick: The most-clicked story in The Morning yesterday was about the spread of hand, foot and mouth disease. Taboo breaker: Rose Leiman Goldemberg wrote the screenplay for 'The Burning Bed,' which starred Farrah Fawcett as a wife exonerated for killing her husband. The TV movie helped start a national conversation around domestic abuse. Goldemberg has died at 97. Trending: People online were searching for the former N.B.A. star Gilbert Arenas after he and five others were arrested in Los Angeles, accused of illegally hosting high-stakes poker games at his home. He denies the charge. N.C.A.A.: Troy Taylor, Stanford's former head football coach, filed a defamation lawsuit against ESPN and one of its reporters over an investigative story that alleged Taylor 'bullied and belittled female athletic staffers.' Swimming: Ryan Lochte's record in the 200-meter individual medley fell after 14 years. Léon Marchand of France beat Lochte's time by 1.31 seconds. Jason Momoa knows what he looks like. But he prefers to think of himself as a 'sensitive alpha male' — not a hunky bruiser. No matter how you spin it, he's a bona fide action star, having played a warlord in 'Game of Thrones,' a sword master in 'Dune' and an amphibious superhero in 'Aquaman.' Momoa recently returned to Hawaii for a different kind of project, the Apple TV+ series 'Chief of War.' Alexis Soloski, a Times culture reporter, went to the beach with him in Honolulu to learn why he pushed so hard to make a serious-minded period drama about his home. More on culture A procession fit for the prince of darkness: Birmingham sent off Ozzy Osbourne with a brass band and a regal hearse. Here are some of the most anticipated books coming in August, including new novels by R.F. Kuang and Louis Sachar. Late night hosts are still joking about Trump and Epstein. Make your own pesto with five ingredients. Perfect your plank. Prepare for a natural disaster with these items that survivors said were crucial for them. Read this profile of Liam Neeson, who is on a mission to make you laugh. Here is today's Spelling Bee. Yesterday's pangrams were cognate and cotangent. And here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle, Connections, Sports Connections and Strands. Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox. Reach our team at themorning@
UPI
21 minutes ago
- UPI
At least 6 killed, more than 50 hurt in major Russian attack on Kyiv
July 31 (UPI) -- At least six people were killed and more than 50 were injured in Kyiv overnight during an hours-long Russian airborne assault on the Ukrainian capital that caused an apartment building to collapse. Three of the fatalities were in the nine-story apartment block in Sviatoshynskyi, a western outer-suburb. Kyiv Military Administration Head Tymur Tkachenko said a six-year-old boy was among those killed and that 10 other children were injured. Tkachenko warned that with Russian drones and missiles causing widespread damage to more than 25 sites across the city, including a children's hospital ward, a higher education institution, a school and a kindergarten, he expected the death toll to rise. The number of children injured was the highest since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, according to Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko. Calling the strikes "insidious" and "calculated," President Volodymyr Zelensky said it was part of a broader offensive against the eastern half of the country that saw Russia launch more than 300 missiles and eight missiles that also targeted the Dnipro, Poltava, Sumy and Mykolaiv regions. "The attack was extremely insidious and deliberately calculated to overload the air defense system. Kyiv was the main target for 'shaheds', other drones and missiles, though there is damage in other regions as well," he said in a post on X. "Rescue operations will continue as long as necessary -- until the fate of every person is clarified. There are sufficient forces and resources. I am grateful to everyone who is working to save lives and provide assistance," Zelensky added. The latest airborne assault came two days after U.S. President Donald Trump slashed a 50-day deadline for Moscow to agree on a cease-fire with Kyiv or face tough new economic sanctions to "10 or 12 days." Trump said he was withdrawing the 7-week window he announced July 14 after meeting with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Monday at Trump's Turnberry golf resort on the west coast of Scotland. "There's no reason waiting. It's 50 days. I wanted to be generous, but we just don't see any progress being made," Trump said at a joint news conference with Starmer.
