Johannesburg's last hope may be the ballot box
We do not have to live like this, with our municipalities crumbling.
The outcry against dysfunctional local governance is growing. Presidential and ministerial interventions are underway, and the auditor-general has released another devastating report.
Will any of these fix our municipalities? Johannesburg, South Africa's richest city, is an obvious example of failure.
Business Leadership SA CEO Busi Mavuso says Johannesburg, which has been in a state of gradual decline for many years, cannot manage its R89.4 billion budget adequately.
Mavuso bemoans the lack of financial management skills in municipalities, noting: 'There simply aren't enough qualified people working in local government to ensure the accounts are done properly.'
She doesn't single out individuals, but I will. Joburg's member of the mayoral committee (MMC) for finance, Margaret Arnolds, has no financial skills or qualifications.
An internet search will tell you where she went to high school, while on Facebook she says she 'studied media philosophy at Unisa'. Ja, nee. Very reassuring.
ALSO READ: Joburg can only be saved by fair municipal elections
With that skills deficit, no wonder she did not want to engage with our team's constructive suggestions in the build-up to last week's budget speech.
Joburg's budget is not fully funded, being over reliant on loans, whose repayments burden ratepayers. The trend is unsustainable.
Borrow, borrow, borrow while, at the same time, chasing away ratepayers, is an approach worthy of a Darwin award. Who will fix Joburg? Certainly not the current crew.
Cooperative Governance Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa recently launched a review of local government. However, in an interview with the Sunday Times, he gave the impression of passing the buck.
Asked about consequence management, he deflected responsibility to provincial MECs. Pressed further, he said he wasn't going to ask the relevant Gauteng MEC why Joburg's mayor hasn't been fired.
So, no pressure there. What about Cyril Ramaphosa's presidential working group? We are told the group is active in Joburg.
It reportedly includes chambers of commerce, township economy business associations, plus civil society groups such as the Johannesburg Crisis Alliance and the SA National Civics Organisation.
ALSO READ: Broken promises and failing services are sinking Joburg
There is no mandate for this. No detail has been presented to council. Indeed many elected councillors feel undermined by this unelected intervention which has yet to show any progress.
Daily there is social media coverage of 'high impact service delivery' attributed to the mayor. Despite photographs and hagiographic descriptions, the overall impact is risible.
Deterioration continues apace. The daily grind of water and electricity outages, sewage spills, unreinstated excavations, faulty traffic signals and nonworking streetlights is relentless.
More and more people are having their water or electricity cut off, often erroneously. Reconnections are taking too long, with ward councillors in the crossfire.
Who will break this pattern? Hlabisa says some interventions in municipalities have been going on for more than 10 years, with no improvement.
We cannot rely on any president, minister, provincial MEC, municipal MMC or civil society group to save Joburg. You can do it, collectively as voters.
At the earliest opportunity, use your vote to get rid of the unqualified, incompetent, corrupt people who are ruining our great city. We do not have to live like this.
NOW READ: Democracy is the winner in VAT hike drama
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
16 hours ago
- IOL News
Murder of court officials: Parliament expresses grave concern, seeks to engage NPA
Regional court prosecutor Tracy Brown was shot and killed in her vehicle at Gqerberha in the Algoa Park precinct on Thursday. Image: Facebook Chairperson of Parliament's portfolio committee on justice and constitutional development, Xola Nqola, has expressed outrage at the cold-blooded murder of public prosecutor Tracy Brown in Gqeberha, Eastern Cape. IOL reported on Friday that the murder of the female public prosecutor in front of her child and partner has been described as an attack on the rule of law. Tracy Brown, a regional court prosecutor, was shot and killed in front of her house at Lotton Street, Young Park in Gqeberha on Thursday after four men alighted from a white Polo vehicle and fired multiple shots at her vehicle. Nqola said protectors of the justice system in South Africa are not safe. 'This is indeed a tragedy where the protectors of our criminal justice system are not safe anymore. This is unacceptable and no stone should be left unturned to bring the culprits to book,' he said. According to reports, Brown was ambushed and shot multiple times by four armed assailants while sitting in her car, in full view of her partner and child. 'The brutal nature of this assassination-style killing is deeply disturbing and represents a direct attack on the justice system and those who serve it with dedication and courage,' he said. This incident follows the tragic murder of Elona Sombulula, a court official at the Engcobo Magistrate's Court, in April. The parliamentary committee is 'gravely concerned' by what appears to be a pattern of targeted violence against officials within the justice sector. 'The murder of Ms Brown is not only a devastating loss to her family and colleagues, but an attack on the rule of law in South Africa. Prosecutors serve at the forefront of our fight against crime and corruption. When they are targeted, it threatens the foundations of our constitutional democracy. 'The committee sends its heartfelt condolences to Ms Brown's loved ones and colleagues during this painful time. The committee also calls on law enforcement agencies to prioritise the investigation and ensure that those responsible are swiftly apprehended and face the full might of the law.' Nqola said the portfolio committee will engage with the Department of Justice and the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) on urgent measures to enhance the safety and security of prosecutors and court officials across the country.
The Citizen
19 hours ago
- The Citizen
iLembe Chamber Entrepreneur Programme kicks off
Twenty-five aspiring entrepreneurs attended the first induction session of the Entrepreneur 2025 Programme, hosted by the iLembe Chamber of Commerce on Saturday. Among the excited participants was Bongiwe Mpanza, a fashion designer from Groutville and owner of Mawazo Designs. Mpanza said she was eager to gain insights from industry experts to help grow her business. 'We are about to be equipped with the essential tools to thrive in this highly competitive industry, and I cannot wait to learn everything I can,' said Mpanza. This marks the beginning of a transformative entrepreneurial journey. Participants will progress through various training stages, including mentorship with industry professionals, refining their presentation skills, developing business plans and preparing for the final business exhibition in late October, where one winner will be selected. Stay in the loop with The North Coast Courier on Facebook, X, Instagram & YouTube for the latest news. Mobile users can join our WhatsApp Broadcast Service here, or if you're on desktop, scan the QR code below.
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
New parties fuel apartheid-era divisions, warns Jeff Radebe
JEFF Radebe, ANC KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Convenor, issued a warning to South Africa's political landscape, explicitly challenging entrenched power structures, political opponents, and high-profile figures undermining the nation's constitutional progress. Image: Sizwe Dlamini/Sunday Independent JEFF Radebe, ANC KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Convenor, this week, issued a warning to South Africa's political landscape, explicitly challenging entrenched power structures, political opponents, and high-profile figures undermining the nation's constitutional progress. In his Freedom Charter Lecture delivered at Unisa on Thursday, Radebe made a call to resist those seeking to dismantle the gains of decades of struggle for justice, and a clarion for radical reform rooted in the ideals of the Freedom Charter. 'These formations, which mushroomed in the aftermath of the 2024 electoral outcomes, seek to construct a society that is the antithesis of the Freedom Charter,' Radebe said, criticising emerging political entities that 'mobilise on the basis of racial exclusion and chauvinism'. He cautioned that these groups aimed to 'reverse the gains of constitutional democracy' and 'restore elements of apartheid logic', particularly 'the pursuit of parliamentary supremacy'. 'They are building 'Black Parties' as a counterweight to the vision of non-racial unity,' he said, calling their actions 'an attempt to undo the progress we have made as a nation'. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Radebe's critique extended beyond domestic politics into foreign policy, where he condemned those 'who once spoke for the state', now supporting actions that threaten South Africa's dignity. 'The position of the Republic of South Africa, not any political party or former official, is the custodian of its foreign policy,' he emphasized. 'Silence is not neutrality—it is complicity. 'It is profoundly disturbing,' he continued, 'that some within our own country, who once occupied high office and bore the constitutional duty to speak on behalf of the Republic have chosen to undermine our principled foreign policy positions,' especially regarding the ongoing conflict in Western Sahara. 'We must state unequivocally: the position of the Republic of South Africa is to reaffirm unwavering solidarity with Western Sahara,' he said, condemning individuals who 'support rogue actions that undermine our principled foreign policy positions'. In his broader internal critique, Radebe condemned what he saw as a betrayal of revolutionary ideals. 'Supporters of newly established political parties that vehemently oppose the ideals of the National Democratic Revolution… seek to construct a society that is the antithesis of the Freedom Charter,' he said. 'They attempt to reverse the gains we fought so hard for, and we must resist with every ounce of our revolutionary spirit.' He made it clear that these political moves threatened 'the democratic, non-racial, and inclusive future envisioned by the Charter', and cautioned that, if these trends were not stopped, 'we risk turning back the clock to worse than apartheid'. Recalling the revolutionary origins of the Freedom Charter, Radebe stated: 'The Charter was born from the collective dreams and demands of ordinary South Africans. It was adopted by the people, and only later endorsed by the ANC as policy. That endorsement marked a major ideological shift: from resistance to reconstruction, from protest to programme. 'It is vital to remember that the Freedom Charter was not initially an ANC document. It was adopted by the people,' he reiterated, underscoring its grassroots origins and moral authority. 'It remains the moral compass of our post-apartheid state… these principles continue to guide us in our efforts toward justice and equality.' Shifting his focus to governance, Radebe took a sobering stance on systemic failures across the country. 'Over 90% of our municipalities are financially distressed or failing,' he noted, describing the situation as 'systemic decay'. 'In too many towns, water has not flowed in months, electricity is unreliable… and waste goes uncollected. These are not isolated failures; they signal systemic decay.' He warned that: 'When local government fails, it is not simply a service failure — it is a breach of the Constitution. The collapse of local government is the collapse of legitimacy,' he emphasised, framing current shortcomings as a betrayal of revolutionary principles of service and justice. In economic terms, Radebe denounced the ongoing inequality entrenched by the legacy of apartheid. 'Wealth is still largely controlled by those who benefited under apartheid,' he said, condemning the continued influence of 'corruption, elite capture, and institutional failure'. He highlighted the plight of skilled professionals, noting: 'South African pilots, among the most skilled professionals in our society, must plead for fair wages from foreign shareholders who extract profits from our skies but invest little in our country.' He also slammed the devastating impact of illicit financial flows (IFFs), which 'bleed our continent and our country dry to the tune of R80 billion to R100bn annually,' according to estimates. 'These flows are orchestrated theft from the public purse. IFFs are acts of betrayal against the developmental aspirations of our people. 'We must adopt a binding anti-IFF strategy, strengthen the Financial Intelligence Centre (FIC), criminalise corporate tax avoidance, enhance cross-border transparency, and repatriate stolen assets through multilateral partnerships. It is not anti-business to demand accountability; it is pro-development.' The speech also addressed systemic inequalities and inefficiencies in public service, citing the 2024 Auditor-General's report, which revealed that 'more than 90% of our municipalities are in distress or failing', with water not flowing in months and waste uncollected. 'These failures are a breach of the Constitution,' Radebe said. 'Local government is the frontline of our democracy… its failure is a failure of the social contract.' He called for a new, inclusive national dialogue — 'a modern-day Kliptown' — to reshape South Africa's future based on participation and collective ownership. 'This dialogue must not be a technocratic conference for the privileged few. It must be a radical forum where the people speak and shape the future… much like the process that led to the Freedom Charter, the dialogue must reflect the radical democratic spirit of collective authorship, not elite consensus.' Radebe urged the South African youth to lead this effort: 'Today's youth must lead in reimagining these frontiers of freedom… They must not be left behind but be the drivers of our future.' In closing, Radebe advised: 'Democracy is not inherited; it is built, and rebuilt, by every generation that refuses to accept injustice as normal.' He reaffirmed his commitment to lifelong resistance to corruption and inequality, and warned: 'If we fail to confront this fiscal injustice, we surrender the economic sovereignty that our freedom demands.' His words serve both as a warning and an appeal: 'The time has come for us to choose: Will we allow the Freedom Charter's dream to fade into history, or will we seize it anew and forge a Just and free South Africa?' Get the real story on the go: Follow the Sunday Independent on WhatsApp.
