Pityana prepares for another legal showdown with Absa and SA Reserve Bank
Former Absa board member Sipho Pityana is bracing for another bruising battle with the bank as well as the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) in the court of law in his fight for reform in the banking sector.
This comes as Absa and the Sarb's Prudential Authority (PA) both filed applications for leave to appeal the Pretoria High Court ruling last month that vindicated Pityana in his claim that the PA broke the law in interfering with his possible nomination as Absa chair in 2021.
The PA controversially consulted with third parties regarding his suitability for the chairperson role, particularly following inquiries into his resignation from AngloGold Ashanti amid allegations of sexual harassment - claims he firmly denies.
The court found that the PA acted unlawfully by adopting an informal process to review Pityana's nomination, as prescribed by the regulations in place under the Banks Act.
Pityana's legal battle began when he sought a declaratory order against the PA, claiming they had operated outside the legal framework established for such considerations. He did not seek any relief against Absa.
However, Absa said it would take the judgment on review.
'After careful consideration of the 13 June 2025 High Court judgement, Absa will respectfully seek leave to appeal. It should be noted that the Court made no findings against Absa, save to order that it was jointly liable with the Prudential Authority for the applicant's costs,' Absa told Business Report on Monday.
The court's judgment, delivered by Judge Flatela Luleka last month, established that the PA had indeed overstepped its bounds by failing to follow established protocols, thus denying Pityana the opportunity to contest objections to his appointment.
'The [PA] acted unlawfully and in excess of its power per the Banks Act 94 of 1990 by engaging in an informal process with the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank] in connection with the nomination of [Pityana] as chairperson of the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank's] board of directors, and in particular by notifying the [Absa Group] and [Absa Bank] of its objection, alternative intention to object to [Pityana's] nomination,' read the judgment.
PA spokesperson, Thoraya Pandy, also confirmed on Monday that the PA is going back to court on the matter.
'Yes you are right, we have lodged an appeal. The documents are in the public domain and you can reach out to the courts for it, as we do not share it directly to anyone,' Panday said.
Speaking with Business Report last month, Pityana said the case had raised serious concerns regarding the independence of the Sarb and also urged for a formal investigation into what he describes as "cosy relationships" between key figures in the banking sector.
He said the judgement raised a number of new questions in terms of transparency, good governance and ethical conduct in the financial sector's regulatory environment, as well as accountability when laws are broken.
On Monday, Pityana said there was nothing really surprising about these applications for leave to appeal.
'The more curious one is why Absa is appealing the judgement when no finding is made against them. Indeed, why are they spending so much resources on a case in which they are cited only as an interested party. It already speaks to collusive behaviour,' Pityana said.
Pityana's legal battle extends beyond this ruling; he is also contesting his removal from the Absa board through separate legal proceedings.
BUSINESS REPORT
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
15 hours ago
- IOL News
Words on wealth: why are interest rates still high when inflation is so low?
Explore the complex dynamics between interest rates and inflation in South Africa, as we analyse the South African Reserve Bank's strategies and their impact on the economy. Image: Bloomberg Inflation is something we can't avoid – it's a bit like death and taxes. Traditionally, South Africa has had high inflation in comparison with developed countries, and that's a fundamental reason why the rand has steadily declined against the currencies of those countries. The Covid-19 pandemic upended that trend, and who knows what the effects of US tariffs will be. Whether we return to what now seems was a much safer, more stable world before Covid remains to be seen. As of June, our year-on-year Consumer Price Index inflation rate was 3.0%. Over the years, the SA Reserve Bank (SARB), through controlling interest rates, has done an admirable job of keeping inflation within its target range of 3-6%, for the most part. In comparison with other African countries, our inflation is low. Zimbabwe is an obvious example of a collapsing economy with runaway inflation, but even in countries with stable, growing economies, inflation is a problem. Nigeria has inflation of over 22%, according to Trading Economics; Egypt's rate is about 15%; and Rwanda's is over 8%. Kenya and Namibia are in a similar band to us – their current rates are 3.8% and 3.7% respectively. Looking further abroad, Brazil's rate is 5.4% and Turkey's is a terrifying 35.1%. Recently, the SARB has said it wants to bring the inflation target down so that 3% becomes the middle of the target band. Ironically, to do this, it would need to keep interest rates high, and I would suggest that they are too high as it is. Inflation rate vs interest rate In the following exercise, I compare the CPI inflation rate with the prevailing interest rate (the bank repurchase, or repo rate, as determined by the SA Reserve Bank). A fair comparison of the two rates involves percentages of percentages, which sounds complicated, but bear with me. Before Covid, inflation was averaging 4.5%, smack in the middle of the SARB's target range of 3-6%, and the repo rate was averaging 6.75%. Therefore, the repo rate was 50% higher than the inflation rate. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading When Covid hit, the economy froze and inflation plummeted, reaching a low of 2.1% in May 2020. By then, the SARB had already started slashing the repo rate – it plunged from 6.25% in February 2020 to 3.5% at the end of July, remaining at that record low for over a year. For most of that time, between July 2020 and March 2021, inflation hovered around 3.1%. The difference between the two rates was minor: the repo rate was just 13% higher than the inflation rate. By the end of the pandemic, inflation had soared, reaching a high of 7.8% in July 2022. Over the following two years, it steadily declined to 2.8% in October 2024, and it has averaged about 2.9% since then. When inflation was at 7.8% in July 2022, the repo rate was 5.5% – in other words, the repo rate was about 30% lower than the inflation rate, in a rare reversal. But by then, the SARB was rapidly hiking the repo rate to catch up with the high inflation, so that by July 2023, the repo rate reached a high of 8.25%. It remained there for a year, until July 2024, by which time inflation had dropped to 4.6%. The rates had righted themselves: the repo rate was now 80% higher than the inflation rate. Fast forward to June this year. The repo rate at 7.25% is 142% higher than the inflation rate at 3.0%. That's an enormous difference, considering it was only 50% higher before Covid. Even with a drop to 7%, it will still be 133% higher than the CPI inflation. This means that even in a bank savings account with a relatively modest 6% interest rate, you're getting a substantial after-inflation return of 3%. But while the high repo rate is great for savers, it's terrible for borrowers – think of mortgage bond holders whose interest rates are high, but where inflation is not substantially increasing the value of their properties. Juggling act Things are not as simple as I have perhaps conveyed. The SARB's rate decisions are forward-looking, and with the current uncertainty around tariffs, it has been justifiably cautious – inflation could rear its head again at any moment. On the other hand, keeping rates high unnecessarily is bad for economic growth. It's a delicate juggling act, as beleaguered US Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell knows all too well. Commenting on the SARB's low-inflation stance, FNB economists Mamello Matikinca-Ngwenya, Siphamandla Mkhwanazi, Thanda Sithole, and Koketso Mano say they think the shift will happen soon, with the SARB trying to take advantage of the currently benign inflation environment. But they say such a process takes time, and factors such as weather patterns, cyclical food inflation, and the need for traction on structural reforms may derail it. 'We still anticipate inflationary pressures that will make it difficult to sustain the current rate of inflation and believe that the SARB will have to work towards a 3% target as a medium-term objective,' the FNB economists say. Foord chief investment officer Nick Balkin says SARB's thesis is that a lower inflation rate will shrink Treasury's debt‑service bill and release scarce funds for social priorities. But although the SARB has generally delivered on its mandate to keep prices stable within its target range, he says real economic growth has barely averaged one per cent a year since 2014. 'Stabilising prices has not unlocked capital expenditure or boosted economic growth. If anything, it was the weaker growth that helped keep inflation in check,' Balkin says. 'Without meaningful, structural state interventions to address the root causes of constrained economic growth, the debt burden may even worsen.' * Hesse is the former editor of Personal Finance. PERSONAL FINANCE
IOL News
17 hours ago
- IOL News
Finance Minister dismisses speculation on 3% inflation target
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has dismissed speculation about a formal shift to a 3% inflation target, affirming that any changes will follow due consultation with the Reserve Bank, Cabinet, and other stakeholders. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has firmly dismissed speculation that government will formally adopt a 3% inflation target, following a recent announcement by the South African Reserve Bank's (SARB) Monetary Policy Committee (MPC). The SARB's MPC had indicated a preference to target inflation at 3% going forward, raising expectations that the Ministry of Finance would officially endorse this shift during the upcoming Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS). However, Godongwana made it clear that "Minister Godongwana has no plans to do this."
The Citizen
21 hours ago
- The Citizen
South African Reserve Bank lowers repo rate to 7% following inflation dip
The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) has reduced the repo rate by 25 basis points to 7%. It comes into effect from August 1. This decision was announced by SARB Governor Lesetja Kganyago during a media briefing on July 31. It follows a unanimous vote by the bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC). Kganyago said the rate cut reflects a strengthening rand, improved inflation expectations, and stable economic indicators. ALSO READ: Gauteng Health and Wellness MEC celebrates World Diabetes Day 'The June Consumer Price Index print showed headline inflation at 3% and core at 2.9%, still at the bottom of our target range,' he noted. 'While food inflation has picked up – mainly due to meat prices – and fuel prices are falling at a slower pace, we still forecast inflation to average 3.3% for the year.' The governor confirmed that inflation is expected to stabilise around the target midpoint in the coming period, with risks to the outlook now seen as balanced. Growth expectations revised Economic performance in early 2025 has been mixed. Although growth in the first quarter was reported at just 0.1%, in line with SARB expectations, downward revisions to previous GDP figures and possible higher US tariffs have prompted the bank to revise its 2025 growth forecast downwards. ALSO READ: Repossessed properties insights 'Underlying growth remains weak due to ongoing supply-side constraints, especially in logistics. Business and consumer confidence also dipped during the first half of the year,' Kganyago said. Despite this, the SARB expects gradual improvements driven by ongoing structural reforms. Shift in inflation targeting Kganyago announced a shift in the SARB's inflation targeting framework, with the bank now preferring inflation to settle at 3%, the bottom of the existing 3–6% target range. 'This strategic shift has helped strengthen the rand and reduce long-term borrowing costs,' he said. ALSO READ: Familiarise yourself with the interest rates and know how they affect you 'We will now use forecasts anchored at 3% inflation in future MPC meetings and continue working with National Treasury to achieve lasting low inflation.' Kganyago added that reduced inflation expectations would expand monetary policy space and enhance the resilience of the policy framework. The move reflects the SARB's longer-term goal of reducing uncertainty and entrenching price stability.
