SAHRC's 'pro-foreigner stance' comes under fire from ActionSA's Mashaba
Mashaba was speaking in Durban ahead of his party's legal showdown with the eThekwini municipality at the Pietermaritzburg high court on Thursday.
He was accompanied by the party's national chairperson Michael Beaumont and provincial chairperson Zwakele Mncwango on inspections of failed sewer infrastructure sites across the municipality.
'I am asking myself, when does this chapter 9 institution protect the rights of South Africans? The only time is when foreigners enter the country illegally,' said Mashaba.
Mashaba's comments came amid national attempts to prevent foreigners from being admitted and treated at government health-care facilities from the end of June.
The SAHRC said such practices are unethical and unlawful, and urged health and police authorities to act.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Investigations demanded against KZN MECs amid corruption claims
THE MEC of Education in KwaZulu-Natal, Sipho Hlomuka whose department is embroiled in allegations of tender irregularities regarding the school nutrition programme THE MEC of Health in KwaZulu-Natal, Nomagugu Simelane, has distanced herself from allegations that she had a hand in the abrupt termination of Vuma FM presenter, Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma's contract. TRIBUNE REPORTER ACTIONSA has written to KwaZulu-Natal Premier Thami Ntuli, urging him to investigate Health MEC Nomagugu Simelane and Education MEC Sipho Hlomuka on various allegations levelled against them. The DA has also joined the fray and asked the Minister of Basic Education Siviwe Gqurube to take over the R2.9 billion National School Nutrition Programme (NSNP). The party also welcomed the commitment by KZN Finance MEC, Francois Rodgers, to initiate a preliminary investigation following serious allegations of corruption implicating Hlomuka and several ANC-linked figures within the administration of the NSNP. Simelane is facing allegations of abuse of power and interfering in the abrupt termination of Vuma FM presenter Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma's contract. The allegations surfaced earlier this week, and KZN Health was swift in quelling the rumours, issuing a statement after hours on Monday distancing the MEC from the allegations, adding that as a woman she would never do such a thing against another woman. Ngobese-Zuma is the founder of the anti-illegal immigration movement, March and March, which has had a few brushes with the health department over the members of the movement blocking undocumented immigrants from accessing public healthcare facilities. ActionSA leader in KZN, Zwakele Mncwango, said the premier shouldn't hide behind the deals of the government of provincial unity (GPU) to drag his feet at launching an investigation against the MECs. Hlomuka is embroiled in the school nutrition tender of his department, with his wife's company being one of the chosen bidders to supply food at various schools. "We are writing to you to express our deep concern regarding the serious allegations of irregularities, corruption, and abuse of power within the Department of Health and Education. These allegations undermine the public's trust in the provincial department and its commitment to good governance, accountability, and transparency," reads ActionSA's letter. "Specifically the allegations against the MEC of Health regarding the abuse of power in relation to Vuma FM and the presenter Jacinta Ngobese, as well as the allegations of interference in the tender process for the nutrition programme by the MEC of Education, are grave and require immediate attention. "It is particularly concerning that you have remained silent on these matters, despite your previous rhetoric on issues such as illegal immigration. Notably, Jacinta Ngobese has been a vocal advocate against illegal immigration, and it is alarming that she is allegedly being victimised for her stance. Your silence on this matter raises questions about your commitment to protecting those who speak out against issues you have publicly condemned." Vuma FM issued a statement yesterday denying the Health MEC's involvement in the termination of Ngobese-Zuma's contract; however, just last month the station unveiled its new lineup with her still being the presenter of the midmorning show, The Cruise. The allegation was that Simelane had threatened to pull out all Department of Health advertising from the station, and she would also encourage other departments to do the same if Ngobese-Zuma was not removed. Yesterday, the Health MEC was on Ukhozi FM and clarified that the March and March movement, like every person, has a right to protest; however, every person in South Africa has a right to access health services if they are sick. She said her department can't turn away sick people from their facilities regardless of their immigration status, as it would open floodgates of legal action against the department. Simelane explained their conundrum as the department on undocumented immigrants citing the example of turning away a TB patient and the ripple effect it would have on them travelling by taxis and infecting other passengers who in turn infect others. She said there are discussions underway at the national level on a plan to have the immigrants' countries of origin help South Africa fund their healthcare. The DA's spokesperson on education, Sakhile Mngadi, who's also a member of the provincial legislature, said, "In the event that the allegations prove true, MEC Sipho Hlomuka must be removed from office without delay. Corruption cannot be tolerated at the expense of hungry children and the future of our province." And businesses that operate under the NSNP have also complained about irregularities and favouritism in the bidding process. The spokesperson for the Department of Education, Muzi Mahlambi, said, "The process is underway and has not been finalised for anyone to cry foul." He said they have no knowledge of these allegations, and those bidders who feel aggrieved know the relevant platform where to report their allegations. The programme has always had challenges like budget constraints and payment delays to service providers. Yesterday the ANC in KwaZulu-Natal, in a statement, welcomed Vuma FM's clarification on Ngobese-Zuma's contract and said this should put to bed the unfounded allegations against Simelane. On the issue of the nutrition tender, the ANC said, "The ANC understands that this process is at an appeal stage where those who have made bids and seek to appeal must forward their appeals to the Treasury Department. The ANC has full confidence that the provincial government has adequate capacity to handle appeals in a just and transparent manner."
The South African
5 hours ago
- The South African
'There's no white genocide': US lawmaker pleads SA's case amid sanctions bill
US Representative Jonathan L. Jackson, during an address to the House Foreign Affairs Committee, has opposed H.R. 2633, the US-South Africa Bilateral Relations Review Act of 2025 that aims to sanction South Africa and some ANC officials. On Wednesday, he said the bill 'does absolutely nothing to advance our bilateral relations with South Africa and in fact threatens to undermine it'. Jackson described the bill as 'not diplomacy' but 'coercion', based on a 'deeply fogged premise' that ignores the complexities and significant progress made together. Jackson stated that there was 'no credibility, no truth to saying white South Africans have experienced genocide'. 'Those were manufactured pictures,' he added, and emphasised the absence of a white genocide in South Africa. Jackson noted South Africa is the largest US trading partner in Africa, with over $20.5 billion (R359 billion) in two-way trade. He described South Africa as a strategic partner and a strong democracy committed to human rights. The two countries cooperate on global issues like health, climate, trade and education, Jackson added, stressing the importance of 'mutual respect' and 'respectful dialogues' to build on progress and yield benefits for both nations. Jackson warned that the proposed bill would increase tensions and undermine the progress South Africa and the US had already made. He urged Congress to allow diplomacy to 'play a central role in resolving political differences' based on international law and respect for sovereignty. He reminded the committee that the US had had relations with South Africa for less than 30 years since apartheid ended, and said South Africa had the right to an independent point of view. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Daily Maverick
6 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
SA's organised crime optics — suspicions blur lines between ‘gangsters', celebrities and flashy politicians
Shootings. High-profile figures in the entertainment industry. Politicians. Rogue cops. While there have always been rumoured links between these different arenas, South Africa's unprecedented policing scandal is adding substance to related suspicions. Politics, entertainment and shootings — these elements are part of South Africa's seismic policing scandal that keeps erupting with fresh developments and suspicions. While this saga emphasises just how fragmented the country's law enforcement arena is, it also highlights the proximity of certain politicians to individuals who have become the targets of shootings. This is not to suggest the politicians are in the wrong — they are not simply guilty by association. The overall situation, though, points to a blurring of lines between some public servants and people publicly known for reasons unrelated to the state. This reinforces ideas that political influence is seeping into various arenas. Or, more specifically, what's potting in some political offices is trickling into — and merging with — other spaces and even affecting street-level violence. Optics and organised crime There are optics associated with organised crime — and with politics. Prolific long-term lawbreakers may not flaunt their wealth. They know that discretion helps create hurdles in 'follow the money' investigative paths that lead to jail cells. Financially flamboyant criminals attract more scrutiny. They may not care though, especially if they feel they are above the law. Some organised crime suspects in South Africa flash their wealth — they use luxury cars reinforced against bullets. There are stories of Rolex watches discovered during arrests, and some individuals accused of crime enter courtroom docks in designer gear. Suspects can, based on material wealth, come across as celebrities. Now, just to be clear, people can spend their honestly earned personal money however they choose. This extends to politicians. In a South African context, though, politicians in decision-making positions who are wealthy — and who show it — inevitably draw scrutiny. This is because they are meant to be working to safeguard residents and improve the living conditions of the masses of people who are struggling to survive while up against factors including poor governance and state corruption. Some may therefore view it as crass when elements of politics edge towards celebrity-style realms and reality show-type grandeur. Outfits and opulence On 6 July 2025, KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi held a pivotal press conference during which he made astounding accusations that suggest that some of those in power are selling out South Africans. The optics of this briefing were notable, with some saying it created the impression of a coup. Mkhwanazi wore Special Task Force camouflage — he previously headed the unit — and was surrounded by armed police officers. While his attire was scrutinised and, in some instances, criticised, it may make some sense if what Mkhwanazi alleged is true. He said a drug cartel, headquartered in Gauteng and with ties to South America, was running a criminal syndicate that was embedded with corrupt state figures. It is common knowledge that international cartels are ruthless and murder those who get in their way. Mkhwanazi also alleged that at the end of last year the police minister at the time, Senzo Mchunu, issued a directive to disband the Political Killings Task Team to shield politically connected members of a criminal syndicate from prosecution. Mkhwanazi's other claims included that Mchunu was in cahoots with, among others, attempted murder case accused Vusi 'Cat' Matlala. Mchunu denied the accusations but was placed on leave. As for Matlala, central to the allegations against Mchunu, he seems to be someone who enjoyed an opulent lifestyle. According to News24, he had 'bankrolled a luxurious existence for himself and his family, marked by profligate spending on palatial homes, luxury cars and high-end fashion'. Matlala faces criminal accusations in connection with the attempted murder of actress Tebogo Thobejane, who was wounded in a Sandton shooting in October 2023. Other shootings of high-profile Gauteng figures fit into this broader matrix in which politicians keep cropping up. [WATCH] As the ANC, we do not think that the matters raised by General Mkhwanazi border on politics. We think the matters are so serious that they border on criminality #KhokhelaRamaphosa #ANCRenewalAtWork — ANC SECRETARY GENERAL | Fikile Mbalula (@MbalulaFikile) July 15, 2025 In reaction to Mkhwanazi's allegations, ANC Secretary-General Fikile Mbalula, who was once the minister of police and who is nicknamed 'Razzmatazz' for his flashiness, took to the platform X. Before we get to what he posted on there, it is noteworthy that Mbalula's attire often gets attention. A few years ago, The Citizen even published a lifestyle piece about his 'best looks'. A section of that article referenced what it termed his 'rapper riche' outfits, saying: 'Keeping it young and trendy Mbalul[a] dabbles in loungewear, urban gear, and can often be seen in luxurious Gucci, wearing signature cardigans and embellished beanies. 'He's often spotted in hoodies and comfortable Gucci tracksuits.' Back to issues of national importance. Crime and politics Mbalula, in reaction to Mkhwanazi's recent accusations, posted on X on 15 July 2025: 'As the ANC, we do not think that the matters raised by General Mkhwanazi border on politics. We think the matters are so serious that they border on criminality.' There are obvious overlaps between politics and organised crime, and where they overlap, they are effectively one and the same. Take, for example, the State Capture that crushed the country when Jacob Zuma was president between 2009 and 2018 (when the ANC led South Africa before the Government of National Unity that is now in place). Mkhwanazi's recent accusations suggest the development of other iterations, or the continuation, of that capture. Mbalula, meanwhile, aside from talking about politics bordering on criminality, knew an individual Mkhwanazi referenced during his pivotal press conference — rapper Kiernan Forbes, also known as AKA. In 2020 Mbalula appeared on a TV show that Forbes hosted. He was South Africa's transport minister at the time. Maybe I should start a TV App and calling it's MegaFIX TV ? I've now watched #TheBraaiShowon #AKATV Good job @akaworldwide thank you for the engagement – big ups to your precessional production team. — ANC SECRETARY GENERAL | Fikile Mbalula (@MbalulaFikile) June 11, 2020 Forbes, who was based in Gauteng, went on to be murdered in a shooting with his celebrity chef friend, Tebello Motsoane, in KwaZulu-Natal in February 2023. During his press conference earlier this month, Mkhwanazi pointed out that the police in KwaZulu-Natal had made arrests in that case, while suspects were yet to be taken into custody for other incidents involving high-profile individuals in Gauteng. Mkhwanazi said the suspects in those Gauteng cases had been identified, but prosecutors were basically dragging their feet in signing off on arrests. It appeared that among those Gauteng cases was one linked to Oupa John Sefoka, better known as DJ Sumbody, who was murdered there in a shooting in November 2022. DJ Sumbody's murder Sefoka's Instagram account is full of dazzling photographs. Think designer clothing, liquor and luxury cars. Through entertainment venues he had been associated with individuals including alleged 28s gang boss Ralph Stanfield, who was arrested at his home in the upmarket Cape Town suburb of Constantia in 2023. Sefoka's funeral was an elaborate one. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Djsumbodysa (@djsumbodysa) Among those who spoke at it was EFF leader Julius Malema, whose name is among those embroiled in the VBS bank scandal, and who faces accusations in connection with the alleged discharge of a firearm at a party event in 2018. Back to the Sefoka case. Arrests were only carried out recently, on 21 July 2025, three years after the shooting and only after Mkhwanazi's press conference during which he implied that certain prosecutors were holding up cases. Another politician crops up here. Firstly I believe Kenny 100%, I can't expect everyone to believe him hence we launching a full investigation to proof what we know already know which is that he is innocent. We will share the whole process and findings. — Gayton McKenzie (@GaytonMcK) July 22, 2025 News24 reported that when the police arrested Katiso Molefe, a key suspect in the Sefoka murder case, at his Sandton home, the Patriotic Alliance's Kenny Kunene was outside the house. Kunene, who has a well-documented past involving unrelated crime, insisted to News24 that he was merely accompanying a young journalist there and that he had no relationship with Molefe whatsoever. The Patriotic Alliance's Gayton McKenzie, South Africa's Minister of Sports, Arts and Culture, suspended Kunene the day his presence outside the suspect's home was reported on. McKenzie said this was simply to go through due processes as he believed that Kunene was innocent of any wrongdoing. Now, McKenzie has been open about his past that has involved crime and time in jail. He has before referred to his younger self as 'a common criminal' who became a gangster around the age of 12 or 13 years. As a minister, he has not shied away from that. Gang suspicions It is in this arena that a web of shootings (some with suspected links to gangs in the Western Cape) and court issues start unfurling. These predate, and now include, Sefoka's murder. Politicians' names, for various reasons and again not to suggest that they are in the wrong, are dotted in between. Former Hard Livings gang boss Rashied Staggie was murdered in Cape Town in 2019. Staggie had previously indicated he was backing McKenzie and Kunene's Patriotic Alliance. About a decade ago McKenzie had referred to Staggie as 'a leader'. In 2021 William 'Red' Stevens, widely reputed to have been the most senior 27s gangster, was killed in a shooting in Cape Town. At the time Stevens was facing criminal charges in connection with a murder plot. McKenzie spoke at his funeral. Alleged 28s gang boss Stanfield has several co-accused in the case he is currently charged in. Two of the co-accused face accusations in connection with Stevens' murder. Stanfield also faces charges for a murder conspiracy relating to Staggie's killing. He previously faced other housing tender-linked charges, that were provisionally withdrawn, alongside former DA Cape Town human settlements mayoral committee member, Malusi Booi. Stanfield was among those acquainted with Sefoka, who was murdered in the 2022 Gauteng shooting. It was Sefoka's funeral at which Malema spoke. On 21 July 2025, police officers happened upon Kunene outside the home of one of the suspects arrested in connection with Sefoka's murder. This web, even if the politicians mentioned in it are totally innocent of wrongdoing, is concerning because it is a tiny fragment of a much more expansive web. Mkhwanazi's recent accusations, while yet to be fully tested, highlight other parts of this web and suspected overlaps between organised crime and politics. So far, President Cyril Ramaphosa seems to have taken Mkhwanazi seriously — he has appointed a commission of inquiry to investigate his allegations. As for Malema and McKenzie, they are among politicians who have expressed support for Mkhwanazi (although McKenzie was one of those who viewed Mkhwanazi's press briefing attire as coup-esque). 'Politicians who must still go to prison' The two politicians have quite a past. McKenzie wrote an open letter to Malema back in 2014. A section said: 'Julius, you and I are not 'revolutionaries'. We both know that. We both shop at the same Louis Vuitton and Gucci shops. We both have watches worth hundreds of thousands… 'For people like us to call ourselves revolutionaries is an insult to history's real revolutionaries.' (For his part, at an unrelated event, Malema previously told journalists: 'I bought Louis Vuitton and Gucci before VBS… No one can tell me what to wear and not to wear.') McKenzie had also stated in the letter to Malema: 'You get two kinds of politicians in this country: the ones who come from prison and those who must still go to prison.' Mkhwanazi's recent accusations, paired with past State Capture allegations, now underscore some of McKenzie's words. There are undoubtedly politicians 'who must still go to prison'. Even if the intent behind Mkhwanazi's accusations against politicians and figures in the state is questionable, his allegations have at the very least brought focus onto an arena involving suspicions of rogue state and political activity in organised crime. These kinds of suspicions are not new. And they emphasise how criminality — from killings on street corners, to dirty money spending sprees and political skullduggery — cuts through vastly different sectors and endangers innocent residents. DM
